Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this a harsh thing to do to adult son?

289 replies

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 00:04

DS1 is 20 and there have been issues with screen addiction since he was a teen. We’ve tried many things to get him to regulate himself but he just won’t. He fucked up his GCSEs due to it.

He has not worked apart from a few months part time on 2 occasions since he left school. Did 3 years at college, dropped out in first year of A Levels and changed courses to a BTEC which he scraped through and started at Uni last September. I wasn’t happy at knew he wouldn’t work hard and told him to defer for a few years but he promised he would. Lives at home as accommodation costs £1k a month! but is only just over an hour away. I had told him to get job over the summer before he started Uni to save for the accommodation but he didn’t. He hasn’t actually attended since last November. Says it’s OK to do it online.

His days consist of staying up all night talking shit to his mates while playing games, then going back to bed in morning for the whole day. Doesn’t wash regularly, breath stinks and only goes out if his mates arrange something on the odd occasion.

He actually wakes up DH who works very long hours due to how loud he talks and there has been major rows about it.

He apparently can’t get a job. Hasn’t had one since he had a Christmas temp one, as he’s not getting replies to applications although he’s actually missed interviews as been asleep!

He doesn’t pay rent although I took money off him from his first student loan payment as he lost his Dads bike and damaged a car by riding into it which we had to pay for. He told his mates we were exploiting him financially!

Found out he has spent all his last student loan which he got in April probably on online games and now has no money left at all! Not on drugs as he doesn’t go out to use them!

We took him on a fabulous holiday abroad last month, all inclusive, loads of activities, pool, beach, evening entertainment to try to liven him up but he spent most of it in his hotel room! He was furious we made him come too.

I had told him if he’s going to continue at Uni this year, he needs to move out into halls as I refuse to support him any longer but his maintenance loan won’t cover this so he needs to earn over the summer. Still no job and he spent the day in bed today AGAIN despite saying he wasn’t going to. I went out and found him there after asking him to cut the grass having asked him for 2 weeks now.

He needs us to be guarantors for his Uni halls but I’ve told him no as he’s not reliable to pay his rent and probably won’t get a part time job then either.

I asked him many times whats going on, could he be depressed, told him to go to GP, ask for blood tests, ask for counselling but he can’t be bothered. He’s quite happy when he’s online with his mates though.

He has a big gaming PC which needs an Ethernet cable for WiFi. I have cut it and he doesn’t have the cash to buy another one which I won’t let him connect anyway. He says I had no right to damage his property!

I’ve also told him as he can’t afford to live in halls, he has to quit Uni and get a full time job as we won’t support him any longer so he can pay rent or get out!

He’s always been lazy despite being highly intelligent. used to be lovely but now has rages if he’s asked to anything, no respect and very arrogant and I just don’t know what to do anymore. I’ve lost the plot many times telling him how disappointed I am that he’s doing this and what the hell is he doing but he can’t seem to sort himself out.

AIBU?

OP posts:
GoldPig · 03/07/2022 09:43

DS15 is on this path although we limit access to devices and push for chores to be completed. He needs to be micro managed though! He’s full of big ideas about what he’ll do without following through eg drew up a CV for weekend work but then didn’t go to more than 3 high street stores with it. Have ordered Jordan Peterson 12 Rules in hope …

MarshaMelrose · 03/07/2022 09:41

EntertainingandFactual · 03/07/2022 09:29

I’ve only read the OP’s posts so sorry if it’s been covered - Why physically cut a cable when you can just change the WiFi password?

Because he doesn't use wifi. He uses an ethernet cable.

GoodThinkingMax · 03/07/2022 09:41

DS1 is 20 and there have been issues with screen addiction since he was a teen. We’ve tried many things to get him to regulate himself but he just won’t.

@MadeAMessOfParenting if this really is an addiction - and it definitely sounds like it! Then maybe you need to let go. If you were to approach your situation from the assumption that your DS is an addict, then that might change your perspective & help a little?

Of course, if his twin brother has a diagnosis of ASD, then it's quite likely your DS does as well. But there is very little you can do to control his behaviour (that control should probably have happened back when he was 12 or 13). But if your DS won't do anything about it, then you don't have much power/control, frankly.

So instead -- Have a look at the resources available for families of addicts offered by AA - I think the organisation for families (and those affected by others' addictions) is called Al-Anon.

