Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of Fabulous Plus size influencer stories on my feed.

34 replies

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 07:41

Now don't get me wrong these girls/ women are beautiful and I love how confident they are in their skins. They glow.
However the comments alway descent into the usual vile fat shaming territory. This is so damaging. Telling someone they are gross or a burden in the NHS is not going to help.
I am plus size (obese) but working on it right now . Historically I lost a significantl amount of weight all by myself but regained it when my child's Mental Health took a nosedive. We have been to hell and back. At the moment I feel good about myself and things are stable in my personal life and my Mental Health is slowly improving as DD is more settled and in a better place mentally. The weight is coming off again as I am focusing on what my body can do and I am striving to push my body further.
The things that people think should help actually don't IMO. I have had Medics suggesting a little exercise for example . Well I exercise loads (100k Ultra level and I don't need to be told to avoid junk food fgs. My eating was a reaction to serious shit in my life to which I had bugger all support.
So AIBU

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 20:37

@WorkEvent I know. I was just explaining my focus. Medics foalll tge time though as they make assumptions re my lifestyle.

OP posts:
WorkEvent · 04/07/2022 19:42

@Deeplydippy74 I didn’t tell you to exercise?

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 11:57

@ManateeFair I follow no one on Instagram. I was scrolling though Facebook and absentmindedly opened a single àrticle. On that article I noticed someone questioned why The Sun/Fabulous and constantly showing these posts as it brings out the haters and it got me thinking.
@WorkEvent my health as far as I know isn't affected by my obesity as far as I know but obviously I would be faster if I lost a few stone. That is my focus. Telling me to do a little exercise is patronising when I walk 100KM events.

OP posts:
WorkEvent · 04/07/2022 11:20

People deserve to feel happy and beautiful regardless of their size. Being obese increases the risks of health problems, it doesn’t guarantee them. Fat isn’t a moral issue. Very few (if any) people are looking at plus size influencers and thinking ‘I aspire to put on weight to look like that’ but if they can make some people feel more positive about themselves, then great. I follow a few mid/plus size influencers. I’m currently a size 12-14. They make me feel more confident about myself and I can see what looks good on body shapes that look like.

5128gap · 04/07/2022 11:19

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 11:08

@5128gap I have not said it does for all people but it works for me and I am sure I amnit thr only one to actually stop focusing on what my body looks like but on what it can do and to work on fitness .
If weigh gain us linked to Mental Health telling someone they are grossly overweight fior example is not going to help.

I think there's two things.
Firstly the link between obesity and ugliness and negative character traits should be challenged and broken. I think the plus size influencers do a great job of this. I think and hope that they are instrumental in raising self esteem.
Secondly, the link between obesity and health issues should not be ignored or glossed over in order not to damage self esteem.
Health, beauty, worth as a person are all entirely different things and should be treated as such. If ones health is impacted by their weight, its right they should be told, just as if it were impacted by alcohol or smoking. They shouldn't however be told that their weight makes them ugly or of less value.

ManateeFair · 04/07/2022 11:15

Why are you reading the comments?

You're following plus-size influencers because (I assume) you want body-positive role models you can identify with, get style inspiration from, learn confidence from etc. Your inspiration is them, not random people on the internet who comment on stuff. Follow plus-size women if you want to, but don't read the comments at all because you are fully aware that it will be counter-productive. It sounds like you['re basically punishing yourself with them. Just stop ffs.

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 11:08

@5128gap I have not said it does for all people but it works for me and I am sure I amnit thr only one to actually stop focusing on what my body looks like but on what it can do and to work on fitness .
If weigh gain us linked to Mental Health telling someone they are grossly overweight fior example is not going to help.

OP posts:
LemonadeSunshine · 04/07/2022 11:07

Spanielservant · 04/07/2022 09:48

But obesity isn't positive. And people's first thought is that really fat people are slobs. It's human nature. Stop pretending it's beautiful. It's really not. And all the bollocks euphemisms like big girls and chubby don't stop it being obesity which we should not be encouraging the next generations to 'embrace'

Err no actually, my first thought is whether they may have a condition or require medications which either prohibit healthy metabolism, hinder exercise or affects hormonal balance.
I certainly don't agree that the fat people should be hidden away in the back offices. Thank goodness I don't know anyone as narrow minded and opinionated as you irl

Georgeskitchen · 04/07/2022 11:00

Obesity should not be glamorised . Its dangerous and it is a drain on health services. There are programmes on TV glamorising dangerously obese people and doctors are being told not to tell patients they are overweight in case they get offended. What a ridiculous state of affairs

5128gap · 04/07/2022 11:00

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 10:31

My point on a personal level and I an sure I am not the only onr is is that an obese or overweight person will find it very difficult to change if they are coming from a point of self loathing. Vile comments either in real life or on social media etc feed into that.
Changing mindset is very important. I tend to lose weight when feeling good about myself and for me this relates to what my body can do and I know I will be stronger if I lose more weight.
Negative comments bandied around us more likely to stop the person bothering. Fir example my sport is challenging but also inclusive. I have never been made to feel less of a competitor because I am not a quick for example. Had thst been the case I could have given up and made things worse.
I subscribe to Rebel Fit and that is more uplifting.
Obviously a certain amount of stability in Life also helps.

I think there is an equally valid argument though that obese and overweight people who are perfectly happy with themselves don't change either. My mum was that person. Perfectly happy obese and made no changes. Her weight was responsible for her death in her early 60s.
I loathe the cruelty of fat shaming, and am strongly of the opinion that the link between weight and beauty should be broken. But I think its incorrect to say that body positivity is the best way to bring about physical health improvements for obese people, and a generalisation to say that improved self esteem helps weight loss. It may for some, but by no means for all.
Plus size influencers neither encourage nor inspire weight loss, so at best their impact on health is neutral. That's not to say they don't help with self esteem, which is very valuable in other ways.

