Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I a 1950s man?

145 replies

SurprisinglyKnackered · 04/07/2022 09:56

I'm knackered and pissed off, and don't know whether to work on myself or try to change the situation. I feel like everything's on me (too much responsibility, etc), and don't know whether this is just life and I need to suck it up or whether my DP needs to do more. Here's the situation:

  • 3 teenage/pre-teen kids
  • I work full time in social sector. Demanding job (quite well paid, but not massively so). Earn about 80% of family income.
  • DP works PT from home, on flexible hours. Brings in a bit of money, but more as an added extra.
  • He does most of the day to day cooking.
  • He does most of the day to day cleaning.
  • He does more of the practical tasks around the house (although not so much contacting professionals to do specific jobs - plumbers, etc. - see point below about mobile phone),
  • He does more day to day walking of the dog than I do.
  • I organise vets, deworming, etc., of the dog.
  • I do all/most of the organising of stuff (deep cleaning/sorting STUFF in the house).
  • I do all driving (fair amount, with all kids' stuff) as he doesn't drive.
  • I do most of the general arranging of stuff (for kids, for the house, etc), as he doesn't have a mobile phone.
  • I organise dentist/doctors' appointments for kids, and mostly take them.
  • I mostly take the kids to their clubs, etc. (see driving point).
  • I do most of the financial stuff as he doesn't do online banking.
  • I do most of the online shops, and all the larger shops in person (see previous point about driving).
DP is a kind, intelligent, responsible man. To be fair to him, before we had kids, I didn't drive or have a mobile phone or do online banking either. It was a way we lived, driven by ethical decisions. But once we had kids, I changed as they grew and needed (I felt) to fit in more with the world their friends lived in. I just feel like I'm carrying so much, and that I may explode. It's become quite a sensitive subject, so I don't want to bring it up again with DP If the answer is that I should work more on myself.

AIBU to think AAAAAARGH?

OP posts:
Shade17 · 04/07/2022 14:27

If he’s got 3 kids then he certainly couldn’t give a fuck about the environment!

Sillyotter · 04/07/2022 14:21

What are his actual ethical objections to having a phone and driving?

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 14:14

Who does the meal planning out of interest. I can’t fathom how he does all cooking but you do order. Even if he plans and gives you a list surely some stuff is out of stock or you shop to make use of offers.

DoloresMores · 04/07/2022 14:09

I think this thread conflates two issues- 1) his ethical/aesthetic lifestyle choices; and 2) the fact he's not pulling his weight.

I actually have some sympathy with the first issue- there's something to be said for not living your life mediated through a screen and I would respect him for trying it if he wasn't just relying on you to do it all for him. Presumably OP also gets where he's coming from given that she also used to live like this pre-kids. Maybe it's worth some family discussion about how to live in a way which accords with both OP's and her partner's values that isn't just that he gets to stick to his principles and OP deals with the fall out.

Second issue- he's simply not doing enough. There is presumably nothing in his world view that precludes eg making doctors appointments- he's just leaving it to you because he can. I have zero sympathy on this stuff and don't see it as anything to do with his lifestyle choices- he chose to be a dad so he needs to step up.

He would say that if I decide to stop driving or get rid of my mobile that that would be great - we'd just live differently, and the kids would adapt.

This sort of false reasonableness would annoy me. On the surface, it sounds like he's being reasonable but actually it's a complete refusal to compromise- he has set out what he is willing to do and OP's choice is to do everything else or accept a complete change in lifestyle- he won't be budging. It's also inconsistent- if he can't do doctors and dentists etc because he doesn't have a mobile and won't drive, how will these things be dealt with if you give up your phone and car? Obviously you'd find a way to manage, which suggests that he could find a way to manage now if he felt so inclined.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 04/07/2022 14:03

And if he us going to live by these principles then he needs to find work arounds that work for the family. Eg cycle somewhere with the kids or get an uber with them. Or move somewhere with great transport links

The whole thing is really illogical if they're going to get a lift off you anyway then it doesnt matter which one of you is driving.

