Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you 'have it all' and are you happy for it?

135 replies

TheLostNights · 02/07/2022 19:18

By that I mean:

  1. A good and happy marriage or relationship
  2. Children
  3. Nice home
  4. Good job which pays well
  5. Opportunity to spend time with kids as flexible working
  6. Lots of friends and good social life
  7. Close to family
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 03/07/2022 21:48

Having it all isn't what makes you happy! You can always find that fly in the ointment.

Having a happy nature is all that is required.
The happy gene is a wonderful thing.

boopdeflouff · 03/07/2022 20:17

I have it all, except I don't own my own home (there is a renting culture where we live) and we live in a different country to our family (although technology makes daily contact easy).

Although DC1 has SN and I don't quite know what the future holds, the provisions here are excellent.

We won't be able to retire here, I am a little worried about that, and Brexit has complicate matters as I don't want to return to the UK. But, I have a rainy day jar and am happy to wait and see what happens.

It hasn't always been this way, but I have always been healthy, had a good relationship, lived in a beautiful part of the world and enjoyed my children. Money isn't my main focus in life, but I know I am lucky to be like this.

Summerwhereareyou · 03/07/2022 20:00

@Mellie555

I couldn't agree more!
Many families I knew like that lost everything including mine.
One family in particular really fell froma height.
I'm never jealous of anyone like that.

I'm on nmw but I feel extremely rich at the moment,I earn but also have plenty of time with the DC which is v important to me at the moment.
Unfortunately what I don't have is my family.

MoodyTwo · 03/07/2022 19:38

I don't have it all, but yes I am very happy x

Thepeopleversuswork · 03/07/2022 19:14

I dislike the phrase "have it all" intensely because I think this is largely a coded rebuke at women who seek both to have children and to work. It's a phrase which is rarely levelled at men and it fails to take into account several critical points about women's lives, particularly:

a) that the vast majority of women these days have to work at least a bit
b) that as a woman, not working makes your life and that of your children financially precarious and;
c) that working and having children doesn't automatically mean you are always biting off more than you can chew and run totally ragged. Plenty of people manage all these things without vast amounts of stress.

Also, as many previous posters have indicated, the list you have drawn up that constitutes "having it all" is intensely subjective.

Who is to say that these six things are things that everyone wants above all else? Many people are happier single than in settled relationships. Many women prefer not to work. Some people are NC from their families and that suits them fine. It's a totally political interpretation of what "should" make someone happy.

For the record I tick everyone of those boxes bar number 6: close relationship with family. I consider this to be largely a byproduct of good luck and with a bit of single-mindedness thrown in. It happens to make me more or less contented with my life although its not perfect but I can acknowledge that masses of people wouldn't want all or any of the things on this list. And fair play to them.

I really wish we would stop asking this question of women.

LaWench · 03/07/2022 18:50

I do have most of that and I'm contented, it's my favourite state as I believe happy can be short-lived. I don't feel like we have it difficult at present, we've had tough times and as a result, we are risk averse and cautious decision makers, when we make changes they've usually been for the best and paid off.

A balance of luck and good judgement, I suppose. I never stayed with dickhead boyfriends or in jobs that didn't value me, luck that I found a good guy and fell into a job with a flexible employer.

TheLostNights · 03/07/2022 18:27

Most people who have posted are very happy and I also dont agree that this can only be temporary. I have primary age kids and most of the parents are still together and have nice lives.
I just think she is fooling herself to think those that have done well for themselves are all secretly miserable

OP posts:
Fairislefandango · 03/07/2022 15:12

She likes to believe that people who have it all aren't exempt from it all crashing down and may be secretly unhappy.

Well she's right, isn't she! Of course nobody's immune to things crashing down. And of course some people who appear on the surface to have it all are secretly unhappy. She probably us saying it to make herself feel better, but those things are still 100% obviously true!

Cheshiresun · 03/07/2022 14:52

I don't have 4 of those things, but I'm extremely content, and consider myself fortunate, despite not having most of the listed things!

We're all different and different things bring contentment.

Mellie555 · 03/07/2022 14:49

TheLostNights · 03/07/2022 12:00

I was out so didn't see the replies until now.

I started this thread because I have a friend who is late thirties, single and never married, still lives at home, works but few hours, has chronic illnesses etc, only me as a friend. She likes to believe that people who have it all aren't exempt from it all crashing down and may be secretly unhappy. I think she just says this to herself to feel better about her own situation and wanted to prove the point that people can have it all and are genuinely happy, not just pretending.

Your friend is 100% right. No one knows what goes on behind closed doors and of course many of the having it all lot are unhappy statistically.

the primary school my boys went to (10years ago now more or less) was in a very prestigious location. I was a struggling young single mum living in a tiny council flat. I would drop the kids off at bday parties at weekends at these enormous mansions, the cars that were driven were all luxury. The mothers were all ‘ladies who lunch and gym’ and the fathers were all bankers etc.

it used to make me feel down until my mum once said to me ‘you never know what goes on behind closed doors’ and that’s stuck with me forever

i take no glee from this at all but many of those wealthy families from those days have since lost everything financially, had affairs and divorces, a couple of them have sadly died or, even more tragically, lost a child, and all those other horrible things which can happen in life.

in the meantime, my own life has done a 360 and earning 6 figures (ok so I’m not living in one of those mansions but that is never going to happen anyway unless I suddenly earn millions or win the lottery lol).

makes me realise how your life can change in an instant from the perceived ‘having it all’

Mellie555 · 03/07/2022 14:39

sammysal · 03/07/2022 08:45

Understanding the precariousness of any of these things is key to contentment (there but for the grace of god I go) no one is protected from losing one of the 'ticks' on the list and knowing you could still be happy with 'imperfection' speaks more of the person than those who need to apparently 'have it all' to be happy.

I sense a lot of complacency on this thread and I think those are the people who would come unstuck by losing something off their life tick list.

Absolutely! Having it all is definitely just a temporary thing in life, sadly. It may be for decades, or years, months or weeks but it is always just a temporary state

TedMullins · 03/07/2022 13:15

TheLostNights · 03/07/2022 12:00

I was out so didn't see the replies until now.

I started this thread because I have a friend who is late thirties, single and never married, still lives at home, works but few hours, has chronic illnesses etc, only me as a friend. She likes to believe that people who have it all aren't exempt from it all crashing down and may be secretly unhappy. I think she just says this to herself to feel better about her own situation and wanted to prove the point that people can have it all and are genuinely happy, not just pretending.

That’s a very odd reason to start a thread, almost like you want to rub her misery in her face? Of course people can “have it all” and still be unhappy - it’s not an insulator from mental illness or unexpected tragedy. Look at celebrities who’ve seemingly “had it all” - loving family, wealth, success etc - and taken their own lives. Robin Williams, Chester Benington for example.

Some people have all this and are happy of course. some people have none of this and are happy, some people have a few from the list and are happy, some have everything and are never fulfilled. There’s no one size fits all. Your friend is probably (understandably) resentful and unhappy that illnesses have limited her in what she could do with her life, but she isn’t wrong that having these things doesnt always mean automatic happiness.

TheLostNights · 03/07/2022 12:00

I was out so didn't see the replies until now.

I started this thread because I have a friend who is late thirties, single and never married, still lives at home, works but few hours, has chronic illnesses etc, only me as a friend. She likes to believe that people who have it all aren't exempt from it all crashing down and may be secretly unhappy. I think she just says this to herself to feel better about her own situation and wanted to prove the point that people can have it all and are genuinely happy, not just pretending.

OP posts:
Bearsan · 03/07/2022 11:34

Yes though 4 is my retirement income as I've retired early.
5 DC are grown up.

Somethingsnappy · 03/07/2022 11:02

memyselfi · 03/07/2022 09:21

Honestly when the op doesn't contribute it makes it feel like research.

Yes, I was just thinking the same. The thread started yesterday!

For what it's worth, yes I have all those things at the moment, but only very recently. And in the past I've had very few of them. But I'm happy now and I was happy in the past too. I feel more secure now, so that enhances the happiness, but it's balanced by the worry that something might go horribly wrong. I don't take it for granted

TheNinny · 03/07/2022 10:32

I have everything except my house is quite average and needs a bit updating but it’s functional, and I consider us lucky to have our own house. I’m not super social or free time due to young child, but do have friends and go on evenings every so often. I work full time with flexible start/end times agreed and I will approach them later to ask for 1-2 days home working, but as it’s nhs (admin) may not be possible due to a few things. But
otherwise, yes to everything else.

I am happy, and feel really fortunate to be in this position. Ive had it a lot worse in my past. But I don’t necessarily agree this list is everything you need to feel happy. I was still happy and contented when I didn’t tick the list as much.

CounsellorTroi · 03/07/2022 09:56

I have no children so cannot by definition “have it all”. I’m happy nevertheless.

DangerouslyBored · 03/07/2022 09:36

I have all of those things, apart from children but currently pregnant so come October, I will
have one!

Yes, I am very happy and have an idyllic lifestyle. No one’s life is perfect though, my MiL is getting over cancer, I sometimes have horrible anxiety 🤷🏻‍♀️

LovelyYellowLabrador · 03/07/2022 09:31

Think everyone’s idea of what having it all means

but I think it’s alot of pressure for most people and unrealistic
you maybe have it all at some points but that can proabky only last for a certain while and thjgg be a will always happen

id rather prioritise

sammysal · 03/07/2022 09:30

It's far from dwelling on it all come crashing down. It's enjoying life when it's good but having the perspective that life is (hopefully) long and by its nature has to have both happiness and sadness.

Losing one ingredient of what we are taught is key to a 'perfect' life doesn't knock the wise person off course, but if you've spent your whole life defining yourself as someone who has it all you're less likely to weather the storm and be less happy overall. Eg losing a loved partner would be devastating - some can rebuild from that and others would be forever defined by the loss.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 03/07/2022 09:26

I don't have even half of your list and I'm extremely happy with my life.

I have no desire to have kids ever though Grin

memyselfi · 03/07/2022 09:21

Honestly when the op doesn't contribute it makes it feel like research.

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 03/07/2022 09:14

I have all of that in some form and am extremely grateful for it. I have a well paid job but it's remote and flexible so I work from home and can do things like go to DD's sports day at school without asking anyone's permission. I do have to work hard, and DH doesn't work so does most of pick-ups, etc. We have been through a lot over the last few years with family death that resulted in quite a bit of upheaval including moving in with my dad, so you could say that we don't have a nice home (we are living in a beautiful house, but it's not ours), but hopefully that will happen this year.

Even with all these things there are plenty of stresses and drama and I work very hard to support my immediate and extended family (both financially, emotionally and practically). I'm lucky to have some wonderful friendships and a great relationship with DH & DD. I've had to deal with secondary infertility, bereavement, life changing injury on DH's part and lots of upheaval, but I massively value all the positive things and yes, am happier for them. So I guess I would say - these things don't solve all your problems in life, and they take effort to build and maintain, but they give you a stronger foundation to cope with what life throws at you.

HairyScaryMonster · 03/07/2022 09:06

I have that list, although DH has health issues which means I do more around the house and with the kids and have to make plans with others to go out sometimes.

Sswhinesthebest · 03/07/2022 09:04

Yes I do. I am very content with my lot in life. I appreciate what I have. Dh has the good job which has enabled me to work part time in a job I enjoy but doesn’t use my qualifications. I don’t have the stress of my previous career. I had many years as a sahm.

Dh has all on your list too, except he works more hours. He isn’t so content. He compares himself and our lifestyle to that of our siblings and feels he should be in a better career position. I feel proud of him that he has got as far as he has career wise and enabled the lifestyle that we have. He doesn’t see this. He doesn’t resent me, but feels he hasn’t progressed as far as he should. Me working more wouldn’t change his frustrations.

I feel the difference between us is ambition, comparison to others and time to ourselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread