Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To insist on a new kitchen and insist he pays for it?

320 replies

alittlecroquetta · 02/07/2022 20:24

Hi all.

Reasons why we need a new kitchen:

  • we moved here nearly 9 years ago and first thing we said was new kitchen.
  • it's over 20yrs old and starting to look really worn. 3 doors almost hanging off. Holes in the lino. Dishwasher packed up 3 weeks ago.
  • can't get new dishwasher as it's 20+ years old, discontinued and built-in. DP not taking his turn doing the dishes like he said he would. I've done the dishes 19 days to his 2 days. I hate doing dishes. I think now is the time to finally invest in this new kitchen we've spoken about for years.

Why I think he should pay:

  • we had a joint savings account since we moved in together. 3/4 of that was money I saved from my salary (I'm the higher earner) and 1/4 was a remortgage.
  • I pay the mortgage and every other bill apart from council tax which he pays.
  • we hit a rough patch at the start of the pandemic and nearly split up. I took MN advice and took half the money from the savings account. We've since got back together but we haven't put the money back into the savings account.
  • my half has dwindled significantly due to the rising cost of living. Prices of everything going up. I had to buy a new car because we were using his car but when we split obviously he took it and I needed a car for work. I've had to dip into the savings to cover the bills. I've told him numerous times that I was into my overdraft and I need us to split the bills proportionately to our wages. It has fell on deaf ears.

When I raised the new kitchen again today he said we are not in a financial position to get a new kitchen because I can't contribute to half of the cost. I said my "half" has been swallowed up by bills and just because the remainder of the savings are in his account it doesn't make them "his because I provided most/all of it. He said I was the one who chose to split the money when we almost split.

AIBU?

OP posts:
fallfallfall · 03/07/2022 17:21

have him pay 50/50 as he should and give him an allowance of sorts? many men do this for women.

fallfallfall · 03/07/2022 17:20

do NOT lump all money together unless formally wed or in a rock solid relationship with excellent financial boundaries.

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 16:56

CecilyP · 03/07/2022 16:39

He can't afford to pay half. He doesn't earn enough.

Are you sure? If he was in a house share or HMO wouldn’t he be paying more rent and bills?

OK yes he does have enough coming in to pay half but after half the bills and his personal spends - petrol, phone, etc he would be left with next to no spare cash at all. I don't think that's fair? That's why I keep suggesting proportional split or just lump all money together.

OP posts:
CecilyP · 03/07/2022 16:39

He can't afford to pay half. He doesn't earn enough.

Are you sure? If he was in a house share or HMO wouldn’t he be paying more rent and bills?

fallfallfall · 03/07/2022 16:33

The full financial disclosure needs to be discussed. Economic times have changed, rising cost of living etc.
if you run out of money you will loose the house, if it’s inevitable then some maintenance and upkeep may be needed to sell at the best price.
bottom line you are both living beyond your means if indeed his wage is so minimal.

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 16:19

fallfallfall · 03/07/2022 15:50

Do you ever sit down and go over each other’s finances as a couple?
do you genuinely know where each other’s pennies are? Including pensions?
what has he done with the recent financial split of savings? Should he be using that to fund the 50/50 of bills? Why is he not volunteering this for house reno’s including painting and repairs?

We sat down and went over finances when we were in the process of getting a mortgage together. Never done it since.

I don't know what accounts he has or how much money he has/where it is. Everything is separate.

OP posts:
fallfallfall · 03/07/2022 15:50

Do you ever sit down and go over each other’s finances as a couple?
do you genuinely know where each other’s pennies are? Including pensions?
what has he done with the recent financial split of savings? Should he be using that to fund the 50/50 of bills? Why is he not volunteering this for house reno’s including painting and repairs?

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 15:29

MiniPiccolo · 03/07/2022 15:25

OP tell him to start paying for half of everything or fuck off. Fuck proportional income.

He can't afford to pay half. He doesn't earn enough.

OP posts:
MiniPiccolo · 03/07/2022 15:25

OP tell him to start paying for half of everything or fuck off. Fuck proportional income.

Crumpleton · 03/07/2022 15:23

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 11:49

Yes I've felt like I've been flopping along too. I get very restless and frustrated. Hence why I'm feeling the need to jump in and do something i.e. the kitchen.

He would absolutely 100% never go for that. Why would he? I wouldn't either if I was in his position. The only solution is to either get him to pay his way or split and sell up.

Of course he wouldn't go for that. Why wouldn't you want to own a 50% share of a property while only paying a fraction towards it.
Equally he doesn't want to contribute to a new kitchen, he doesn't need or want a new one the old one to him is probably doing the job.

But my point is you at least deserve a larger share while contributing more and I think we both know that if you went ahead and did the kitchen from your own pocket your partner wouldn't suddenly be a different person. He helped around the house at first to get a foot back in the door then slipped back to being the real him and in seeing you're putting up with it you have to face it that that is how he's going to be.
Your partners very lucky that he has someone willing to pay such sums to ensure his comfort.

I really feel for you but by splitting up with him, your doing, and taking him back has shown him that you really do need him in your life and I'm guessing for him he feels that's his feet under the table and it's all your getting.

fallfallfall · 03/07/2022 14:46

I find it hard to believe that your successful at work and so ineffective at home.
is it his dick that has you so enmeshed with him? Honest question?
we’re talking simple math here, cost of living has gone up HE needs to pay more. You paid for XYZ, he needs to pay for ABC.
the unfinished jobs are driving you nuts, either he does them or he contacts it out.
IF he’s unwilling to discuss, pay up, work then the reality is both of you have different priorities and staying together being miserable is a wasted life.

billy1966 · 03/07/2022 13:31

Surely you have proof of the deposit?

Help yourself OP.

You are going to end up badly off financially unless you really cop yourself on.

elessar · 03/07/2022 13:08

You say you would have to accept the deposit being gone in the case of a split, and that he would argue that he was paying the mortgage.

So he's not a decent man then? (I mean that's already evident in the way he's treating you - but you wouldn't even trust him to behave honourably and with fairness?)

Genuinely what does he have going for him?

I split with my ex a few years ago, the deposit for the house was from him - nothing in writing to say as such, but obviously I agreed it should go back to him before we split the rest of the equity. Because I'm not an arsehole?

OP he agreed to "pay half" the kitchen because he was using the logic that his half would be from the joint account that you'd saved the money into. He never had any intention of paying half of his own money.

You'll never get anywhere with this person. The only option is to put your foot down about a fair split of bills and costs going forward. But you know he won't agree to it. He clearly has no respect for you .

I hope you find the strength to walk away from this loser.

Glittertwins · 03/07/2022 12:48

Good luck OP, you will work out what to do

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 12:25

Nanny0gg · 03/07/2022 12:17

Absolutely, I wouldn't expect anyone to say 'That's it, I hear you, I'm off'

However when what is said isn't particularly acknowledged, I suppose I was looking for a response of some kind - even if it's a 'I'm not ready to hear that yet'

I'm sorry. I promise I am taking everyone's comments on board. It's been eye-opening. But due to being burned previously, I'm not ready to take drastic steps yet. Although I think I know deep down that those steps do need to be taken.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 03/07/2022 12:21

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 10:00

He could take steps to improve his earning potential but for some reason won't/doesn't. If I lost my job, we'd definitely be up shit creek.

Bet he'd do it if you split up.

Can you explain (to yourself) why you say you love him?

What is loveable? He doesn't think about you at all. He leeches off you and he doesn't even seem kind.

I think you need to explore that

Nanny0gg · 03/07/2022 12:17

PyongyangKipperbang · 03/07/2022 00:41

This is real life, not TV.

Many many many MNers have done what the OP is doing, I was one of them. Posting to reset our vision of what is normal. We get that reality check after years of living as the boiled frog and that takes time to come to terms with.