Trivester · 04/07/2022 14:02

We divide jobs with an eye to mental
load. An easy example is that whoever does the laundry also irons and puts away, declutters (all the way out of the house), mends, buys new clothes for kids, checks shoes fit, organises kit for clubs etc, organises dry cleaning, makes the beds etc.

The other partner can help but all the decisions and mental load lie with one person.

would it be worth looking through the household/career responsibilities and grouping them like this?

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 04/07/2022 14:00

Is there a reason why he can't do online stuff on a laptop/ desktop if he works online?

Is there a reason why he can't sort things over the phone and using a calendar and a pen (eg dogs appointments). Presumably he must be online or on the phone for work, and that doesn't cross his ethical boundaries? Why cant he do the online shop on his lunch break or something?

I think fundamentally it's ok to have these ethical preferences but it's starting to really affect yours and your childrens lives and it's not ok to inflict these on others. Sometimes pragmatism has to come into it, for a few years. Like others have said, if you had the same stance, then your kids would really miss out, on a social life, on hobbies, on school stuff. Which most parents would think is not acceptable.

Also why doesnt he work more? If he is opting out of the nitty gritty if family life he could surely at least help by financially contributing more.

I'd lose all respect for a man that expected me to pick up the slack so he could live by his principles. If he insists then he needs to find work arounds that dont rely on you doing the things that are apparently against his principles! Not owning a mobile but being happy to use someone elses to organise your own social life doesnt seem principled it seems pedantic and lazy

Regularsizedrudy · 04/07/2022 13:58

I think rather than asking “is this fair?” you should ask “is this working?”

it might be a fair split of labour but it’s clearly not working for you and wearing you down. You need to talk about changes you can both make. It doesn’t have to be a blame game or competition. If he’s a decent partner he should want to support you when you are struggling.

SaintHelena · 04/07/2022 13:53

We pay all bills by direct debit - we use an insurance broker who emails us with quotes and we just pay online - dh does supermarket shop.
I cook evening meals which I have done virtually every night for 40+ years of marriage.which incenses me but I know dh would make zero effort so I'm stuck there but someone cooking on the evening would rate v highly withme.
Could you use a laundrette for bedding - could you ignore deep cleaning til DCs have left home or st least dh does some

beastlyslumber · 04/07/2022 13:50

Why is he working part time? He needs to get a full time job. He sounds lazy as fuck. I couldn't respect a man who behaved that way.

LizzieSiddal · 04/07/2022 13:42

At first glance, if vets appointments and dental visits made your top 8? then I suspect you might be massively underestimating what your DP does.

Did you bother to read all the OP’s posts? All the Dc have extra medical needs so far more work than normally associated with 3 children.

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 13:42

Hopefully his mates or his sports club will do an activity or trip he misses out on because you have resigned as his social secretary.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 04/07/2022 13:36

oobeedoobee · 04/07/2022 12:45

I agree that you've allowed him to 'cherry pick' things to do for the family, and you've decided that because the DC's lives have grown, so yours had to grow to include driving and appointments etc.

I'd sit DH down and tell him that you cannot continue doing all the jobs you do, and that he now has to do some 'growing' of his own to help his DC !

Step 1 is to buy him a mobile phone.
Step 2 is to book driving lessons for him.
Step 3 is to divide all chores/admin/jobs equally i.e so that you both get equal 'downtime' and 'leisure' time.

Eh? What are you on this just makes more work for OP.

Don't follow this just stop facilitating him. He needs to sort the shopping, he can do it online, walk, cycle or drive, up to him but if he doesn't do it he deals with the fallout.

Tell his mates once to use DH's email or landline and then mute them/block them.

