Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to work.

824 replies

kahase72 · 03/07/2022 01:06

Hi. I’m a housewife currently. I have 3 DC, youngest 15. I’ve been out of work for about 18 years to take care of my DC. My DH wants me to go back to work now theyre more independent but I don’t want to. We don’t really NEED money, but it would be nice to have it. AIBU to not go back?

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 05/07/2022 17:24

of course YABU, why should he fund your whole life on his own? That's so selfish

Anothernamechangeplease · 05/07/2022 17:23

SAHMonMN · 05/07/2022 17:08

The thing is, very few parents are ever going to have exactly the same jobs with exactly the same hours; do exactly the same tasks with the kids and so on so on. This is not realistic. Children don't need two clone parents! Even where two parents are working, you'll personably get one who tends to do the ferrying to whatever club / activity at the weekends, one who gravitates more towards helping with the maths or whatever; one who tends to cook more; or if the packed lunches or whatever. All parents, working or not, have different personalities and will naturally gravitate towards certain things.

I can only speak for myself, but I never felt as if I needed my husband to be doing exactly the same things as me (parenting-wise) day to day. That would just be inefficient. I know he could make a packed lunch; or get the PE kits ready or whatever the day to day stuff is, but I didn't particularly NEED him to be doing that. Why would I? He did other things with them - sports on the weekends; lifts, plays various video games; bike rides; camping trips; computer / tech related homework help ... so many things that weren't my particular forte. Just play to your strengths basically. Similarly, he didn't NEED me to be making money, so all that side of things I didn't have to worry about. It's still a partnership snd of course you are equal parents, but you allow each other to focus and play to your strengths and natural inclinations. Ok, I might have been more involved in the kids academics and schools, but they wouldn't have been in those schools were it not for money he was able to generate (and I sound never have been able to put 4 kids through school on the type of money U was likely to make). So different roles, but the same common goal which is the kids education. Then we have shared ventures - eg, properties we've bought and renovated. He will sort the finances, I manage the renovations on site. It's still teamwork, but it's a better use of our time and resources. It's easier for us to have our own roles than be doing the same things day to day. Also, things change over the years and these days he's WFH and as visible to the kids as I am anyway. It's rarely as clear cut as people may think. That's my experience anyway.

Of course parents will have different strengths and preferences. Nobody is saying that they have to do exactly the same things with their dc. However, in my personal opinion, it's preferable for both parents to have a similar level of hands-on involvement and time with the dc so that both can build equally strong relationships. For that reason, I have always felt it important for both DH and I to maintain a good work-life balance and for both of us to be fully involved at home. Just because I happen to be the higher earner in our family, I don't see why that should mean that I would want to sacrifice my relationship with my dc. And I would question his values if the situations were reversed and he was happy to leave it all to me.

WimpoleHat · 05/07/2022 17:21

Funnily, it did also help my husband be, not a more involved parent, because he was always pretty equally involved, but our life and both our parenting became more fun and relaxed because we weren't always one step ahead of chaos

Fully agree with that, @Mummyford . People are mixing up “not having to worry about the domestic stuff” with “not being an involved parent”. And the two are not synonymous. My DH was hugely present for the kids when he got home from work, at the weekends, in the holidays - and would always prioritise getting to school concerts etc. He just wouldn’t have to worry about who was picking them up from school, what they’d be doing in the school holidays when he wasn’t off or whether they had school uniform.

Plus - the threads on here are myriad. “How do people cope with two FT working parents?” is a pretty common topic for discussion. And the answer is always to be very organised at the weekends: kids’ clubs, batch cooking, washing uniforms etc. Which is fine - nothing wrong with that and all very sensible. But to me, the real value of one of us being at home was that didn’t have to happen at the weekends: we had the time (and were fortunate to have the money) to be able to do loads of fun trips and activities as a family, because the cooking and shopping could wait until Monday.

It’s a choice borne out of privilege, absolutely. But it’s a lifestyle choice which works really well for some families. Two people in very senior City/legal/business jobs may well earn 7 figures between them, but they won’t have much at all in the way of time with their family. If you both love your jobs, then maybe that suits you. If you see it as more of a means to an end, then maybe it doesn’t…..

SAHMonMN · 05/07/2022 17:08

The thing is, very few parents are ever going to have exactly the same jobs with exactly the same hours; do exactly the same tasks with the kids and so on so on. This is not realistic. Children don't need two clone parents! Even where two parents are working, you'll personably get one who tends to do the ferrying to whatever club / activity at the weekends, one who gravitates more towards helping with the maths or whatever; one who tends to cook more; or if the packed lunches or whatever. All parents, working or not, have different personalities and will naturally gravitate towards certain things.

