Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£9250 paid to be bullied by goons...

59 replies

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 01:42

One year teacher training with QTS, costs £9250, but I only did four weeks of the course. I dropped out having been bullied by Personal Mentor, having never thought that could happen to me. It was a shock.
The university still charged me £2000, and when I appealed, it was like talking to a brick wall. The tutor had already warned me that I'd been bullied at that particular school, since the previous trainee had been bullied to the point of nervous breakdown by this same Personal Mentor. So that might be the reason for the lack of refund. However. It's alot of money to pay to be bullied by goons.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ToadiesCouzin · 04/07/2022 17:28

Did you complain in writing? Do you have an email that you sent to the uni detailing the lack of support at the time? An email requesting to switch schools and the reasons why? That might help your case. Sadly, you're probably right that if it's a case of he said she said, you might not get anywhere. But it's a lesson to always put everything in writing!

howdoesatoastermaketoast · 04/07/2022 14:42

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 10:34

Yes - it is a strange thing isn't it? When teaching is an absolute joy, (I did TEFL in Spain before DD arrived and loved it!) and when students can be so interesting, why is it that in British schools, the bullies seem to prevail?

By the way, I won't let this put me off teaching. I will return to TEFL. 😁

(some) Senior managers bully staff, gives them no moral high ground when (some) staff bully pupils, which gives them no moral high ground when pupils bully pupils.

/arrgh

Ohthatsexciting · 04/07/2022 12:55

The tutor had warned you would be bullied before you applied?

I think that the Uni has had so many similar complaints in the past, that they just automatically swing into action, and write off the student that does highlight mentor bullying as "unfit to teach."

this sounds like gossip and hearsay to me

Oceanus · 04/07/2022 12:01

I think words matter: either mistakes were made or you were bullied...! It's not the same. Not all students will be placed where they wanted. Still, you used the word "bullied" before and now you're talking about "mistakes being made"? You're either minimising what happened to you or making a mountain out of a molehill. Think about it as you mentioned your institution in a very public forum.

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 11:58

stayingpositiveifpossible · 04/07/2022 11:51

A duty of care to the students (and the children)?

Surely that is enough evidence for bad practice? They should have signed a contract with the uni. Therefore the uni is also at fault!

I think that the Uni has had so many similar complaints in the past, that they just automatically swing into action, and write off the student that does highlight mentor bullying as "unfit to teach."

It is a brutal attitude and doesn't help weed out the Personal Mentors who have a bad reputation - but that does seem to be the way.
Therefore, I'm happy to go back to TEFL and stay in a part of education, which is less stressful and less bitchy and where I've got a good reputation already. The problem with the PGCE is that you are establishing a reputation as a teacher during your trainee year, amid people who don't seem to be respectful or intelligent or good. Of course, other people will disagree, because they had a very good Personal Mentor and all is well. It's down to luck, sadly.😭

OP posts:
YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 11:53

Oceanus · 04/07/2022 11:47

I can't believe you were sent to a school where they knew, in advance, you'd likely be bullied! That's bloody unacceptable. It means sb else was bullied before, they knew it had unhappened and they did nothing to sort out the problem. Surely, you have plenty of legs to stand on when proceeding with a complaint. I would complain to Offsted (in for a penny, in for 9000 quid!).

Thank you Oceanus - the Post-Covid teacher training scene might be a factor. There were more students than there were Placement places, and this caused confusion amid the student body. Some were placed with a two hour commute each way, home to school and back. Some were given no placement at all, due to lack of available placement places. Some were making their own arrangements for placement by calling schools directly, and then instructing the placement team at the Uni, to put them there - which - caused friction at the Uni, Obviously, the students were getting really concerned and were taking matters into their own hands. Some students couldn't be placed because there were delays in getting their DBS. With all this going on, it was inevitable that mistakes would be made.

OP posts:
stayingpositiveifpossible · 04/07/2022 11:51

A duty of care to the students (and the children)?

Surely that is enough evidence for bad practice? They should have signed a contract with the uni. Therefore the uni is also at fault!

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 11:49

poetryandwine · 04/07/2022 11:26

OP,

I agree you should pursue this with the OIA if you have exhausted processes at your university. BTW, did you intend to identify it, given you are concerned about being outed?

Sadly I think you are correct that preserving relationships with schools is the priority. I really hope you are able to put together a good case - having sat on a number of university appeals committees, may I just emphasise that it will be all about following procedures and presenting evidence - and get justice.

Thank you poetry and wine.
I didn't mean to identify the University, but I am not sure how to delete a part of a post, once it is up there. Admin, can you help?
Thank you for your advice from one who has sat on university appeals. The problem is "giving evidence" when it is a case of being bullied. There isn't any clear evidence for bad practise when it comes to Personal Mentor conduct.

OP posts:
Oceanus · 04/07/2022 11:47

I can't believe you were sent to a school where they knew, in advance, you'd likely be bullied! That's bloody unacceptable. It means sb else was bullied before, they knew it had unhappened and they did nothing to sort out the problem. Surely, you have plenty of legs to stand on when proceeding with a complaint. I would complain to Offsted (in for a penny, in for 9000 quid!).

poetryandwine · 04/07/2022 11:26

OP,

I agree you should pursue this with the OIA if you have exhausted processes at your university. BTW, did you intend to identify it, given you are concerned about being outed?

Sadly I think you are correct that preserving relationships with schools is the priority. I really hope you are able to put together a good case - having sat on a number of university appeals committees, may I just emphasise that it will be all about following procedures and presenting evidence - and get justice.

Cass02093 · 04/07/2022 11:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 04/07/2022 10:40

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 10:32

There may well be "robost measures in place to protect you as a trainee" 5mins, but perhaps not at the University that I atttended. Instead there seemed to be "robust measures" to ensure a massive online bitching session, with a view to negating the point of view of the bullied trainee and write them off.

However, I am sure that better Universities have these "robost measures" of which you speak.

Ahhh see I mustn't have gone to a "good enough" uni either. My first PGCE mentor was horrendous, not bullying but mentally checked out and I got an average of 7 minutes with her a week and she was using the extra PPA to catch up on her own work and using my "observed lessons" to leave me unsupervised while she did other stuff so she could leave at 3:30. I started my second placement basically where I was at the start of my first one. Thankfully my second mentor was amazing. It's all well and good universities writing anything into "policies" but when they're not taking action or listening to you, or are minimizing your concerns, or blaming you for failures in their own system, what can you do?

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 10:39

StaunchMomma · 04/07/2022 09:17

Bullying of staff in schools is rife. I hear it so often.

Your mentor sounds like an utter nightmare. Make sure you put in a complaint against them, especially as a student prior to you suffered under them too.

I was bullied out of teaching too. It's horrible leaving something you've worked so hard for but honestly, your mental health is more important.

People in the private sector wouldn't believe the stuff that goes on in schools. It wouldn't be tolerated.

I do feel that bullying of staff in schools is rife, yes. But as my background is modern languages and TEFL, I think I can stay in teaching, but in a more relaxed workplace. So I feel as if I dodged a bullet by getting out of the PGCE.

OP posts:
YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 10:37

Zilla1 · 04/07/2022 09:36

Might there be any value in asking how MMU think they've complied with their duty of care to you by placing you with a known bully without support?

When I made my appeal, I did ask about that. Didn't get much of a reply. They don't seem to do "duty of care" there. The main thing that they wanted to do was remain on good terms with the school where the placement was held, due to the lack of placement places. In fact, one of their emails was trying to negotiate another trainee to take my place! And yet - what with me and the previous trainee - there were TWO complaints made about this Personal Mentor.

