Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

1st birthday etiquette

36 replies

Clairejay34 · 02/07/2022 23:47

Dd2s first birthday is coming up and we are thinking of going for a meal in the afternoon with close family to celebrate it. However close family (parents, siblings and their partners and kids) is 25 people!! So my question is aibu to ask people to pay for their own meal? Should we be paying for everyone?

If we were just going with a handful of people we would pay but due to the amount of people its going to cost us around £500, which we just can't afford at the moment due to me being on mat leave and a recent house move, and also the increased cost of living.

I know my family won't mind at all and we always split the bill for things like this, but when we are invited to a birthday meal with the inlaws they always pay (we do offer but they always decline) however they are a lot better off than us financially.

For DD1 we just had a party in the house but due to the amount of people that were there and people arriving late and staying very late I just found it too stressful so I said I wouldn't have that many people in my house all at once again.

We are going to a brewers fayre type place that also has a soft play..I will pay for all the kids to get in to the soft play. Its not overly expensive..maybe £20 per person for a meal.

So..
Yabu - you should pay for everyone since you have invited them.
Yanbu - it is normal for everyone to pay for their own meal.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QueSyrahSyrah · 03/07/2022 09:10

Agree @aSofaNearYou. I wouldn't be offended to not be invited if the organisers had gone for something small, but if I were invited to a 1st birthday party by family or a close friend I'd definitely want to be there (and wouldn't mind paying my own meal in OP's scenario).

For me it's when they reach school age and have full class parties in soft play areas that I lose interest in attending Grin

aSofaNearYou · 03/07/2022 08:56

Rachie1973 · 03/07/2022 08:54

However much your family love your little one they won’t want to attend a 1 year olds birthday party. It’s far more important to you, as it should be than it is to them.

People say this a lot on here tbh but I don't think it's true at all.

I wouldn't make it a huge event but I've never known anyone be totally uninterested in a family members 1st birthday to the point they actively don't want to go (unless they dislike their family), it's just an excuse to all meet up if nothing else. People on MN are overly dismissive about 1st birthdays.

Rachie1973 · 03/07/2022 08:54

However much your family love your little one they won’t want to attend a 1 year olds birthday party. It’s far more important to you, as it should be than it is to them.

reluctantbrit · 03/07/2022 08:53

I would go for a hall, maybe find one with an outdoor space and just get picnic food and a cake.

Check that it starts after nap times otherwise you have tired children. Friend's did their 1st birthday party at 2pm, middle of nap time and it was awful.

I think going for dinner for a child's birthday is over the top until they are a lot older.

aSofaNearYou · 03/07/2022 08:45

I wouldn't do this for a 1st birthday tbh, it's not very kid friendly even if there is a soft play so it's essentially a pointless expense.

I would go for a picnic.

mirrorballer · 03/07/2022 08:42

Clairejay34 · 03/07/2022 00:26

@Doorsdoyle @onemorerose the place we were thinking of going has a soft play area, so I thought would suit both kids and adults. But I'm seeing its probably too much.

I remember going for meals at a place like this with young children. The kids whine constantly to go in the soft play, including when everyone is eating. You buy them food they don't want, everyone is pissed off and honestly the food is usually quite shit anyway.

Do the hall thing or go for a picnic.

Re paying for meals.
I've never been out for a meal and expected the host/inviter to pay for me. I have one friend whose parents always insist on paying if we see them and my in-laws too but that's it.
I find it a really strange expectation and one that I've only ever seen on mumsnet. So whilst I implore you not to go to the restaurant, if you do there should be no expectation for you to pay.

Icecreamsodaloda · 03/07/2022 08:41

I agree a hall is a great idea that way people can't outstay their welcome, you could even hire some soft play equipment, say you are providing tea, coffee and soft drink but if anyone wants a drink they are welcome to BYOB. Morrisons do some great value party platters as well.

SunshineLollipopsRainbow · 03/07/2022 08:34

Just another comment to add doing the hall is a good idea as you hire the hall for a specific time so those that turn up late can't just stay late like if you have it at your house 😀
There's all sorts of kid equipment you ca hire too, bouncy castle, ball pits, ride on toys, those big soft play building blocks.

Autienotnaughtie · 03/07/2022 06:28

It depends on your lifestyle. If when you invite people out you usually treat them I can see they might think your paying. But if you normally go for food together and split bill why would this be any different. It's funny some people saying your event you pay. Where I'm from (oop north) if you go out for someone's birthday usually your friends/family cover cost of your meal or get you drinks as well as paying for themselves. If my friend invited me out for her 30th I would not assume for one second it was her treat. It's her birthday!!

Dinoteeth · 03/07/2022 06:22

Op do it at home but afternoon, and state a time on the invites, Saturday between 2 and 4 so they are long gone before bedtime. And don't offer dinner so they will leave.

You are being daft to do a restaurant for 25 people. And the 1 yo old getting passed up and down the table. That sounds horrendous.

Caspianberg · 03/07/2022 06:14

I would just do invite for cake at your house at 3pm. Everyone can come
by for tea and cake in the garden

then take 1 year old yourselves to a local farm or zoo type place

Bournetilly · 03/07/2022 06:11

I agree with hiring a hall if you don’t want to have it at home. I do think it’s ok to ask people to pay for themselves (maybe pay for a round of drinks when you arrive and the soft play). I just don’t think it’s a good place for a 1st birthday when you have other children coming too, the parents won’t be able to sit and enjoy the meal they will be running after their own children.

girlmom21 · 03/07/2022 05:56

I'd just take the kids to soft play and have a birthday tea at home if you must.
You can order some M&S party platters to save any stress.