I can only speak for myself, but I never felt as if I needed my husband to be doing exactly the same things as me (parenting-wise) day to day. That would just be inefficient. I know he could make a packed lunch; or get the PE kits ready or whatever the day to day stuff is, but I didn't particularly NEED him to be doing that. Why would I? He did other things with them - sports on the weekends; lifts, plays various video games; bike rides; camping trips; computer / tech related homework help ... so many things that weren't my particular forte. Just play to your strengths basically. Similarly, he didn't NEED me to be making money, so all that side of things I didn't have to worry about. It's still a partnership snd of course you are equal parents, but you allow each other to focus and play to your strengths and natural inclinations. Ok, I might have been more involved in the kids academics and schools, but they wouldn't have been in those schools were it not for money he was able to generate (and I sound never have been able to put 4 kids through school on the type of money U was likely to make). So different roles, but the same common goal which is the kids education. Then we have shared ventures - eg, properties we've bought and renovated. He will sort the finances, I manage the renovations on site. It's still teamwork, but it's a better use of our time and resources. It's easier for us to have our own roles than be doing the same things day to day. Also, things change over the years and these days he's WFH and as visible to the kids as I am anyway. It's rarely as clear cut as people may think. That's my experience anyway.

DillonPanthersTexas · 05/07/2022 16:56

Lets not put all men and all women and all kids in stereotyped buckets…

You must be new here

Popcorn77 · 05/07/2022 16:54

Pruella · 05/07/2022 09:18

See maybe this is where men genuinely are different - I absolutely am “troubled” by when sports day is as I like to attend if I can. I also wouldn't spend my weekends doing hobbies or whatever as I want to maximise my time with DS at the weekends. Often the working fathers spoken about on these threads seem much more detached from their children than working mothers are.

I am not going to sports day. I organised something at work and did not realise it was sports day when I did. my kid wont care at all but it bothered my partner who is going. Lets not put all men and all women and all kids in stereotyped buckets…

Anothernamechangeplease · 05/07/2022 16:12

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 05/07/2022 15:05

Don't the SAHPs with uninvolved WOHP partners worry about what would happen to their kids if something happened to the SAHP?

Actually that's an important point. .A colleague of mine suddenly realised that God forbid anything happened to his SAH wife he would have to outsource a lot of what she did as his job involved long hours and a lot of travel. We had life insurance through work, he hadn't even thought about life insurance for his wife. My DH didn't have life insurance either once our endowment matured so we took it out for the same reason. Worth thinking about.

My bigger worry would be about the emotional impact on the kids if so much of their care falls to one parent. If the WOHP doesn't really get involved in the day to day stuff, then how will they really know their kids well enough to support them if something awful happens to the SAHP? Some of these parents sound like virtual strangers to their children if their partners are to be believed.

As a WOHP myself, I would hate for someone else to do all of the stuff that I do for my dd while I slogged away for a few more hours at work. I love my job and I've been lucky enough to have a very successful career, but that's only one aspect of my life and I would never be prepared to sacrifice everything else for the sake of it. I honestly don't think that's a healthy approach for anyone. I see doing stuff for dd as an integral part of parenting and essential for our relationship. Why would I want to miss out on that just because I have a career?! It is really important for me to know exactly what is going on in her life, who her friends are and what they're like, what she's working on, what she's struggling with, what she's looking forward to, what she's worrying about, what her likes and dislikes are etc. I would not thank another parent for taking all of that responsibility from me, nor would I respect another parent for leaving all of that stuff to me. My child has two parents and I want her to have a proper relationship with both of us!

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 05/07/2022 15:05

Don't the SAHPs with uninvolved WOHP partners worry about what would happen to their kids if something happened to the SAHP?

Actually that's an important point. .A colleague of mine suddenly realised that God forbid anything happened to his SAH wife he would have to outsource a lot of what she did as his job involved long hours and a lot of travel. We had life insurance through work, he hadn't even thought about life insurance for his wife. My DH didn't have life insurance either once our endowment matured so we took it out for the same reason. Worth thinking about.