OP posts:
YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 10:34

Sunshine10012 · 04/07/2022 10:32

Doesn’t surprise me. Majority of teachers are bullies (not all before I get blasted!)
that’s Partly why a lot of kids are bullies.
school is just usually an all round horrible place for teenagers (especially) to be raised in.

Yes - it is a strange thing isn't it? When teaching is an absolute joy, (I did TEFL in Spain before DD arrived and loved it!) and when students can be so interesting, why is it that in British schools, the bullies seem to prevail?

By the way, I won't let this put me off teaching. I will return to TEFL. 😁

OP posts:
YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 10:32

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 04/07/2022 10:27

LMAO! Robust measures... that's a good one!

There may well be "robost measures in place to protect you as a trainee" 5mins, but perhaps not at the University that I atttended. Instead there seemed to be "robust measures" to ensure a massive online bitching session, with a view to negating the point of view of the bullied trainee and write them off.

However, I am sure that better Universities have these "robost measures" of which you speak.

OP posts:
Sunshine10012 · 04/07/2022 10:32

Doesn’t surprise me. Majority of teachers are bullies (not all before I get blasted!)
that’s Partly why a lot of kids are bullies.
school is just usually an all round horrible place for teenagers (especially) to be raised in.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 04/07/2022 10:30

@Dancingwithhyenas I wonder if you had the same mentor who bullied me off my first term of NQT. Absolutely bizarre, spiteful woman. When I raised it, I got sacked. She'd been there 20 years by then.

PeekabooAtTheZoo · 04/07/2022 10:27

justfiveminutes · 04/07/2022 02:25

I think I'd have asked for a different mentor, or a different school, rather than drop out completely. There are quite robust measures in place to protect you as a trainee.

LMAO! Robust measures... that's a good one!

Zilla1 · 04/07/2022 09:36

Might there be any value in asking how MMU think they've complied with their duty of care to you by placing you with a known bully without support?

YetanotherPGCEdropout · 04/07/2022 09:23

Thank you everyone! Really good advice and I'm sorry about the typing error. I will follow up with the complaint.

OP posts:
SarahProblem · 04/07/2022 09:21

Have you appealed via The Complaints team and received a response?

If not do so and if you have send the response and your original complaint with whatever evidence you have to the Office of the Independent Adjudicator. Do it quickly as there is often a strict time limit.

goldfinchonthelawn · 04/07/2022 09:19

believable not abel. I can spell. Honist! Wink

goldfinchonthelawn · 04/07/2022 09:18

ToadiesCouzin · 04/07/2022 07:08

So did your tutor know your mentor would be a bully, warned you about it, then did nothing when you struggled? I think that's worth pursuing, put in a complaint that you weren't adequately supported by the university. But as an aside, given the state of teacher recruitment in this country, the fact that trainee teachers (the same could be said for nurses etc) are charged over £9k to train is absurd. And that we can lose new recruits so easily, for something that could and should have been sorted by the university, is scandalous, we need you! Anyone would think the government don't want schools staffed with trained professionals. Maybe we'll move to fully remote education soon, have massive halls filled with students sitting at computers all day doing online learning (like in Mexico). We won't need very many teachers if we do that, just some adults for crowd control will do. We can get away with paying them peanuts, and there's probably some great opportunities for friends of the government to make a killing on contracts for all that new tech and IT support we'll need. A proper "education" will be for those who can go to private schools only, which is as it should be of course. We can't have the great unwashed getting ahead of themselves.

Fuck. Why does this sound so believabel. That makes me feel sick. Nothing more powerful than ensuring the masses are insufficiently educated. USA has been doing it for years.

StaunchMomma · 04/07/2022 09:17

Bullying of staff in schools is rife. I hear it so often.

Your mentor sounds like an utter nightmare. Make sure you put in a complaint against them, especially as a student prior to you suffered under them too.

I was bullied out of teaching too. It's horrible leaving something you've worked so hard for but honestly, your mental health is more important.

People in the private sector wouldn't believe the stuff that goes on in schools. It wouldn't be tolerated.