Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to expect child’s father to do all travelling?

131 replies

Hebra387 · 03/07/2022 19:46

I split with sons dad over ten years ago, son is now nearly 13. We moved 3.5 hours away from all friends and family to a completely new area as I inherited some money and felt it best to invest in buying a property outright, although it meant moving so far away. (I also didn’t earn enough to get a mortgage). Son was happy for us to move as we’d experienced some traumas in our hometown.

Initially sons dad travelled to us every other weekend and stayed in my guest room which did NOT work out, my ex agreed this was not working. So we agreed to travel half the distance every fortnight and travel half the distance to bring son home, so essentially sharing the travel equally.

Sine Covid I was made redundant, started a new WFH role and that company went into liquidation as well, in the meantime son has developed severe anxiety around attending school and is being assessed for additional needs. So I have very limited options for work at the moment, and a very old banger which needs constant maintenance with the amount of miles I would need to do.

Few months back son has huge falling out with his father and vows not to go and see him anymore (which has been on the cards for some time, their relationship was limping along with lots of encouragement from me to keep it going.) I have since decided that due to fuel costs being so high, barely having enough money to pay bills and pay for food for a boy who eats a lot now, I cannot realistically afford to keep travelling half way and back every fortnight. Sons dad has a company car so doesn’t have to pay to maintain it, and can claim back fuel expenses, lives with his mum and has a very good job. I’ve explained the situation to my ex and said that the times our son wants to see him (which are few and far between currently) that he will need to do all the travelling. I’ve said if he wants to reduce maintenance money in light of this or see our son much less (only school holidays for eg) that’s all fine, and to just work it out with our son who’s old enough now to sort out with his dad when he sees him. I’ve also mentioned he could come down here and stay at a cheap B&B to save fuel costs and time.

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChiselandBits · 04/07/2022 13:22

It really isn't as simple as "who moved". Everyone seems to be assuming that the dad would have been hands on, regular contact, 50/50 if she hadn't moved. The Op hasn't said either way but its not uncommon for NRPs to do fuck all when living round the corner. If that were the case, the OP as the RP, is perfectly justified to do what is in her and the child's best interests, which is NOT always to bend over backwards to facilitate some half arsed EOW or less arrangement and scupper herself financially in the process. As the RP she will be paying the vast majority of all costs associated with that child and doing all of the actual parenting. Why should she ALSO have to do 50% of his tiny amount of input? There are some unknown variables here but lets not jump to assume that she is automatically in the wrong for moving to a place her and her child are happy and have made a life. The ex could have applied for a prohibited steps order, or asked for 50/50 care. If he did and a court rejected it, I'd have more sympathy but in the absence of that, I'm with the OP. Its different when an NRP moves away (assuming they were EOW or less) and expects the RP to share the travel, as they are already doing very little, and then the "who moved" thing becomes relevant, but not in this case.

PeekAtYou · 04/07/2022 13:04

A judge wouldn't make a 12/13 year old go to his dad's house if he didn't want to. He would be judged old enough to never see Dad if that's what he wanted.

You are unreasonable to move 3.5 hours away and expect dad to do all the travelling but if your ex is happy to do so then you don't need to ask us. My ex moved 3.5 hours away and does all the travelling because he moved. He used to live 40 mins away so it's a massive shock for my teens who understandably moan about how far it is. When you decided on a location 3.5 hours away didn't you realise it would negatively affect your son's relationship with his dad? As I said earlier ex used to live 40 mins away and this worked well. Far enough to live different lives but close enough to be able to see the kids easily and go to school events.

justfiveminutes · 04/07/2022 12:53

"but he beats the responsibility of not adequately financially supporting his child."

I know they arranged it between themselves rather than going through cms but I don't think he pays less than he should does he?

OP how much does he pay you?

Midlifemusings · 04/07/2022 12:28

You put your son in a situation where he was exposed to an abusive man and experienced trauma and you moved him away from his dad. You bought a house but are now house poor and can't afford to feed him properly and you moved to a much cheaper area which likely has less CAMHS services.

I am not surprised your son doesn't want to see his dad much right now. It is really hard for dad to maintain a good relationship given your decisions and his current mental health state that makes him not want to leave the house.

You seeing son as needing to be rescued from dads when he calls and deciding to work from home so son can be at home with you all do and not go out is not necessarily what is most healthy for your son.

I really hope he gets some mental health help soon. 13 isn't an easy age to be in the situation he is in. Expecting dad to do all the travel is unreasonable however at this point your son's mental health is a bigger issue than who drives where.

Frankola · 04/07/2022 12:20

You moved. The person who does the moving should facilitate travel and travel costs. Standard rule apparently.

I know this sounds harsh OP but your personal finances are not his problem. Have you managed to find other employment?

howtomoveforwards · 04/07/2022 11:42

She could have saved some. So if she lost her job she didn’t have to welch on her obligation to facilitate her son’s contact with his father

Really? You know that, about a stranger on the internet, that she could have saved some of the inheritance she received?

You’ve been apart a decade and where he lives and what he spends his money on is none of your business

So you can judge where the OP lives and what she spends her money on, but she can't do that in relation to her ex?!

TrashyPanda · 04/07/2022 10:10

Sharing the travelling is the only fair option.
or you could travel to his and stay in a B&B so you are close for your son.

TBH you do not give the impression you wish to facilitate a relationship between father and son.

SarahProblem · 04/07/2022 09:32

You are being incredibly unreasonable this situation is entirely of your creation.

You moved away and you wonder why their relationship is strained? You don't have a mortgage based on what you said. You really need to get a job and get a car and to be honest, grow the hell up.

The amount of disposable income and his living arrangements are nothing to do with you as you've split. As long as he pays his maintenance.

Herejustforthisone · 04/07/2022 09:22

How
much maintenance does he pay?

Snog · 04/07/2022 08:50

I think that if your ds wants to see his dad you should absolutely facilitate this to the best of your abilities. Really only you know what this looks like in your circumstances right now.

RewildingAmbridge · 04/07/2022 08:21

You just say to him look I've not been to CMS all these years, but I cannot afford this travel, if you were paying the CMS rate I could, so it's up to you. I'd almost guarantee his contact with his child drops off a cliff.
You do bes bear some responsibility in that you moved so far away, but he beats the responsibility of not adequately financially supporting his child

SleeplessInEngland · 04/07/2022 08:09

You moved that far away so I’m not surprised they have a not-great relationship. At that distance it barely stood a chance.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 04/07/2022 07:38

I’ve always thought it so unfair that one partner 99% of the time the dad, has to do all the traveling. Before we moved, it was costing us two tanks of fuel a month! Now it’s one tank a month but it costs the same as roughly 1.5 tanks did previously. DSS mum point blank refuses to drive and is also fiddling CMS, UC and Child benefit so could afford the fuel (before anyone says anything we know this as older child told us) It all grates rather a lot.

millymollymoomoo · 04/07/2022 07:21

The really unreasonable part was moving your some 3.5 hours away to begin with

liveforsummer · 04/07/2022 07:20

Surely the solution would be for dad to collect dc on Friday and you go and pick up when they are ready to come home? I know you say you can't afford it but then you say you'd deduct the travel expenses from maintenance for him so that doesn't make a huge amount of sense. It would also free up your Fridays and make it possible for you to find Monday- Friday work. Doesn't sound like it will be that frequent anyway if someone isn't wanting to go much. I do think YABU to expect him to do all the driving and fork out for accommodation on top for minimal contact because your ds doesn't even want to leave the house

Pinklady245612 · 04/07/2022 07:20

A lot of this, from your response, seems to be financial. So why have you said to your ex that he can reduce maintenance payments? You're out of the money either way so facilitate the relationship

justfiveminutes · 04/07/2022 07:15

I think it's a bit rich to say that they don't have a great relationship due to seeing each other infrequently, when you moved 3.5 hours away. I know you inherited money and wanted to buy a secure home but couldn't you have found somewhere nearer?

You also seem very focused on the fact that he has more disposable income than you, when he achieves this only by living with his mum while you own a house outright.

And as pp have said, you can't claim fuel for personal miles.

He's maintained regular contact for 10 years, picked up the lion's share of the driving recently without complaint, paid regular maintenance and, presumably, not said a word when his son calls you to collect him early and you do.

Having said that, if you genuinely can't afford it, then there is no option but to sit down and work out an alternative schedule that everyone is happy with, but if I was your ex I'd be upset about quite a lot of this and I think it's great that you've managed to stay amicable throughout.

Cervinia · 04/07/2022 05:51

I highly doubt your ex can claim fuel mileage for trips to see his son, thats not how person use works on a company car. Sorry but you moved away, I understand why, but I voted YABU.

Your last line in the OP said the father could come to you and stay in a B&B to save fuel costs & time, how does that save fuel costs and time for him? Or did you mean for you?

coffeecupsandfairylights · 04/07/2022 05:37

YABU.

You chose to move 3.5 hours away to the middle of nowhere 🤷🏻‍♀️

HarryPopper · 04/07/2022 04:00

You moved 3.5 hours away in the sticks away from your son's father, family, friends and connections. He knows that mum is not working and stressed about money. Do you also bad mouth the father in front of him? Your son is now anxious and going through further assessments. He is isolated at home with you all day. You refuse to formalise the maintenance through CMS or ask for more money. You're overly picky with your work choices when you're struggling to manage. You'll be a long time on UC with all these extra conditions you've put for a job. Just seems all your way or no way and very inflexible.

Sons need their fathers especially at this age, unless the father is abusive of course. He is a moody teen, of course he will have arguments with dad sometimes. It'd be wrong to sever their relationship over silly teen drama. It's a tumultuous stage for everyone and you should facilitate their relationship. Therefore, I think YABVU.

StoppinBy · 04/07/2022 03:54

YABU. You chose the move and therefore forced the travel, you are responsible for at least half the travel costs and I think your ex has already been more than reasonable about that.

Newmumatlast · 04/07/2022 03:54

Hebra387 · 03/07/2022 20:09

If I earned over £35k a year and he was on universal credit of £625 a month and £80 child benefit I would’ve paid for all the travel if our son wanted to see his dad yes.

Presumably you have no mortgage? What is maintenance on top of this and are you getting the right amount?

In principal I think yabu as you moved and most of the time the court would expect 50/50 (which given you moved is actually arguably still unfair to Dad). Agree with others though that at 13 your son would have a say about contact.

Selttan · 04/07/2022 03:21

Sorry if I've missed this but what response did your ex have when you asked him?

If he's against it, is perhaps not so much the money side but the time spent traveling? Could you see if he is willing to help out with petrol costs in the interim and still split the travel?

CJsGoldfish · 04/07/2022 03:01

AnneLovesGilbert · 03/07/2022 20:38

You ruined the chance of them having a better relationship by moving away. He might be a useless arsehole but you chose a house in the sticks which used up the whole inheritance over 3 hours away over his chance to have a meaningful day to day relationship with his dad.

Expecting credit for any of that is extremely rich. You did no one but yourself any favours and it was free money, not something you worked for.

You need to make whatever changes are necessary to improve your own situation, it’s not your ex’s responsibility. You’ve been apart a decade and where he lives and what he spends his money on is none of your business. He’s gone way above and beyond travelling to you at all.

100% this.
It's clear you are only going to do what suits you here so not sure why you bothered posting 🤷‍♀️

Lachimolala · 04/07/2022 01:34

@GylesBrandrethNewJumper There’s no one universal experience with the family court system, so I’m not really sure how to respond to this. All cases are different so all experiences I should imagine differ vastly.

@Steptoeandson It would depend on the results of cafcass assessments of him, but generally speaking the older a child gets the more of a voice they have.