Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is wrong to smoke and breastfeed?

84 replies

Solesister · 02/07/2022 14:42

My friend thinks this is ok and I really really don’t! Surely the toxins get into the milk?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
girlfriend44 · 11/07/2022 21:00

It's disgusting to smoke full stop breastfeeding or not.

ivorthengine · 11/07/2022 20:46

at the same time?

Definitely

MolliciousIntent · 11/07/2022 15:09

Honestly I'm not surprised that someone stupid enough to smoke is also stupid enough to believe that breastfeeding means it's OK to smoke with a baby

Dogtooth · 11/07/2022 15:08

You're absolutely right OP, that's why all handmaids should be transported to health camps as soon as they're impregnated

Samsnite · 11/07/2022 15:01

Her baby is also terribly colicky and unsettled, constant chest infections etc but she still doesn’t question it?

Hugasauras · 11/07/2022 14:59

Yep every source I've read says it's better to breastfeed and smoke than to smoke and formula feed. Obviously ideally no one would smoke when they have a baby at all, but if the smoking is going to happen regardless then it seems breastfeeding is still preferable.

The thinking that 'If I breastfeed then it's perfectly safe/fine to smoke' is warped though.

OdeToSadDisco · 11/07/2022 14:58

Of course it goes without saying that it's far better not to smoke, but the science says it's better for a smoking mother to beeastfeed than formula feed.

Samsnite · 11/07/2022 14:58

She intended to formula feed initially but felt ‘too guilty’ 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

MolliciousIntent · 11/07/2022 14:55

Solesister · 11/07/2022 14:54

I am not saying I am the perfect parent, I am saying my friend thinks it is ok to smoke just because she breastfeeds which I completely disagree with.

Yeah she's absolutely wrong. But she shouldn't stop breastfeeding.

Solesister · 11/07/2022 14:54

I am not saying I am the perfect parent, I am saying my friend thinks it is ok to smoke just because she breastfeeds which I completely disagree with.

OP posts:
ihavenocats · 11/07/2022 14:43

lyns86x · 02/07/2022 14:50

Hmmm surely it's not better to breast feed if you're a smoker? Not just because of what gets into the milk but also because of the smell on your skin and hair etc with the baby very close to you.
Surely it would be better to formula feed if you're a smoker!?

No, breastmilk is always better than formula. Formula does not convey immunity, line the gut properly, prime the immune system, it's not a tailor made nutrition source for the baby.

MolliciousIntent · 11/07/2022 14:19

lyns86x · 02/07/2022 14:50

Hmmm surely it's not better to breast feed if you're a smoker? Not just because of what gets into the milk but also because of the smell on your skin and hair etc with the baby very close to you.
Surely it would be better to formula feed if you're a smoker!?

No, not at all, because living with a smoker increases the chance of a baby dying from SIDS, and so does not breastfeeding. So if you smoke, breastfeeding helps to mitigate the increased SIDS risk. It's utterly grim though, and I would 100% judge anyone who couldn't put their baby's wellbeing over their need for a fag.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 11/07/2022 14:16

roarfeckingroarr · 02/07/2022 14:59

Surely some things are worthy of judgment. If you have a baby, the very least you can do is stop ingesting toxic chemicals while you grow and feed it?

There might be lots of things worthy of judgement but, unless you're actually a judge and perfect, that judgement is rather impotent.

What do you do to judge, out of interest?

Do you tut?

Give a hard Paddington Bear stare?

Talk loudly about transgressing person to anybody who will listen?

Approach errant individual and correct them in no uncertain terms?
Go on a march?
Declare it 'a hill to die on' (and once declared, no further action needed).
Find a chatboard to proclaim to that said activity has incurred your displeasure?

I actually am interest in the concept of judging because from what I've seen, it changes nothing.

10HailMarys · 11/07/2022 14:08

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

It's got nothing to do with moral judgements. It's got nothing to do with drinking the kool-aid. It's based on the scientific evidence; it's not an opinion. It is the absolute opposite of being 'through the looking-glass'. What do you want doctors to do? Not act on research? Lie to parents so they don't offend people who think any recommendation is a criticism of their choices?

I couldn't give a shit whether people formula-feed or breastfeed their kids. Obviously breastfeeding isn't going to be right for everyone, and that's fine. I don't think formula-feeding is evil. I wouldn't give it a second thought what someone feeds their kid. I don't have kids and I've no idea what my mum fed me on.

All that the advice is saying is that if someone wants to breastfeed, they don't have to stop doing it because they smoke, because the evidence suggests that the effect on the baby is so minuscule that it is outweighed by the benefits of breastfeeding.

It is not wrong to breastfeed you are a smoker. It not wrong to feed your child on formula milk either. It's not a competition. Neither is neglect. Get a grip.

TheKeatingFive · 11/07/2022 13:58

Let me say it loud and proud: any mother who smokes and breastfeeds her child has both well and truly drunk the koolaid and is wildly neglectful.

Did you not read the information posted from the nhs above?

Passthetena · 11/07/2022 13:55

Unfortunately smoking is an addiction. And like a pp said its so much easier to give up when the baby is growing inside you but as soon as they are here the cravings hit hard, combined with hormones that's how people end up smoking again with a small infant. Ive been there, my ppa was awful and smoking was a brief 5 minutes of normality (i also formula fed due to my milk not coming in...gasp!). As long as they follow the guidelines for doing it as safely as possible (no touching baby for 30 mins after, change clothes, wash hands and brush teeth) and aren't smoking around the baby then let them have the coping mechanism they need! FWIW I've since given up completely and thanks to comments like some on here I feel like that period of my life is something to be deeply ashamed of despite the fact that without it my anxiety could have been quite considerably worse. Luckily my health visitor and the professionals and loved ones around me were a lot more understanding than some people on here.

JoieDeLivres · 11/07/2022 13:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Alopeciabop · 11/07/2022 13:47

How can people even turn this into a pro breastfeeding lets slag off formula thread? Enough already. I’ve never once heard someone complain that their life was ruined by their parents giving them formula (that literally life-saving drink) so please just give it a break. This is a thread about smoking. And no, it isn’t ok to smoke when you have a baby. In fact it isn’t ok to smoke at all. It’s bad for you. We all know this.

KevinTheKoala · 11/07/2022 13:45

Wow some of the responses on here are just nasty. Personally I think it's better that children grows up with a parent who can admit that they are not perfect than a parent who is openly vile about other people who might be having a really hard time. What was the point of even starting this thread? We all know it's better not to smoke, under ideal circumstances nobody would - but the world isn't ideal and everyone makes bad decisions in one way or another, there's no need to be so openly vicious towards others.

10HailMarys · 11/07/2022 13:44

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

@JoieDeLivres This is what the NHS has to say:

Don't stop breastfeeding if you smoke

As a new mum, not smoking is also the single most important thing you can do to protect your own health. However, if you're finding it hard to quit smoking, it's important not to stop breastfeeding. Breastfeeding will still protect your baby from infections and provide nutrients they can't get from formula milk.

So both the posters you're mocking are, in fact, totally correct and there is a ton of research to back up what they're saying.

riesenrad · 11/07/2022 13:41

Is it wrong to be overweight when you have young children who depend on you? Wrong to do dangerous things such as cycling in big cities in case you get knocked off your bike? Wrong to eat junk and not get your five a day

All of those can creep up on you, you don't make a decision one day to get fat in the same way that you make a decision one day to smoke.

As for cycling, any accident is not your fault, that's the fault of moronic drivers who think they own the road. The only exception being if you decide to cycle up the inside of lorries or buses, I hope you don't!

LemonPledge555 · 11/07/2022 13:39

@MrsAvocet thanks - I came on to post the same link 👍🏻

riesenrad · 11/07/2022 13:39

roarfeckingroarr · 02/07/2022 14:54

Yeah it's disgusting, almost as bad as smoking while pregnant.

I agree. And why on earth would you be smoking while breastfeeding anyway. Surely everyone stops smoking when pregnant?

Actually I am surprised any woman who smokes gets to the stage of having sex, given her breath will stink and you look 50 at 30 due to leathery skin. I suppose if your partner also smokes he won't care. Poor baby with two stupid parents. And yes I am being judgey. I can not understand why anyone younger than me would have even started smoking.

JoieDeLivres · 11/07/2022 13:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Firesidefox · 11/07/2022 13:31

Ideally no, you wouldn't, but where do you draw the line? Is it wrong to be overweight when you have young children who depend on you? Wrong to do dangerous things such as cycling in big cities in case you get knocked off your bike? Wrong to eat junk and not get your five a day?

It's a difficult one. I am very much in favour of personal responsibility, and against the idea of a nanny state.

NB I do not smoke, am not overweight and do eat a lot of fruit and veg. I do, however, cycle to work in central London, which some people could consider irresponsible given I have three children.