Divide up kids clubs duty etc. He can either walk/cycle them there, get the bus or drive, but you don't pick up after him. Likewise the admin stuff, divide it up, some are his responsibility, he can use the computer or the landline to sort them. Medical dentist and vet appointments are easily done by phone, insurance is more tricky but he has a computer. Stop picking up after him.

Zilla1 · 04/07/2022 13:31

At first glance, if vets appointments and dental visits made your top 8? then I suspect you might be massively underestimating what your DP does.

myuterusistryingtokillme · 04/07/2022 13:31

And when his mates text my mobile to organise their social arrangements via me, I do sometimes have to grit my teeth!

I would stop doing stuff like this (and giving him lifts anywhere) straight away, you can't choose to opt out of modern life for 'ethical reasons' just to push it all on to someone else and benefit from modern technology in that way

He does seem to want it all his way, working part time using the Internet but offloading a load of home related stuff to you because it's online? He should take over the shopping and banking

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 13:28

Twocrabs20 · 04/07/2022 13:22

He needs to learn to drive. This is not negotiable.

This will free up soooooo much time for your occasional rest or recreation, and occasionally being at home on your own for the occasional peaceful child free moment. Etc.

He can drive just chooses not to due to ethics but the ethics don’t prevent him being a passenger!

Dixiechickonhols · 04/07/2022 13:26

Hanswurst · 04/07/2022 12:50

I think the problem here is the difference between your and his attitudes.

Due to his ethical views (actually IMHO it’s an excuse for laziness, but for the sake of argument let’s just call it that) he doesn’t actually care if some things don’t happen. So if you stopped doing certain things like ferrying the kids around, doing a proper shop etc, they wouldn’t get done and he wouldn’t care - he would just accept it as a “different lifestyle” and expect everyone, especially the kids to adapt.

You on the other hand want to enable your kids to go to clubs, see friends, have access to a varied and interesting diet, etc. It matters to you that the kids get this. You are aware that if they did not have this “luxury” they wouldn’t die, and they would probably adapt. But as their mother you want them to have what YOU perceive as the best, most enriching life you can offer them.

This is a fundamental difference in opinions of what good parenting looks like, and I am sad to say you will struggle to change his mindset.

I have gone through similar with STBXH, albeit his excuse/explanation wasn’t ethics, it was laziness/selfishness. So for example, when I was home at the weekend I would make a nice family breakfast for all of us, including DCs to enjoy. It was family time for all of us and a chance to chill together, have a catch-up, etc.
Due to working shifts though, I am sometimes working over the weekend. On those days, STBXH would sometimes not get up until 11/12 o’clock, so breakfast would be more like lunch, it was rushed because the dogs needed walking and everyone was cranky because they had been lazying around for hours before the “official
start of the day”.
When the DCs complained his answer was they should just sort themselves out, they were teens/pre-teens and were unlikely to starve. And while I understand that yes, he is right, they weren’t going to waste away and are perfectly able to sort their own breakfast as they in fact do every weekday, the issue wasn’t about just feeding themselves. The DCs mostly just enjoyed the family element and the routine of having a breakfast together.
The difference in attitude is massive, and I’m afraid in our case I have now given up to try and make him understand.

That really is the nub of the issue. How far is he prepared to let children miss out? At the minute he doesn’t have to deal with fall out. If you died tomorrow and he carried on in his stance would he be happy to see them miss out or would he sort? Eg DD’s prom was £25 via scopay online. Would he not pay and deal with upset 16 year old (everyone went). Would he be proactive and ring school/send cash. Maybe think of scenarios where you have done stuff for kids recently is he really happy for them to miss it. If he is then I really don’t think I could be in a relationship with someone who let there kids be upset and repeatedly miss out, it’s deadbeat dad territory.

Twocrabs20 · 04/07/2022 13:22

He needs to learn to drive. This is not negotiable.

