Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I a 1950s man?

145 replies

SurprisinglyKnackered · 04/07/2022 09:56

I'm knackered and pissed off, and don't know whether to work on myself or try to change the situation. I feel like everything's on me (too much responsibility, etc), and don't know whether this is just life and I need to suck it up or whether my DP needs to do more. Here's the situation:

  • 3 teenage/pre-teen kids
  • I work full time in social sector. Demanding job (quite well paid, but not massively so). Earn about 80% of family income.
  • DP works PT from home, on flexible hours. Brings in a bit of money, but more as an added extra.
  • He does most of the day to day cooking.
  • He does most of the day to day cleaning.
  • He does more of the practical tasks around the house (although not so much contacting professionals to do specific jobs - plumbers, etc. - see point below about mobile phone),
  • He does more day to day walking of the dog than I do.
  • I organise vets, deworming, etc., of the dog.
  • I do all/most of the organising of stuff (deep cleaning/sorting STUFF in the house).
  • I do all driving (fair amount, with all kids' stuff) as he doesn't drive.
  • I do most of the general arranging of stuff (for kids, for the house, etc), as he doesn't have a mobile phone.
  • I organise dentist/doctors' appointments for kids, and mostly take them.
  • I mostly take the kids to their clubs, etc. (see driving point).
  • I do most of the financial stuff as he doesn't do online banking.
  • I do most of the online shops, and all the larger shops in person (see previous point about driving).
DP is a kind, intelligent, responsible man. To be fair to him, before we had kids, I didn't drive or have a mobile phone or do online banking either. It was a way we lived, driven by ethical decisions. But once we had kids, I changed as they grew and needed (I felt) to fit in more with the world their friends lived in. I just feel like I'm carrying so much, and that I may explode. It's become quite a sensitive subject, so I don't want to bring it up again with DP If the answer is that I should work more on myself.

AIBU to think AAAAAARGH?

OP posts:
whynotwhatknot · 04/07/2022 12:45

the ethical thing is hilarious as he has 3 children im more ethical than him and i have a car and a phone (no dc)

he wants a social life tell himt o organise it himself-hes picking and choosing because youre allowing it

youre being a mug

Paprikapommes · 04/07/2022 12:37

Is part of the issue that you have to think/act for him as well as your DCs? I'd imagine for some tasks it's like having an extra DC. And does he ever reciprocate that level of care for you?

You shouldn't be organising a grown man's social schedule. Similarly who organises your DPs appointments and transportation? Does that fall to you?

I get that he's proactive in terms of set tasks, but not everyone gets to pick and choose what they like. His "ethics" seem very selective. Won't have a mobile, also cba to use a landline... refuses to drive but will accept lifts. Hmm

My DM "didn't drive" and was chauffeured around by my dad for 4 decades. Since the divorce funnily enough she's much more independent and drives all over, but she still tries it on for lifts and is often only motivated to drive to things that she wants to do/see. It's stubborness, not a physical or ethical inability.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 12:35

My elderly mum won’t use mobile/internet. She gets around it but it’s harder work. It’s her choice though. Eg if she needs to book a train she goes in person to ticket office.
I suspect you just step in and do it eg quickly go online and book. I’d pause each time and think.

SkankingWombat · 04/07/2022 12:32

You are not a 1950s Husband, you are a Woman Who Has It All ie all of the stresses and exhaustion of FT work plus the lion's share of the housework and childcare!
I'm sure there are indeed lots of small 'invisible' jobs he does that you don't see, but that doesn't change the fact he doesn't do a fair number of the big visible jobs. If he is meant to be doing the majority of childcare and house stuff (which he should be if he's home more), it isn't feasible to not drive or have a mobile unless everythingis on your doorstep and the computer is permanently on and pinging when you get emails. I would be dumping it all back on him and letting him figure out if he either relents and rejoins modern life (at least until the DCs are old enough to organise themselves) or finds a tedious and convoluted work-around.

As a comparison, DH is the breadwinner in our house also earning ~80% of our household income and is out of the house/WFH for double the hours I am (50 vs 25). He works FT, but also does all washing up, 1 school pick up per week, showering DCs, ~25% of the gardening, cleans the bathroom once a week, 2 extracurricular drop offs and 1 pick up (only because I'm taking the other DC somewhere else), and deals with the utility bills when it is time to renew deals. I do everything else for the house/garden/DCs inc DIY. Our DCs are a bit younger, but that feels fair a split as we get a similar amount of leisure time and neither of us is more burnt out than the other. I wouldn't expect him to do nothing to help at home/with DCs but if he did all you do OP, I'd be a lady of leisure!