DarkGlassesAndHat · 05/07/2022 14:19

@SAHMonMN

Sometimes, if one partner in a marriage has certain opportunities it makes sense to go for that for a given time. For instance, there is a couple we've known since uni. They got married quite young (about 25). She has not worked since she was about 28 when they had their first DC. He founded a company and would work abroad one week, home the next. They moved out of London to a very rural location so work options for her would have been limited, even if she'd wanted to work. So, some might call him a 'disengaged parent' because he worked away a lot and had a SAHW. If you met him though, he's the most lovely down-to-earn guy and has a brilliant relationship with his kids.The payback for his work focus and her making this easy for him, is that when he was about 40 he made a life-changing amount of money - I'm not sure how much exactly, but about £200 million I think. So since 40, he hasn't really had to work. They still live in the same house as they always lived in and have a very simple life really. But my point is, they had certain opportunities and knew what they were doing as a family. They did it together with the common aim to change their children's futures. Now they are about 50. Not only do they not need to work, but their kids are more than set up for life.

And every SAHM in a scenario like that, there are thousands, maybe millions, whose husbands are working themselves into the ground to keep a roof over the family's heads while their wives stay at home because "too busy doing life admin'..." or "sorting out pet insurance", etc.

Comedycook · 05/07/2022 14:17

Well you'd think that @Kanaloa but the amount of events schools seem to put on is unbelievable! I feel like I'm always there. End of term is particularly busy...I have 4 events in the next two weeks. Dh wfh and picks up our youngest dd11 from school when I'm at work but if he has meetings or needs to go into the office then we need to sort childcare. It's just an adjustment really from me always being available.

xogossipgirlxo · 05/07/2022 13:30

Your husband is telling you to go to work, which means he's not happy with current situation in your relationship. You should think about that. Besides, what harm does it do to go part time? You can still enjoy housekeeping duties plus it might be good for both of you.

DillonPanthersTexas · 05/07/2022 13:25

I’m not bothered if someone doesn’t want to work but just say you can’t be arsed/want to chill at home everyday. ‘I need to help my 15yo make life decisions, cook up big bowls of food, and host their friends’ is just a bit weak.

It does amuse me when people here talk of 'managing the household' as if they are the CEO of a FTSE 100 multinational rather then living in a three bed semi. My favourite essential 'chore' listed on a previous thread was 'checking local Facebook groups for anything that might affect the house/family'.

Orangello · 05/07/2022 13:03

Yes I'm sure many working parents can be very much involved in their DC's life. I am and I work more than full time. Just that this argument was used on this thread, that it's great if the working parent never needs to even think about anything domestic and child-related

Anxiernie · 05/07/2022 12:41

One of the reasons we both work and both share the childcare is exactly that we both should worry and care what's going on with DC. One of my best friends is SAHM and in their household indeed the DH never thinks about their children, their friends, activities, issues. I think he is vaguely aware what school they're in, but maybe not. And what can she say, she's a SAHM, kids are her job, he is 'working hard so deserves the weekends to relax and do his hobbies', as he says.

I was raised with a SAHM and a FT working dad. The above certaintly wasn't my experience and he was doing shift work. Far from it. If a parent doesn't care, they just use working as an excuse, it's not the default.

Kanaloa · 05/07/2022 12:12

Comedycook · 05/07/2022 09:12

I think that's very true @SAHMonMN before when I was at home al the time, DH was never troubled by what day sports day was on, what after school activities were happening, a DC being ill and having to be home from school, an early pick up time at the end of term...he lived his life utterly unencumbered by these day to day things. Now I'm working, we are having endless conversations and having to coordinate our time.

Surely it’s not a huge job co-ordinating around two working days a week?

SAHMonMN · 05/07/2022 11:40

Oh I see, Anothernamechangeplease. I wasn't really talking about having less concern for their children's 'well-being' as such. I don't mean to imply that. I rather meant the different 'headspace' that comes from that knowing your child is always with the other parent.

And yes, I do totally agree that women, even if they are working, still have a tendency to carry this 'mental load' more than their male counterparts.

There are pros and cons to anything. You just have to work out for yourself in your own situation which pros outweigh which cons for your particular family.

WimpoleHat · 05/07/2022 11:39

Sometimes, if one partner in a marriage has certain opportunities it makes sense to go for that for a given time.

Agree with this, @SAHMonMN . But it’s not just the people with opportunities to become a tech millionaire - it’s the decision lots (not all - but many) people take when one parent goes for partnership in a City law firm, or a senior role in the City or business. Because when you have two people doing that (long hours, unpredictability, lot of travel, working weekends etc) your kids have a very different sort of life and family experience. Not everyone wants that - and if you don’t, you have the money to choose a different lifestyle and family set up. (And you’re far, far better off financially than people where both parents have average 9-5 jobs, albeit in a riskier position. But anyone smart understands this and saves some of that money for a rainy day.)