This will free up soooooo much time for your occasional rest or recreation, and occasionally being at home on your own for the occasional peaceful child free moment. Etc.

dearhummingbirds · 04/07/2022 13:16

Seems like you’re taking a lot of the ‘mental load’ and it’s taking its toll.

amp.theguardian.com/world/2017/may/26/gender-wars-household-chores-comic

Obviously he is in chipping in with household chores, but it feels like you’re taking on more responsibility.

Name99 · 04/07/2022 13:12

I still don't understand the driving thing
Ethical reasons ? The aesthetics of the car?

JudgeRindersMinder · 04/07/2022 13:03

SurprisinglyKnackered · 04/07/2022 10:00

He can drive. He just doesn't want to (ethical reasons, and inertia).

Ethical my arse if you’re picking up his slack!

In our household I’m the part time worker, and I do all the stuff you’ve listed that you do, as well as the stuff your dh does. He’s taking the piss and hiding behind “ethics”. I don’t think he’s very ethical at all towards you!

5128gap · 04/07/2022 13:00

Its very controversial on here, as the accepted narrative seems to be that cooking and cleaning is a huge job and that a part time or SAHP works just as hard as a working one. But in all honesty, having been in both your position and your partners, I'm inclined to agree with you. Cleaning a house does not take all day. Nutritious meals can be prepared in half an hour. Working part time with responsibility for domestics affords you huge amounts of flexibility and down time that's simply not available to a person working full time. I think he should be doing a lot more. (Just as I'd think a woman in his position should, for the avoidance of doubt.)

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 04/07/2022 12:52

It's the mental load, you are carrying that for the whole family. That's what takes up the head space, never being able to switch off. He needs to pull his weight with organising the dc

Hanswurst · 04/07/2022 12:50

I think the problem here is the difference between your and his attitudes.

Due to his ethical views (actually IMHO it’s an excuse for laziness, but for the sake of argument let’s just call it that) he doesn’t actually care if some things don’t happen. So if you stopped doing certain things like ferrying the kids around, doing a proper shop etc, they wouldn’t get done and he wouldn’t care - he would just accept it as a “different lifestyle” and expect everyone, especially the kids to adapt.

You on the other hand want to enable your kids to go to clubs, see friends, have access to a varied and interesting diet, etc. It matters to you that the kids get this. You are aware that if they did not have this “luxury” they wouldn’t die, and they would probably adapt. But as their mother you want them to have what YOU perceive as the best, most enriching life you can offer them.

This is a fundamental difference in opinions of what good parenting looks like, and I am sad to say you will struggle to change his mindset.

I have gone through similar with STBXH, albeit his excuse/explanation wasn’t ethics, it was laziness/selfishness. So for example, when I was home at the weekend I would make a nice family breakfast for all of us, including DCs to enjoy. It was family time for all of us and a chance to chill together, have a catch-up, etc.
Due to working shifts though, I am sometimes working over the weekend. On those days, STBXH would sometimes not get up until 11/12 o’clock, so breakfast would be more like lunch, it was rushed because the dogs needed walking and everyone was cranky because they had been lazying around for hours before the “official
start of the day”.
When the DCs complained his answer was they should just sort themselves out, they were teens/pre-teens and were unlikely to starve. And while I understand that yes, he is right, they weren’t going to waste away and are perfectly able to sort their own breakfast as they in fact do every weekday, the issue wasn’t about just feeding themselves. The DCs mostly just enjoyed the family element and the routine of having a breakfast together.
The difference in attitude is massive, and I’m afraid in our case I have now given up to try and make him understand.

oobeedoobee · 04/07/2022 12:45

I agree that you've allowed him to 'cherry pick' things to do for the family, and you've decided that because the DC's lives have grown, so yours had to grow to include driving and appointments etc.

I'd sit DH down and tell him that you cannot continue doing all the jobs you do, and that he now has to do some 'growing' of his own to help his DC !

Step 1 is to buy him a mobile phone.
Step 2 is to book driving lessons for him.
Step 3 is to divide all chores/admin/jobs equally i.e so that you both get equal 'downtime' and 'leisure' time.