Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this a harsh thing to do to adult son?

289 replies

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 00:04

DS1 is 20 and there have been issues with screen addiction since he was a teen. We’ve tried many things to get him to regulate himself but he just won’t. He fucked up his GCSEs due to it.

He has not worked apart from a few months part time on 2 occasions since he left school. Did 3 years at college, dropped out in first year of A Levels and changed courses to a BTEC which he scraped through and started at Uni last September. I wasn’t happy at knew he wouldn’t work hard and told him to defer for a few years but he promised he would. Lives at home as accommodation costs £1k a month! but is only just over an hour away. I had told him to get job over the summer before he started Uni to save for the accommodation but he didn’t. He hasn’t actually attended since last November. Says it’s OK to do it online.

His days consist of staying up all night talking shit to his mates while playing games, then going back to bed in morning for the whole day. Doesn’t wash regularly, breath stinks and only goes out if his mates arrange something on the odd occasion.

He actually wakes up DH who works very long hours due to how loud he talks and there has been major rows about it.

He apparently can’t get a job. Hasn’t had one since he had a Christmas temp one, as he’s not getting replies to applications although he’s actually missed interviews as been asleep!

He doesn’t pay rent although I took money off him from his first student loan payment as he lost his Dads bike and damaged a car by riding into it which we had to pay for. He told his mates we were exploiting him financially!

Found out he has spent all his last student loan which he got in April probably on online games and now has no money left at all! Not on drugs as he doesn’t go out to use them!

We took him on a fabulous holiday abroad last month, all inclusive, loads of activities, pool, beach, evening entertainment to try to liven him up but he spent most of it in his hotel room! He was furious we made him come too.

I had told him if he’s going to continue at Uni this year, he needs to move out into halls as I refuse to support him any longer but his maintenance loan won’t cover this so he needs to earn over the summer. Still no job and he spent the day in bed today AGAIN despite saying he wasn’t going to. I went out and found him there after asking him to cut the grass having asked him for 2 weeks now.

He needs us to be guarantors for his Uni halls but I’ve told him no as he’s not reliable to pay his rent and probably won’t get a part time job then either.

I asked him many times whats going on, could he be depressed, told him to go to GP, ask for blood tests, ask for counselling but he can’t be bothered. He’s quite happy when he’s online with his mates though.

He has a big gaming PC which needs an Ethernet cable for WiFi. I have cut it and he doesn’t have the cash to buy another one which I won’t let him connect anyway. He says I had no right to damage his property!

I’ve also told him as he can’t afford to live in halls, he has to quit Uni and get a full time job as we won’t support him any longer so he can pay rent or get out!

He’s always been lazy despite being highly intelligent. used to be lovely but now has rages if he’s asked to anything, no respect and very arrogant and I just don’t know what to do anymore. I’ve lost the plot many times telling him how disappointed I am that he’s doing this and what the hell is he doing but he can’t seem to sort himself out.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Notanotherwindow · 03/07/2022 11:50

I would pay first month's rent and deposit on a room in a houseshare, pack up his stuff, move it over there and telling him this is where he lives now, take the key to your house off him and tell him he isn't coming home, it's time to grow up. Warn him that he has one month's rent paid and he needs to do it in future so needs to either find a job or a comfy looking bus shelter. Refuse to help. He needs to grow up.

Muminabun · 03/07/2022 11:49

I applaud you op. Life is difficult for most people. You are showing him some tough love after chance after chance. You are right to totally cut off his gaming. He is addicted. If he was my son I would do the same. I would also buy him some books and running gear and tell him his new hobby is couch to five k and reading and to ease him into work gently I would get him to do volunteer work for a cause he cares about and build up his cv. He is clearly not ready to attend uni. If you don’t do this now then look at so many posters on mumsnet where the uncle, brother whatever is still at home gaming at 40+ with elderly parents. HE needs help to stop this destructive behaviour and I think you and your DH are stepping up for him And showing him a lot of love. Good for you.

EmmaH2022 · 03/07/2022 11:47

BestZebbie and a few others seem to have missed the fact he has a good social life and those friends are giving him money.

PeopleRStrange · 03/07/2022 11:46

You can usually disable the Ethernet ports in the router settings, and also restrict to only known/trusted devices, so you could have kicked the machine off the internet without cutting the cable.

ofwarren · 03/07/2022 11:44

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 11:32

Thanks all.

DS1 does NOT have ASD or ADHD! Yes his twin has ASD and a learning disability and him having ASD was explored years ago. Not by formal assessment though as it took 6 years for DS2 to get formal diagnosis of the ASD.

He is not avoiding social interactions by not going to Uni. He immediately made a big circle of friends when he first started. Crashed over in their halls a few times over the weekends. He actually pissed them off with his views on something, was challenged so ‘unfollowed’ them in anger which is a major social faux pas, was challenged on that and now does not speak to any of them. That’s why he won’t go into Uni! We have tried again and again to tell him not to fuck up his course for something as stupid as that and it would have been forgotten.

He is extremely arrogant and hard headed, thinks he’s more intelligent than anyone else and we know nothing of course.

He is walking around the house laughing at videos on his phone atm. That was also an addiction a few years back. Watching jackass type videos and listening to KSi on You Tube.

There’s no way I’m giving him a penny for Uni! It’s bullshit that parents are expected to facilitate their adult children’s choices! I left home at 18. DH was doing National Service at 18! He’s laying in bed all day, flushing his loan money down the toilet and not doing the work!

Did posters saying that not read that I have been DS2’s carer with a younger DC too(11), only recently started working, struggled on DH’s wage only for years with him working his arse off. The holiday was our first ever since we had the twins! He ruined it despite saying he wanted to come at first, then expected me to cancel his ticket knowing we wouldn’t get a refund! No way is money from me working going to him so he can carry on dossing. Nuts!

Interesting..
So his twin has ASD..
Autism is hereditary so the odds of having another child with it are higher. Also, especially those with what would be known as 'High functioning autism' are not picked up until teenage or even adult years.
Your description of his behaviours, especially with his friends certainly sound like that of an autistic person.

BellePeppa · 03/07/2022 11:44

Would he consider a job where you live in? If he joined an agency that offer that kind of work it may at least put him on the road to independence?

EmmaH2022 · 03/07/2022 11:44

The "old and incapacitated" comment made me laugh. All they will care about is their money and food supply and personal staff services have gone. They certainly won't be helping their parents, if they wanted to, they don't know how to adult.

OP have you thought about showing him this thread?

I am seeing mum later, so will ask after the friends who have these 40 somethings in their houses. But I do know that many of them aren't in touch much. The situation kind of envelops them and is a real downer.

i wish you the best of luck with it.

LilianLenton · 03/07/2022 11:43

YANBU OP. I would tell him that he needs to pass his course or get a job & start paying an appropriate amount of rent considering he’s now an adult. Or he’s welcome to move out, you can’t afford to keep him for free, as you will not have the funds to do so. His choice. And he’s to stop preventing you from sleeping, & do an appropriate share of the housework if he chooses to stay.

BestZebbie · 03/07/2022 11:42

From your OP, wouldn’t he say that he is doing what he can and you are being unreasonable? He has joined a university, and is attending online as the university allows. He can’t move to live in and have a direct social life on his doorstep like the others as he can’t afford it as you won’t act as his guarantee or as you trust him less than his equally broke friends parents trust them. He has tried (and continues to try) to find supplementary work as you ask and in fact has had two temporary jobs, but the employment market for a 20yr old full time student with middling-to-poor GCSEs isn’t great. He games as an escape from his situation as he is socially isolated and lives with his parents, who are burned out from manual work and care responsibilities for his twin. You pressured him to leave his escape and his online support network of loyal friends to go to the beach, which he made clear he didn’t want to do, and then guilt tripped him for not being suitably grateful. He has passed his first year but you are constantly on his case, calling him lazy, and are aggressively changing the goalposts for your support - which is already less than many or even most students receive (which he might understand is out of your control or not, but will still feel unfair). As the final straw, you have gone into his room and damaged his property, illustrating double standards (you were very against property damage during the bike incident) and also possibly actually committing a crime against him as he is now an adult and the pc was a gift from his also adult friends, not provided as part of the house and therefore arguably your property also. This is has left him isolated from his support network, which probably feels abusive to him as you already have a lot of power over his life.

I agree that he does need to wash and attend important appointments, and try his best to not wake his father, but he isn’t a two year old acting up and you are treating him very aggressively and with absolutely no benefit of the doubt whilst he is in a vulnerable position.

BellePeppa · 03/07/2022 11:40

Charlize43 · 03/07/2022 09:36

One day when you are old and incapacitated, maybe even on a life support machine... just hope that he doesn't remember that you cut his Ethernet cable.

I think maybe take a moment for reflection.

That’s the stupidest thing I’ve read on here. He would have to be an evil psychopath to do that.

LilacPoppy · 03/07/2022 11:39

If he hasn’t been assessed you have no idea if he has ASD or ADHD. You are abusive and neglectful. Do not destroy others property and act like a parent and step up to your moral obligation to pay the difference between the maximum loan so he can live in halls.
You are responsible for most of this situation not your ds.

BetteDavies · 03/07/2022 11:38

YABU - having lavished expensive holidays on him and supported him in expensive uni accommodation (cutting the cable is just a tiny part of this). How did he get to uni if he couldn't be bothered to resit English GCSE? He needs to move out - maybe one of his generous friends will take him? You also need to better support his twin. You can get the support you need to find him appropriate training, to move forward- there are agencies who can help (my son is an adult with disabilities).

MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 11:35

At least he slept last night and is up as no PC last night!

OP posts:
MadeAMessOfParenting · 03/07/2022 11:32

Thanks all.

DS1 does NOT have ASD or ADHD! Yes his twin has ASD and a learning disability and him having ASD was explored years ago. Not by formal assessment though as it took 6 years for DS2 to get formal diagnosis of the ASD.

He is not avoiding social interactions by not going to Uni. He immediately made a big circle of friends when he first started. Crashed over in their halls a few times over the weekends. He actually pissed them off with his views on something, was challenged so ‘unfollowed’ them in anger which is a major social faux pas, was challenged on that and now does not speak to any of them. That’s why he won’t go into Uni! We have tried again and again to tell him not to fuck up his course for something as stupid as that and it would have been forgotten.

He is extremely arrogant and hard headed, thinks he’s more intelligent than anyone else and we know nothing of course.

He is walking around the house laughing at videos on his phone atm. That was also an addiction a few years back. Watching jackass type videos and listening to KSi on You Tube.

There’s no way I’m giving him a penny for Uni! It’s bullshit that parents are expected to facilitate their adult children’s choices! I left home at 18. DH was doing National Service at 18! He’s laying in bed all day, flushing his loan money down the toilet and not doing the work!

Did posters saying that not read that I have been DS2’s carer with a younger DC too(11), only recently started working, struggled on DH’s wage only for years with him working his arse off. The holiday was our first ever since we had the twins! He ruined it despite saying he wanted to come at first, then expected me to cancel his ticket knowing we wouldn’t get a refund! No way is money from me working going to him so he can carry on dossing. Nuts!

OP posts:
latetothefisting · 03/07/2022 11:27

fUNNYfACE36 · 03/07/2022 04:12

The idea is that parents make up the portion of the maintenance loan that the student isn't entitled to.
If you had done this and he had moved into halls at a uni, he would likely have made friends and engaged with the University experience. Living at home has kept him isolated from his new peers and new social opportunities. University gives most young people independence and the chance t o gly the nest.By refusing to act as guarantor ( which nearly every parent does) you are keeping him trapped
I think living at home with his parents and disabled sibling must be pretty grim fir a lad of 20, and the gaming is what keeps him going

Fuck me this is disgustingly disablist - why would living at home with parents and disabled sibling be any worse than living at home with a sibling without disabilities? Particularly as OP has said sibling actually contributes more to the family and is more pleasant to spend time around than DC1! Disabled people aren't a puunishment to their family you know!

All those saying if DC1 had been supported to live in halls he would be more socially engaged are ridiculous - I knew people who never came out of their rooms in uni and that was 15 years ago! Plus it's completely normal for people to live at home and go to uni nowadays - I know loads of people who did so. If DC is this unsociable now, with his family and friends he's grown up with within easy distance, why would he suddenly buck up and engage with random strangers? All living in halls would achieve is him accruing an extra 15 grand plus worth of debt over 3 years, plus OP losing money that could be much better spent on the rest of the family. Would you like to work all week just to throw your money down the drain?

I can see the point of the posters saying he probably has some sort of gaming addiction but OP can only help with that if he agrees he does, and agrees to engage in support to stop it. Otherwise the sharp shock of MAKING him leave home and get a job is probably the only thing that will get him off his computer.

Quincythequince · 03/07/2022 11:19

Kick him out OP.
Tell him to leave and not come back.

cakeorwine · 03/07/2022 11:14

Penners99 · 03/07/2022 10:59

So many people here who do not know the difference between wired and WiFi connections.
WiFi usually has a password, wired does not.
HTH.

Some routers can block devices - and only allow devices on a network. Regardless of wired or non wired.

Reading this with interest as relevant to DS.

Penners99 · 03/07/2022 10:59

So many people here who do not know the difference between wired and WiFi connections.
WiFi usually has a password, wired does not.
HTH.

GCRich · 03/07/2022 10:45

When you said "He was furious we made him come too" is does rather sound like you are reaping the rewwards of infantalising him. Who on earth forces their 16 year old to go on holiday with them, let alone their 20 year old?

BUt yeah, he needs to stand on his own to feet, he is not going to benefit from further infantilisation.

LunchBoxPolice · 03/07/2022 10:42

Sounds exactly like my relative who has autism.
I think there’s more going on with your son than laziness

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 03/07/2022 10:35

ProperVexed · 03/07/2022 09:12

@LiesDoNotBecomeUs
@KathyWilliams
Please could you tell me which Jordan Peterson book to start with? I'm watching this thread with interest as my DS21 is similar but perhaps not quite so bad. I might have to bribe him to read the book though......

