Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd home from uni.. we are struggling to adapt. Aibu to admit and to ask for tips?

311 replies

Superdoopas · 03/07/2022 17:24

Dh and I have been by ourself mostly for 4 years now as dd did a degree that involved placements in the holidays.
We have got quite set in our ways. We are semi retired and love a quiet house .. its our haven.
Dd has come home and whilst she is being lovely.. we are struggling to adapt.
For example , I like to spend hours alone in the kitchen batch cooking by myself... find it really relaxing / creative.
Dd knows this but just came in an started chatting. I cant follow recipies and chat.
She cooks a full english mid am.. i normally clean the kitchen each am then its really good for rhe day.
Little routines that I love.

She is looking for a job and applications are in but until then ( may be a long time due to competition) we are starting to feel a bit frazzled.
She is lovely, but she is young with a need for lots of company wereas we often do things like sit and read. I repeat to myself that we are reallt helping her etc , but we are struggling to adapt.
Any pearls of wisdom that can aid us in this transition please.

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 04/07/2022 12:26

thing47 · 04/07/2022 10:00

Sure, depends on what you mean by long term, though. DD2 (mid 20s) lived away for university for 4 years, has been living back with me for the past 18 months (during Masters and now working locally).

I would argue she has shown she is perfectly capable of living independently but would rather live with me for now. And I like it. YMMV, of course, we're all different.

@thing47

how long will you like it for?
when she’s 40 and she’s still living with you would you like it then?

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 12:19

@EnterACloud I've just bought the book for a friend's big birthday and a copy for myself. We shall both enjoy it. Thanks

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 12:11

EnterACloud · 04/07/2022 11:47

This is a bit niche but there's a short story called The Unrest Cure by Saki, OP reminds me of the character in that.

I don't know how it is,'' he told his friend, I'm not much over forty, but I seem to have settled down into a deep groove of elderly middle-age. My sister shows the same tendency. We like everything to be exactly in its accustomed place; we like things to happen exactly at their appointed times; we like everything to be usual, orderly, punctual, methodical, to a hair's breadth, to a minute. It distresses and upsets us if it is not so. For instance, to take a very trifling matter, a thrush has built its nest year after year in the catkin-tree on the lawn; this year, for no obvious reason, it is building in the ivy on the garden wall. We have said very little about it, but I think we both feel that the change is unnecessary, and just a little irritating.''
Perhaps,'' said the friend, it is a different thrush.''
We have suspected that,'' said J. P. Huddle, and I think it gives us even more cause for annoyance. We don't feel that we want a change of thrush at our time of life; and yet, as I have said, we have scarcely reached an age when these things should make themselves seriously felt.''

That's brilliant I can see it in friends husband's more than the women I know, to be fair we're more able or expected to be flexible, not sure which though at times

LobeliaBaggins · 04/07/2022 11:57

I love Saki! "Romance at short notice was her specialty". That reminds me a bit of OP's DD as well.

rookiemere · 04/07/2022 11:55

EnterACloud · 04/07/2022 11:47

This is a bit niche but there's a short story called The Unrest Cure by Saki, OP reminds me of the character in that.

I don't know how it is,'' he told his friend, I'm not much over forty, but I seem to have settled down into a deep groove of elderly middle-age. My sister shows the same tendency. We like everything to be exactly in its accustomed place; we like things to happen exactly at their appointed times; we like everything to be usual, orderly, punctual, methodical, to a hair's breadth, to a minute. It distresses and upsets us if it is not so. For instance, to take a very trifling matter, a thrush has built its nest year after year in the catkin-tree on the lawn; this year, for no obvious reason, it is building in the ivy on the garden wall. We have said very little about it, but I think we both feel that the change is unnecessary, and just a little irritating.''
Perhaps,'' said the friend, it is a different thrush.''
We have suspected that,'' said J. P. Huddle, and I think it gives us even more cause for annoyance. We don't feel that we want a change of thrush at our time of life; and yet, as I have said, we have scarcely reached an age when these things should make themselves seriously felt.''

That's wonderful- thank you for sharing that.

Wilkolampshade · 04/07/2022 11:53

Oh OP you have my sympathy.
DD1 came home a year ago after a 4 year course and it certainly has required some renegotiation. She isn't the same person she was 4/5 years ago and neither am I.
When she arrived she was in a pretty poor state and needed some care so in a way, that was easier, I could still 'mum' her a bit. But as she's grown in confidence and wellness we've probably had more fractious moments as she seeks to establish her independence and I've found it necessary to remind her that this comes with some responsibilities. There has been a lot of tongue biting on both sides I'm sure. What helped was:
1/ her getting a job. ANY job, initially. She has an excellent graduate program type role now, BUT took other work until it came through. It gave her financial freedom and got her out of the house. Good for both of us.
2/ Tell her the problem. 'Love, light of my life, beloved fruit of my loins etc etc, I love you more than I can say BUT Monday mornings? I need the kitchen to myself, UNINTERRUPTED, or no-ones getting fed'
3/This will pass.

