Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 17:19

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:00

Exactly, if anything we want to discourage birth rates long term (and that’s what’s predicted) because the forecasts are that we don’t have the environment to support this many people at this level of resource consumption. That’s also the reason a childless tax is highly unlikely.

You’ll get short termist politicians trying to prop it up with less overt taxes and policies but if they were after a quick solution to the population burden they’d be looking at reducing the bulge before they hit retirement not the bottom.

I agree with this but hope we do not get short term politics around this, especially anything as suggested in op

But what do you mean by reducing the bulge? Are we taking people out ;

Oh I don’t think there’ll be any ‘quietening’ or anything, but if I was given to conspiracy I’d guess the state of the NHS doesn’t come without a silver lining.

I suspect there’ll be a lot of conversations initiated about quality vs quantity when it comes to longevity along with the widely expected rises in retirement ages shortening the length of time someone is economically inactive at the end of their lives (tbf there was an extraordinary length of time between rises in pension ages whilst life expectancy was rising).

I’m not against euthanasia with a hell of a lot of conditions attached and I suspect that it’ll become a regular point of debate in coming decades. Most people want to reach old age but it’s almost always accompanied with an unspoken caveat of decent health which sadly isn’t the case for lots of people.

LaurieFairyCake · 04/07/2022 17:18

All of our demands for a workforce can be met by immigration

It's a lovely (selfish) act to have children but we don't NEED them apart from our individual emotional urges

LaurieFairyCake · 04/07/2022 17:17

We don't need to have children

CounsellorTroi · 04/07/2022 17:16

I think the reason why my SIL is pregnant and I am not has less to do with our individual financial situations. Its because Israel is a much more tribal society and they celebrate families and children. The UK is much more individualistic and this influences our decisions.

Israel is the most pronatalist country on earth. Women are under enormous pressure to have children. Those who don’t are nothing. The book Regretting Motherhood by Orna Donath features mainlyIsrarli women and is an eye opening read.

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 17:15

Just to add, even if lots of couples started having lots of babies now, it would be 19 years before the first of them would enter the workforce.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 17:09

Phobiaphobic · 04/07/2022 17:07

We're about to enter a time when AI and robotics will replace huge numbers of jobs across all kinds of areas. That means a lot of people without work. We need to start making care jobs far more lucrative and attractive.

I'm assuming care work will go one of two ways

More people go into it because of a lack of other jobs due to ai and robotics

Or we get care robots who look after us

Maybe a mix of both

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:08

CaptainSensiblesRedBeret · 04/07/2022 17:05

As if a telegram from the Queen is going to motivate me to have children 😆😆😆

Just to remind you one’s grandchildren have all the privileges possible to make child bearing and raising easy could you be a good subject and do the same and have more 😀

Phobiaphobic · 04/07/2022 17:07

OperaStation · 04/07/2022 14:25

Yes, all of those things need to be funded and will always need to be funded. How do you propose that works when our working age population is massively depleted because of years of low birth rates? What we can afford to pay for via taxes will be massively depleted. Who will pay for hospitals and social care?

I’m not saying this idea is a silver bullet but it’s a sensible idea. We can’t just bury our heads in the sand.

We're about to enter a time when AI and robotics will replace huge numbers of jobs across all kinds of areas. That means a lot of people without work. We need to start making care jobs far more lucrative and attractive.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 17:06

FrippEnos · 04/07/2022 17:03

I would be ok with this if those that had children were then taxed when the child leaves home.

Its simple three kids.
When the first leaves home your tax goes up.
same with the second
and then with the third.

Its only fair because you are no longer supporting your children and should be putting more money into society because you no longer have children to pay for.

Let the flaming commence :)

See this is closer to what I proposed. So instead of people without children getting taxed more than people with children, give those with children a lower tax burden from when they have children until the children are a certain age.

But personally I think 18 is too late. If the exception is to cover the horrific cost of childcare then surely it is only needed until childcare is no longer needed e.g. school holiday, warp around care etc.

ScrollingLeaves · 04/07/2022 17:06

Also here men especially don’t always want commitment.

As someone posted earlier about Israel, in some countries there is generally more value added to the idea of having a family.

CaptainSensiblesRedBeret · 04/07/2022 17:05

As if a telegram from the Queen is going to motivate me to have children 😆😆😆

FrippEnos · 04/07/2022 17:03

I would be ok with this if those that had children were then taxed when the child leaves home.

Its simple three kids.
When the first leaves home your tax goes up.
same with the second
and then with the third.

Its only fair because you are no longer supporting your children and should be putting more money into society because you no longer have children to pay for.

Let the flaming commence :)

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 17:03

You know what would encourage women to have more children:

A working CMS system which means men can't essentially stop paying for their children
Cheaper and more secure housing
Better childcare provision
Better paternity leave
Flexible jobs that encourage parents of both sexes to have the flexibility to do school drop offs and pick ups etc
Less zero hours jobs with all the instability they bring
No gender pay gap

Do you know what wont encourage women to have children:

Taxing them from 18 or whenever so they have even less chance of getting secure housing, even less chance of saving to adequately support themselves during their maternity leave
Making it easier for men to be more financially secure by having children (by avoiding tax) whilst still not making it harder for them to escape paying for those children

Also chillingly
Given how low the rape conviction rate is
And how some rapists are successfully managing to get access to children granted that are a result of the rape

Any tax that incentivises having children could easily lead to an increase in rape against women of child bearing age

MercurialMonday · 04/07/2022 17:00

Exactly, if anything we want to discourage birth rates long term (and that’s what’s predicted) because the forecasts are that we don’t have the environment to support this many people at this level of resource consumption.

Ideally they want a slower slump down - so decreasing but at slower rate bit TBH Europe will probably get by with immigration even with the associated problems it will just take time to get that widely accepted.

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:00

Exactly, if anything we want to discourage birth rates long term (and that’s what’s predicted) because the forecasts are that we don’t have the environment to support this many people at this level of resource consumption. That’s also the reason a childless tax is highly unlikely.

You’ll get short termist politicians trying to prop it up with less overt taxes and policies but if they were after a quick solution to the population burden they’d be looking at reducing the bulge before they hit retirement not the bottom.

I agree with this but hope we do not get short term politics around this, especially anything as suggested in op

But what do you mean by reducing the bulge? Are we taking people out ;

sparechange · 04/07/2022 16:59

Emotionalsupportviper · 04/07/2022 16:41

Not everyone is childless by choice.

Some people can't have children. Others may have lost their child/ children - this is just cruel.

I had to have 11 rounds of IVF to have DS1, with several losses along the way including one still birth

Understandably, my mental health was absolutely shredded at several points

I think being taxed as a childless selfish non-member of society would have pushed me over the edge
Not to mention seriously compromised my ability to pay for my IVF…

carefullycourageous · 04/07/2022 16:56

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 16:55

So taxing people who are infertile?
Taxing those who know they should not have children and so do not?
Sounds a very poorly thought out idea.

Maybe they will allow people who are infertile to get an exemption, a bit like they do with those who have a third child following rape.

This whole idea is disgusting.

MercurialMonday · 04/07/2022 16:55

https://www.newstatesman.com/comment/2022/07/why-the-birth-rate-is-falling

But there’s something more specific to the UK happening, too. For the last few years, the number of women who don’t have kids by their 30th birthday has climbed steadily. But the number who don’t have them by 45 — the point at which the ONS says, in a phrase unnervingly reminiscent of Kazuo Ishiguro’s Never Let Me Go, women “complete childbearing” — has remained fairly flat since the early 2000s. The obvious reading of this data is that women are leaving it later to have children; having fewer kids and a lower national fertility rate are the inevitable results.

Why would they be doing this? This is where we get to the easy question I mentioned: because having a child requires both money and stability, and for more than a decade now the entire world seems to have been conspiring to deny the under-40s either. Since 2007 this country and its economy has rolled from crisis to crisis: the crash, the recession, austerity, the next recession brought about by austerity, Brexit, the pandemic, another recession (a really big one this time) exacerbated by the war in Ukraine. Anyone under 35 has never known the good times.

What they have known, though, is an economy in which wages barely rise, a huge pile of debt if they’re a graduate and a housing market in which the only way to attain secure housing is to buy but the only way of buying is to inherit money, move a long way from the best jobs markets or, preferably, both. Throw in the cost of childcare, often compared to a second mortgage — which, given the size of mortgages these days, is no small deal — and the whole venture seems prohibitively, terrifyingly expensive.

Basically this ^^ and nothing will be done as it's too big and hard.

We're a decade older but got hit badly in 2007 and had been struggling before then due to getting on housing ladder by ourselves no inheritance and having kids relatively young DH was 30. We had our last just before and it was mainly dire and dangerous maternity care that put us off more a lack of job security and housing played a role as well.

Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 16:55

riesenrad · 04/07/2022 16:43

Yes it will. There may be a couple of messy decades where we have more elderly than young, but with the climate emergency we are going to have that anyway.

Exactly, if anything we want to discourage birth rates long term (and that’s what’s predicted) because the forecasts are that we don’t have the environment to support this many people at this level of resource consumption. That’s also the reason a childless tax is highly unlikely.

You’ll get short termist politicians trying to prop it up with less overt taxes and policies but if they were after a quick solution to the population burden they’d be looking at reducing the bulge before they hit retirement not the bottom.

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 16:55

So taxing people who are infertile?
Taxing those who know they should not have children and so do not?
Sounds a very poorly thought out idea.

carefullycourageous · 04/07/2022 16:54

riesenrad · 04/07/2022 16:43

Yes it will. There may be a couple of messy decades where we have more elderly than young, but with the climate emergency we are going to have that anyway.

It would take ages and be really very grim until it does.

onthefencesitter · 04/07/2022 16:53

*quite common for secular israeli women to have 3 children...

carefullycourageous · 04/07/2022 16:52

CraftyGin · 04/07/2022 13:51

Childless adults don't get child benefits, so that a bit like a reverse tax.

Confused childless adults don't have the costs involved in raising a child so don't need the benefit.
Not receiving a benefit is nothing like a 'reverse tax'.

onthefencesitter · 04/07/2022 16:52

onthefencesitter · 04/07/2022 16:52

my SIL in Israel is renting and she is pregnant with her first DC. Indeed the housing crisis in Israel is even more serious than in the UK (it is much more expensive and private renting is also precarious; you need a 30% deposit to buy in israel etc). Indeed the birth rate in israel is the highest in the OECD; its quite common for secular israeli women with careers to have children. Childcare provision is much better and the child benefits are better, but life is still expensive so I would not say that it is child friendly esp from a finances perspective.

my DH and I live in London and own our flat and probably on a higher household income, but we are still waiting despite being happily married for 8 years (I am 30 this year) cos I plan to upgrade in the next few years and want to do so without a child being factored in the affordability criteria.

I think the reason why my SIL is pregnant and I am not has less to do with our individual financial situations. Its because Israel is a much more tribal society and they celebrate families and children. The UK is much more individualistic and this influences our decisions.

This is an excerpt from an article:

'But while elsewhere in the West, middle-class families might limit the number of children they have because of the cost of raising them, in Israel that rationale is heard less frequently.
Ron Ganot, who was selling collapsible, lightweight wagons for children at the BabyLand event, says he and his wife are expecting their third child. Family is central to his life, he says, and he gets together every week with relatives.
“We definitely need more money, and we have rising expenses,” he says, “but I want a large family and the cost of living won’t stop us.”

onthefencesitter · 04/07/2022 16:52

tillytown · 04/07/2022 16:43

None of my group of friends have kids, not because they can't or don't want them, its because none of us can afford our own homes, none of us earn enough, and none of us have jobs that would let us be able to actually parent a child. And most importantly, they know that if they broke up with the childs father they would be completely fucked over with child support and wouldn't be able to feed the kid. Fix housing, fix the cost of living, fix the work until you die culture, and fix how you support single parents, and then you'll get more babies.

my SIL in Israel is renting and she is pregnant with her first DC. Indeed the housing crisis in Israel is even more serious than in the UK (it is much more expensive and private renting is also precarious; you need a 30% deposit to buy in israel etc). Indeed the birth rate in israel is the highest in the OECD; its quite common for secular israeli women with careers to have children. Childcare provision is much better and the child benefits are better, but life is still expensive so I would not say that it is child friendly esp from a finances perspective.

my DH and I live in London and own our flat and probably on a higher household income, but we are still waiting despite being happily married for 8 years (I am 30 this year) cos I plan to upgrade in the next few years and want to do so without a child being factored in the affordability criteria.

I think the reason why my SIL is pregnant and I am not has less to do with our individual financial situations. Its because Israel is a much more tribal society and they celebrate families and children. The UK is much more individualistic and this influences our decisions.

This is an excerpt from an article: