Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

my landlord’s unable to absorb cost of living increase

319 replies

originstory · 02/07/2022 12:31

so he’s raising my rent during a 1 year contract. AIBU to refuse?

I got a letter from landlord saying my rent is going up by 5% (£40). he explains that he’s no longer able to continue absorbing rising costs so has to pass it onto his tenants. regrets having to do this, feels forced into it by circumstances beyond his control etc. if I had a rolling month to month contract, fair enough, I’ve had rent increases in previous properties which is just what happens. but I signed a 1 year contract in February so didn’t think he could raise the rent during that contract? my googling appears to back me up but maybe someone will tell me I’m wrong. however, I’m considering just sucking it up for an easier life. AIBU to dispute this?

reasons to dispute it:

  • I have a contract until Feb 2023 so I feel he’s being cheeky to increase rent during it. Obviously it will increase when that ends and converts to a month to month rolling contract, which is fine.
  • The cost of living increase is hitting ALL of us (and will continue to get worse) and I must admit I have less sympathy for a landlord who owns multiple properties than I do his tenants
  • I don’t have a high income (at all) due to reduced capacity for work due to a chronic illness, which he knows. in fact it’s so low that I started claiming UC for the first time last year, so I resent paying him an extra £40 a month that could go towards my gas bill or food shopping

reasons to just agree:

  • he’s a good landlord, sorts repairs and problems promptly and reasonably
  • he’s correct in that he’ll be paying more for hallway lighting etc
  • he’s a nice man so I’d feel bad saying ‘i’m not giving you more money, too bad’
  • 5% is a very reasonable increase so it seems stupid to cause problems over it. If it was more I’d have less of an issue saying no
  • I felt lucky to find a landlord to rent to me in the first place due to my low income/ being on UC so it would be stupid to sour our relationship over £40
  • If I refused to pay I’d be wondering if he’s going to get rid of me when the contract is up because I ‘caused trouble’ and then I’d be back in the position of not knowing if I can find anyone willing to rent to me. i had several agencies refuse to let me even view properties as I’m on UC (illegal but it still happens)
  • honestly, I don’t like confrontation and it’s simply easier to just agree

AIBU to dispute this?

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 14:18

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 13:53

So I would say the debt fuelled madness has been going on for at least 23 years minimum.
Most of these so called idiots that you have no sympathy for are ordinary hard-working people. There is enormous potential for the very people that you think you want to help to get caught in the crossfire of all this i.e. the ones whose income was never enough to even cover their rent or bills.

be careful what you wish for because at the moment the whole deck of cards is being held up by Debt and if that supply is cut off as we saw in 2008 the people who will suffer the absolute most are the very poorest in society. Luckily in 2008 there was still a bit of a cushion, that’s gone now. You’d have to be a bit of a cunt to wish their lives to get worse in order to financially gain yourself.

I'll take your last line and repeat it back to you - that you would have to be a bit of a c**t not to want a better, more sustainable economic model for future generations. The current one is working rather poorly for anyone who hasn't loaded up on debt or already has assets. Largely by thanks to their date of birth.

Massive amounts of disenfranchisement to come if this continues.

It's not about me benefitting - I'm fine, thanks.

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 13:53

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 12:57

Eh?

If someone - whoever - has been borrowing lots of money and gets margin called because zero interest rate policy can't last forever - that is their problem!!!

Cash savers and people who have tried not to borrow excessively or participate in this debt fuelled madness have been fucked over for 14 years. I will not shed one tear for anyone in debt.

So I would say the debt fuelled madness has been going on for at least 23 years minimum.
Most of these so called idiots that you have no sympathy for are ordinary hard-working people. There is enormous potential for the very people that you think you want to help to get caught in the crossfire of all this i.e. the ones whose income was never enough to even cover their rent or bills.

be careful what you wish for because at the moment the whole deck of cards is being held up by Debt and if that supply is cut off as we saw in 2008 the people who will suffer the absolute most are the very poorest in society. Luckily in 2008 there was still a bit of a cushion, that’s gone now. You’d have to be a bit of a cunt to wish their lives to get worse in order to financially gain yourself.

badgermushrooms · 03/07/2022 13:16

Loics · 02/07/2022 13:55

I don't think it was you OP, but people failing to see how landlords have rising costs and demonising them for increasing rent costs.
We won't be increasing rent on any of our properties as rising costs aren't really affecting us, but many landlords have one property to eventually make some money for retirement, some have inherited a property and are trying to supplement income... They will be paying more for their fuel, energy, food, etc. too. Mortgages will be more expensive when fixed terms run out, I think it's reasonable to expect a fair rent but not reasonable to expect rent to stay the same for a long time when everything else is going up.