Good luck. X

EnterACloud · 04/07/2022 11:47

This is a bit niche but there's a short story called The Unrest Cure by Saki, OP reminds me of the character in that.

I don't know how it is,'' he told his friend, I'm not much over forty, but I seem to have settled down into a deep groove of elderly middle-age. My sister shows the same tendency. We like everything to be exactly in its accustomed place; we like things to happen exactly at their appointed times; we like everything to be usual, orderly, punctual, methodical, to a hair's breadth, to a minute. It distresses and upsets us if it is not so. For instance, to take a very trifling matter, a thrush has built its nest year after year in the catkin-tree on the lawn; this year, for no obvious reason, it is building in the ivy on the garden wall. We have said very little about it, but I think we both feel that the change is unnecessary, and just a little irritating.''
Perhaps,'' said the friend, it is a different thrush.''
We have suspected that,'' said J. P. Huddle, and I think it gives us even more cause for annoyance. We don't feel that we want a change of thrush at our time of life; and yet, as I have said, we have scarcely reached an age when these things should make themselves seriously felt.''

Nanny0gg · 04/07/2022 11:44

AnnieMill · 04/07/2022 10:08

I’m really not sure how else to interpret OP’s attitude at the inconvenience of having her home for a while. I know not all parents love their children and want to support them until they’re properly on their feet, but it baffles me why people who want to be left alone have kids at all.

Still, I can assure OP and any parent like them that their children will soon get the message and stop bothering them! I know I did, and it’s not something you soon forget.

You may get by on duty, but love is a relationship that must be maintained. A well loved child will check in on you in your old age regularly and do all they can to maintain your quality of life, because you’ve taught them to express love as care. A child who felt like an unwelcome burden will one day treat you the same. Expect an email link to the local care home and not much else.

So, would you be prepared to have your child home forever? If not, how long?
At what age do you think you can send them on their way?

I love my kids. They've all been back more than once. I accommodate them, make room for them, accept that they don't always do things my way.

But I'm bloody glad when they've gone!

It's my house. It's my home. They want homes of their own and after my DH and I being parents for 40+ years we deserve to have peace and quiet and do what we want when we want in our own house without considering anyone else.

justasking111 · 04/07/2022 11:40

Thinking of OP this morning. I'm going into hospital tomorrow for a minor procedure. So I've been cleaning, washin, hoovering etc because I'm not able to bend, lift for four weeks. I'm not supposed to sneeze or cough either

DS has a stinking cold and is wombling around coughing and sneezing while he makes a snack, clutters up the sitting room. He's moping because university is finished and he'll be parted from his partner until they both get proper jobs.

I'm trying not to snap at him but he's in the way that's for sure

Nanny0gg · 04/07/2022 11:32

hassletassle · 03/07/2022 20:56

Dear me, your poor daughter. It doesn't sound like she's doing anything wrong ... other than existing. It's not "someone else living in your home", it's "your child living in their home!". She's only been gone 4 years! Just get over yourself and stop wishing your own (well behaved) child wasn't there.

'Only' four years?

Is there a length of time when you can consider it permanent?

burnoutbabe · 04/07/2022 11:30

sutrely your batch cooking needs some focus in the same way that if she needed to study for the morning, she could not do it if you were sat with her chatting away?

So just mention that Monday mornings (or whenever) is batch cooking day so youll need the kitchen free and empty for that process. My boyfriend does that when its BEER MAKING DAY - he needs to measre stuff etc - i can grab quick coffee but i wouldn't insist on chatting to him - just as i wouldn't if he was working or on a call.

Meraas · 04/07/2022 11:26

@thing47

So are you saying a house is only the home of the person who pays the mortgage? Hmm, that's an interesting take.
So in the years when I was a stay-at-home mum looking after a young family and DH was paying the entire mortgage out of his salary, it wasn't actually my home? I would beg to differ on that one.

That's not what the poster was saying. A marriage/couple is a partnership. Children are meant to be raised and launched into the world and make their own way in life (with whatever parental support the parents see fit).

An adult child has no automatic legal right to their parents' home. If the adult calls the police, who would the police remove, the adult child or the parent who owns the home?

DiamanteDelia · 04/07/2022 11:15

oviraptor21 · 04/07/2022 10:42

What about a parent who's treated like no more than a convenience - somewhere handy to live rent free and never do any cleaning?
Children who feel unwelcome may well have behaved in a way that made them unwelcome.

