Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this a harsh thing to do to adult son?

289 replies

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 00:04

DS1 is 20 and there have been issues with screen addiction since he was a teen. We’ve tried many things to get him to regulate himself but he just won’t. He fucked up his GCSEs due to it.

He has not worked apart from a few months part time on 2 occasions since he left school. Did 3 years at college, dropped out in first year of A Levels and changed courses to a BTEC which he scraped through and started at Uni last September. I wasn’t happy at knew he wouldn’t work hard and told him to defer for a few years but he promised he would. Lives at home as accommodation costs £1k a month! but is only just over an hour away. I had told him to get job over the summer before he started Uni to save for the accommodation but he didn’t. He hasn’t actually attended since last November. Says it’s OK to do it online.

His days consist of staying up all night talking shit to his mates while playing games, then going back to bed in morning for the whole day. Doesn’t wash regularly, breath stinks and only goes out if his mates arrange something on the odd occasion.

He actually wakes up DH who works very long hours due to how loud he talks and there has been major rows about it.

He apparently can’t get a job. Hasn’t had one since he had a Christmas temp one, as he’s not getting replies to applications although he’s actually missed interviews as been asleep!

He doesn’t pay rent although I took money off him from his first student loan payment as he lost his Dads bike and damaged a car by riding into it which we had to pay for. He told his mates we were exploiting him financially!

Found out he has spent all his last student loan which he got in April probably on online games and now has no money left at all! Not on drugs as he doesn’t go out to use them!

We took him on a fabulous holiday abroad last month, all inclusive, loads of activities, pool, beach, evening entertainment to try to liven him up but he spent most of it in his hotel room! He was furious we made him come too.

I had told him if he’s going to continue at Uni this year, he needs to move out into halls as I refuse to support him any longer but his maintenance loan won’t cover this so he needs to earn over the summer. Still no job and he spent the day in bed today AGAIN despite saying he wasn’t going to. I went out and found him there after asking him to cut the grass having asked him for 2 weeks now.

He needs us to be guarantors for his Uni halls but I’ve told him no as he’s not reliable to pay his rent and probably won’t get a part time job then either.

I asked him many times whats going on, could he be depressed, told him to go to GP, ask for blood tests, ask for counselling but he can’t be bothered. He’s quite happy when he’s online with his mates though.

He has a big gaming PC which needs an Ethernet cable for WiFi. I have cut it and he doesn’t have the cash to buy another one which I won’t let him connect anyway. He says I had no right to damage his property!

I’ve also told him as he can’t afford to live in halls, he has to quit Uni and get a full time job as we won’t support him any longer so he can pay rent or get out!

He’s always been lazy despite being highly intelligent. used to be lovely but now has rages if he’s asked to anything, no respect and very arrogant and I just don’t know what to do anymore. I’ve lost the plot many times telling him how disappointed I am that he’s doing this and what the hell is he doing but he can’t seem to sort himself out.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Chooksnroses · 03/07/2022 10:17

waveyourpompoms · 03/07/2022 00:19

He’s right, you shouldn’t be damaging his property. He’s an adult and destroying other peoples things isn’t acceptable.

You also say you made him to go on the holiday and then were annoyed he acted like he didn’t want to be there? It obviously wasn’t fabulous to him.

If you want him to move out fair enough, but the way you have behaved here is unacceptable.

If I was @MadeAMessOfParenting I'd be in a screaming rage at him, and I don't think cutting his Ethernet cable would have been the only thing I'd have done! If he doesn't like it, he can leave home and start paying for his own stuff.

Rainbowbaby13 · 03/07/2022 10:15

waveyourpompoms · 03/07/2022 00:19

He’s right, you shouldn’t be damaging his property. He’s an adult and destroying other peoples things isn’t acceptable.

You also say you made him to go on the holiday and then were annoyed he acted like he didn’t want to be there? It obviously wasn’t fabulous to him.

If you want him to move out fair enough, but the way you have behaved here is unacceptable.

😂😂

Really?? OP clearly has tried lots of ways to sort him out and cutting the cable was a last resort although I suppose she could just sit back and take her son treating the place as a free hotel

Blurp · 03/07/2022 10:13

It sounds like you're still treating him like a child rather than an adult. It's not right of you to destroy his stuff, but you can limit his access to your stuff (ie WiFi). Just turn it off at night, or change the password.

Why are you taking him on holiday? Especially when he doesn't want to go? Next time leave him at home (he'd probably have quite a nice time on his own with unlimited WiFi).

Personally, I wouldn't kick him out; it sounds like he needs support and would flounder in his own, but I'd sit him down and explain that you're not going to fund him - you'll feed him the basics (ie exactly what you eat, no snacks etc) and maybe provide toiletries and basic clothes, but if he wants anything fancy he needs to get a job and earn it himself.

On another note - has he ever had counselling regarding his twin? I have a friend who was one of twins; her brother had been starved of oxygen at birth and was quite severely disabled. She always felt guilty that she was fine and he had so many difficulties. Might your son be feeling that way and just be a bit "stuck" in his feelings?

Wishihadanalgorithm · 03/07/2022 10:12

It is likely that the OP’s son is in some way neurodivergent but this doesn’t give him the right to behave as he has been doing.

OP, is clearly at the end of her tether and from an outsider it does all seem to be a giant mess.

The GP is a good place to start as is student welfare. It may be OP has to set the meetings up and accompany DS to make them happen but this really should be happening before next term of uni.

A PP suggested, having a talk which is neutral, not blaming, not arguing but laying out the problem with DS and getting him to face that this situation cannot go on needs to be done. See what solutions he has.

Finally, every poster saying 20 is so young really need to get a grip. At 20 you are an adult, can go to prison, drive a car, vote etc. etc. He is a man, not a boy, and needs to take ownership for his choices. All actions have consequences and I think part of the issue here is that the DS hasn’t really faced any.

FWIW, I think some tough love, some support and some advice from experts are needed here but this situation is untenable.

KosherDill · 03/07/2022 10:12

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 02:12

I only cut it today @Fenella123 . He has no money. I have told him if another appears I’ll cut it too. His mates would probably give him one. They all actually clubbed together to get him the PC (custom built, cost £900) 2 years ago. They all had jobs, he didn’t, I wouldn’t buy one for him so they took pity on him. I couldn’t believe that he wasn’t embarrassed! They’re not online mates, he’s known them since school. He went away with them for a few days recently and they paid for his food after he pissed away his Uni loan.

He had had a part time evening job (1st job) but was let go (by mutual agreement according to him) as he couldn’t get up so didn’t turn up. He started at 6pm! I had been waking him at first but stopped. He was supposed to be saving up for a PC from that but spent all his money online too.

He’s missed two driving theory tests as he was asleep. He also missed retaking his English GCSE as he was asleep. His first day of Uni, his Dad found him asleep in his gaming chair and he would have missed his train if he hadn’t checked why he hadn’t left!

We have other 3 DC at home including his disabled twin brother who through no fault of his own has no education or training provision and I’ve been fighting for a year to get him one. Been waiting for a SEND Tribunal since February which has just been postponed until December! Even he isn’t in bed all day, helps with chores, wants to be doing something.

DS1 has a place at the top Uni in the UK for his subject but can’t be bothered to go! Some of the students in his college class didn’t get a place there. Uni totally his choice. I didn’t want him to go as I knew he’d be like this but had to support him! Thought he might grow up in a few years and should go then.

We don’t have spare cash to pay his £1k a month London accommodation! We live an hour away. I have been DS2’s carer, had to give up my career, and only just started working again last year as managed to get a WFH job as need to to be around for him.

His Dad works 12-14 hour days in a physically demanding job in his mid 50’s. We have fit and able adult DS1 laying in bed all day and waking us up during the night when he’s swearing about being killed in a bloody game!

Have you said all his directly to him?

Ask him how it feels to see his parents working their arses off for the family while he is bone idle, dirty and contributes nothing.

Phobiaphobic · 03/07/2022 10:10

waveyourpompoms · 03/07/2022 00:19

He’s right, you shouldn’t be damaging his property. He’s an adult and destroying other peoples things isn’t acceptable.

You also say you made him to go on the holiday and then were annoyed he acted like he didn’t want to be there? It obviously wasn’t fabulous to him.

If you want him to move out fair enough, but the way you have behaved here is unacceptable.

There's always someone who will criticise the OP despite everything she's dealing with. Sort out your internalised misogyny.

LuckySantangelo35 · 03/07/2022 10:08

Charlize43 · 03/07/2022 09:36

One day when you are old and incapacitated, maybe even on a life support machine... just hope that he doesn't remember that you cut his Ethernet cable.

I think maybe take a moment for reflection.

@Charlize43

and do what??

keep doing all his cooking and cleaning and washing and allow him to live with them forever rent-free loafing around their house being disrespectful and stinking the place out just in case he decides to be spiteful in their old age?!

Does cutting a sodding internet cable (which was done to try and help him) negate the fact that every single bloody day they feed him and provide him with a warm clean and safe home? That they don’t take any rent of him. If years down the line he remembers about the cable and forgets about all the stuff parents have done for him that says a lot more about him then it does them - that he is a nasty petty person

fuck that!

there really is a train of thought on mumsnet that you have to let your adult dc get away with bloody murder out of pure fear that they may treat you badly when you are old.

well if my DC were that way inclined frankly I wouldn’t want them in my life when I was old and vulnerable - I’d be ashamed of them.

goldfinchonthelawn · 03/07/2022 10:08

Pumpkinjam · 03/07/2022 01:36

Some people are so harsh. He’s a 20 year old student with no life experience and no real friends by the sound of things.

