Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this a harsh thing to do to adult son?

289 replies

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 00:04

DS1 is 20 and there have been issues with screen addiction since he was a teen. We’ve tried many things to get him to regulate himself but he just won’t. He fucked up his GCSEs due to it.

He has not worked apart from a few months part time on 2 occasions since he left school. Did 3 years at college, dropped out in first year of A Levels and changed courses to a BTEC which he scraped through and started at Uni last September. I wasn’t happy at knew he wouldn’t work hard and told him to defer for a few years but he promised he would. Lives at home as accommodation costs £1k a month! but is only just over an hour away. I had told him to get job over the summer before he started Uni to save for the accommodation but he didn’t. He hasn’t actually attended since last November. Says it’s OK to do it online.

His days consist of staying up all night talking shit to his mates while playing games, then going back to bed in morning for the whole day. Doesn’t wash regularly, breath stinks and only goes out if his mates arrange something on the odd occasion.

He actually wakes up DH who works very long hours due to how loud he talks and there has been major rows about it.

He apparently can’t get a job. Hasn’t had one since he had a Christmas temp one, as he’s not getting replies to applications although he’s actually missed interviews as been asleep!

He doesn’t pay rent although I took money off him from his first student loan payment as he lost his Dads bike and damaged a car by riding into it which we had to pay for. He told his mates we were exploiting him financially!

Found out he has spent all his last student loan which he got in April probably on online games and now has no money left at all! Not on drugs as he doesn’t go out to use them!

We took him on a fabulous holiday abroad last month, all inclusive, loads of activities, pool, beach, evening entertainment to try to liven him up but he spent most of it in his hotel room! He was furious we made him come too.

I had told him if he’s going to continue at Uni this year, he needs to move out into halls as I refuse to support him any longer but his maintenance loan won’t cover this so he needs to earn over the summer. Still no job and he spent the day in bed today AGAIN despite saying he wasn’t going to. I went out and found him there after asking him to cut the grass having asked him for 2 weeks now.

He needs us to be guarantors for his Uni halls but I’ve told him no as he’s not reliable to pay his rent and probably won’t get a part time job then either.

I asked him many times whats going on, could he be depressed, told him to go to GP, ask for blood tests, ask for counselling but he can’t be bothered. He’s quite happy when he’s online with his mates though.

He has a big gaming PC which needs an Ethernet cable for WiFi. I have cut it and he doesn’t have the cash to buy another one which I won’t let him connect anyway. He says I had no right to damage his property!

I’ve also told him as he can’t afford to live in halls, he has to quit Uni and get a full time job as we won’t support him any longer so he can pay rent or get out!

He’s always been lazy despite being highly intelligent. used to be lovely but now has rages if he’s asked to anything, no respect and very arrogant and I just don’t know what to do anymore. I’ve lost the plot many times telling him how disappointed I am that he’s doing this and what the hell is he doing but he can’t seem to sort himself out.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Newrunner29 · 03/07/2022 08:08

TigerRag · 03/07/2022 07:27

She's tried with the GP. But he can't be bothered.

I'd like to point out my adhd assessment questionnaire is at doctors and I haven't been able to get it to do, I really struggle with procrastination and it's all part of adhd so it may not be just that he can't be bothered. If someone was depressed and not going to doctors because they were struggling would u also assume they cannot be bothered?!

BeckyWithTheGoodHair010101 · 03/07/2022 08:04

Everyone saying change the wifi password, it's clearly a WIRED connection straight into the router with a long Ethernet cable. Cutting the cable is the equivalent of changing the wifi password!

Penguinevere · 03/07/2022 08:01

It’s an addiction.

MrsMontyD · 03/07/2022 07:58

Why do people keep mentioning covid? I can think of two friends with brothers in their 40s living at home in very similar situations, it's not that uncommon unfortunately and covid probably had much less impact on people who sleep all day and game all night than it did on the rest of us.

I'd echo the pp who said their brother ruined her parents retirement. I have a friend who's brother is doing the same, he contributes absolutely nothing and is a burden rather than a support to his elderly parents. In his mid 40s and never had a job or taken any qualifications beyond GCSE, no relationships. When his parents die he'll have no where to live and no income.

Quackpot · 03/07/2022 07:55

Change the WiFi password

FlipFlops4Me · 03/07/2022 07:53

And to those saying 20 isn't an adult, I'm sure a lot of us got our first jobs and moved out of the family home a lot earlier than that. And a lot of us were working, living at home and paying our parents a proper rent.

This poor bloke is never going to grow up at this rate.

Imogensmumma · 03/07/2022 07:50

Work out how to turn your wifi off with a parental lock at say 1am and then keep moving it earlier so it’s not waking your DH

if he doesn’t like it well tough, he can always move out or go to uni. I think you are getting a lot of heat here for no reason you are trying to stop him being lazy his whole life so well done on intervening , otherwise known as parenting which it seems a lot on MN are scared to do…. Actually be the parent means sometimes being the ‘bad guy’

FlipFlops4Me · 03/07/2022 07:50

He is a total taker! Could you pack up his stuff and change your locks? He can go and stay with these mates of his who are so willing to pay for him?

And yes it sounds harsh but nothing short of a bomb is going to get this manchild out of mummy & daddy's comfy home. He needs to know that living costs. Eating costs. You've kept him, fed him, been insulted by him for a great many years. He's an adult, fully capable of holding down a job if he wants to.

Push him out of the nest for his own sake.

aSofaNearYou · 03/07/2022 07:44

I disagree that you shouldn't have cut his cable. If he wants to be bankrolled by you and take no steps towards independence then in return he should be treated like a child.

I think tough love is what he needs at this point OP. I feel for you, it sounds like a nightmare.

Philisophigal · 03/07/2022 07:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn at the user's request.

stargirl1701 · 03/07/2022 07:42

It sounds exactly like brother who is still doing the same aged 43. My Dad is in his mid 70s.

Skodacool · 03/07/2022 07:41

waveyourpompoms · 03/07/2022 00:19

He’s right, you shouldn’t be damaging his property. He’s an adult and destroying other peoples things isn’t acceptable.

You also say you made him to go on the holiday and then were annoyed he acted like he didn’t want to be there? It obviously wasn’t fabulous to him.

If you want him to move out fair enough, but the way you have behaved here is unacceptable.

Are you serious! He most certainly is not an adult. You do, however, need to stop enabling his behaviour.

RampantIvy · 03/07/2022 07:39

This sounds so difficult for you @MadeAMessOfParenting. I think the university situation will resove itself because if he fails his first year he will either have to do resits or retake the year. You are doing the right thing by not paying for accommodation.

Can you change the Wi-Fi password and switch it off at night?
Apart from the addiction is there a possibility that he has ADHD or something else going on?

Alarchbach · 03/07/2022 07:34

OP you totally did the right thing. Tough love is needed and I’d have done the exact same thing. I’ve no time for idleness. Ignore those saying uou shouldn’t have cut the cable. He’s taking the piss.

justfiveminutes · 03/07/2022 07:31

"She's tried with the GP. But he can't be bothered."

Just telling him to go to the GP won't be enough but she managed to get him on a holiday he didn't want to go on so I think it will be possible.

OP, being honest, when you drew lines in the sand in the past (regarding computer use, getting a job etc) did you follow through with the consequences when he stepped over them? if so, he has learnt that you don't really mean it, and this will feel like a big adjustment.

nothingfound · 03/07/2022 07:28

Pumpkinjam · 03/07/2022 01:36

Some people are so harsh. He’s a 20 year old student with no life experience and no real friends by the sound of things.

We have just come through a socially isolating pandemic that has messed with our mental health and social skills. He has also not been given the opportunity to meet new people / live with his peers.

So many people will say oh but by the time I was 19 i had two kids and a full time job so no excuse….but this isn’t the case for your boy who sounds like a typical student….so seriously give him a break and stop assuming he’s going to end up a 40 year old screw up still living at home!!

Be kind, pay for his accommodation,
let him game, show him you’ll trust him
and be his guarantor ….worst that happens is you’re back at square one a few months down the line but maybe a gentle push in the right direction and showing him you trust and support him will help turn things around! Even if it takes a couple of years.

This goes back beyond Covid. He's an adult, he's old enough to know what he's doing and has no respect or care for his parents.

"Let him came, show him you'll trust him" what do you think they've been doing before they got to this point?
Pay for his accommodation, be his guarantor? You've got to be joking! (Even if they could afford to pay for his accommodation). Parents - make yourselves financially vulnerable to support a man-child who couldn't give a stuff about supporting you.

TigerRag · 03/07/2022 07:27

SaintHelena · 03/07/2022 05:52

All those saying make him leave home -- errrr how? Change the locks and make him starve on the doorstep?
Start with your GP and see if you can get some proper advice and support.

She's tried with the GP. But he can't be bothered.

NewBlueGoo · 03/07/2022 07:24

Your son sounds like a lot of autistic young adults I know. (I work in mental health, predominantly with autistic & ADHD adults). Has he had an assessment?

WhereIsVillanelleWhenNeeded · 03/07/2022 07:16

I think you need an intervention. You and DH need to get him out of his room and ask him some pertinent questions, then listen to his answers, without any interruptions. Explain calmly your concerns giving him an opportunity to respond. It sounds like he’s been infantilised by you and no boundaries were put in place earlier so you need some rules. For example set some chores, can he cook a meal, iron clothes, wash and tidy up after dinner? If he does the job/s then he can have the WiFi or a new cable. Maybe he needs to hear something other than negativity from you. He needs to know the consequences of his actions but without crushing his spirit. If he’s in education I wouldn’t expect any housekeeping money but if he’s not in education I would expect a contribution to the household finances. Of course you need to address this but do you ever just talk to him about anything other than what he’s doing wrong? He’s probably thinking ‘oh here we go again’ whenever you want to speak to him.

hattie43 · 03/07/2022 07:05

waveyourpompoms · 03/07/2022 00:19

He’s right, you shouldn’t be damaging his property. He’s an adult and destroying other peoples things isn’t acceptable.

You also say you made him to go on the holiday and then were annoyed he acted like he didn’t want to be there? It obviously wasn’t fabulous to him.

If you want him to move out fair enough, but the way you have behaved here is unacceptable.

It's not unacceptable

This is out of desperation and you have condemned without any suggested solution .

Why should this adult son freeload indefinitely. Will he still be gaming through the night in his childhood bedroom at 43 ? The line has to be drawn somewhere and his lifestyle is not healthy .

Mindymomo · 03/07/2022 06:55

My DS would easily have gone down this route, he spent nights gaming and sleeping daytime, only just passed a couple of GCSE’s. Never really bothered as he always said he wanted to work with my DH doing plumbing. Well that didn’t work, he couldn’t be bothered to learn, go to college, but basically thought he’d get paid for doing next to nothing. After a few massive rows, he had to himself a full time job. He’s 26 now, still at home, still gaming, but much less. We have a rule in our house midnight is cut off time in the week. I’ve told both my DS’s if they don’t like it, they can leave. I have unplugged the router a few times and changed password. Have you made next year’s application for student loan, I wouldn’t do it until things change at home. He just thinks he can manage on student loan, do a bit of studying and game all night.

Onceuponatimethen · 03/07/2022 06:51

Op I do wonder if there’s more going on here than laziness.

Some of his behaviour sounds like it could be very high functioning ASD to me. He sounds like he wants to avoid social contact, also very rigid.

He also sounds to me like he could have ADHD - the incident with the bike eg.

justfiveminutes · 03/07/2022 06:51

Autienotnaughtie · 03/07/2022 06:37

You sound really unreasonable. I didn't charge my kids rent while they were at uni. They had their loan and I gave them money for food (they lived out.) they did both get jobs as they wanted more money but it was their choice. He's an adult if he wants to play games he can and yes lectures are usually online to do can study from home. I agree with making him paying the for damage for the bike but suggest you pay him now for the damage to his property. If you don't want him to live at home it seems harsh but fair enough , support him to move in to accommodation. But currently you are treating him like a child but expecting him to behave like an adult. If he's an adult then he gets to makes his own choices.

She doesn't charge him rent.

justfiveminutes · 03/07/2022 06:49

I am a teacher and the pupils who present like your son are almost always neurodivergent. You describe characteristics of both ASC and ADHD in your post.

You managed to make him go on holiday, so now make him go to the GP to start the ball rolling with an assessment, and to discuss mental health issues such as depression.

Make an appointment to speak with the relevant person at university and go with him (welfare office, personal tutor). My decision on whether I'd support him to stay would depend on how he is doing. If he's at a top university, as you say, and passed the first year, then I wouldn't want to be responsible for taking away that opportunity.

If he doesn't get the full maintenance loan then you are supposed to top that up. If you can't, and he won't work to top it up himself, then would he rather move to a uni with cheaper accommodation than continue living at home?

If he is ND then the support Uni can put in place for him, to support organisation and so on, could make a big difference.

I absolutely understand your frustration. You have tried to help him for many years without success. I am not someone tutting that you cut his cable. But to me he sounds like someone who still, unfortunately, needs your help and may do for several years yet.

Lovelycupofcoffee · 03/07/2022 06:48

I’m sorry you are going through this . I’m just coming out of the other side of this hopefully. My teenage son felt it was ok to spend all his time gaming or getting drunk then threatening me. I called the police the last time it happened . I did discover that there were other issues going on in his life which were affecting his behaviour. Could he be depressed ?