Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To despair that so many people have appalling table manners?

289 replies

Redpanda99 · 03/07/2022 22:21

Maybe I am just old fashioned, but when did it become acceptable for people to make loud slurping and lip smacking noises, chew with their mouths open, talk with their mouths full, scrape their fork against their teeth with every mouthful...aaargh!!! Whatever happened to good table manners? How can people eat and drink so noisily with no consideration for the people they are with? Surely it can't just be me who finds it disgusting? It gives me the rage!

OP posts:
Topseyt123 · 04/07/2022 11:19

LouisRenault · 04/07/2022 00:06

Elbows on the table is perfectly fine too, and a completely natural thing to do.

It's extremely annoying if you're sitting next to the person with elbows on the table. And how can you use your cutlery properly with your elbows on the table?

No it isn't annoying, unless you lean so far forward that you have your back virtually to them.

Nobody uses cutlery while resting their elbows on the table either. They just rest there when not using it.

Silly comments.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 04/07/2022 11:19

One of my friends, who is right handed, uses his knife and fork in the wrong hands, and he 'holds' the food with his knife and then uses his fork to drag the food apart.

It just looks so messy.

Why on earth are you paying this much attention to how a friend eats? If someone was picking up their plate and licking it then yes, I’d be raising my eyebrows, but studying how someone cuts their food and then judging them on it? Weird.

I'm really old fashioned, I think you do not know where your children may end up in life, knowing how to use cutlery correctly, in the correct order is one less thing to worry about if you are dining with the queen.

I wondered how long this would take 🙄I’m still amazed that we’re on page 5 and that no one has boasted about having been to high level military banquets yet.

Veol · 04/07/2022 11:16

Table manners vary enormously from country to country which suggests there isn’t a right way to eat food. Even slurping is considered polite in some countries but it would definitely be frowned upon by OP. I’ve always taught my children to have good table manners but I have always been slightly puzzled by people who are so worried about them.

BlackCatTabbyCat · 04/07/2022 10:56

Cutlery in "wrong hands", elbows on the table etc don't bother me but I can not stand noisy eaters. Its absolutely disgusting and unless there is medical reasons there is no excuse to eat like a pig 🤢🤢

PipeScatter · 04/07/2022 10:38

My DH eats loudly and I've finally got used to it, but I still cringe when we have to eat out with others. I've realised relatively recently that his is due to an issue with the shape of his mouth - he literally can't chew and keep his lips together at the same time. That's made me feel slightly better about it.

I should have realised sooner that it was a physical issue, rather than not being taught manners, as his sibling doesn't do it.

Even after 15 years though he doesn't seem to have realised I can't look him in the face while he's eating!

Other things like elbows on the table, not scraping your cutlery on the plate, etc, I grew up with so I tend to still not do it, but it doesn't bother me if other people do (although the scraping cutlery goes right through me!).

BashfulClam · 04/07/2022 10:28

I had my left hand injured badly as a child, while it recovered I had to use my fork in my right hand and now that’s what I do. A woman at a work meal pointed out I was using the wrong hand. I just stared at her and said ‘we’ll would you prefer the food in my mouth or on your lap as I make a total mess using my left!’ She tied to make out she was joking.

torquewench · 04/07/2022 10:25

I watched a singer (think he's called Youngblood, looked like a Robert Smith wannabe) on Sunday Brunch a while back. Slumped in his seat eating with his mouth open and talking with his mouth full, on the telly. 🤢🤮

FrankLampardsBrokenHand · 04/07/2022 10:23

I couldn't care less what hands people hold their cutlery in, or where they rest their elbows.

But eating with your mouth open, talking with a mouth of food, slurping, lip smacking, teeth bashing etc are things that impact on other people who are expected to endure it. People who do those things should stay at home.

tomatopsste · 04/07/2022 10:15

stayingpositiveifpossible · 04/07/2022 09:57

My dad was left handed he has passed on now bless him.

He told me at school they used to tie his left hand behind his back.

It is historical apparently. People used to say left handers were witches.

To me they are simply very special.

Same as my dad!

MeMe3Spoons · 04/07/2022 10:14

If someone is doing something unhygienic, like talking with their mouth full or using their own cutlery in shared food I would feel offended. Beyond that I can't really bring myself to care about 'table manners', who made these rules anyway and why?

liveforsummer · 04/07/2022 10:14

Sux2buthen · 03/07/2022 22:34

Talking with your mouth full is a bit gross but 'the wrong hand' is a load of tripe.

This - making unpleasant noises affects you. Seeing the chewed contents of someone's mouth is yuk! I can't for a second get upset at what hand someone holds their fork in. Perhaps they are left handed for example. Even if not, who cares?!

Triffid1 · 04/07/2022 10:09

And actually, to add to the kid-centric approach - it's why children aren't taught to wait for everyone else or why they are allowed to just wander off when they're finished. Both of which I hate.

Triffid1 · 04/07/2022 10:07

choosername1234 · 04/07/2022 08:56

I think it's absolutely fine to be relaxed about these things in your own home or in a relaxed restaurant with close friends/families.
But...you have to be aware that in certain social situations you will be silently judged for lack of (table) manners. And by not teaching these societal norms to your children they too will be judged as they get older.
It would be great if this didn't happen but I think we need to teach our children to thrive in the world we live in, not an ideal world we wish would exist

I was coming on here to say a version of this. I do think that the exact details of which hand you use etc is certainly less of an issue today, but broadly speaking, polite considerate eating is important in certain circumstances. I'm always telling the DC that they can choose to ignore the rules when they are adults... but they still need to know them.

Overall, I'm relatively not-strict but I do insist on closed mouth eating, no shovelling and, largely, no elbows on table (there are casual moments where it's okay). But I am constantly surprised how few of the DC's friends have similar basic standards. I don't think it's because people don't eat together. I think it's because of the very kid-centric approach many parents have today - I've heard people say things like "Why should my children have to stick to these antiquated rules?" etc. Hell, DH says it sometimes and I always go back to @choosername1234 's response above.

Bluevelvetsofa · 04/07/2022 10:07

Left handed people are certainly very special, in a good way. Creative, intuitive, artistic etc.

I use my fork in my left hand because that’s what my right handed parents taught me. They were very particular about using a knife correctly, not like a pen, so that bothers me more than which hand it’s in.

nickthefox · 04/07/2022 09:58

Penguintears · 03/07/2022 23:44

I think "despair" is a bit dramatic. There are many things to despair about in the world and table manners is not one of them.

However, I do find it difficult that some of my relatives' children have not been taught what is polite behaviour at the table. Watching ipads and ignoring the conversation at 12yo is just rude. As is starting eating before everyone else has been served. Particularly bad is leaving the table as soon as they're finished without saying a word!

So YABU to "despair" but YANBU to be irritated.

That's funny, I purposely give the younger ones their dinner to eat first because they're slow, so as I'm serving up I stagger the plates so we roughly finish on time.

as for elbows on the table
I used to think it was tripe but it turns out tiny elbows are capable of BIG spills!

stayingpositiveifpossible · 04/07/2022 09:57

My dad was left handed he has passed on now bless him.

He told me at school they used to tie his left hand behind his back.

It is historical apparently. People used to say left handers were witches.

To me they are simply very special.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 04/07/2022 09:54

My new approach - not getting stressed by these things but approaching them with humour...😀

stayingpositiveifpossible · 04/07/2022 09:54

I was in the cinema the other day not far from someone who was slurping VERY loudly.

I gave a considered response 'Could you do that a bit louder please?'

They DID. But it didn't last long as they got bored. Thank goodness.

tomatopsste · 04/07/2022 09:52

RampantIvy · 04/07/2022 09:42

What is it with this discrimination against left handers?

It is not rude in any way to hold your knife in your left hand, and to say so is rude and discriminating. I am right handed and if i was cutting a steak with my knife in my non dominant (left) hand I would be very clumsy and probably end up with food on the table.

So please stop saying that people are using cutlery in "the wrong hands". This is the 21st century not the Victorian era.

👏 👏

BeReet · 04/07/2022 09:51

I am left handed and the rest of the family are righties. All my kids eat with the knife in their left and fork in their right as I do because I am the one who taught them how to use cutlery.

There is no open mouth chewing or any other disgusting habits because I, and two of the DC, have misophonia and cannot bear it. For that reason we always have background music on at mealtimes too.

I am a TA in a primary school and I work lunchtimes. I have taught my class about using cutlery, keeping mouths closed whilst chewing and saying please and thank you to the dinner ladies. They've picked it up beautifully tbh, they're good kids

Itwasntmeright · 04/07/2022 09:51

As far as I’m concerned as long as someone can get the food from the plate to their mouth without making a mess, chew and swallow without making disgusting sounds, showing me the contents of their mouth or spitting food everywhere, their table manners are fine. I couldn’t care less which hand they hold their fork in, whether they hold a knife like a pencil, eat everything with a spoon or even use their fingers, as long as they can do it without making a mess or putting anyone else off I don’t care.

malloo · 04/07/2022 09:44

Don't think I would notice if someone had their knife and fork the 'wrong' way round, and I don't get why elbows on the table is rude, it's just a comfortable way to sit, and you lift them up when you're eating anyway.

But noisy eating I can't stand. I have a relative who is bizarrely strict with her kid about 'asking to leave the table' and finishing everything on his plate but doesn't seem to care about him eating with his mouth open, it's grim. Doesn't even make sense, isn't it easier to keep your mouth shut when you eat then there's no risk of your food falling out?

Whitehorsegirl · 04/07/2022 09:44

Using the ''wrong'' hand or elbow on tables don't bother me.

It is no so much about etiquette for me and more about people who are messy eaters, which I don't like: chewing with your mouth open, making a lot of noise, talking with a mouth full of food, leaking your fingers, picking your teeth. I find that disgusting.

I was once having lunch with my line manager and she started using two fingers to gather the last of the sauce in her plate then stuck them in her mouth. She did that until there was nothing left. I really would not expect this of a mature adult...

I would not want to be friend with and certainly would not date anyone who did not have decent table manners in that sense.

RampantIvy · 04/07/2022 09:42

What is it with this discrimination against left handers?

It is not rude in any way to hold your knife in your left hand, and to say so is rude and discriminating. I am right handed and if i was cutting a steak with my knife in my non dominant (left) hand I would be very clumsy and probably end up with food on the table.

So please stop saying that people are using cutlery in "the wrong hands". This is the 21st century not the Victorian era.

Allthegoodusernamesareused · 04/07/2022 09:32

I'm right handed, but was taught to use a knife and fork by my left handed mother, and eat with my cutlery in the "wrong" hands. TBH I really don't give a shit what any random snob thinks about that.

I don't chew with my mouth open, or speak with my mouth full, because it's disgusting, and my kids no better than to do that. Visiting children, not so much, but I'll ask them politely not to do it.

Elbows on the table don't particularly bother me, but my husband hates it.

We all wait to start eating until everyone has their food, the only exception is when we're eating out if someone's main course is delayed and others are going to get cold.

Swipe left for the next trending thread