Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 16:03

No one has children to provide future tax payers, they have children because they can and want to. It's for them, not anyone else

I suppose so, but the resulting human being is usually pretty invested too.

I understand the presentation of this particular argument is galling and insensitive but I don’t like the framing that child free people are doing the parents a favour. They’re not, it’s the resulting child, that will grow into a adult and peer, that should benefit from tax spending.

Children are only children for a relatively short time, if you want a generation that you will interact with to be educated and relatively stable then taxes are required for the good of society.

ReeseWitherfork · 04/07/2022 16:00

@ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave She’s referencing work by Hans Rosling. It’s worth dipping your toe into.

Sexnotgender · 04/07/2022 15:59

Imagine being devastated at being unable to have children and then the government fucking taxes you for it. Cunts.

CredibilityProblem · 04/07/2022 15:59

Women aren't choosing to have fewer babies just because the current UK government are a shower of shit.

All over the world, wherever infant mortality is low and women have the right to education and self-determination, fertility levels are dropping below replacement levels. Loads of countries which are on paper more family friendly than the UK have lower birth rates.The only European country with higher that replacement fertility levels is the Faroe Islands. If we wanted to increase fertility rates here we'd need to a) subsidise child care like the Danes and Swedes b) give massive tax breaks like the French (though probably not describe them as extra tax on the childless).

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependencies_by_total_fertility_rate

whumpthereitis · 04/07/2022 15:58

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 15:51

Overall I’m with the pp who pointed out the madness of continually getting bigger growth for younger population as some kind of Ponzi scheme

Who has suggested continually growing? We are way below replacement level. At least 20 countries are expected to see their population halve in the next 70 years. These countries will all be fighting for immigrants.

The state is set up as a Ponzi scheme, my NI & tax funds other things. It doesn't go into a pot for me. How do you propose to fund everything when we are already at crisis levels in the NHS & social care when there are millions more older people but far fewer younger people?

The obvious answer is immigration, but of course it’s not necessarily an ‘easy solution’ that is without its own issues.

I don’t know the solution, I’m neither an economist nor a social scientist. Not knowing a solution does not, however, legitimize a bad one. And this is a bad one.

DogInATent · 04/07/2022 15:57

Ah, the latest, greatest idea from the people formerly telling everyone:


  • you shouldn't have children unless you can afford them

  • you can't build houses here, the country's full

  • we don't want foreigners there are too many people here already

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:56

Butchyrestingface · 04/07/2022 15:49

This Oxford University demographer is a right cunt, isn't he?

Interesting that this opinion piece is published just after the US repeals its abortion laws. It's almost like they want to force women, sorry, BIRTHERS, to have kids by whatever means necessary.

One of the arguments I saw to repeal roe vs wade was that there were too many infertile people in the USA who couldn't adopt american babies, and by outlawing abortion there would be more american babies for infertile people to adopt.

Inhumane arseholes

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 04/07/2022 15:55

restedbutexhausted · 04/07/2022 14:58

Just popping on to say that I agree with all of this apart from overpopulation. That's actually a myth. There is plenty of space and resources for everyone in the world. In fact, the entire global population could fit inside the state of Texas with a population density lower than that of NYC.

Sorry to be that person!

Oh come on, engage some critical thinking.

This is completely irrelevant, seeing as there are no current plans to move the world's population to Texas. The UK does NOT have enough natural resources to feed its current population, let alone a growing one. We rely on importing food (and much else) from other countries, many of which won't be able to export as much in future because a) their own populations are growing and b) climate change will render a lot of current fertile land unusable.

Yes, we need to keep breeding in ever expanding numbers to prop up the pensions pyramid scheme. No, this is not a sustainable solution. It'll be nasty when the pyramid collapses, but it's inevitable.

HippyRhino · 04/07/2022 15:55

ReeseWitherfork · 04/07/2022 13:44

This isn’t incentivising having children, it’s punishing those who don’t. Surely two different things?

They could make having children far more desirable by improving parental leave and pay or making childcare more affordable. Simple.

Completely agree. A bigger incentive to have children would be to make wages liveable whilst paying childcare fees, better parental leave and so on... Not taxing childless people! Wtf.

I always hate the arguments on these sorts of threads too that everyone who has children is doing everyone else a massive favour and it's totally selfless.

Yes obviously future generations are important but I cringe at the implication anyone is having children for anything other than selfish reasons. No one has children to provide future tax payers, they have children because they can and want to. It's for them, not anyone else.

vermicello · 04/07/2022 15:54

Madness! Childless adults already pay far more tax considering they are paying for all sorts of benefits for families with children that they don't get. The benefits system actively rewards having children and childless people get hardly anything. If anything people should be taxed for having children, most are net takers and heavily contribute to climate change, carbon footprints and plummeting resources.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 15:53

ancientgran · 04/07/2022 15:40

I remember this coming up when I was at school. Very Joyce Grenfell jolly hockeysticks headmistress said she didn't look at it like that. She had no children but she had benefitted from her mother's maternity care, school, can't remember about nursery, so she viewed it as paying it back rather than her subsidising people who had children.

Yes, but then suggesting those of us that don't have children pay additional tax is specifically suggestion we subsidise those that already have children

There is a big difference between my tax being used to pay for schools and maternity care despite me not having children, and putting the burden of childcare costs on me specifically because I don't have children.

One is about benefitting society as a whole to ensure that choices that may be outside someone's control do not unfairly disadvantage them (and I will agree our society currently does not do enough of this) and the other is penalising me specifically for choices that are outside of my control.

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 15:53

In time areas of the globe will become inhabitable we may well welcome lower population growth to accommodate more people

I’m glad the general view is it’s madness though

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 15:52

Interesting that this opinion piece is published just after the US repeals its abortion laws. It's almost like they want to force women, sorry, BIRTHERS, to have kids by whatever means necessary.

This is what frightens me.

JudgeJ · 04/07/2022 15:52

YesNoMaybeNot · 04/07/2022 13:42

Most ridiculous idea.

Totally stupid! The childless tax payers could argue that they should pay less tax as they take less from the system.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 15:51

Overall I’m with the pp who pointed out the madness of continually getting bigger growth for younger population as some kind of Ponzi scheme

Who has suggested continually growing? We are way below replacement level. At least 20 countries are expected to see their population halve in the next 70 years. These countries will all be fighting for immigrants.

The state is set up as a Ponzi scheme, my NI & tax funds other things. It doesn't go into a pot for me. How do you propose to fund everything when we are already at crisis levels in the NHS & social care when there are millions more older people but far fewer younger people?

Simonjt · 04/07/2022 15:50

We have two children, so two sets of state education, nhs medical care etc. We both work part time.

If we were child free we would both work fulltime and pay more taxes, we would probably climb the career ladder more, we would also be spending more money. We wouldn’t be using tax payer money for state education or nhs care for children. So technically we would be taxed more anyway as state education is really a rebate for parents who don’t send their children to public school.

There are more gay couples than children available for adoption, so if you wish to adopt and are approved but there aren’t enough children for matching, does that gain you a tax get out of jail free card?

Butchyrestingface · 04/07/2022 15:49

This Oxford University demographer is a right cunt, isn't he?

Interesting that this opinion piece is published just after the US repeals its abortion laws. It's almost like they want to force women, sorry, BIRTHERS, to have kids by whatever means necessary.

SirenSays · 04/07/2022 15:46

Most people I know who don't have children, have chosen not to have them because they can't afford them.

ChrisReasBathEggs · 04/07/2022 15:45

People are not having children or having fewer children because of housing, cost of living and extortionate child care. I'm not sure why it is such a surprise that over 65s now outnumber under 16s. Why can't this government and so called experts see the obvious?

I recall when I had my first child in the mid 2010s that my manager was shocked that we didn't get tax credits, despite both me and partner working in fairly low paid jobs full time. He didn't get that if I went part time i probably would still get nothing or barely enough to make it worth applying. In the early 00's when he had his children he got a lot of support with tax credits with both him and his wife being in professional roles. How times have changed.

I think young people see the bone numbing knackering slog of bringing up kids while working full time, not even having a stable home to house their kids in and still being broke despite this. They are deciding that that kind of life is not worth it. Not surprising at all.

Will anything get done about this ticking time bomb and pensions? Will it fuck! The gen Xers are about to get royally shafted now too to pay for this imbalance.

I don't agree with this article though, but then it's a nonsense bullshit article to get people fighting amongst each other so we don't look at the increasing protests, a cost of living crisis and a self serving, corrupt government (and useless BoE) that would make a labotomised slug look competent.

HesterShaw1 · 04/07/2022 15:43

While I appreciate and support many of the arguments against the idea of a tax on childlessness which have been put forward, what I was basically saying was that, for someone like me, it would add insult to injury!

While I'll apologise for my "fucking snide" expression, you don't necessarily know what people's personal circumstances are while they are discussing and debating. I'm "someone like you" - was never able to have children. I gradually came to terms with it and now given the state of the country and those governing it, I am glad.

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 15:43

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 15:22

You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

Yes but then we have to be attractive to immigrants & I'm not sure we are so much.

I don’t see why not but as pp said they too will grow old and need various things

Overall I’m with the pp who pointed out the madness of continually getting bigger growth for younger population as some kind of Ponzi scheme

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:42

IncompleteSenten · 04/07/2022 15:41

That'll be the case whether they move here or are born here.

To quote @Threepeonies above, "Which is precisely why enforcing laws that encourage higher birth rates is a Ponzi scheme."

IncompleteSenten · 04/07/2022 15:41

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:38

You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

Young people will one day be old people.

That'll be the case whether they move here or are born here.

ancientgran · 04/07/2022 15:40

emmathedilemma · 04/07/2022 15:37

This! In bucket loads!!

I remember this coming up when I was at school. Very Joyce Grenfell jolly hockeysticks headmistress said she didn't look at it like that. She had no children but she had benefitted from her mother's maternity care, school, can't remember about nursery, so she viewed it as paying it back rather than her subsidising people who had children.

RedWingBoots · 04/07/2022 15:40

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 15:38

You can increase immigration to increase the number of young people.

Young people will one day be old people.

Immigrants from the older nations in the EU use to come here for a few years, work and/or study then go home before they started costing lots.

In fact I know people from newer EU countries who have come back to their home country. Though Covid helped a lot.