A couple of friends of mine have found Al-Anon really helpful to them for coping with an addict. The emphasis in Al-Anon is not on the addict, but you. And teaches you that:
you didn't cause the addiction
you can't control it
you can't cure it.

All of that has to come from him. That's what is called "rock bottom" - when an addict realises what they have lost and decides for themselves to do something about it.

You need to seek advice for yourself (and your DH) about how to manage the situation. At what point will you throw him out of the family home? Because you may have to do that. At what point can you force a Social services intervention?

Good luck, OP. It sounds unbelievably difficult, and there is the impact on your other DC and your whole family. Flowers

goldfinchonthelawn · 03/07/2022 09:36

nonevernotever · 03/07/2022 09:30

You're right to tackle this now. I can see so many similarities with my brother in law. My MIL didn't really take it seriously for many years, let him stay at home, facilitated his gaming by paying for everything, plated up meals and left them ready for when he got up etc . It got gradually worse over the years until it was like having an aggressive and unpredictable giant hamster in the house. With a lot of support from the rest of the family she eventually sold up and moved 300 miles away in order to dislodge him (he was 50!) . He now has a flat and a job and is probably as happy as he will ever be, but what a waste of 30 years .

Sorry but 'aggressive and unpredicatable giant hampster' made me howl. I'm sure it's not funny living with it but brilliant description.

Charlize43 · 03/07/2022 09:36

One day when you are old and incapacitated, maybe even on a life support machine... just hope that he doesn't remember that you cut his Ethernet cable.

I think maybe take a moment for reflection.

goldfinchonthelawn · 03/07/2022 09:35

YANBU at all. You are being both brave and loving, which he will see in time. I would do the same but I would make it 100% clear that my action was out of love not as a punishment.

I'd make a list for him of each of those individual things you have complained about and at the end of each item I'd add: this is not healthy adult behaviour. It won't help you lead a fulfilling life.

i would explain to him that he seems badly addicted to screens and you will help him break the addiction if he owns up to it but can't if he won't.

I would ask him to come up with a plan of things he is prepared to do to start growing up and that you will support him.

Try to keep the temperature very calm. Not worried or angry but absolutely practical and neutral, as if you were an outside observer or counsellor. IME, teen boys respond far better to this approach.
.

nonevernotever · 03/07/2022 09:30

You're right to tackle this now. I can see so many similarities with my brother in law. My MIL didn't really take it seriously for many years, let him stay at home, facilitated his gaming by paying for everything, plated up meals and left them ready for when he got up etc . It got gradually worse over the years until it was like having an aggressive and unpredictable giant hamster in the house. With a lot of support from the rest of the family she eventually sold up and moved 300 miles away in order to dislodge him (he was 50!) . He now has a flat and a job and is probably as happy as he will ever be, but what a waste of 30 years .

EntertainingandFactual · 03/07/2022 09:29

I’ve only read the OP’s posts so sorry if it’s been covered - Why physically cut a cable when you can just change the WiFi password?

VioletInsolence · 03/07/2022 09:28

I have a son like this but he lives at his dad’s. It’s very tricky because he does have Asperger’s and ADHD and his dad hasn’t acknowledged until recently it so I’m still (remotely) trying to sort out his assessment. His dad of course gets annoyed because he sometimes gets woken up. My son isn’t even at uni. I’m not sure how much of it is screen addiction (more reading books on screen with my son) or difficultly sleeping. He has mental health problems too but he won’t make the effort to do anything about it. I’ve had to ask the autism centre to send all correspondence to my address because he opens it and just throws it somewhere.

I'm autistic and I’d say that although it isn’t an excuse to become a hermit, it can make life very difficult and there have to be some allowances made or what the point of a diagnosis? I was undiagnosed for 42 years and tried to do what everyone else does and it’s left me very fragile health-wise. I don’t know how you get the balance right though and I was far more passive as a young person than my son is and always felt a moral duty to be doing something so even when I was doing course after course, I did all my parents’ cleaning without being asked.

There are loads and loads of kids like this. They can’t keep up with the competition and there’s no incentive for them to work because they know they won’t be able to buy a house. All my son thinks about is global warming and nuclear war and he can’t see a future.

RedHelenB · 03/07/2022 09:28

You lost the moral high ground damaging his property. You need to buy him another. However, the payment of WI-FI is down to you so I'd change the password as he's not paying anything towards it. He's your son, you need to talk to him, get to the bottom of things.

