Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
chiffchaffchiff · 04/07/2022 17:53

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 17:44

All of our demands for a workforce can be met by immigration

Are you immigrant? I think it's a bit offensive when people just assume immigrants (who are often demonised) are desperate to come & meet "our" needs. Like ai said the UK will be in competition with other countries who also desperately need immigrants so immigrants will hold more of the power. why will the immigrants want to leave their counties in the future? I think we will see increased migration from the UK to other countries as young people will have better opportunities elsewhere. i'm very grateful my dc have dual citizenship

I'm not the OP but I'm an immigrant and I have been here for years. Not sure I want to stay if they're going to punish me for being childless though.

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:49

I did move to the U.K. and my parents and family have done various moves so we’re quite mobile - not hugely but do tend to make big moves once

So I don’t see it as too bad - London was a huge pull for many of us

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:47

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 17:44

All of our demands for a workforce can be met by immigration

Are you immigrant? I think it's a bit offensive when people just assume immigrants (who are often demonised) are desperate to come & meet "our" needs. Like ai said the UK will be in competition with other countries who also desperately need immigrants so immigrants will hold more of the power. why will the immigrants want to leave their counties in the future? I think we will see increased migration from the UK to other countries as young people will have better opportunities elsewhere. i'm very grateful my dc have dual citizenship

Climate change will be a push

Countries that get more unbearable will cause shifts

whumpthereitis · 04/07/2022 17:47

AffIt · 04/07/2022 17:44

This.

I feel nothing but sympathy for those who want children and can't have them, but I don't have children because I don't want children: there is no amount of money you could pay me that would change my mind.

I find the notion that I'm some kind of incubator that could be bought as more than a little offensive.

Yep. The idea that because someone freely made the choice not to have children means they should be penalized for it isn’t exactly an attractive one either.

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 17:46

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

Does that include the infertile?

Does it include those who chose not to have children because they didn't want to pass on various illnesses, including mental ill health?

Childless adults are already disadvantaged by the system we have. They pay just as much into the system as parents but get very little back. Childless working adults heavily subsidise single parents working part time on top up benefits. Probably not a popular fact to point out on mumsnet 😂

If anything, childless adults should pay less tax.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 17:44

All of our demands for a workforce can be met by immigration

Are you immigrant? I think it's a bit offensive when people just assume immigrants (who are often demonised) are desperate to come & meet "our" needs. Like ai said the UK will be in competition with other countries who also desperately need immigrants so immigrants will hold more of the power. why will the immigrants want to leave their counties in the future? I think we will see increased migration from the UK to other countries as young people will have better opportunities elsewhere. i'm very grateful my dc have dual citizenship

AffIt · 04/07/2022 17:44

Sofadog · 04/07/2022 17:27

Really uncomfortable with some of the comments on here that seem to suggest it would be more unfair to do this to people who can’t but have tried to have children. As if somehow just having this for people making a conscious choice is ok. Once again pedalling the narrative that people who choose not to have children are somehow worth less in society. It’s a shitty idea for everyone that would be affected.

This.

I feel nothing but sympathy for those who want children and can't have them, but I don't have children because I don't want children: there is no amount of money you could pay me that would change my mind.

I find the notion that I'm some kind of incubator that could be bought as more than a little offensive.

whumpthereitis · 04/07/2022 17:42

Sofadog · 04/07/2022 17:27

Really uncomfortable with some of the comments on here that seem to suggest it would be more unfair to do this to people who can’t but have tried to have children. As if somehow just having this for people making a conscious choice is ok. Once again pedalling the narrative that people who choose not to have children are somehow worth less in society. It’s a shitty idea for everyone that would be affected.

Those that choose not to have children often have more disposable income, and there will always be those resentful of this and seek to ‘right’ it. It’s usually the same ones that present their having children as being a selfless sacrifice they made on behalf of society.

carefullycourageous · 04/07/2022 17:41

I’m not against euthanasia with a hell of a lot of conditions attached and I suspect that it’ll become a regular point of debate in coming decades. Most people want to reach old age but it’s almost always accompanied with an unspoken caveat of decent health which sadly isn’t the case for lots of people. Hopefully you mean voluntary euthanasia. Involuntary euthansia is just murder with a posher name.

iBrows · 04/07/2022 17:41

What a shit idea. It would obviously affect men, but would disproportionately affect women who take the risks when it comes to having children.

LegInLegOut · 04/07/2022 17:41

Bloody hell.
Sorry that you can't have children Ms Smith, however I'm sure it will help your heartache to give up some of your wages to help those who can.
It's outrageous! For some it's not a lifestyle choice.
I don't smoke, never have. Should I pay a percentage of my wages towards those who do to help fund their choice?
Shame on that man and on anyone who agrees with him!

XenoBitch · 04/07/2022 17:39

Are childless men going to be taxed too? What if a man finds out that he fathered a child that he knew nothing about... will he get a rebate?
What if a man found out the kid he thought was his, was actually someone elses.... would he have to pay up a lump sum?
Or is it all only going to apply to women? (which I bet is what the person suggesting this is getting at).
It is just a horrible idea all round.

wannabeamummysobad · 04/07/2022 17:38

CraftyGin · 04/07/2022 13:51

Childless adults don't get child benefits, so that a bit like a reverse tax.

Neither do high earners with children

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 17:37

I’m not against euthanasia with a hell of a lot of conditions attached and I suspect that it’ll become a regular point of debate in coming decades. Most people want to reach old age but it’s almost always accompanied with an unspoken caveat of decent health which sadly isn’t the case for lots of people.

That's the flip side isn't it. More people working till they drop, no retirement & euthanasia

Blossomtoes · 04/07/2022 17:37

Spot on @carefullycourageous.

RJnomore1 · 04/07/2022 17:35

This is a jaw droppingly awful idea!

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:33

Sofadog · 04/07/2022 17:27

Really uncomfortable with some of the comments on here that seem to suggest it would be more unfair to do this to people who can’t but have tried to have children. As if somehow just having this for people making a conscious choice is ok. Once again pedalling the narrative that people who choose not to have children are somehow worth less in society. It’s a shitty idea for everyone that would be affected.

You are right. It’s unfair for anyone without dc regardless

carefullycourageous · 04/07/2022 17:33

Sofadog · 04/07/2022 17:27

Really uncomfortable with some of the comments on here that seem to suggest it would be more unfair to do this to people who can’t but have tried to have children. As if somehow just having this for people making a conscious choice is ok. Once again pedalling the narrative that people who choose not to have children are somehow worth less in society. It’s a shitty idea for everyone that would be affected.

I don't think it would be OK for anyone, I disagree with that stupid marriage tax allowance, I would disagree with this because I am a liberal.

It is also obviously stupid because either it will be tokenistic, in which case it will have no impact, or it will be financially meaningful, in which case you will encourage unsuitable people to have children which will cost a fortune to resolve when they end up injured/in care/badly educated.

I am old enough to remember when having a baby to get a council house* was a bad thing. Now having a baby to get a tax break is a good thing?

*I don't subscribe to this myth, btw.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 04/07/2022 17:31

I'm pretty sure that Ceausescu did something similar in the 1970s.

A natalist policy isn't a desirable policy. (massive understatement there)

MarshaBradyo · 04/07/2022 17:31

'There is no reason this has to be done by a human' apart from the fact that lack of human contact is soul-destroyingly lonely.

True. It was bad enough for the pandemic. We saw the devastating effect on people isolating in care homes or shut in cells 23 hours a day. Inhumane at the time so we’d need more than robots.

carefullycourageous · 04/07/2022 17:28

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 17:20

We will get care robots helping with some things. So a robot could easily have compartments for medication and have an alarm when a compartment opens for someone to take their next medication. As long as someone can physically pick up and swallow the medication, and has the cognitive ability to understand they need to do this, there is no reason why this has to be done by a human.

But some things like changing an incontinent adult would probably require a very sophisticated robot that would just be too expensive. I think the aim will be to reduce the number of care visits by a human to people living at home through AI.

'There is no reason this has to be done by a human' apart from the fact that lack of human contact is soul-destroyingly lonely. Modern 'care' is already awful. Remove the humans it gets even worse.

Sofadog · 04/07/2022 17:27

Really uncomfortable with some of the comments on here that seem to suggest it would be more unfair to do this to people who can’t but have tried to have children. As if somehow just having this for people making a conscious choice is ok. Once again pedalling the narrative that people who choose not to have children are somehow worth less in society. It’s a shitty idea for everyone that would be affected.

Cornettoninja · 04/07/2022 17:23

FrippEnos · 04/07/2022 17:03

I would be ok with this if those that had children were then taxed when the child leaves home.

Its simple three kids.
When the first leaves home your tax goes up.
same with the second
and then with the third.

Its only fair because you are no longer supporting your children and should be putting more money into society because you no longer have children to pay for.

Let the flaming commence :)

This kind of already happens with child benefit/childcare element of UC it’s just distributed differently to what’s being proposed in the link.

Poppy61 · 04/07/2022 17:21

That would be a great way to treat a couple who are having trouble conceiving. Just add insult to misery. Wonderful idea. Really well thought out.

antelopevalley · 04/07/2022 17:20

We will get care robots helping with some things. So a robot could easily have compartments for medication and have an alarm when a compartment opens for someone to take their next medication. As long as someone can physically pick up and swallow the medication, and has the cognitive ability to understand they need to do this, there is no reason why this has to be done by a human.

But some things like changing an incontinent adult would probably require a very sophisticated robot that would just be too expensive. I think the aim will be to reduce the number of care visits by a human to people living at home through AI.