Anothernamechangeplease · 05/07/2022 11:28

It's rarely as binary as SAHM = 'disengaged husband.' It totally depends!

Oh, I quite understand that, and I'm sure that there are some very involved parents despite having SAHPs at home. Indeed, I'm sure that most WOHPs would choose to be involved and engaged with their kids over and above just making a lot of money.

I was referring specifically to the type of arrangement that you described in a previous post, in which the WOHP never seemed to give a moment's thought to their child's wellbeing, never knew what was going on for them in school etc, walked out the door without even giving a thought to where their children were/what they might be doing, because all of that was dealt with by the SAHP. That seems to me to be rather an extreme set up that I wouldn't personally regard as being desirable.

SAHMonMN · 05/07/2022 11:07

I really don't think it's as binary as people make out on here. People are just faced with different choices. Unless you've been in someone else's marriage, circumstances or financial set-up, you can't say what you would have done yourself. It's rarely as binary as SAHM = 'disengaged husband.' It totally depends!

Sometimes, if one partner in a marriage has certain opportunities it makes sense to go for that for a given time. For instance, there is a couple we've known since uni. They got married quite young (about 25). She has not worked since she was about 28 when they had their first DC. He founded a company and would work abroad one week, home the next. They moved out of London to a very rural location so work options for her would have been limited, even if she'd wanted to work. So, some might call him a 'disengaged parent' because he worked away a lot and had a SAHW. If you met him though, he's the most lovely down-to-earn guy and has a brilliant relationship with his kids.The payback for his work focus and her making this easy for him, is that when he was about 40 he made a life-changing amount of money - I'm not sure how much exactly, but about £200 million I think. So since 40, he hasn't really had to work. They still live in the same house as they always lived in and have a very simple life really. But my point is, they had certain opportunities and knew what they were doing as a family. They did it together with the common aim to change their children's futures. Now they are about 50. Not only do they not need to work, but their kids are more than set up for life.

Ok, this is maybe an extreme example, but obviously, there are people out there who have opportunities to make life-changing amounts of money and it's very apparent if you know or are married to someone like this, that they don't generally achieve that by working 9-5 and keeping a tally on who does the laundry! This kind of conversation doesn't even come into it. You may have an average / well paid job, but this may seem irrelevant in the overall financial context. It's no coincidence, that many men around here who have SAHWs also work flexibly or retire quite early eg. in their 40s. By this time, it's not about salaries. The family have made investments and this kind of thing. Ok, it's not 9-5 or 'routine' parenting, but it's not 'detached' either. The kids see and understand what the parents are doing for them and why.

Anothernamechangeplease · 05/07/2022 10:40

Don't the SAHPs with uninvolved WOHP partners worry about what would happen to their kids if something happened to the SAHP? Isn't it all a bit precarious if only one parent is actually doing the emotional labour of parenting and the other doesn't really know what's going on? That would fill me with fear tbh.

Orangello · 05/07/2022 10:30

One of the reasons we both work and both share the childcare is exactly that we both should worry and care what's going on with DC. One of my best friends is SAHM and in their household indeed the DH never thinks about their children, their friends, activities, issues. I think he is vaguely aware what school they're in, but maybe not. And what can she say, she's a SAHM, kids are her job, he is 'working hard so deserves the weekends to relax and do his hobbies', as he says.

Anothernamechangeplease · 05/07/2022 10:30

It's a little sad to think of all of these working parents who seem to use the excuse of having a SAHP to opt out of all parenting responsibilities other than providing financially. Parents who apparently never spare a thought for where their child is, what they are doing, what's going on in their lives etc. I could never respect a partner who had so little interest or emotional involvement in raising their children, and I could never be that parent myself. How sad for the children to have only one parent who is actually engaged and involved, with the other being little more than a cash cow.

Personally, I much prefer an arrangement where both parents have a lot of hands-on involvement in all aspects of parenting, where the responsibilities and rewards of bringing up children are shared equally. It makes for more balanced relationships in my view, but each to their own.

SAHMonMN · 05/07/2022 10:05

My husband also mainly WFH these days. It's not about people needing to justify 'mum guilt' or lack of it. Nor is it a competition. I don't doubt for one second that people manage without SAHMs or cleaners or whatever. This is how the vast majority live anyway these days. What I'm saying is, if you don't HAVE to, then you don't have to! It's as simple as that really. Nobody sets out to make life more complicated and hectic than it needs to be. Different financial contexts; different amount of children; different jobs; different locations - all these things impact how families organise themselves. There are many paid jobs that, to an outsider may seem pointless and 'redundant.' Doesn't mean people won't still choose to do those jobs. As long as they see the point of what they're doing and it works for them, who cares about anyone else? What relevance is it?

