Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does anyone else feel sorry for Prison Officers?

114 replies

girlfriend44 · 02/07/2022 14:22

Honestly what a horrible job, could you do it? Imagine having to deal with all these child murderers etc on a daily basis and probably call them by their first names etc?

Working with the dregs of society day in. day out, I couldnt, hats off to them. How do you keep it together knowing that they have starved, beaten, and abused a child etc?

OP posts:
Americano75 · 02/07/2022 18:04

'Dregs of society'?

You've not got a bloody clue OP.

Louiselady500 · 02/07/2022 17:32

49% of children that have been in care end up in the prison system.

39% of the prison population have suffered childhood abuse.

If Logan Mowangi had managed to survive his abusive and horrific childhood but then himself became a murderer or child abuser would you still be calling him ‘the dregs of society’ or would you feel that society had completely failed him and is to blame for the eventual outcome.

dustandroses · 02/07/2022 17:28

Well said @anybloodyname

dustandroses · 02/07/2022 17:26

@Devotedcatslave prisons have always ran on the goodwill of the prisoners. It doesn’t matter how many staff you have, if you unlock over 800 prisoners in one go. B

The Strangeways riot (and others) demonstrated that.

Having good interpersonal skills can look like friendliness from the outside.

anybloodyname · 02/07/2022 17:25

I'm a nurse, have worked in a prison setting alongside many prison officers

Some of them love it , cope well and become respected trusted and good role models

Some of them are absolute pricks and enjoy the control

Some of them are not cut out for it at all

Same in forensics and general nursing where most large centres will see a custodial patient at some point - you get used to the personal feelings and become quite closed off to it

I've met some Cat A prisoners that you would not believe for one second what they are capable of - pleasant , polite , educated , articulate, presentable - but you would never ever allow them within an inch of your family

georgarina · 02/07/2022 17:12

(WC kept his head down)

georgarina · 02/07/2022 17:12

girlfriend44 · 02/07/2022 15:27

I could not deal with murdering scumbags and people who kill and abuse children.

For example
Star Hobson
Logan Mwangi
Baby P
Arthur.

Imagine having to deal with them on a daily basis. Thanks to those that do.

Yep he did intake for Wayne Couzens. Said he just kept his head down and refused to speak the entire time. But said at least he's where he deserves to be.

Devotedcatslave · 02/07/2022 17:12

I feel sorry for them. It is a tough job with insufficient training and crap pay. I can see why they appear over friendly with the prisoners, because there are so few of them they rely on prisoners goodwill to keep them and other inmates safe. I wouldn't work in a prison for all the money in the world.

katscamel · 02/07/2022 17:09

I used to work in a prison though in Education not an officer. I didn't officially know what my students were in for unless they told me and even if it was for something pretty horrendous just treated them like any student anywhere else.

aweegc · 02/07/2022 16:40

And prison officer training in Norway is 2 years vs about 2 weeks in Scotland (from memory).

ShirleyJackson · 02/07/2022 16:40

It’s funny this thread has come up. I live not far from a massive Category A prison, and the other day I drove past an officer standing at the bus stop waiting to go home. He was only a young fella, and he looked absolutely knackered.

I remarked to DH that I didn’t envy him his job. DH just shuddered. He used to be a Police Officer, and says the only time he was ever scared was when he went into prisons - not because of the inmates. He reckons they’re just horrible, smelly, miserable, desperate places.

aweegc · 02/07/2022 16:39

Worth looking at Fritzi Horstman's work with prisoners.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=FVxjuTkWQiE

Stats also show that prison officers have similar rates of childhood trauma to inmates. They also show that the average age of death for career prison officers is 2 years after retirement. It's a very tough job, but the system is set up in a way that actually benefits nobody, us included. For it to benefit us, prisoners would need to be reformed upon release and the majority have spent their time inside being further traumatised and basically made less socially able to fit in.

I'm personally not in any rush to defend child abusers and killers but the idea that every prisoner is scum and the dregs of society is nonsense. I'd say many of them did what could only have been expected after the horrors of their childhoods. A bad childhood isn't an excuse, but it does underlie many of the mental health problems these guys have.

Worth noting too that when they have therapy in prison - if it's available and they want to - it's not actually confidential. Imagine having therapy and your boss could find out what you've been saying and some colleagues could see you're in a session or going to one and when you exit that room after therapy you're immediately in a hostile environment. So basically they're screwed. The system doesn't work.

Check out what they do in Norway if you want to know a system that works better for everybody.

AliMonkey · 02/07/2022 16:36

I'm not sure I feel sorry for them, given they chose the job, but I am very grateful to them. I imagine it's like many jobs, there's lots of bits that aren't much fun, but I also think that there will be some prisoners who the prison officers know they have helped to turn their lives around when in prison so I can see there would be job satisfaction from that, as well as knowing that you are keeping many dangerous people from being free to commit crimes again.

dustandroses · 02/07/2022 16:36

@IfIhearmumagaintoday it is like a day out for them ☺️

StoneofDestiny · 02/07/2022 16:35

Yes I do. In the highest category prisons they face assault daily, yet are also expected to be councillors, advisors, therapists and have eyes in the back of their heads. Many of those in prison are from extremely challenging backgrounds that have given them no proper parenting. Many are suffering from mental health issues and have very low IQ's. Prison officers have to keep them safe as well as themselves safe - and be vigilant to ensure there are no suicides.

Yes - 'they chose the job' but many are doing it rather than be unemployed. There is shockingly low retention rates. Besides - it's not whether they 'chose it', it's the fact we need people to do it. The officers are doing the dirty work for us - keeping those people off the street we don't think should be out here with us. Prison officers have to treat these people like human beings - that's what they are. Many won't even know what crime the prisoners is in for.

I couldn't do the job - I'm very glad someone is doing it. I do think they should be paid more - and so should the police.

HRTQueen · 02/07/2022 16:35

I feel sorry for the those that are overworked abs had their safety compromised or have not been supported what targeted by a prisoner

some are absolutely great but have met those that love the power trip I think these people tend to be found out quite soon now

maddening · 02/07/2022 16:33

Crankley
"They have chosen to do the job. They weren't pressganged into it so no, I don't"

Feel sorry for is maybe the wrong question though - yes they chose the job but it is possible to appreciate that they chose a tough job that many of us would not do, like hard manual workers, nurses, people that work in tough or really unpleasant environments, people that have to dedicate a lot of time to build skills and knowledge etc etc

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 02/07/2022 16:32

@Squareflair I agree with you. The saying you choose the job is silly what does that mean? Young people often change fields and not just that many of us even on this thread wouldn't like to do each others jobs.

Nutsabouttopic · 02/07/2022 16:25

@dustandroses my father and my brother have very interesting conversations alright. As my father says hes reared whole families through the system. Prisoners now are more drug related or gangland compared to my fathers time. My brother earns a very good wage but he works a lot of overtime

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 02/07/2022 16:24

mortalprojections · 02/07/2022 14:57

In my own career (nhs hospital setting) I have quite a lot of interaction on the daily with Prison officers. They are often extremely rude to staff, unprofessional and either best mates with the prisoner or go out of their way to humiliate them. This is not a blanket observation but a majority. I'm sure it is a thankless job but no I don't pity them. Do you feel sorry for anyone else who has chosen a job in law enforcement or criminal justice?

So glad you have written this. I don't know what OP means by dregs of society. You surely meet all types of people including professionals too or don't they include dregs OP.

I'm in a hospital setting too I have never had an office be rude to me personally but they definitely toss it off, think its a laugh with the prisoner themselves and it's unprofessional. I've also known the officers to go to sleep...ask for tea and coffee like it's a day out for them all.

Your probably unaware of what an officers role entails OP.

Longmoorlane · 02/07/2022 16:19

When did you do the role @dustandroses , out of interest?

Fifi0102 · 02/07/2022 16:19

girlfriend44 · 02/07/2022 16:04

could you happily deal with people like Ian Huntley everyday though,

i could not and would not be wanting to have a laugh with him at all.

Not Ian Huntley level but yes I've dealt with murderers and child sex offenders. It's a job and you have to be professional. If you treat someone horribly how can you build a therapeutic relationship ? Of course they are some vile people I've had someone threatening to rape me and try to attack me but I still act professional. I don't like what they have done but I recognise they are a real person with their own likes/dislikes personality traits, they aren't just their offence. Forensic services believe in recovery and rehabilitation even if they will never leave prison or hospital.

If you think about all the horrible things people do all the time, you wouldn't be able to do the job.

dustandroses · 02/07/2022 16:16

@Nutsabouttopic My experience very much resonates with your DF I reckon it would be an interesting eye opener for him and your brother to discuss how different it is now. In your DFs day I expect he worked 30 years for a 40 year pension as the last 10 we got 2 for 1, we were well rewarded financially. Not so much these days.

girlfriend44 · 02/07/2022 16:04

Fifi0102 · 02/07/2022 15:50

I work within forensic services with some child sex offenders and murderers. Of course the index offence is at the back of your mind for risk assessment but no I don't find it horrendous anymore or take it home with me. Some people do horrendous things but that isn't their entire personality some can be quite funny and outgoing. You separate the person from their offences whilst also being aware of it.

could you happily deal with people like Ian Huntley everyday though,

i could not and would not be wanting to have a laugh with him at all.

OP posts:
Nutsabouttopic · 02/07/2022 16:01

I grew up the child of a prison officer. We had a good life because my father earned very good money by working a lot of overtime. We were very comfortable but my father did not drink or go to the club, his friends were the same. We, the children, are still friends now as adults. There were times my fathers life was in danger but we didn't realise at the time. He was threatened on many occasions by drug lords and in riots. He is a compassionate man. He told us you can hate the crime but not the person, he was there to do a job he was not judge or jury. That saying when I as a teenager was out one night and some guy came over to talk to me and told me to tell my father that xxxxx said to say hello I saw a different side of him. Police were involved rapidly and some on the inside sent a warning to this man. Overall my father was happy in his job, served thirty years, made great friends and money which we benefited from. My brother is now a serving officer as are many former officers children