Ok, so they've made a big investment and it hasn't worked out. They'll have to sell up and try something else, like any other person who chooses to invest their excess capital in the hope of increasing it. Why are we supposed to feel more sympathy for a landlord than for someone who bought shares in Google? You can't pick and choose the bits of capitalism that suit you - you have to accept the risks as well as the rewards.

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 12:59

(debt that has been taken on willingly and without looking at the consequence of rate rises that is)

anyone in debt because the cost of living means their income is less than their essential expenses and they've had to borrow from predatory lenders has my full sympathy.

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 12:57

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 08:36

Simultaneously they had (hopefully) a last hurrah of asset prices rises; and now I'm praying reality bites for everyone who's been getting high on cheap money.
Thats lots of working parents on this site @SwanBuster
Taking their assets and putting them into the hands of landlords with cash and corporations sounds a spectacular plan, said nobody ever.

Eh?

If someone - whoever - has been borrowing lots of money and gets margin called because zero interest rate policy can't last forever - that is their problem!!!

Cash savers and people who have tried not to borrow excessively or participate in this debt fuelled madness have been fucked over for 14 years. I will not shed one tear for anyone in debt.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 03/07/2022 11:19

Hintofreality · 02/07/2022 12:38

Like many, many others my mortgage payment has increased. Shall I just refuse to pay that as well?

If it was illegal for them to raise it, yes I would

Xenia · 03/07/2022 11:11

Comparing with the past can be hard. In 1900 90% of people rented from private landlords (did not own any property). After the war my parents put off babies for TEN years as they needed 2 full time professional wages to buy their house in the NE of England in which they lived for 50 years and that was very hard as my father kept being called up for national service and let down so no one would hire him even as a doctor for a few years. Women could not easily get mortgages in their own names as everyone expected them to leave work and have babies. There was then massive inflation in the 1970s (60% over 3 years at one point) so not an easy time for many and I definitely remember there were council house waiting lists, films like Cathy come home, lack of housing etc etc.

Then we had 1982 when I graduated - a blood bath - 3m out of work, biggest unemployment in the UK for FIFTY years. I applied for 139 jobs and had 25 interviews before getting one during the last year of my degree. Again like my parents we needed two full time professional salaries and to buy before babies to be able to afford our first house bought in 1984 which had to be out here in zone 5 outer London as inner London then and now was far too expensive. It was so hard to buy as London was so expensive my husband's school offered flats to teachers and nurses lives in nurses homes etc. We lived in one school flat and I had a mattress on the floor when pregnant but were able to buy just before I gave bith. I worked until I was in labour and went back at 2 weeks full time. I am just not convinced times are harder now. Also when I came to London in 1983 it was hard to find places to rent as the rent acts had meant no l;andlords who were decent would let out a property as the rents could be fixed for life at £10 a year etc. So my first place as a trainee lawyer in London was one room with a sink and a hob (bed sit) and a dirty shower down the corridor everyone shared for the first term until my husband joined me and we moved to the school flat.

dianthus101 · 03/07/2022 09:17

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 00:23

It was not easy to buy a house in the seventies as there were very strict mortgage rules. You needed references, a history of saving with the relevant bank, and low multiples of wages. But if you had a steady permanent job, then prices were still less.
Early seventies there was still slum clearance happening with some still living in places with no bathroom. But there was a lot of council house building which meant if you were prepared to move, you could get a house much more easily.

I didn't say it was easy in the 70s. I said that it was much easier than today. My parents bought their first house in their early 20s as new graduates.

Ballcactus · 03/07/2022 09:04

Adelishious · 02/07/2022 14:49

Pay it. LL is asking for very reasonable increase in line with increased costs of living to all. I know some have suggested asking that you ask LL to show you a breakdown of cost, but my lord, landlords, especially with mortgage are barely breaking even as it is and if if he feels he needs more money then he needs more money. I don't think many tenants realise that the prices of rent compared to bought prices is actually very reasonable atm. £40 isn't a large increase. When you consider that the landlord is trusting to look after an asset of theirs often worth hundreds of thousands of pounds I think more tenants should be grateful someone has a home for you to rent. A £100,000 ferrari costs around £1000 per day to rent with a £5000 upfront deposit and people pay it. Yabu, pay with thanks!

This comment is hilarious. If he feels he needs more money he needs more money… what the actual fuck? If the landlord cannot cope with people living in their asset it’s the wrong job for them and they need to sell. And you need your head screwing on.

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 08:36

Simultaneously they had (hopefully) a last hurrah of asset prices rises; and now I'm praying reality bites for everyone who's been getting high on cheap money.
Thats lots of working parents on this site @SwanBuster
Taking their assets and putting them into the hands of landlords with cash and corporations sounds a spectacular plan, said nobody ever.

Zebedee55 · 03/07/2022 08:15

Legally, you can fight it. Realistically, I'd pay it - but try to get an agreement that he doesn't increase again next February.

Rents, social or private, can be increased at the rate of inflation, and are forecast to go up by at least 10% next year. So, if you don't have another increase in February, you might actually save on it.

Interest rates are expected to keep going upwards, which will affect many mortgages/landlords.

Decent private rentals, if on benefits, are becoming harder and harder to get. Social housing is virtually non-existent unless you are a very high priority.

The abolition of the S21 seems to be following the path that most other government promises go down - big announcement, then it gets kicked into the long grass.🙄

So, unfair as it is, in your circumstances, I'd suck it up - but try to ensure no further increases next year.

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 00:24

Mid to late seventies is when council housing got much easier to get.
Private housing standards though were often very low.

antelopevalley · 03/07/2022 00:23

It was not easy to buy a house in the seventies as there were very strict mortgage rules. You needed references, a history of saving with the relevant bank, and low multiples of wages. But if you had a steady permanent job, then prices were still less.
Early seventies there was still slum clearance happening with some still living in places with no bathroom. But there was a lot of council house building which meant if you were prepared to move, you could get a house much more easily.

dianthus101 · 02/07/2022 23:58

Lineala · 02/07/2022 19:11

No there wasn't. There was council housing, but it was not freely available, there was still a list and a very long wait. The PRS was very poor because the Rent Acts put landlords off, because they made it very difficult to both evict and or increase the rent. At the end of the 70s the Rent Acts were abolished and the Assured Tenancy introduced, and then the Assured Shorthold Tenancy in if I remember, the early 80s. So the housing market at that time was dire, as it is now. And, there was a huge amount of very poor slum housing owned by large corporations and slum landlords with very little help for the tenant in those circumstances. Things are very much better now, for both the tenant and the landlord, although the market is becoming skewed again due to changes in Housing Law that are coming and those already recently passed to make rental properties scarce.

I've never heard anybody suggest that housing is easier now than it was in the 70s. Everyone I knew lived in a council house in the 70s. I didn't hear of anyone being on a long waiting list for one as there were many more than there are today. It was much easier to buy a house as well.

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 23:49

The clear and present danger now is that markets might decide that the dubious attractions of Sterling are far outweighed by the risks. A “Sterling crisis” would force the Bank of England into raising rates, crashing the property market to which the economy is, increasingly, an adjunct.

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 23:39

Yeah, I think the effects of QT and rate rises will be very interesting. The Fed are being far more aggressive than the bank of england thus far. If there continues to be a difference between their behaviours, then sterling is even more toast than it has been already. Maybe that's what the BOE / gov wants. They want the debt inflated away. They don't care if a loaf of bread rises to £4....

Inflation will be out of control if sterling tanks but perhaps the government is engineering that so that their debts will be inflated away.

Given it's a global economy though, I'm not sure how much control our government will have over what happens next.

SwanBuster · 02/07/2022 23:13

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 21:40

@SwanBuster

Agreed HTB and SD freeze increased asset (house prices). Other countries did similar though, Australia in particular. It really has been a global frenzy. It isn't just landlords who have been affected by this though, it's everyone who has bought it sold a property.

I still think this Tory government have come down harder than any other government on landlords. My reasons are already mentioned.

Out of interest, what do you think is coming next? I think QT and interest rate rises mean that all those who used debt to invest in housing are likely in trouble.

100% agree it's not just been UK.

I think this 'tough on landlords' stuff i think has been a signal to the smarter ones to get out.

Simultaneously they had (hopefully) a last hurrah of asset prices rises; and now I'm praying reality bites for everyone who's been getting high on cheap money.

Yeah, I think the effects of QT and rate rises will be very interesting. The Fed are being far more aggressive than the bank of england thus far. If there continues to be a difference between their behaviours, then sterling is even more toast than it has been already. Maybe that's what the BOE / gov wants. They want the debt inflated away. They don't care if a loaf of bread rises to £4....

Anyway - all I hope for is some kind of proper reset. They had the chance in 2008 worldwide and didn't. Now we have had 14 years of even more disenfranchisement for the global youth. I think it's time the scales were tipped the other way. Otherwise big trouble ahead in many different ways - some peaceful but tragic (the lie flat movement where the youth say 'whats the point') and some not so likely to be so peaceful (more nationalism etc).

FOTB · 02/07/2022 21:51

If the LL is trying to put prices up during your contract, he's probably struggling. Which means that even if you pay the increase, he might still be struggling. So, I'd get ready for him to try to sell the property. It's usually easier to sell with vacant possession... which means an eviction notice for you in due course.

I'd be inclined to not pay the increase, but to squirrel away that £40 (plus whatever you can) for a deposit for a new place. You just know you're going to have to move on again soon. The question is when.

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 21:40

@SwanBuster

Agreed HTB and SD freeze increased asset (house prices). Other countries did similar though, Australia in particular. It really has been a global frenzy. It isn't just landlords who have been affected by this though, it's everyone who has bought it sold a property.

I still think this Tory government have come down harder than any other government on landlords. My reasons are already mentioned.

Out of interest, what do you think is coming next? I think QT and interest rate rises mean that all those who used debt to invest in housing are likely in trouble.

SwanBuster · 02/07/2022 21:26

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 19:29

@SwanBuster

The inflation of assets prices has been global but I do agree with you.

Tory Gov since 2010 - CGT on 2nd homes, removal of tax relief on mortgages, abolish letting fees, removal of section 21 no fault eviction, EPC regs.

Agreed - that's global ultra low rate central bank policy that's boosted asset prices, not just here.

For balance on what our gov have done though -

help to buy 2013 was a total charade that should have been labelled help to sell, and almost instantly put 20% on the price of housing.

Then we had the recent stamp duty holiday - now, stamp duty is a stupid tax, but any tinkering causes stupid behaviour by the public. The one thing stamp duty does is it has to be paid in cash - you can't borrow for it so by lowering it and allowing people to put more down - up went prices.

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 21:16

Eeksteek · 02/07/2022 21:10

That is a fair point, so I shall bow out and sell up. Clearly landlord=bastard, no matter what. I don’t know what renters will do, but given the animosity, I’m just relieved it won’t be my problem.

OP, I wish you luck. I hope you find a solution and I hope your landlord doesn’t sell.

The thread really hasn't gone your way, has it.

Eeksteek · 02/07/2022 21:10

That is a fair point, so I shall bow out and sell up. Clearly landlord=bastard, no matter what. I don’t know what renters will do, but given the animosity, I’m just relieved it won’t be my problem.

OP, I wish you luck. I hope you find a solution and I hope your landlord doesn’t sell.

originstory · 02/07/2022 21:08

ps thank you for all the replies and helpful advice Smile

OP posts:
originstory · 02/07/2022 21:07

re posters saying ‘if you want to stay long term you should pay the increase’, I agree somewhat, hence my post. i actually don’t love this property (in fact there are things I hate about it) and would never have taken it if I’d been a more ‘attractive’ tenant with my pick of the market. I’m not desperate to stay on at the end of the tenancy BUT the fact that I’m a pretty financially shit tenant means I was delighted to find a landlord that understood my position and was still willing to rent to me. i snapped his hand off taking this property and felt so lucky to get it and although I sometimes come home and think ‘I really don’t like my home’, at least it’s a place of my own, rather than a cheaper flat share. In an ideal world I’d move to a much nicer place but clearly I’m
not in an ideal position as a tenant hence being worried about losing this place by rocking the boat. I don’t love it but I also don’t hate it in the same way I’d hate a flat share situation. Which is telling me I should just suck up the rent increase. Landlord has read my message but no reply so far

OP posts:
daisychain01 · 02/07/2022 20:40

amoosee · 02/07/2022 17:33

Woop woop, its the sound of the thread police.

No it's the sound of some one who recognises a bit of courtesy of not derailing @originstory 's thread with detritus about landlords and whose posts are clogging up this thread and mouthing off while contributing bugger-all to actually assisting and supporting @originstory Your ignorance just shows you up.