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 12:31

Do you buy him things? Eg if he needs some sports equipment only sold online or something bulky do you facilitate it.
I can see dilemma as if you don’t presumably he’d just shrug and say never mind and the kids would miss out because no one had paid online for school trip, able to take them to scout camp etc.
If he was a single parent his life would be a lot harder eg he’d have to make then lunch for school if he wouldn’t top up their lunch accounts online, get a shopping trolley to carry groceries home. I suspect if you went away for a few weeks to somewhere with no phone/internet he’d have overcome some objections.

DiamanteDelia · 04/07/2022 12:27

Can you sit down and talk all this through with him, and ask him to take responsibility for some specific things, eg doctors, dentists, prescriptions, vets, banking etc. (As in, be completely on top of them, not just making appointments etc when prompted by you.) Leave it to him to work out how to do it in a way that's compatible with his lifestyle.

SAHMonMN · 04/07/2022 12:26

I think this has nothing to do with the 1950s, but more to do with him being quite odd, tbh. I don't think I could be going with a husband who doesn't drive. It's too limiting. Also, no mobile phone! Wtf! I think he needs to get over his 'ethics' because he's just putting more strain into you. If he wants to live like that, he should go off grid and be a hermit or something. It's not reasonable or practical in 2022 with kids in school and general life. I don't know how you cope with him OP.

Motnight · 04/07/2022 12:26

He is taking the piss.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 12:23

He could do online shop if he cooks it makes sense. Just set up account with card no need for mobile banking. If he’s using internet for work it’s no problem to do that at lunchtime.
Make him responsible for all appointments for children - hospitals are still set up for phone/paper letter as some older people don’t have internet etc and hospitals are public transport accessible. He just needs to explain.

Ellie56 · 04/07/2022 12:22

The first thing I'd do is block all his bloody mates. Who do they think you are - their social secretary? Angry

SurprisinglyKnackered · 04/07/2022 12:20

Kitten2 · 04/07/2022 12:16

What is it that you want?

You want him to bring in more money? Do more around the house? Drive?

Appreciate you're struggling. It's not a sarcastic/ rhetorical Q.

Good question. I want to feel like my mind has more space in it, and less like I'm drowning in stuff to think about and do (combination of work and home probably). And just to feel less RESPONSIBLE? I do accept that being responsible is just part of being a grown up...

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 12:17

I’d stop the mates nonsense. Tell him and his mates you aren’t his social secretary. Then delete everything. I bet he finds a way to contact them. No payments on his behalf so he can’t go to events.

SurprisinglyKnackered · 04/07/2022 12:17

HarryPopper · 04/07/2022 11:57

Organizing vets and dentists take, what? 15 minutes every 3 months? Taking children places because you drive makes sense. As you work more, it makes sense that you get to spend time with your children when you're at home as he sees them more and possibly sometimes without you. It's good that you get to hang out with your children.

He does the daily drudgery and you do a big clean once every 3 to 6 months.
I think he does a lot tbh. A lot of your tasks are admin which I personally find a doddle that I can do with my eyes shut but some people find it overwhelming. Online banking is a walk in the park. You're not even stuck in a queue or have to go on your Saturday morning. You can literally do all this in your pjs in bed in front of Netflix. I'd rather do admin all day than clean bathrooms, cook and walk the dog. Plus, you are secure in a better paid job so you have more independence to leave should you wish to. I think you've got the sweeter deal so yes you are definitely a 1950s man in my eyes. Enjoy your perks!

Thanks @HarryPopper - interesting take, and I'm reading all perspectives. I reckon the doctor and dentist thing is far bigger than that, actually. All the kids have some medical needs, and there are quite a few appointments, prescriptions to organise and sort, phone calls to make, chasing up of various stuff.

I'm not great at admin, so probably others could do a lot of the stuff I do more efficiently that I do it, to be fair.

OP posts:
Kitten2 · 04/07/2022 12:16

What is it that you want?

You want him to bring in more money? Do more around the house? Drive?

Appreciate you're struggling. It's not a sarcastic/ rhetorical Q.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 12:16

He sounds hard work. If he truly wanted to opt out/live off grid he wouldn’t pick and chose and if he’s concerned re environmental impact he wouldn’t have fathered 3 children (assuming they aren’t triplets!)
Can he up his hours as he’s not able to do more at home due to his life choices.
I’d seriously look at what you both do task wise and time taken and have a discussion.