PeanutButterOnToad · 03/07/2022 05:34

I would host the party you can afford tbh, otherwise you will be stressed about the bill at the restaurant, trying to sort it out at the end will be a nightmare and a sit down meal with a whole lot of small children is not the most relaxing experience regardless of the soft play part. A picnic in a park with a playground would be my first choice if the weather is good, it's probably what most people do here (Aus) and generally works well. "Bring a plate" is expected and easy. Otherwise a community centre/hall.

DrJump · 03/07/2022 04:53

Given its your own brother and sisters surely you can just say hey we are going to xyz pub for dinner would love to join us. We will buy drinks for the table and have a cake.

ZuliKyanLarsFoz · 03/07/2022 04:40

Have a big picnic. Tell everyone to bring a picnic blanket and you provide sandwiches and cake. Get some games that people can play and some balloons to tie to a tree. Your 1yo can roam around and older children can play with a ball etc. Job done.

BasiliskStare · 03/07/2022 04:27

I see what you have said about DD1s birthday but I would do something at home a great deal cheaper. A one year old isn't going to be over the moon about going to a restaurant. I would do it at home and try to limit the time and if possible the people. But - perhaps sandwiches and cake laid out and an eg "between 2 and 5 " type invitation. a sit down meal for 26 people for a 1st birthday is not what I would have done - but hey you must do what suits you .

DuarPorte · 03/07/2022 04:09

A sit down meal for a ONE yr olds birthday is a bit ridiculous!

cake and balloons at home with just her grandparents!

Rainbowqueeen · 03/07/2022 03:59

For a child’s birthday party you need to host. So do what you can afford.

What about afternoon tea at your house from 2-3.30 with cake cutting at 3? Then it’s a limited time and you can supply tea coffee soft drinks a few sandwiches scones fruit platter and cake.

Make sure the invitation has a start and finish time and come up with a few phrases togivepeiplethe hint that it’s time to go Eg wrap them up some cake and hand it to them saying thanks for coming, this is for you to take with you.

DPotter · 03/07/2022 02:49

I can see how a restaurant alongside a softplay would be attractive, however take it from me - the parents wouldn't get a moment's peace and be able to enjoy their meal for the kids wanting to go over to the softplay area.

community hall with buffet and maybe a bouncy castle - so much easier all round

DockOTheBay · 03/07/2022 01:59

Of course you don't have to pay for them all! Just make sure its clear from the outset so nobody gets a nasty surprise on the day.

However, I would probably change it to either just you plus grandparents (and step grandparents) which would be a much more manageable number. Can you even book a pub table for that many without pre-ordering?

Alternatively as others have said, book a small hall and do a mini party. This is what we did for DDs first birthday and invited about 30 people. I made cold buffet food and brought along some balloons and toys for the kids to play with, stuck on a CD of Disney songs.

BelleMarionette · 03/07/2022 01:22

Hire a hall, even better a children's community centre (so it will have a soft play/play area) and self cater. You can ask family to bring a dish.

Or you could hold it in the park if good weather (but have a plan B in case it rains).

I wouldn't feel comfortable inviting people, and asking them to pay. £20 a head is also quite expensive, and given the cost of living crisis might stretch a lot of people's budgets.

SkankingWombat · 03/07/2022 01:13

Can you have it at home but with another 'out of the house' commitment afterwards that means you have to go out by X time? (And let all family know in advance that's the case) Also, if you make it clear it's just tea and cake without anything more substantial on the food front, that should help to starve them out the door on time.
A meal out for that many inc DCs seems OTT and chaotic in itself TBH, and you do need to be offering to pay I think (and running the risk of being taken up on it) even if each nuclear family is likely pay for themselves. The other option is to prune the guest list to just parents and their partners, giving a total head count of 10 inc your DCs.
FWIW, I would just have a party at home and accept family were likely to overstay. For much less than the £500 you are talking aboit for the meal, you could buy in sandwich platters etc to make the day easier. If you time it for later in the day, you can just take DCs off to bed after a couple of hours (at their usual bedtime) and hide up there until everyone's gone.

TeapotTitties · 03/07/2022 00:52

Clairejay34 · 03/07/2022 00:21

@TeapotTitties the people we are inviting are immediate family only..we have 5 siblings between us all of which have partners and kids, (so ten adults and 6 kids) dhs parents are divorced and remarried so between them and my parents there are 6 of them, and then me, dh and our 2 dcs make 26 people, there's no one we could really cut from that list.

Yes I think I am over thinking it, will definitely look in to a party in a hall, thanks for the suggestions :)

No I get that but why are you inviting them to a baby's birthday 'party'? Will they even want to attend even if they don't have to pay for their meal?

Surely at that age they just send a card/present or pop round for tea and cake if you're doing anything at all?

It would be completely different if this was a toddler rather than a baby, but as it stands this is a meal for no-one other than you and the baby's dad.

I think dropping by for tea and cake would be far more appropriate, especially as I'm sure they'll feel obliged to fork out for a present as well as their own food/drinks etc.

Yodaisawally · 03/07/2022 00:28

Have a party at home with some sandwich platters, the kid isn't going to know or care.