Its not simply a case of her asking "is this ok", us saying "No it isnt, it abuse" and her her saying "ok! We will leave tomorrow!". It isnt as simple as that, if it was then no woman would ever be abused beyond the first time.

She needs time to resee him with her new eyes. To see the reality that she wasnt seeing before and coming to terms with it. And when she has done that she will start to make her plans, it may take months but she will get there as we all did. The last thing she needs is people posting on here needing the instant gratification of a happy ending for her, what she needs is long term support until she is ready.

Absolutely, I wouldn't expect anyone to say 'That's it, I hear you, I'm off'

However when what is said isn't particularly acknowledged, I suppose I was looking for a response of some kind - even if it's a 'I'm not ready to hear that yet'

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 12:15

Fully aware that I made a stupid decision last time. Hence why I said I'm not doing anything until I'm emotionally and financially prepared this time.

OP posts:
alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 12:07

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 03/07/2022 12:05

I gave him half the savings because that's what the people of MN advised me to do at the time

Right, so you’re a well-paid professional who hands a cock lodger half her savings, on the say-so of internet randoms? Bullshit.

No, but every thread you read on here about people splitting up, the advice is always take half the money from the joint account so he can't screw you over and leave you with nothing. My solicitor also advised that I need to leave half if we were splitting up.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 03/07/2022 12:05

I gave him half the savings because that's what the people of MN advised me to do at the time

Right, so you’re a well-paid professional who hands a cock lodger half her savings, on the say-so of internet randoms? Bullshit.

Aquamarine1029 · 03/07/2022 12:03

You've already wasted so much time on this man. It's tragic. Just get rid of him.

alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 12:02

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 03/07/2022 11:57

Before you take any steps or legal advice start putting the bills into joint names

Definitely do not do this. It is handing him ammo to argue that he is making a fair contribution.

Because everything comes out of a joint account that we both pay into, my solicitor advised that this will be seen as him contributing. And he can argue that he's been paying the mortgage.

OP posts:
alittlecroquetta · 03/07/2022 12:01

Crimeismymiddlename · 03/07/2022 11:52

Op the big problem is not an outdated kitchen or chores. It is the fact that you have actually purchased a house that a man who you’re not married to owns half of. You pay every bill, for all the food and effectively gave him half your saving when you broke up.
Even by mums net standards this is insane, it’s not even like the normal cocklodgers on here who do it by stelth, you actively agreed when you moved in that you would pay all the bills.
Please get some self worth because I can only assume he has never treated you out of his hoard of money, no holidays, no flowers not anything because he obviously does not love you.
Before you take any steps or legal advice start putting the bills into joint names. Tell him, and none of this ‘he said no’ rubbish that it is 50/50 now. So you have can save. Then get a solicitor to see how fucked you are with the house, or if you can salvage the 9 years worth of mortgage payments. I bet you put most, if not all the deposit down so at least you have that. Lastly, don’t worry about him, he has his savings and probably a back up since you last broke up just in case.

I gave him half the savings because that's what the people of MN advised me to do at the time.

I didn't actively agree to pay all the bills either when we moved in but the split felt more proportionate when we first moved in together. The council tax was and still is high. The mortgage and utilities were low - unfortunately they're not now. And he used to do all the food shopping too which he does still buy bits and pieces during the week but largely fallen to me now too.

He does buy me flowers every week but I've told him before the flowers and trinkets are lovely but what I actually really want is for him to finish painting the bathroom door and fix the upstairs light fitting.

I paid the deposit for the house but I haven't ringfenced it so that's gone too. I've come to terms with everything needing to be split equally. I brought all that on myself.

OP posts:
MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 03/07/2022 11:57

Before you take any steps or legal advice start putting the bills into joint names

Definitely do not do this. It is handing him ammo to argue that he is making a fair contribution.

cottagegardenflower · 03/07/2022 11:56

Can you buy him out and end the relationship. Seems the best option