Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:40

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:38

You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

Young people will one day be old people.

Which is precisely why enforcing laws that encourage higher birth rates is a Ponzi scheme

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:39

I can imagine the mess of financial advisors having to advise people it would be cheaper to divorce and marry someone fertile

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:38

You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

Young people will one day be old people.

ancientgran · 04/07/2022 15:38

Pinkflipflop85 · 04/07/2022 13:46

Great way to rub salt into the wounds of women who can't conceive/have miscarried/experienced stillbirth.

And a pretty shitty thing to do to women who have every right to choose not to have children.

And presumably their partners because men can want children as well and not be able to have them and men also have a right to choose.

emmathedilemma · 04/07/2022 15:37

Ducksinthebath · 04/07/2022 14:16

Arguably those without children are already paying for so many services they don’t use (maternity care, schools, nursery hours) that this really does add insult to injury.

This! In bucket loads!!

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:36

I wonder how they would treat lesbian couples e.g. does everyone who hasn't had a child have to pay more e.g. in a lesbian couple the woman who hasn't birthed the child has to pay more. Which would be discrimination compared to heterosexual couples.

Would you have to do DNA tests to prove you actually fathered a child, or is being on a birth certificate sufficient.

If they decide just being in a couple is sufficient what about a polygamous relationship? How about we bring in a fertile woman to have a baby for me and my husband so we don't get taxed. We could call her OfthreepeoniesDHsname...

Change123today · 04/07/2022 15:35

Madness! I have two friends one is childless by choice one would love to have a child & has already paid for IVF.

My choice (wasn’t necessarily easy) was to have two children. I need to house, clothe and feed them!
My choice to pay for two lots of child care, swimming lessons and now one in uni as she doesn’t receive the full maintenance loan I need to also help her.

Just looking at the above even having 2 is a massive long term commitment! A 3rd would have meant probably husband and I reduce our pension payments as for the first I didn’t pay in until she was at school as I couldn’t afford it.

Taxing everything and anything isn’t the answer - spending & supporting in the right way would be a better way!

Highwind · 04/07/2022 15:33

I thought automation was going to replace a lot of jobs anyways. So perhaps desperately trying to increase the worker ant population whilst also decreasing the number of jobs (and hence the ability to tax them isn’t the best idea).

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:29

The thing is if the government introduced a scheme whereby parents had their tax burden reduced for say the first 10 years of their children's life, in order to offset the cost of childcare I wouldn't have an issue with that

But personally I think immigration is the answer. And I don't think we should have a choice over it. Richer countries have contributed more to climate change than third world countries yet it is now more of the third world countries that are suffering the impact of it. I don't just think we could take more immigrants, I think we should have to.

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/07/2022 15:27

Introduce a universal basic income so people don't HAVE to work to survive and we will see more people choosing to raise children.

But that will never happen because people cannot STAND to think that someone else is getting something for nothing.

It will be a cold day in hell before I'll pay a tax for the fact I cannot (and from a genetic pov, should not) have kids!

pigsDOfly · 04/07/2022 15:27

Ludicrous idea.

Does he really think that paying less tax is going to be the lure that makes people rush out and reproduce?

What about those that have no one to reproduce with or those that can't, they're all going to be penalised for their lack of social commitment.

Not every child is a wanted, loved child but you keep popping out those unwanted children because you'll be paying less tax.

Anyone who can seriously write: 'on the birth of the third child, they would receive a telegram from the Queen' is not worthy of having anything they write taken seriously.

Fernticket · 04/07/2022 15:26

Pinkflipflop85 · 04/07/2022 13:46

Great way to rub salt into the wounds of women who can't conceive/have miscarried/experienced stillbirth.

And a pretty shitty thing to do to women who have every right to choose not to have children.

This.
This is a huge slap in the face to those of us who are not childless by choice.

TheOGCCL · 04/07/2022 15:25

When you start to think The Handmaid's Tale isn't that farfetched after all...

This country just doesn't make having children an attractive proposition, unless you have a strong biological desire.

This is a good book on the topic, albeit American
www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00KK6CBCY/ref=dp-kindle-redirect?_encoding=UTF8&btkr=1

Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 15:25

*an older generation was lost to world wars.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 04/07/2022 15:24

@Traveller3367

Surely the answer to that is immigration. We're going to have huge numbers of people being displaced due to climate change, water shortages etc in the decades ahead. We're really not going to be short of young people wanting to enter the country any time soon.

The usual suspects will whinge about their culture being eroded etc etc but if we're not producing our own offspring then so it goes. We're going to have way bigger problems than that to worry about in the years ahead anyway.

Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 15:24

It’s going to happen in under some guise or another, although probably not as overtly as taxing people without children.

The simple fact is our population (despite what some sectors of the media would have you believe) is shrinking at the youngest ages but lasting longer at the older ages. There’s a significant bulge in the Middle Ages meaning that we won’t have the economically active population to be able to support the very youngest and the very oldest at the same levels we’re used to currently.

It looks like it might level out in a couple of generations but we haven’t got the ‘advantage’ of baby boomers who lost a lot of a generation to world wars.

Tax childless adults
babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 15:24

ReeseWitherfork · 04/07/2022 13:44

This isn’t incentivising having children, it’s punishing those who don’t. Surely two different things?

They could make having children far more desirable by improving parental leave and pay or making childcare more affordable. Simple.

Well that kind of amounts to the same thing, in that in order to subsidise childcare and provide other financial benefits to people who have children, you would either need to raise taxes or divert existing tax revenue away from other things and into families with children.

But it would be a less blatant way of doing it.

Phrenologistsfinger · 04/07/2022 15:23

This enrages me so much! Tax me for my ten miscarriages or my failed rounds of IVF?! For my suicidal feelings? For my sad and desperate void of a future without children? Hell no! I would leave any country that brought this law in and never look back. Thankfully it is unlawful.

There are too many humans as it is let alone selfish, angry, abusive, disordered ones causing havoc in the world. Like this chump.

Getoff · 04/07/2022 15:23

That article is extreme and I don't agree with the concept but there needs to be an acknowledgement of the importance of having children and a next generation.

I don't agree that there's any need to do anything about the birth rate. Before this guy starts proposing solutions to the "problem", he needs to come up with some convincing arguments that there is a problem. What we expect, a birth-rate slightly below replacement rate, is not a problem, even if it results in a long-term gradual fall in population in the UK, which it probably won't, due to immigration.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 15:22

You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

Yes but then we have to be attractive to immigrants & I'm not sure we are so much.

whumpthereitis · 04/07/2022 15:22

It’s sad that the solution to a failing system pyramid scheme always seems to be the removal of rights and/or bullying ‘incentives’ designed to prop said system up, thus delaying the inevitable.

I’m childfree and honestly you couldn’t pay me enough to have children. I’m a net contributor to the economy, and I’m lucky in that if this absurdity was introduced I could vote with my feet out of the country. I can’t imagine I would be the only one either.

someone earlier mentioned Ceaușescu. He actually started with a ‘softer’ natalist policy to encourage births. It didn't work, so the policies became increasingly totalitarian. Even then, illegal abortion rates were incredibly high, as was child abandonment. The resultant social catastrophe is still being dealt with today. Tactics like these are not going to produce a good outcome.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:21

Changes17 · 04/07/2022 15:14

I never understand the points about not paying for schools, nurseries etc if you don't have children. We benefited from them when we were children, so we pay for new generations to benefit now we can afford to pay. And in retirement, these new generations will be paying for your pension.

In a similar way, those of us of working age pay for hospitals we're less likely to be using now but may have as babies/children and will most likely use in the future.

PS this suggestion is mad and will never happen.

I haven't seen anyone suggest we don't pay the tax. But the reality is that I am paying tax for things that I will never see the benefit from personally. I don't begrudge that, I think that is right and appropriate because I believe in a society that supports parents and children.

What I fundamentally disagree with is the person who wrote this article and several people on this thread agreeing that because I haven't provided a replacement body to act as a carer when I am older I am somehow a second class citizen who should be taxed more for my selfishness.

An alternative theory could be:

I didnt choose to be born. The only people with the choice to create the burden of care for me in my old age were my parents. Therefore parents should be taxed more.

Its just as stupid and illogical.

Also:

And in retirement, these new generations will be paying for your pension. I will just stop my pension contributions now shall I. And tell my employer to stop theirs.

QueenofDestruction · 04/07/2022 15:20

Meant childless not single

maddiemookins16mum · 04/07/2022 15:18

This makes me so cross. It’s another way of saying those without children (for whatever reason) are not as important as those with. We already see that, the pitying looks, the being expected to work in the School holidays, at Christmas etc. The fact childless people (especially men) have little (if any) chance of getting social housing.

QueenofDestruction · 04/07/2022 15:17

Its really easy for higher earning single adults to move to another country who doesn't tax them more.

Swipe left for the next trending thread