It was Petersons: '12 Rules for Life'

I didn't bribe DS to read it... almost forbade it in fact (for JP's anti-feminism).

Banned books always sell well :) and this was so much better than the ICEL stuff he had found online. He was certainly looking for something about being a man.

Pleaseletmeconfirm · 03/07/2022 10:26

wantmorenow · 03/07/2022 10:18

I'm going through similar with my 19DS. He is super intelligent but has been kicked out of first year of university for non-attendance and no work.

He is unable to "adult" - he is at rock bottom. He has so much potential but seems to fuck it up every time. Gaming through the night in halls almost certainly was a factor. Procrastination, unable to see consequences of inaction, lack of awareness. Will buy this book too and see if it helps.

Having your son at home and not in halls probably was a big factor in why your son passed first year so well done to you. It's so frustrating isn't it. My son is lovely, polite, popular, funny and talented but completely useless unless someone pushes him constantly or holds his hand through every process. Unfortunately he hides his problems until they are too far along to pull back from. He's lost his uni place, his girlfriend, didn't fill in a simple form to withdraw from halls and give key back which has added another £2,200 to his debts and is being chased by debt recovery people from halls and SLC. He's overwhelmed daily and I'm always trying to fix things but too late.

He's genuinely bewildered by the world and mostly in a state of anxiety all the time. Am trying to get GP help (again) but what can they do. I got him a job which he enjoys and is probably saving his mental health currently - can you apply for jobs on his behalf? I know it's a bit weird but I rang a few local tourist type bars and just kind of offered his services and said he was rubbish on phone. We wrote his CV and I physically took him to the bars and waited outside for him. They took him on and he is doing well. He wanted a job - but just couldn't get it independently. I wish you well.

That sounds difficult for you and your family. That's great that your son is doing ok at his job and I don't blame you for trying to help him out. Hopefully he will get better soon. Becoming an adult is scary, teens are bombarded with pressure and it's not surprising it's too much for some.

JustDanceAddict · 03/07/2022 10:22

I’m no psychologist but I have DCs w MH issues and there are a lot of issues here.
Do you think there’s neurodiversity because I had no idea that my DD was not neurotypical until she told me how she’d been masking all these years.

He prob is addicted to gaming, it could be a distraction from ‘real life’ and a way to interact w friends without having to go out. If you cut his cable then it’s his ‘lifeline’ cut, whatever you think of gaming (and yes the loudness is v annoying but you need to agree on some boundaries here together).

Not washing/day sleeping is also a signal to me he’s prob depressed or anxious. It’s a real red flag. He prob doesn’t want to admit it as MH can still be taboo.

My DD has also found it hard to get a uni job, it’s often through contacts as even though they say places are crying out for staff, they want experience or someone who has been recommended.

Can you sit down with him and talk like equals and come to some type of agreement? You don’t want him living like this and he probably doesn’t either but it’s the easy way out for him to not assume any responsibility.

Meem321 · 03/07/2022 10:20

Other posters have mentioned aspergers and adhd. He does, have traits and behaviours that indicate he may be on the spectrum somewhere.

For those saying he's a lazy toerag, yes he is. But there may be a reason beyond his control.

Please, as frustrating and soul destroying as it is, seek an assessment ASAP. My 45 Yr old cousin started like this at 13. He's not left the house since, and rarely in fact leaves his bedroom. It's no life for any of you.

wantmorenow · 03/07/2022 10:18

I'm going through similar with my 19DS. He is super intelligent but has been kicked out of first year of university for non-attendance and no work.

He is unable to "adult" - he is at rock bottom. He has so much potential but seems to fuck it up every time. Gaming through the night in halls almost certainly was a factor. Procrastination, unable to see consequences of inaction, lack of awareness. Will buy this book too and see if it helps.

Having your son at home and not in halls probably was a big factor in why your son passed first year so well done to you. It's so frustrating isn't it. My son is lovely, polite, popular, funny and talented but completely useless unless someone pushes him constantly or holds his hand through every process. Unfortunately he hides his problems until they are too far along to pull back from. He's lost his uni place, his girlfriend, didn't fill in a simple form to withdraw from halls and give key back which has added another £2,200 to his debts and is being chased by debt recovery people from halls and SLC. He's overwhelmed daily and I'm always trying to fix things but too late.

He's genuinely bewildered by the world and mostly in a state of anxiety all the time. Am trying to get GP help (again) but what can they do. I got him a job which he enjoys and is probably saving his mental health currently - can you apply for jobs on his behalf? I know it's a bit weird but I rang a few local tourist type bars and just kind of offered his services and said he was rubbish on phone. We wrote his CV and I physically took him to the bars and waited outside for him. They took him on and he is doing well. He wanted a job - but just couldn't get it independently. I wish you well.