There's no suggestion that OP's daughter is like this- she describes her as lovely.

oviraptor21 · 04/07/2022 10:42

What about a parent who's treated like no more than a convenience - somewhere handy to live rent free and never do any cleaning?
Children who feel unwelcome may well have behaved in a way that made them unwelcome.

oviraptor21 · 04/07/2022 10:39

How wildly off the mark to suggest that OP doesn't love her DD or that she isn't prepared to support her until she can support herself. Fortunately the last page of posts seem to have a bit more awareness of the issues that having adult children at home can bring. One of them is that you can't really tell them what to do. You can ask them and hope that they are reasonable. Otherwise you have to just suck up their untidiness or noisiness or being in your kitchen or bathroom or watching the TV when you've previously had freedom to use it when you choose. How accommodating your DC is may well determine how long they get to stay in your home - yes, your home.

AnnieMill · 04/07/2022 10:08

I’m really not sure how else to interpret OP’s attitude at the inconvenience of having her home for a while. I know not all parents love their children and want to support them until they’re properly on their feet, but it baffles me why people who want to be left alone have kids at all.

Still, I can assure OP and any parent like them that their children will soon get the message and stop bothering them! I know I did, and it’s not something you soon forget.

You may get by on duty, but love is a relationship that must be maintained. A well loved child will check in on you in your old age regularly and do all they can to maintain your quality of life, because you’ve taught them to express love as care. A child who felt like an unwelcome burden will one day treat you the same. Expect an email link to the local care home and not much else.

TheDepthsOfDespair · 04/07/2022 10:04

NRTFT

sorry if it’s already been suggested but perhaps some cbt could help you to recognise patterns in your thinking around this and help you to change the thought patterns. Lots of cbt websites and apps available.

thing47 · 04/07/2022 10:00

SurfBox · 04/07/2022 08:57

My 20something DCs still come and live at home from time to time (in between periods of renting their own places, or studying away). They will always be welcome because, you know, they are my children and it's their home

easy to say with short time stays;if one or 2 of them came back long term you might feel different.

Sure, depends on what you mean by long term, though. DD2 (mid 20s) lived away for university for 4 years, has been living back with me for the past 18 months (during Masters and now working locally).

I would argue she has shown she is perfectly capable of living independently but would rather live with me for now. And I like it. YMMV, of course, we're all different.

thing47 · 04/07/2022 09:53

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/07/2022 09:03

@thing47

Its not their home though is it?

Did they buy it? Is their name on the mortgage? No! So it’s not their home is it.

Where does this infantilisation end? When your son or daughter buys their own house is your house still their home?? No.

Children grow up and become independent and have their own home away from where they grew up (or they should). And that’s normal and natural and a positive thing.

So are you saying a house is only the home of the person who pays the mortgage? Hmm, that's an interesting take.

So in the years when I was a stay-at-home mum looking after a young family and DH was paying the entire mortgage out of his salary, it wasn't actually my home? I would beg to differ on that one.

I agree with your last paragraph, but I don't think that precludes the possibility of DCs returning from time to time in certain circumstances.

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/07/2022 09:49

AnnieMill · 04/07/2022 09:41

Do you think maybe DD took part in so many summer programs because she already knows you resent having her at home?

@AnnieMill

oh get a grip! Op doesn’t sound as if she resents her daughter at all, more that she would find it hard to organise her entire home and domestic routine around her - and why should she?!

LuckySantangelo35 · 04/07/2022 09:48

maryleboneym · 04/07/2022 09:22

I have one DD and she's still really young but im dreading the day she leaves us

Cherish these days before she moves out forever

@maryleboneym

youll change how you feel! Wait until the teen stages etc you’ll be looking toward to the day when your house is your own again and you’re not just ‘’mum” etc

AnnieMill · 04/07/2022 09:41

Do you think maybe DD took part in so many summer programs because she already knows you resent having her at home?

PearlClutch · 04/07/2022 09:34

SurfBox · 04/07/2022 09:16

Children grow up and become independent and have their own home away from where they grew up (or they should). And that’s normal and natural and a positive thing

this and and I think so many on this thread don't understand that yet as their kids are still kids;they will reach a stage where they will totally emphasize with the op.

Yep: once a child has become an adult and left home, they are responsible for themselves, in the usual course of things.

I do know people who call their parents' homes 'home' - even in their thirties/forties, when they've bought their own house and had their own children. It seems they consider their 'real' home is with their parents.

SurfBox · 04/07/2022 09:25

*I have one DD and she's still really young but im dreading the day she leaves us

Cherish these days before she moves out forever*

many parents will say this but time will ultimately change this view. Come back in 20 years time and say you want her back.

eldora · 04/07/2022 09:24

maryleboneym · 04/07/2022 09:22

I have one DD and she's still really young but im dreading the day she leaves us

Cherish these days before she moves out forever

It's quite arrogant of you to give this advice to a woman wo has succcessfully raised her children into adulthood.

Come back in 20 years time.