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 10:48

Telling fat people that they should be ashamed and hate themselves is totally counter-productive. It doesn't make them thin. It doesn't help them to lose weight. It just makes them feel ashamed and hate themselves, neither of which is conducive to a healthy sustainable lifestyle.

Exactly @Palavah These people are making things worse

OP posts:
Palavah · 04/07/2022 10:41

Telling fat people that they should be ashamed and hate themselves is totally counter-productive. It doesn't make them thin. It doesn't help them to lose weight. It just makes them feel ashamed and hate themselves, neither of which is conducive to a healthy sustainable lifestyle.

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 10:36

@Spanielservant this slob walked 100KM continuous last year.

OP posts:
Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 10:31

My point on a personal level and I an sure I am not the only onr is is that an obese or overweight person will find it very difficult to change if they are coming from a point of self loathing. Vile comments either in real life or on social media etc feed into that.
Changing mindset is very important. I tend to lose weight when feeling good about myself and for me this relates to what my body can do and I know I will be stronger if I lose more weight.
Negative comments bandied around us more likely to stop the person bothering. Fir example my sport is challenging but also inclusive. I have never been made to feel less of a competitor because I am not a quick for example. Had thst been the case I could have given up and made things worse.
I subscribe to Rebel Fit and that is more uplifting.
Obviously a certain amount of stability in Life also helps.

OP posts:
5128gap · 04/07/2022 10:04

Spanielservant · 04/07/2022 09:48

But obesity isn't positive. And people's first thought is that really fat people are slobs. It's human nature. Stop pretending it's beautiful. It's really not. And all the bollocks euphemisms like big girls and chubby don't stop it being obesity which we should not be encouraging the next generations to 'embrace'

Obviously obesity is not positive for health reasons. But beauty is subjective. You can see from historical art work that human beings have not always found excess weight unattractive, and we know that some cultures and many people within our own culture find being overweight attractive, or at least not a bar to being attractive. Not everyone who says obese women are beautiful is pretending. The models often have lovely faces, hair and skin that mean that even if you don't like their body shape, they are overall more beautiful than many slimmer plainer women.

Coughee · 04/07/2022 09:54

There's an option to choose not to see stuff on Facebook. Next time something like that pops up find that option - it's probably the three little dots at the top by the name of the account. You can also hide accounts - I've hidden our local rag as the people who comment on the articles are knuckle dragging mouth breathers who make me rage.

Spanielservant · 04/07/2022 09:48

But obesity isn't positive. And people's first thought is that really fat people are slobs. It's human nature. Stop pretending it's beautiful. It's really not. And all the bollocks euphemisms like big girls and chubby don't stop it being obesity which we should not be encouraging the next generations to 'embrace'

Spanielservant · 04/07/2022 09:44

ParrotsAteThemAll · 04/07/2022 09:18

If you were blind would you still refuse to be seen by this nurse?

Yes. How can you look after other people when you can't look after yourself. Moreover, if I were her employer I would move her to a non patient facing role

CousinKrispy · 04/07/2022 09:19

Ugh I know there is so much toxicity in the media and on social media around lots of people, including obviously anyone who dares to be overweight.

OP if you like podcasts check out Maintenance Phase. Like anything I take it with a grain of salt but they do a great job of debunking a lot of the absolute bullshit that's continually spewed forth about dieting and body fat. It really makes clear how much of the "helpful" advice from everyone (other people, the media, doctors) is achieving the exact opposite.

ParrotsAteThemAll · 04/07/2022 09:18

Spanielservant · 04/07/2022 08:44

Actually I think its really unhealthy all this love my bigness shit. It's not healthy physically and all these girls.neing told they can be anything they want have no idea that in the actual world, like it or not, people judge in seconds. Nobody ever said they regretted going from obese to healthy because people treated them in a negative way. The practice nurse at my.mums surgery is so fat she has to have a special chair and widened doorframe. I don't think that's OK. I wouldn't see her.

If you were blind would you still refuse to be seen by this nurse?

DomPerignon12 · 04/07/2022 09:14

Social media is an echo chamber OP. It’s all fake.
Hell even MN is similar, the majority of threads have batshit opinions that’s I’ve never heard anyone express IRL.

5128gap · 04/07/2022 09:06

People have made disparaging comments about overweight women for decades. Few manage to go through life without hearing first hand what the majority of people really think about excess weight. Those that see it as beautiful and positive are a tiny, albeit vocal minority. While they can be very helpful in encouraging women to see their bodies more positively, there is no way they will turn the tide of public opinion. So the choices are, live in a world where the only opinions on obesity are negative, or look to these influencers for some positivity to balance it out, and ignore the inevitable negativity that will accompany it. They're not saying anything you don't already know people think, and it's a shame to miss out on the positivity because of it.

Spanielservant · 04/07/2022 08:44

Actually I think its really unhealthy all this love my bigness shit. It's not healthy physically and all these girls.neing told they can be anything they want have no idea that in the actual world, like it or not, people judge in seconds. Nobody ever said they regretted going from obese to healthy because people treated them in a negative way. The practice nurse at my.mums surgery is so fat she has to have a special chair and widened doorframe. I don't think that's OK. I wouldn't see her.

AngelinaFibres · 04/07/2022 08:40

Stay off social media, don't read anything tabloid. Concentrate on the things that are happening in your real life. Good luck with the weight loss and with your daughter. Xxxx

ChagSameachDoreen · 04/07/2022 08:22

Easy solution. Don't read the Sun.