DogsAndGin · 03/07/2022 09:21

Where’s national service when you need it?! Send him to the army or something. He needs discipline and he needs to get a life.

ofwarren · 03/07/2022 09:19

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 08:31

I also don’t think that autism ASD card cuts that my daughter had crippling autism depression etc but she does live independently she does her own washing she cleans a self she looks after her animals, she makes my dinner when she’s at uni on holiday.

You can't compare other autistic people to your daughter. I know autistic people who will never be able to cook a meal for themselves and ones who really struggle to keel themselves clean. It's called a spectrum for a reason.

Hadtochangeitforthis · 03/07/2022 09:18

MarshaMelrose · 03/07/2022 09:08

Could he have adhd or autism based on what we’re hearing? Working in this area, I think so.
So just like with anything else I’d be saying get it checked out first.

But the ops already tried that and he won't go. You can't make a 20yo go to the gp if he's raging at you. And anyway, at 20, autism or not, he has to want to be involved in, or at the least cooperate with, these processes or nothing will be resolved.

Oh yeah completely get that. But sometimes it’s how you come at the problem ‘I’m sick to death of you, cuts up Ds lifeline, you need to speak to a dr you know!’ Or ‘this isn’t going to work for this family anymore, I’ve booked you an appointment with the Gp, I will put you on loudspeaker and with your permission tell the gp what’s going on with you, as if there is something underlying we can help you so you can do well at uni, get into good employment and be independent’
not saying OP hasn’t done the latter but enabling whatever it is that’s going on is going to take some serious assertive positive action from op

Crimeismymiddlename · 03/07/2022 09:17

Op, I don’t have any advice but I can see why you cut the cable in frustration. Your son is at an age where he does not start to learn the big lessons he will end up staying with you forever. I myself would hate a stinking, lazy gamer being in the house and paying for them to live. You need to start the ground rules now, no internet, he wants it he gets it fitted and pays for it, ditto food and all the other things. Maybe not rent as he is at uni. Must wash, must see the doctor. But he is an adult so not like you can make him do anything and honestly I think the biggest sharpest shock would be him to moving into a shared house, as others have said the other occupants will not put up with anything.
His friends might fund him now, but in ten years they will see him for how he is, a lazy grifter and will have things they need to prioritise instead of a share of a gaming pc and paying for his share
of holidays.

Tillsforthrills · 03/07/2022 09:16

EmmaH2022 · 03/07/2022 00:57

This is a really tough situation and seems quite common sadly. Mum has her friends in their 80s with adults living there in 40s and 50s and not even cooking or cleaning.

I understand why you cut the cable. It's your property isn't it, rather than his?

Why did you make him go on holiday - couldn't trust him alone in the house I'm guessing.

Agree with everything others say re he has to do his own cooking etc.

I know someone who dislodged their adult at 25, only by paying for a flatshare. Being out of the family home had to happen for them to see real life, even a paid for version was better than nothing, and they are adulting properly now.

If you can afford it, I wonder if it's worth paying for halls and ordering his food each week. Everything else, he has to fund.

That’s something I would do. Sounds like a good compromise.

It sounds as if he’s scared or anxious about adulting but that’s not an excuse.

Awful situation for you.

AuntMargo · 03/07/2022 09:15

You seem to know what to do and I suggest you follow it through, for his sake as well as yours. Well done for cutting his cables, thats was a great move. Dont give him access to your wi fi, change the pass word. Stop giving him full stop. He needs some harsh reality. Life isn't free, and he needs to stop sponging on parents.

DancyNancy · 03/07/2022 09:14

Sorry I just see that the cable does not require password as its direct connection.

So...as I said above replace cable. Apologise for damaging his property.
Then remove the outlet in his room.
The wall its on and the room its in is your property so you can decide to not allow permission of that.
If he paid for the actual fixtures ensure its removed undamaged and box it up.

CallOnMe · 03/07/2022 09:13

I’ve not voted as I can’t say YABU when it sounds like you’ve tried many things before.

However this sounds more than just a screen addiction.
Many addicts still hold down jobs or go out with their mates.

He sounds like he has bad anxiety/self image issues and maybe depression which is why he’s hiding away in his room.

When someone has these issues it’s very difficult to get them to go out and do stuff.
Going to uni or getting a new job must literally be torture.

I don’t think he’ll listen if you say about seeing a gp or dealing with his anxiety so I probably wouldn’t mention it and just start small and try and tackle one or two things at a time.

