Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 16:50

HesterShaw1 · 04/07/2022 16:45

Do you get how absolutely heartless and unempathetic your comment was to someone who clearly absolutely wanted children and couldn't have them.

I have been where you are. It's easy and natural to take every last utterance people with children make completely personally. But there was nothing that the poster you quoted said that isn't true - having children costs a fortune. People who say "all they need is love" are wrong.

That reply to that comment was horrific.

That comment was personal. It was a comment to a poster who said they were desperately sad they couldn't have children. To which another poster replied to them specifically and personally that at least they would be richer.

If it had been a general comment on the thread then that's one thing. But to a person directly, no thats heartless and unempathetic and very very personal.

EL8888 · 04/07/2022 16:49

@Ducksinthebath quite. People with no children don’t use lots of services but still end up paying for them indirectly

I have had 2 failed rounds of IVF so would l get discount, as l have tried quite hard to have children?!

AllTheDancers · 04/07/2022 16:48

Kinsters · 04/07/2022 16:36

I don't understand why immigration isn't more widely accepted as the obvious answer to an aging population. I live in Malaysia and they have a specific visa for domestic workers from specified lower income countries, you can sponsor a domestic worker if you've got young kids or are elderly.

Possibly because we don't want to exploit people from low income countries and try to control immigration by ensuring its for legitimate reasons?

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 16:47

Dancingwithhyenas · 04/07/2022 16:39

I think it’s really interesting idea to encourage our society to think very differently about children.

Would you also think it was an interesting idea to ban abortion to raise child birth rates

Would you also think it was an interesting idea to enforce arranged marriages to raise child birth rates

Would you also think it was an interesting idea to stop women from working to raise child birth rates

Would you also think it was an interesting idea to ban contraception to raise child birth rates

Would you also think it was an interesting idea to ban homosexuality to raise child birth rates (plenty of children before have been born to women who would not otherwise have had them because they had no choice but to marry)

Would you also think it was an interesting idea if parents were forced to adopt children who were abandoned because of some of the above practices?

Would you think it was an interesting idea if fertile poor women were forced to become surrogates for rich childless couples to avoid this tax?

Or is it just when it only impacts childless people and not the rest of the population its an interesting idea?

Phrenologistsfinger · 04/07/2022 16:45

@Dancingwithhyenas and would taxing disabled people more also not be an ‘interesting idea’? They cost society. The elderly have assets (as a class) are expensive and economically useless, let’s tax them too. Do need an ‘interesting rethink’ about our elderly as they are at the other end of our demographic bulge?

FGS, it is terrifying that anyone is taking this even remotely seriously.

HesterShaw1 · 04/07/2022 16:45

Do you get how absolutely heartless and unempathetic your comment was to someone who clearly absolutely wanted children and couldn't have them.

I have been where you are. It's easy and natural to take every last utterance people with children make completely personally. But there was nothing that the poster you quoted said that isn't true - having children costs a fortune. People who say "all they need is love" are wrong.

tillytown · 04/07/2022 16:43

None of my group of friends have kids, not because they can't or don't want them, its because none of us can afford our own homes, none of us earn enough, and none of us have jobs that would let us be able to actually parent a child. And most importantly, they know that if they broke up with the childs father they would be completely fucked over with child support and wouldn't be able to feed the kid. Fix housing, fix the cost of living, fix the work until you die culture, and fix how you support single parents, and then you'll get more babies.

riesenrad · 04/07/2022 16:43

Fluffycloudland77 · 04/07/2022 16:14

Surely if less are born less will live to old age and it’ll even out?

Yes it will. There may be a couple of messy decades where we have more elderly than young, but with the climate emergency we are going to have that anyway.

GCRich · 04/07/2022 16:43

Traveller3367 · 04/07/2022 13:45

That article is extreme and I don't agree with the concept but there needs to be an acknowledgement of the importance of having children and a next generation. Having children seems to be viewed as a selfish act. It's as if so many people think they are doing the world a favour by not having kids because of over population and climate change but then what happens when there aren't enough young people to work and pay taxes? Society collapses!
I do think nurturing the future generations should have more importance in the narrative of society

Erm - immigration can be used to fill the gap!

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 04/07/2022 16:43

What crap - there are all kinds of reasons why people don't have kids. My DiL has brittle diabetes and is certainly not well enough to get pregnant. So I'll have no grandchildren, to have children for her would be extremely irresponsible.
What about those who cannot have children?

SleepSleepRaveAsleep · 04/07/2022 16:42

I think they need to improve things for working parents, so better maternity/paternity pay, parental leave and of course cheaper childcare. I've no idea where this money would come from though? Taxing people who don't have children isn't the the answer, could you imagine the outcry if someone was gay and paying more tax because they dont have children, can't see it going down well!

WeAreTheHeroes · 04/07/2022 16:41

Surely this would disproportionately affect gay couples and is therefore discriminatory?

It's a bonkers idea to penalise those who don't have children, whatever the reason they are childless.

Emotionalsupportviper · 04/07/2022 16:41

Not everyone is childless by choice.

Some people can't have children. Others may have lost their child/ children - this is just cruel.

Dancingwithhyenas · 04/07/2022 16:39

I think it’s really interesting idea to encourage our society to think very differently about children.

Phrenologistsfinger · 04/07/2022 16:37

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 14:56

I've already paid over 20k for IVF thanks, unless I get a refund I think I did my bit to try to get pregnant

One of the reasons for the abortion rate shooting up, specifically in the 30+ women who already have children demographic was due to austerity and limiting child benefits to 2 children. The government have specifically driven down the birth rate, not childless/child free people

I already pay taxes for childcare subsidies., maternity fees etc etc. In fact I am likely already taxed more than parents because I will never take time out, work part time etc because of children

I actually have no issue with tax going up to subsidise childcare, I think its ridiculous that parents are placed in a situation where you need two incomes to survive but fill time child care costs as much if not more than one of those incomes in many places, I just don't see why my deformed uterus means I have to pay more for it

My uterus has a congenital abnormality. We could just as easily decide to tax all people with autism higher amounts, because autism can be genetic and their children might need more 121 time at school so the tax could go towards school care. Or blind people could contribute a higher tax towards public transport etc.

But fuck you the people who are saying its not a silver bullet but an idea or not to get emotional about it. I will get as emotional as I fucking want about the fact I am devastated I can't have children and now some prick has decided that means I need to be taxed more.

I'm pretty sure those same people would be up in arms if the article has suggested parents get taxed more because their children cost the state more.

Exactly! We’ve spent £50k on IVF, soon to be £60k. It’s not for want of fvckkng trying that we don’t have kids!

IT’S NOT A CHOICE TO BE CHILDLESS!

Kinsters · 04/07/2022 16:36

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 16:17

The obvious answer is immigration, but of course it’s not necessarily an ‘easy solution’ that is without its own issues.

It's not exactly popular is it?!

I don't understand why immigration isn't more widely accepted as the obvious answer to an aging population. I live in Malaysia and they have a specific visa for domestic workers from specified lower income countries, you can sponsor a domestic worker if you've got young kids or are elderly.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 16:35

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 16:26

I don’t know where you got that impression from. I don’t regret it for a second. But I would be lying if I didn’t say I would be financially much, much better off without them. I would be working full time in a better paying job and I wouldn’t have spent £50k on nursery fees over 3 years.

Do you get how absolutely heartless and unempathetic your comment was to someone who clearly absolutely wanted children and couldn't have them.

Somethingneedstochange · 04/07/2022 16:34

Clarinet1 · 04/07/2022 14:00

So I have had a lifetime of sadness and sometimes tears at not being able to have children and now somebody is saying I should be financially worse off too?!?!?!?!?

Exactly this.

AllTheDancers · 04/07/2022 16:33

Jycclops It is a bad solution - but I think the underlying problem is real. Countries where the birth rate is low do need to incentivise parenthood, and fix the broken, expensive early-years care system. The only way we can do this is through the tax and benefits system.

Hardly. The biggest reported problem in recent years seems to be a dearth of men wanting to settle down in committed relationships with women who are of child bearing age.

TollgateDebs · 04/07/2022 16:33

I couldn't have children but have paid tax since the age of 17 for the whole of society and often for many services I will never need to access, but that's the point of tax. Why the hell are we demonising groups in society and why are we not looking at where what we are already spending is going. Care for all groups should never be about profit! The assumption that children will benefit us in the future is based on what? Surely it depends on the adult the child grows in to? Lazy journalism and I could say that we should tax stupidity in society, as that would make us a bloody fortune given what is being spouted as 'wisdom' currently from so many!

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 16:32

jcyclops · 04/07/2022 16:23

He suggested that in order to incentivise parenthood, a tax should be created to be put on those without children. The Oxford University demographer said: "This may seem unfair on those who can’t or won’t have children, but it recognises that we all rely on there being a next generation and that everyone should contribute to the cost of creating that generation." Mr Morland said the country should spend money collected from the childless tax to fix the UK's "broken, expensive early-years care system".

It seems that nearly everybody disagrees with his solution of a "childless tax" and there are many good reasons stated earlier in the thread. One I haven't seen mentioned is childhood death - "I'm sorry you child has died, but you're now going to have to pay the childless tax".

It is a bad solution - but I think the underlying problem is real. Countries where the birth rate is low do need to incentivise parenthood, and fix the broken, expensive early-years care system. The only way we can do this is through the tax and benefits system. Again many good suggestions have already been posted. Another one I would like to see is that mothers with very young children (say up to 4yo) should have their student loans frozen (with no interest added) or even have amounts credited to their loan account from the state.

Oh wow I hadn't even considered the dead child scenario, I assumed that it would be taxed until you had a child regardless.

It would be a conundrum for the forced birth brigade though wont it who also want to control women's bodies. Life beings at conception unless we want to tax you for it.

dreamingofsun · 04/07/2022 16:30

A better incentive would be to provide somewhere for youngsters to live. If you cant find/afford anywhere without kids you will have no chance with kids. More housing needs to be built and priority given to current residents of the uk. My kids are graduates in professional jobs and they still cant get anywhere

Londonbabyland · 04/07/2022 16:29

@Queenoftheashes and add to that the unpaid child maintenance (around half a billion owed to mums in UK), so definitely a man's problem!

Shamoo · 04/07/2022 16:27

What a ridiculous idea. Fucking morons. I’m so fed up with people being so stupid.

Do we start paying at 18 and only stop when we give birth? Whilst we also demonise single parents? Do I get all my money back if I have a baby at 42? What age does the tax stop and how does that work given people have children at totally different ages and so would pay for different periods.

Do I pay less because I have a job that I couldn’t possibly have if I had had children earlier and the consequence of that is that I pay an absolute fuck tonne of tax every year. I also get zero child benefit for the child I do now have, because I’m very well paid, because I didn’t have kids until gone 40.

People without children already overpay tax comparatively because they take less out of the system.

How are they dealing with step children and people who don’t have children because they take on their partner’s kids.

So stupid.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 16:26

grown by 16%.

An average 85 yr old costs the NHS 5.6 times more than a 30 yr old & a 65 yr old twice as much.

The impact of this is stalling life expectancy as pension ages increases. Like I said we are going to have to pay a lot more tax or get less care & grow old in poverty.