Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
OperaStation · 04/07/2022 16:26

NotAMumNotByChoice · 04/07/2022 14:44

If you regret having children @OperaStation , then I feel sorry for your children

I don’t know where you got that impression from. I don’t regret it for a second. But I would be lying if I didn’t say I would be financially much, much better off without them. I would be working full time in a better paying job and I wouldn’t have spent £50k on nursery fees over 3 years.

BigFatLiar · 04/07/2022 16:25

I think he's just out to make people talk about the issue of the growing aging population.

Perhaps we could connect this to another topic that was on mumsnet and euthanise the over 80s to cut the aging population.

WishILivedInThrushGreen · 04/07/2022 16:25

The article smacks of one of 'those' think tank ideas that gets peddled to gauge public opinion.

It'll disappear very quickly.

HippyRhino · 04/07/2022 16:23

Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 16:03

No one has children to provide future tax payers, they have children because they can and want to. It's for them, not anyone else

I suppose so, but the resulting human being is usually pretty invested too.

I understand the presentation of this particular argument is galling and insensitive but I don’t like the framing that child free people are doing the parents a favour. They’re not, it’s the resulting child, that will grow into a adult and peer, that should benefit from tax spending.

Children are only children for a relatively short time, if you want a generation that you will interact with to be educated and relatively stable then taxes are required for the good of society.

I don't disagree and it's why I, before having my own DC, didn't grumble at paying taxes toward things like maternity care, education, CB and so on...

But I can't stand the 'having children is completely selfless and provides doctors for the childless' posts.

It's not selfless. You may not be wrong in that future generations are important which is why I think the majority of childless people aren't opposed to paying tax toward the things mentioned above because they appreciate it's a benefit to everyone that our young people are cared for and educated etc etc... But it's not a selfless act to become a parent, it's an entirely selfish one and to make out otherwise makes me cringe.

jcyclops · 04/07/2022 16:23

He suggested that in order to incentivise parenthood, a tax should be created to be put on those without children. The Oxford University demographer said: "This may seem unfair on those who can’t or won’t have children, but it recognises that we all rely on there being a next generation and that everyone should contribute to the cost of creating that generation." Mr Morland said the country should spend money collected from the childless tax to fix the UK's "broken, expensive early-years care system".

It seems that nearly everybody disagrees with his solution of a "childless tax" and there are many good reasons stated earlier in the thread. One I haven't seen mentioned is childhood death - "I'm sorry you child has died, but you're now going to have to pay the childless tax".

It is a bad solution - but I think the underlying problem is real. Countries where the birth rate is low do need to incentivise parenthood, and fix the broken, expensive early-years care system. The only way we can do this is through the tax and benefits system. Again many good suggestions have already been posted. Another one I would like to see is that mothers with very young children (say up to 4yo) should have their student loans frozen (with no interest added) or even have amounts credited to their loan account from the state.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 16:22

In time areas of the globe will become inhabitable we may well welcome lower population growth to accommodate more people

I don't think anyone is saying lower population is a bad thing are they?

So in the 10 yrs between 2009 & 2019 population in the UK increased by 7% overall. However the number of 65s & older increased by 23%, around 2m more. And over 85s have green by 16%.

Bloodyel · 04/07/2022 16:20

Punishing people who are already heavily punished by multiple recessions. Clearly thr birth rate raises when people have more money and it falls when they have less. Literally even the most stupid people know this so why doesn't whoever is suggesting this absurd idea?

GemmaEdKitten · 04/07/2022 16:20

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:00

I think it’s a good idea. We all depend on there being a younger generation. We are all f**ked if there is no younger generation and that’s the direction we’re heading in.

At the moment it’s those having children who are overwhelmingly funding the existence of the next generation even though we all benefit from it.

I also agree with educating women about having children earlier in life. I’m always gob smacked by the number who wait until they’re in their 40s. Mumsnet is full of women asking if they’re too old to have kids at 40 something and they will always be reassured by lots of people who have friends who had babies in their 40s. But this is totally misleading. Often it’s not their 1st, often they’ve had to go through hell to have that baby (think several rounds of IVF), and nobody tells you about the thousands of women who did leave it until they were in the 40s only to discover it’s never going to happen for them. Only this week I was speaking to a friend in her mid 40s who has given up hope after multiple rounds of IVF and a horribly late term miscarriage. We need to stop lying to women and telling them they can have it all.

I medically can't have kids, what's your answer to that?

Gymnopedie · 04/07/2022 16:20

Is the idea that people who otherwise wouldn't have children will do so to avoid paying extra tax, rather than to encourage people who already have DCs to have more and get more money?
Either way it's bonkers.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/07/2022 16:17

Ducksinthebath · Today 14:16
Arguably those without children are already paying for so many services they don’t use (maternity care, schools, nursery hours) that this really does add insult to injury.