FilthyforFirth · 04/07/2022 12:14

Where are his ethical concerns around having 3 children? (I'm not having a pop,have however many you want) This is the most hypocritical thing I have read in a while!

CecilyP · 04/07/2022 12:11

He would say that if I decide to stop driving or get rid of my mobile that that would be great - we'd just live differently, and the kids would adapt. I just can't make that leap. And when his mates text my mobile to organise their social arrangements via me, I do sometimes have to grit my teeth!

You should do more than grit your teeth! Tell them to phone the landline or send him a letter! You are not his social secretary. And getting rid of the mobile would be problematic these days as there are so few call boxes left.

Your DH isn’t simply not pulling his weight; his attitude is downright weird.

WinterMusings · 04/07/2022 12:07

@SurprisinglyKnackered

He also does do the online payments for water, gas and electricity bills, and council tax. I do all the phone, computer, broadband, TV stuff. And all car and house insurance (and obviously car maintenance), etc

if he's happy to use the internet, why not a phone?

if he can do some of the 'admin' why not all of it?

why aren't your payments on DD?

tell his mates to email or phone him on the LL, you're not his social secretary

DiamanteDelia · 04/07/2022 12:04

Interesting distinction between ethical and aesthetic choices. I can see the appeal of living in a simpler way with more real connections and interactions, certainly, but it does't sound as if he is really doing this at the moment- he's getting the benefits of not having a mobile phone etc but none of the disadvantages. Meanwhile you're getting double disadvantage- all the stress of modern living without him taking an equal share.

I would just text back the mates to call him on the landline. You're not his secretary.

LizzieSiddal · 04/07/2022 12:03

And when his mates text my mobile to organise their social arrangements via me, I do sometimes have to grit my teeth!

as I said you’re enabling him, just stop it or you’re justified resentment will get worse! You’re not his mother! If he does use a computer then his fronds can contact him via that or the house landline.

HarryPopper · 04/07/2022 12:02

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov ok but that's 5 hours more, presumably the children spend 5 hours or so at their activities too so it's even. Why wouldn't the mother want every opportunity to hang out with her children and see them enjoy themselves at their activities?!

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 04/07/2022 12:00

Harry popper the kids are in school all day- he sees them for maybe 5 hours more than the op?

WinterMusings · 04/07/2022 12:00

NO, you're not being like a 1950's husband, NOT AT ALL.

& he is certainly not being like a 1950's housewife!! At least not the modern equivalent one. In the 1950's life was vastly different & yet he's STILL not even doing as much work!!

you're doing almost all of the thinking/planning/organising, all of the running around after the kids & shopping, laundry etc.

whilst he piddles about working part time, cooking & pushing the hoover about.

How does having 3 children fit in with his 'ethics'?

does he not have legs to walk or bus to the shops?

why can't he do the laundry?

im furious on your behalf that this lazy twat is hiding behind 'ethics' to not pull his weight in your family.

why is he only working PT?

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 04/07/2022 11:59

There is no way I'd be a conduit for his social life. I'd nip that one in the bud completely. And I'd pull back on the appointments etc. Let him do that. I'm a Sahm and I'm dreading the car in the future because I expect I'll be a taxi. Im laughing now thinking of announcing to Dh im going to stop driving for ethical reasons and he'll have to get dc to play dates, parties and swimming lessons

HarryPopper · 04/07/2022 11:57

Organizing vets and dentists take, what? 15 minutes every 3 months? Taking children places because you drive makes sense. As you work more, it makes sense that you get to spend time with your children when you're at home as he sees them more and possibly sometimes without you. It's good that you get to hang out with your children.

He does the daily drudgery and you do a big clean once every 3 to 6 months.
I think he does a lot tbh. A lot of your tasks are admin which I personally find a doddle that I can do with my eyes shut but some people find it overwhelming. Online banking is a walk in the park. You're not even stuck in a queue or have to go on your Saturday morning. You can literally do all this in your pjs in bed in front of Netflix. I'd rather do admin all day than clean bathrooms, cook and walk the dog. Plus, you are secure in a better paid job so you have more independence to leave should you wish to. I think you've got the sweeter deal so yes you are definitely a 1950s man in my eyes. Enjoy your perks!