It sounds like you’re wanting a lot of things to change and so he’s pushing back.
Starting smaller may give you more success.
He needs to know you’re treating him as a mature adult and not a child (even though he’s acting like one).

Does his mates come round to the house?
Could you encourage him to start inviting them around and game at his EOW?
They can get a pizza and hang out in his room.

I would be putting my foot down about him waking his dad up - that would be my first rule that I work on.
Tell him that one the weekends we can stay up talking but week days he needs to turn the headset off - he can still game until late.

What is he doing at uni?
Have you spoken to him about if he’s enjoying it or if he wants to change?
Maybe he could do a gaming course or something?

You can tell him to take a year or 2 and work but my concern would be what if he doesn’t turn up for work!

ProperVexed · 03/07/2022 09:12

@LiesDoNotBecomeUs
@KathyWilliams
Please could you tell me which Jordan Peterson book to start with? I'm watching this thread with interest as my DS21 is similar but perhaps not quite so bad. I might have to bribe him to read the book though......

LampLighter414 · 03/07/2022 09:12

Hope he gets a lady friend and then encourage him to move in with her like a lot of cocklodger’s parents do.

Good luck

MarshaMelrose · 03/07/2022 09:08

Could he have adhd or autism based on what we’re hearing? Working in this area, I think so.
So just like with anything else I’d be saying get it checked out first.

But the ops already tried that and he won't go. You can't make a 20yo go to the gp if he's raging at you. And anyway, at 20, autism or not, he has to want to be involved in, or at the least cooperate with, these processes or nothing will be resolved.

Eightiesfan · 03/07/2022 09:03

I have DS15 who is on exactly the same path as your son. Against my wishes DP bought him an all singing and dancing gaming PC and since then he’s on it all day. Some weekends he’s on there all day, with the minimal time in homework.

He is absolutely obsessive and even though he’s doing his GCSEs next year, he doesn’t seem to care and his gaming is his priority.

It’s impossible to keep track of if he’s gaming or doing homework, so I bought him a low level chromebook for homework, as he’s unable to play his games on there.

However, my son is still at an age that I have some level of control, but it’s still really hard, but I make sure his laptop is not allowed in his bedroom and I also take his phone at night, but your son is 20, those options are not open to you.

Five, ten years from now your son will most likely realise just how much he’s screwed-up his education for something so trivial as online gaming.

Right now, like any addict, his gaming will be the most important thing in his life, nothing you can do or say will make any difference, the solution needs to come from him. I would suggest that he contacts his Uni to get some help and counselling.

DancyNancy · 03/07/2022 09:03

Yabu to damage his property.

Replace the cable. Apologise and Admit to him that it was the wrong thing to do.

Then change the WiFi password.
Change it regularly. No access until he starts paying.

As an interim possibly give him a weekly budget to go out and buy his own food and prepare his own food.
Tell him this is a weekly allowance for 4 weeks and then it will be stopped (giving him 4 weeks to sort out a job). Make him go out and get the food himself. Get him taking responsibility for his own care.

It might sound extreme but...fridge lock and cupboard locks for your own stuff.

I'd actually think buy a small separate fridge for him and one cupboard solely for him. If you're gonna do this you need to do it in a way he has no access to steal your stuff and has to become independent

ABBAsnumberonefan · 03/07/2022 08:57

To be honest OP, i think you need to think about how it got to this point and you and your DH might have to look in the mirror and realise your own roles in this. It didn’t happen overnight 🤔

ABBAsnumberonefan · 03/07/2022 08:56

Sorry but no, I’ve had friends like this at uni who were babied by their parents and they just had no concept of real life at all! It actually ended up causing our house problems and arguments so I have really little sympathy. I graduated uni during the pandemic (my final year was when it all started) and honestly, yes it was hard but equally my parents babying me wasn’t going to help?

I worked all the time I was at uni - my parents helped me and my brother with a set amount and then the rest was on us 🤷‍♀️ by 2nd and 3rd year I was working full time hours alongside studying and graduated with a 1st. The job was remote from home though and we chose our own hours, which is the only reason why I was able to do that.

in fact one of the friends who just had their mum and dad sort everything for them told me I couldn’t have a little moan about being taxed in my payslip because I used the NHS and roads! I asked her what she was doing to contribute and of course she had very little to say.

I have minimal sympathy for people like this and I think his friends will probably start to feel the same when they realise how much they’re paying for him!