Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tax childless adults

542 replies

Acidburn · 04/07/2022 13:41

Hi all

Just saw the below article on LBC news:

www.lbc.co.uk/news/childless-tax-birthrate-uk-cost-of-living-paul-morland/

AIBU to think that this insane?

OP posts:
FortonServices · 04/07/2022 20:03

@hatchyu

Did you selectively miss this part of my post because it doesn't suit your narrative?

My sis is 45 and single and childless. I'm a single parent of 1. I'm only entitled to child benefit but I'm definitely consuming more (as a household) than she is. My career is ok but it's on hold while DD is small, so I'm not going to get promoted and pay more tax in the short to medium term.

To make it clearer, my sis is indirectly subsidising me and my DD. So she is already paying more tax, as a childless person, to subsidise me as a parent.

bigfootisreal · 04/07/2022 19:40

CounsellorTroi · 04/07/2022 18:21

This is not the case, fertility doesn't wane with age. There is no cliff edge at 35.. There is for some people. Fertility varies.

There isn't, the cliff edge was based on church records in france in 1700s when most women died about 35 hence the sudden drop. New studies show there is no cliff edge. Issues with fertility are largely down to other health factors.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 19:37

Maybe compare a single, working, childless 40 yo female with a 40 yo single mother, working part time, topped up by benefits? Over 20 years the singleton will have paid more tax and consumed less in benefits and services.

But why not compare a working person to a mother on benefits. Not all parents are on benefits & not all single people work & don't receive benefits. I just don't think you can generalise. I don't know any parents who get CB or many who get the 30 hours but that's not representative of all parents.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 19:34

This is a good response & a sensible article on the issue

www.newstatesman.com/quickfire/2022/07/taxing-childless-insult-not-a-solution

Penguinsaregreat · 04/07/2022 19:33

Ridiculous idea and I do have children.
If a woman (and the primary decision lies with women) does not want children then that should be the end of it. I doubt a tiny financial incentive will encourage women to change their mind.
I seriously don’t know how anyone can afford to have children right now.
Its not ideal having a child where both parents are out at work almost all day every day, yet can parents afford to both work part time or be sahp?
Then there is the fact that women will face being a single parent more often then not and again most father’s are not good enough. A great father and husband is a rarity.
I look at my childless by choice friends and they have a fabulous life.

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 19:31

@hatchyu

Maybe compare a single, working, childless 40 yo female with a 40 yo single mother, working part time, topped up by benefits? Over 20 years the singleton will have paid more tax and consumed less in benefits and services.

My sis is 45 and single and childless. I'm a single parent of 1. I'm only entitled to child benefit but I'm definitely consuming more (as a household) than she is. My career is ok but it's on hold while DD is small, so I'm not going to get promoted and pay more tax in the short to medium term. There are many other single parents earning part time min wage, paying very little tax (if any) but consuming a substantial amount in benefits and services. This point won't be popular on mumsnet.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 19:25

I expect that a higher amount of childless people are already paying more tax than those with children anyway.

I googled but couldn't find anything. Did read that fathers earn more than men who aren't fathers & reverse true for mothers.

Certainly in my circle we couldn't afford dc & subsequent childcare if we weren't higher tax payers but this will vary around the country.

The childless also get less in both in and out of work benefits and don't consume as many public funded services.

Surely that's quite difficult to quantify?Obviously it depends on earnings so some parents will earn more than non parents. Also there's a huge amount of unpaid carers (usually women) who support older parents which takes away pressure on the state.

IcedPurple · 04/07/2022 19:14

Like ai said the UK will be in competition with other countries who also desperately need immigrants so immigrants will hold more of the power. why will the immigrants want to leave their counties in the future?

For the same reasons they do now, only more so. To escape poverty, conflict, climate change or persecution.

Many parts of Africa have rapidly growing populations. If they can't provide livelihoods for their people now, prompting huge numbers to leave by whatever means possible, why would they be able to do so in the years to come?

I don't think there will be any shortage of people wanting to immigrate to wealthy European countries any time soon.

Daleksatemyshed · 04/07/2022 19:10

I read this on Sunday with a mounting sense of disbelief. This man may be very educated but he's not living in the real world. I've never had any children by choice but I hear SO much about the stupid amount of money childcare costs, people tying themselves in knots to try and cover school holiday care without spending a fortune, it seems the only people who can afford to have larger families are people like Paul?
And who is he to tell women what they should be doing? If a woman only wants one child, fine, I didn't want any, that's my business, Paul will just have to get over it.
I've always worked and paid taxes and NI, never had maternity leave, free nursery hours, child benefit so why should I pay extra tax because I didn't get those things? Paul, quite frankly, you're a twat

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 19:10

@hatchyu

It would be interesting to see how many of the childless are net contributors, compared with those who have children.

I expect that a higher amount of childless people are already paying more tax than those with children anyway. The childless also get less in both in and out of work benefits and don't consume as many public funded services.

Example - 2 identical houses, 1 occupied by a child free singleton and 1 occupied by a family of 4. The childfree singleton only gets a 25% council tax discount, despite consuming 75% less services.

maddiemookins16mum · 04/07/2022 19:02

thesurrealist · 04/07/2022 18:24

I never wanted children and now I'm nearly 50 I sure as hell ain't going to have one now.
I've also spent nearly 30 years contributing to your children's births, education, healthcare etc. I think I've done my bit. I'm earned the right to have my bum wiped thank you very much.

As it is, if I the unlikely event this disgusting and divisive idea ever comes to fruition then I'll actually take my tax and fuck off to another country where I'm not treated as a second class citizen for not reproducing.

too right.

totallyaddictedtocheese · 04/07/2022 18:57

We are about to have our first child and we are going to struggle so much to live from a single wage and statutory maternity pay. Luckily we have saved enough money to get by but its unlikely we will ever be able to afford a second child. Maybe if the government were a bit more generous with maternity pay then more people would have the option of having children if they wanted to.

Dagnabit · 04/07/2022 18:41

So punish those who can’t have or don’t want children or encourage people to have them to avoid extra tax? WTF? I have 2 children and think it is ludicrous.

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 18:40

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:37

@Threepeonies it's why I quoted the post I responded to which wasn't the OP & if you read my other previous posts I said the idea in the OP was nonsense.

And I have apologised

Its a 4 page long thread, I don't remember everyones name to everyones post.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:37

@Threepeonies it's why I quoted the post I responded to which wasn't the OP & if you read my other previous posts I said the idea in the OP was nonsense.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:36

I don’t think labour shortages are because we are less attractive

So Brexit hasn't had an impact?

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 18:35

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:34

@Threepeonies where did I say the tax the childless was a good idea? I was responding to a point specifically about longer life expectancy but not healthier life expectancy

It looked like you were responding the the whole point of the thread, apologies if you weren't

HandlebarLadyTash · 04/07/2022 18:34

It's an opinion.
The childless already pay enough tax.
I couldn't afford to have more children & with hindsight I would have stopped at 1, which would have allowed be a chance of some pension saving.
The largest expenditures in the UK need looking at firts starting with affordable secure housing.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:34

@Threepeonies where did I say the tax the childless was a good idea? I was responding to a point specifically about longer life expectancy but not healthier life expectancy

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:32

I'm earned the right to have my bum wiped thank you very much.

By you of course!

Threepeonies · 04/07/2022 18:31

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 17:37

I’m not against euthanasia with a hell of a lot of conditions attached and I suspect that it’ll become a regular point of debate in coming decades. Most people want to reach old age but it’s almost always accompanied with an unspoken caveat of decent health which sadly isn’t the case for lots of people.

That's the flip side isn't it. More people working till they drop, no retirement & euthanasia

No thats not the flip side to not taxing childless people more

It may be the flip side to not taxing everyone more

It may be the flipside to not coming up with a more imaginative solution

But not charging the childless more than their fair share of tax doesn't directly lead to people not having a retirement and euthanasia

Thatswhyimacat · 04/07/2022 18:28

Also WHY is it that those who support these stupid ideas are always the same people who say we need to control immigration because too many people are in the country already? Surely if I have kids that's just more competition for the schools and medical services I'm constantly told are massively oversubscribed and failing?

Ahhh I get it. They DO want more people in the country...they want more WHITE people.

hatchyu · 04/07/2022 18:27

Japan are innovative. They introduced a law recently that big companies allow workers to stay on the job until they are 70, up from 65 previously. They also introduced a care insurance scheme 20 yrs ago. I believe thats funded by premiums that are put on all citizens over 40. They also overhauled how their healthcare system. We could learn a lot from them.

Memyselfandfood · 04/07/2022 18:26

What an absolute gobshite of an idea.
so because i am unable to have kids, i should be punished further for it?

Thatswhyimacat · 04/07/2022 18:25

I'm already paying tax that goes towards subsiding parents' child benefit, schools etc that I don't partake in, your pregnancy care and children's medical care, free nursery hours, defaulted student loans etc etc. Perhaps once upon a time those without kids were more of a financial cost in retirement, but that is no more as I'll be made to sell my house to fund care. I believe in paying taxes for services that aren't 'for me' for the good of society, but do not tax me more when I am already taking far less out of the system than those with children.