I was thinking this too.

I also wonder about house prices- how can children be born if their parents cannot even afford a home? Foreign. Non resident buyers using houses and flats as investments, and multiple home owners should maybe be curbed. 000s need to be knocked off rents so people sell their extra homes.

How do other European countries provide more affordable nurseries?

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 16:17

The obvious answer is immigration, but of course it’s not necessarily an ‘easy solution’ that is without its own issues.

It's not exactly popular is it?!

Antarcticant · 04/07/2022 16:17

Just some goady idiot putting forth a bonkers idea to generate self-publicity.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 16:15

Women with my condition can technically have children (although due to a combination of things I can't.)

However, women with my condition often have 10+ miscarriages before they actually have a successful birth.

Can you imagine a law that encourages you to go through 10+ miscarriages? How barbaric is that.

zingally · 04/07/2022 16:14

Looks like another attempt by a right-wing man to police women's bodies... He can fuck all the way off.

Fluffycloudland77 · 04/07/2022 16:14

Surely if less are born less will live to old age and it’ll even out?

Queenoftheashes · 04/07/2022 16:12

And I do want children but there’s no great outcome for me in terms of having it all. It’s going to be a pita to juggle everything or just lose my career. I can see why you’d not want to bother.

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 16:11

Children are only children for a relatively short time, if you want a generation that you will interact with to be educated and relatively stable then taxes are required for the good of society.

I think many pay quite high tax amounts, without too much bother (if they are PAYE that is) although ask anyone on tax spectrum and they’d probably like to pay less as is human nature - bar the odd mner who’d apparently like to pay more ;

But if you pay the same rate whether you have dc or not at least there’s no distinction. I have dc and the thought of taxing those without more makes me mad. It’s far too unfair and I also don’t agree with the outcome that it’s pushing.

Queenoftheashes · 04/07/2022 16:11

I’d have had children by now if it wasn’t for lack of interest from my partner. Go sort the men out. They are way less keen than the average woman in my experience.

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 16:10

CredibilityProblem · 04/07/2022 15:59

Women aren't choosing to have fewer babies just because the current UK government are a shower of shit.

All over the world, wherever infant mortality is low and women have the right to education and self-determination, fertility levels are dropping below replacement levels. Loads of countries which are on paper more family friendly than the UK have lower birth rates.The only European country with higher that replacement fertility levels is the Faroe Islands. If we wanted to increase fertility rates here we'd need to a) subsidise child care like the Danes and Swedes b) give massive tax breaks like the French (though probably not describe them as extra tax on the childless).

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependencies_by_total_fertility_rate

I agree. As someone said above, trying to increase the birthrate in advanced Western nations is like holding back the tide. Even in those Nordic countries with excellent state funded maternity leave and childcare facilities, birth rates are pretty low. Even in more conservative regions like the Middle East, where quite recently women often had nearly 7 children on average, birthrates are declining as women get access to education and careers.

Give women the choice, and they will choose to have fewer children. If any. That is true pretty much everywhere in the world. An extra tax isn't going to change that.

ReviewingTheSituation · 04/07/2022 16:09

What a load of old twaddle.

People without children are already over-taxed by paying for education and health services that they will never use (as in they won't have children who use them). I'm not for a moment suggesting that people without children should pay less income tax before I'm misconstrued, but they definitely shouldn't pay any more!

LonelyInAutumn · 04/07/2022 16:08

I think taxes need to be invested into remediation of contaminated land, that would greatly help the housing crisis.

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/07/2022 16:08

Utter madness.

we need to stop our reliance on endless supply of cheap labour, start using the resources we have properly instead of keeping millions underemployed and relying on state handouts.

also, population increase puts intolerable pressure on the environment and the quality of life of everyone.

have fewer children and employ reasonably is the answer.

Londonbabyland · 04/07/2022 16:06

It's not a new idea. Childlessness tax was in place in USSR before USSR collapsed and fertility rates were significantly higher. Importantly, maternity leave was also up to 6 years (unpaid after one but with the place secured).
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_on_childlessness

FOTB · 04/07/2022 16:06

Go to America and get raped. Find yourself unable to access healthcare because abortion is illegal there, and no one wants to help you, lest they inadvertently commit a crime.

Return to the UK. Have an abortion later than you would like, because you had to fly back to the UK to have it done.

Cherry on the top of that awful experience?

Then get taxed for getting rid of a very much unwanted baby.

It feels like the men in the Western world are desperate to reduce women to child-carrying vehicles. Handmaid's Tale, here we come...

AllTheDancers · 04/07/2022 16:05

Sounds like a way to "encourage" women to have children. Theres a lot of this type of thinking around. Many men think that women who won't date them are depriving them of the right to have children.

Might be better forcussing on men who won't settle down or be faithful or good fathers, since creating a society of predominately single mothers might bring its own issues.