We have just come through a socially isolating pandemic that has messed with our mental health and social skills. He has also not been given the opportunity to meet new people / live with his peers.

So many people will say oh but by the time I was 19 i had two kids and a full time job so no excuse….but this isn’t the case for your boy who sounds like a typical student….so seriously give him a break and stop assuming he’s going to end up a 40 year old screw up still living at home!!

Be kind, pay for his accommodation,
let him game, show him you’ll trust him
and be his guarantor ….worst that happens is you’re back at square one a few months down the line but maybe a gentle push in the right direction and showing him you trust and support him will help turn things around! Even if it takes a couple of years.

I get what you are saying about the pandemic etc but gaming is an addiction and he won't improve without his parents disrupting his routine and making life uncomfortable for him until he starts taking some responsibility for himself.

There are students all over UK who had a terrible time starting uni during the pandemic. But they have emerged from the crisis, made friends, found jobs, joined societies and sports clubs. OP's DS could do any of these but he won't unless his existing lifestyle is made impossible for him to continue.

Newrunner29 · 03/07/2022 10:07

zhivagodr · 03/07/2022 08:42

I think we're too quick to suggest he's presenting ADHD or autism. To me it seems he's presenting as a lazy freeloader! I sympathise with you OP.

The OP has mentioned caring for his twin disabled brother, it is not a jump to assume his twin brother could have autism or adhd and that means he could also and just presents differently!

BedisBliss · 03/07/2022 10:07

I could have posted this@MadeAMessOfParenting and mine is now 23, having dropped out of Uni in third year. To add to my issues, I am a single woman maintaining him and my school aged daughter....as he has no income due to missing 'signing on' appointments. My son is filled with self-loathing at being a failure and has cut himself off from 'real life' people as he is so ashamed of himself. His only friends are online. I have no answers for you but understand completely your frustration and why you cut the ethernet cable! It's a hellish situation and I wonder if both my son and yours would benefit from counselling/medication for depression? Feel your frustration and worry!

SpookyButTrue · 03/07/2022 10:06

Summerfun54321 · 03/07/2022 08:35

You’re enabled a gaming addiction by providing continuous WiFi through the night and devices in his bedroom for years and years. Yes he’s 20 and an adult but you should have put an end to this years ago when he was doing his GCSEs. If you don’t help him find a solution now, you’ve enabled this addiction then just washed your hands of him. The time to have acted on this and got strict was years ago but it’s still not too late. Calm down and think together if uni or work if the best thing for him and get him help for his addiction.

I agree with the sentiment here.

You are responsible for this to a large degree OP. He won't have the life skills of a DC that has not been stuck in a darkened room in front of a screen for years.

Real life is alien to a section of society and this is as a result of others enabling that alienation.

Sunbun19 · 03/07/2022 10:06

That gaming pc would have been thrown in the nearest river by now op, no you were not harsh cutting the cable imo

He's needs to get a grip, the only reason he's not trying is because he knows you'll bail him out time and time again

You need to show him it stops now, it's like going back to toddler years and teaching consequences

ChristinaXYZ · 03/07/2022 10:06

Charlize43 · 03/07/2022 09:36

One day when you are old and incapacitated, maybe even on a life support machine... just hope that he doesn't remember that you cut his Ethernet cable.

I think maybe take a moment for reflection.

Let's hope he remembers all the good things his parents did for him and how badly he treated them. Such a silly thing to say.

Acheyknees · 03/07/2022 10:05

If you can't change his behaviour you can certainly change your reaction to it. I would stop cooking, washing his clothes and providing any type of support. I suspect he'll fail his uni course due to his non attendance, if he does, don't try and help him. You've been too supportive with time and money, let him reach rock bottom.
It's the 40th anniversary of the Falklands War this year, I read an account of an 18 year old sailor who served on one of the bombed warships. The things he saw and dealt with at 18 made me cry. Your son can't even get out of bed.
I

KosherDill · 03/07/2022 10:03

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 00:38

Those saying I shouldn’t have cut his cable - what else do you suggest? He could just plug it back in again when we’re in bed and still stay up all night!

I’ve made him box up his PC and put it in the garage several times before but he’s used the excuse that he needed it for Uni work to get it back or he’s made an effort for a few days but it never lasts and he’s finished Uni for this year. Maybe seeing it sitting there but not being able to use it for gaming will focus his mind. He has a laptop but can’t use it for games.

Cable was plugged into my WiFi box which he doesn’t contribute to!

I think you were fine to cut the cable. I'd be smashing the PC. You should change the password on the wifi too.

He is an addict. He must seek treatment.

Spending loan money on online games is appalling.

Tell him he must be out by September 1.

ChristinaXYZ · 03/07/2022 10:03

User3568975431146 · 03/07/2022 00:31

Wow ain't you a charmer. Of course you shouldn't have cut his cable, it's his property. Well done on making a bad situation worse.

I would have chopped it into tiny bits. In what way is the cable the property of a big idle kid who has no money of his own? Even the student loan seems to be got by deception as he appears to do no work for uni.

OP you were right. Stick to your guns. It is not fair on you and will be better for him in the long term too.

Change that Wifi password. Do it weekly. Stick to your guns about him going into halls too or you'll be nagged into giving the wifi password for uni online. If he gets up and works then gets the password if not no-go. Who pays for his phone too? Do not give him pocket money.

There is no way he can't get a student-type holiday or weekend job. There is a labour shortage for low skilled work.

Provenceinthesummer · 03/07/2022 10:03

Turn off the WiFi
Keep it turned off
Provide basic food and bed and nothing else
No money, no Loans - until he gets a job/starts working on uni course then he won’t be doing anything
research local support for gaming addiction and offer to help/support him

Tough love is all that is going to work here
He will thank you one day

SilverGlitterBaubles · 03/07/2022 10:02

I would sit him down and speak to him as an adult. Explain the situation he is in, the impact on his life and future if he fails uni and the impact his behaviour is having on the household. Make an agreement with him to take the following steps

Get a job - and take responsibility for getting up and getting himself there
Wash daily
Do laundry and chores to contribute to the household

If he demonstrates that he can do these things without intervention and nudging from you he can
Have his internet restored subject to daily limits and a curfew
You will consider becoming a guarantor for him to move to uni halls.

LuckySantangelo35 · 03/07/2022 10:01

waveyourpompoms · 03/07/2022 00:19

He’s right, you shouldn’t be damaging his property. He’s an adult and destroying other peoples things isn’t acceptable.

You also say you made him to go on the holiday and then were annoyed he acted like he didn’t want to be there? It obviously wasn’t fabulous to him.

If you want him to move out fair enough, but the way you have behaved here is unacceptable.

@waveyourpompoms

there is always one on here that likes to blame the parents no matter how bad the behaviour of the offsprings

You say - They shouldn’t have cut his internet cable as he is an adult.

Well, he is an adult you’re absolutely right - so he can bloody move out and get a job can’t he??

Pleaseletmeconfirm · 03/07/2022 09:58

I wouldn't have cut the cable but I would have stopped him having access to the internet.

Are you cooking and cleaning for him?

Can you turn the electricity off at night.

How does he pay for his mobile?

RitaFires · 03/07/2022 09:55

Can you contact student support services at his Uni? If he's doing alright despite his terrible timekeeping it would be a shame to force him to drop out.

It sounds like he has mental health issues at the very least and it would probably be a good idea to get him assessed for adhd and autism.

When one of your siblings has special needs it can be really easy to get the message that your struggles aren't important and to just not bother telling your parents about anything because they have enough on their plate. Some counselling could potentially help him regardless of what diagnosis he does or doesn't get.

His gaming PC almost definitely has WiFi capabilities, so cutting his cable hasn't stopped him gaming online, it's just less stable and his ping has increased.

Try and talk to him from the perspective that you love him and want more for him, he may have gotten the impression that he's less important to you than his brother.

Jumperoo56370000 · 03/07/2022 09:49

I wouldn’t have cut the cable, I would have just changed the settings on the router or even removed the cable.

However, he really ought to be able to fix an Ethernet cable. You can attach the plug to the cut end. Although I would probably have to Google the instructions(!)

LindaEllen · 03/07/2022 09:47

I have no idea what you can do about it, but I'm pretty much in the same situation with my partner's son. He spends all his time online, sleeps most of the day, isn't interested in anything else. Says he's looking for a job but won't (or can't!) show us any evidence of this, as it shows we don't trust him (we absolutely don't). He does sod all around the house, hordes dishes and cutlery upstairs and every so often plonks them by the sink for us to wash.

Every so often we will have a go at him, things will change for about an hour where he'll put the hoover round or something, and then straight back to normal.

I do not know what to do, but it's killing us.

Midlifemusings · 03/07/2022 09:45

Failure to launch. There are quite a few resources for parents with young adult children who failed to launch from adolescence into young adulthood. How was he prior to 3 years ago? Did he struggle socially? Academically? Emotionally?

www.optimumperformanceinstitute.com/failure-to-launch-syndrome/
www.scientificamerican.com/article/failure-to-launch-syndrome/

Whatever00 · 03/07/2022 09:44

You shouldn't damage his property. You pay for the Internet so set parental controls on it and limit the times it work. When my bother was bumming around my mum used to wake him up at 7 and put him out the house. He wasn't allowed back in until 6. Working hours. She told him she would do that until he got a job and she did.