If you had a husband who travelled a lot with no fixed schedule, no fixed hours and this type of thing, you may have made different decisions to if you have a husband who works 9-6 for instance. Kids need some routine and stability and not everyone can WFH or work 9-5 or predictable hours. it's a cost / benefit analysis, like anything else. In certain financial contexts, the 'benefit' of the wife's extra income will be negligible in terms if the overall household finances. So in these circumstances, there seems no point in working and paying someone to do a poorer version of what you are doing yourself. It makes no sense. Things like pensions and 'financial vulnerability' can be sorted. I wouldn't recommend any woman making herself financially vulnerable. Tbh, the SAHMs I know are not exactly in that category.

Incywincyspi · 05/07/2022 09:38

I work from home as does DH. No issues with forgotten kit and school runs etc as we are able to do that. Although making yourself available for ferrying in forgotten stuff just cultivates snowflakes who have no responsibility for self. Work places are becoming more and more flexible and are in the majority happy to accommodate time off for appointments etc. there’s no stress here about sports day as we just book in advance. Sometimes I let work know with short notice and I don’t think I’ve ever had a request refused. I never feel the so called “ guilt” you allege that working parents feel walking out the door because I’m still at home and even if I worked out the home I wouldn’t feel guilty. I’m proud to be a working woman and my kids are proud of me too. As for getting the time to chat to my kids- yep I have that in bucket loads. I’m here and we have long chats .

spanishmumireland · 05/07/2022 09:33

SAHMonMN · 05/07/2022 08:39

What I think a lot of people don't understand is that it's not about a list of tasks - eg. who does laundry and who cooks and this and that. That's not really the point of being a SAHM because, to a large extent, you can make those type of tasks last as long as you want. Anyway, one person's concept of "all the housework'" will be very different to someone else's.

The real "work" of being a SAHM - especially if you have quite a few kids - is that you can never walk out the door without either having one or more of them with you, or having first factored in where they are, what they're doing, etc etc.

If you are a working parent with a SAHM, you never have to worry about this. You can walk out the door hands free and ficus in something else for x number of hours. You never have to worry or feel guilty about walking out the door. You never have to worry if they're not happy in the nursery or don't want to go or are ill. You never have to worry about what you're nanny is doing if you have one, or if she spends her whole time on her phone to her boyfriend or whatever. School runs, school holiday plans communication with schools, all homework, clubs and activities - covered. Not by a person who just sees it as a job. But by a parent who loves them unconditionally and will go the extra mile. A mum knows instinctively if they're anxious about something, from day one and through school. It's consistency. You can never pay anyone enough to be as in tune with your kids as their own mother. This is the whole point really.

Tasks like doing the vacuuming can be done by anyone. No SAHM I know thinks of this type of thing as defining her role. You can outsource housework. But some families, where the means is there, prefer not to outsource the 'being there'.

We had 4 DC with roughly 2 year gaps between them so it was over 10 years between having the first and the youngest one starting reception. They were all in different schools at different times and with a London traffic, some days I might not get back from the school runs until almost 10am, only to need to be out again for pick up at 2.30 to get there for 3.30 and get parking. My kids did a lot of things after school and frankly, I couldn't have paid someone enough to do it all. Also, nannies are never going to be across the homework as I was, especially when they had 11 plus exams or other exams. The school run was hellish in some ways, but looking back, that was when they often opened up about friendship issues or other worries they had moving though school. Even in the hours between school runs, I was generally doing something for one of them. That's how it was. So it's not about housework, it's something else and much more than that.

I have three children with small gaps between them. I work full time. My DH works full time. We don't have a cleaner.
All my DC do activities and we supervise their homework and we eat healthy meals trying to make it simple.
We aren't talking about nursery age kids. We are talking when they are all at school and going into secondary school. The SAHM role is redundant. It's non existent. And with the new WFH working from home malarky it makes it even more evident.
We do all those tasks you mention. We love our children to bits and we care about them. The children of working parents tend to be a lot more independent. I think the mum working really forters independence in girls. My eldest (13) in secondary has jobs in the house. The other two have also small jobs. They aren't allowed to be on screens, unless weekend and only for a couple of hours. We WFH/ go to the office so one of us is at home. They have many friends in the neighbourhood.
A lot of women in my area don't work as I live in a wealthy area. It amazes me how they live so oblivious to all the risks they are taking: no pension, risk of redundancy, being dumped, illness etc etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread