Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

my landlord’s unable to absorb cost of living increase

319 replies

originstory · 02/07/2022 12:31

so he’s raising my rent during a 1 year contract. AIBU to refuse?

I got a letter from landlord saying my rent is going up by 5% (£40). he explains that he’s no longer able to continue absorbing rising costs so has to pass it onto his tenants. regrets having to do this, feels forced into it by circumstances beyond his control etc. if I had a rolling month to month contract, fair enough, I’ve had rent increases in previous properties which is just what happens. but I signed a 1 year contract in February so didn’t think he could raise the rent during that contract? my googling appears to back me up but maybe someone will tell me I’m wrong. however, I’m considering just sucking it up for an easier life. AIBU to dispute this?

reasons to dispute it:

  • I have a contract until Feb 2023 so I feel he’s being cheeky to increase rent during it. Obviously it will increase when that ends and converts to a month to month rolling contract, which is fine.
  • The cost of living increase is hitting ALL of us (and will continue to get worse) and I must admit I have less sympathy for a landlord who owns multiple properties than I do his tenants
  • I don’t have a high income (at all) due to reduced capacity for work due to a chronic illness, which he knows. in fact it’s so low that I started claiming UC for the first time last year, so I resent paying him an extra £40 a month that could go towards my gas bill or food shopping

reasons to just agree:

  • he’s a good landlord, sorts repairs and problems promptly and reasonably
  • he’s correct in that he’ll be paying more for hallway lighting etc
  • he’s a nice man so I’d feel bad saying ‘i’m not giving you more money, too bad’
  • 5% is a very reasonable increase so it seems stupid to cause problems over it. If it was more I’d have less of an issue saying no
  • I felt lucky to find a landlord to rent to me in the first place due to my low income/ being on UC so it would be stupid to sour our relationship over £40
  • If I refused to pay I’d be wondering if he’s going to get rid of me when the contract is up because I ‘caused trouble’ and then I’d be back in the position of not knowing if I can find anyone willing to rent to me. i had several agencies refuse to let me even view properties as I’m on UC (illegal but it still happens)
  • honestly, I don’t like confrontation and it’s simply easier to just agree

AIBU to dispute this?

OP posts:
dianthus101 · 04/07/2022 11:47

Nothappyatwork · 04/07/2022 11:20

It’s actually highly unlikely because the conditions under which landlords would sell would mean the lending is tightened to the point where the last people who could afford the house is a first-time buyers.

it really is a case of be careful what you wish for if you’re supposedly a socialist because wanting the big bad Landlord‘s to fail will mean the conditions have to be created which would mean a far higher percentage of ordinary people would also fail. Collateral damage if you like.

Lending criteria wouldn't get much stricter if house prices just dropped a bit or stabilised. The situation at the moment where rich people are buying properties in cash and house prices and rents are rising dramatically as a result leading to poverty is not a good one.

SofiaSoFar · 04/07/2022 11:43

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 11:06

There are plenty of buyers for any property that hits the market

There WERE plenty of buyers but not only has buyer demand dropped over the last month or two but lenders are now tightening up their lending criteria and offering smaller mortgages - adding to reduced buyer demand ie capping the amount they can pay.

There still ARE plenty of buyers.

Prices may soften a little but there are still people with money to spend. And as someone else has reiterated, slightly cheaper house prices don't automatically convert renters to buyers because not everyone renting is doing so just because house prices are 10% too high for them.

It's easy to foresee what will happen next because we've seen it happen in the opposite direction, too.

When the government introduced "help to buy" did that get more people on the ladder? No, it just (massively) increased the developers' profits.

If there are 10 houses for sale and of the 50 people who want to buy them, the 10 with the most money available can pay £250k, that's what they'll sell for.

Bringing in a scheme that now means 15 people have £250k to spend but now the top 10 have £275k just means that the houses will go for £275k.

If we get into a situation where available money softens by 10% it will only mean that the top 10 buyers still get the 10 available houses, but 10% cheaper.

The issue with the housing market isn't landlords owning too many, it's with the availability of homes full stop.

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 11:28

those who are paying cash for the property are most likely to be able to not pay tax on it.

Not sure what you mean? Stamp duty, council tax, tax on rental income?

Nothappyatwork · 04/07/2022 11:24

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 11:06

There are plenty of buyers for any property that hits the market

There WERE plenty of buyers but not only has buyer demand dropped over the last month or two but lenders are now tightening up their lending criteria and offering smaller mortgages - adding to reduced buyer demand ie capping the amount they can pay.

I was the only person have viewed the property that I bought recently that needed a mortgage the other 30 (that i saw - maybe more) were cash buyers. The agent had them all lined up outside and as people were coming out they were offering the asking price for cash.

I believe the market has cooled in some price brackets but the buy to let one most definitely has not and those who are paying cash for the property are most likely to be able to not pay tax on it.

Nothappyatwork · 04/07/2022 11:20

dianthus101 · 04/07/2022 11:17

It's quite possible that many renters will become buyers if house prices fall and become more affordable, which may happen if landlords start to sell.

It’s actually highly unlikely because the conditions under which landlords would sell would mean the lending is tightened to the point where the last people who could afford the house is a first-time buyers.

it really is a case of be careful what you wish for if you’re supposedly a socialist because wanting the big bad Landlord‘s to fail will mean the conditions have to be created which would mean a far higher percentage of ordinary people would also fail. Collateral damage if you like.

dianthus101 · 04/07/2022 11:17

SofiaSoFar · 04/07/2022 11:01

I foresee rents increasing massively over the next few years.

People will say, "they can't, because people won't be able to afford them", but the problem is going to be the number of LLs who give it up and sell.

There are plenty of buyers for any property that hits the market and most renters won't simply become buyers when the market becomes more liquid.

Rental properties will become much less prolific, ergo rents will go up.

Law of unintended consequences, and all that...

It's quite possible that many renters will become buyers if house prices fall and become more affordable, which may happen if landlords start to sell.

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 11:09

@Eeksteek

You haven't explained why you have been unable to remortgage at any point in the last 5 years? Is it because lenders see you as too high a risk? That would worry me given that both interest rates and cost of living are rising. You may be forced to sell over the next year or two.

FortonServices · 04/07/2022 11:06

There are plenty of buyers for any property that hits the market

There WERE plenty of buyers but not only has buyer demand dropped over the last month or two but lenders are now tightening up their lending criteria and offering smaller mortgages - adding to reduced buyer demand ie capping the amount they can pay.

SofiaSoFar · 04/07/2022 11:01

I foresee rents increasing massively over the next few years.

People will say, "they can't, because people won't be able to afford them", but the problem is going to be the number of LLs who give it up and sell.

There are plenty of buyers for any property that hits the market and most renters won't simply become buyers when the market becomes more liquid.

Rental properties will become much less prolific, ergo rents will go up.

Law of unintended consequences, and all that...

dianthus101 · 04/07/2022 10:42

@Eeksteek Of course landlords are people and I'm sure some are nice people. However, I think you need to recognise that there are too many and this has in part, led to high house prices which has meant a whole generation are finding it very difficult to buy a house now. In that context you can't really expect people to feel that you are doing them a favour by being a landlord. If you don't want to be a landlord anymore sell up and get an income by working like most people do.

Kennykenkencat · 04/07/2022 06:34

The one way to stop landlords making any money is to not rent from them.

If you really want to stick to your morals and can’t afford to buy and the council can’t give you a council house they actually own and haven’t leased off a private landlord then there is always the streets

I think people think that councils actually own all the properties they rent out.

People seem to complain about private landlords yet as soon as landlords remove their properties from the long term rental market then there are complaints that there are no properties to rent and the cost of those properties that are available rises as the demand outstrips supply

Coming to an end of our rental in a few months and really worried that I won’t have a house to live in.

I don’t care about how much a landlord makes as long as there are choices for me on the rental market that I can afford

Dexy007 · 04/07/2022 04:05

Really annoying but based on your list of reasons I would pay this. You’ll not easily find another landlord who will take you on on UC. As you said, don’t sour it.

Eeksteek · 04/07/2022 03:22

FortonServices · 02/07/2022 21:16

The thread really hasn't gone your way, has it.

There isn’t a ‘my way’. I was wanting to point out that a) landlords are people, and some are rolling-in-it-bastards and many are not and b) the landlord’s real life options. I also categorically stated I would not and have not ever raised rents in contract (any contract, even after a fixed term) even to ease my own difficulties. And I’m still a bastard, and a stupid one to boot. Can’t win, can I? I was called out repeatedly, and tried to respond and explain my circumstances, and then was called out for taking over a thread. I might as well just raise the rents. At least I’d be comfortable and reviled (as I meant to say before). All that scrimping and still everyone calls you a leeching bastard

Except I’m not. So I won’t. And you’ll still say I am.

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 21:34

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 21:32

Oh but i do give a shit about future generations, that belong to my family. Hence my kids aren’t so stupid to think they can ride out the markets, housing or otherwise 🙄

I know of people who have disowned their parents because they are landlords. Genuinely. I have the utmost respect for those people. I live people with morals and ethics about wider society in general. You are demonstrating zero .

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 21:32

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 21:21

And I think you're a piece of shit too, for not giving a fan about future generations.

Oh but i do give a shit about future generations, that belong to my family. Hence my kids aren’t so stupid to think they can ride out the markets, housing or otherwise 🙄

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 21:24

Oh and as far as 'plenty of equity' goes, leverage can be a real bitch, very fast. Good luck.

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 21:22

Should have said a damn

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 21:21

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 21:01

Lol
im far from panicking im very old, but still under 50, shed loads of equity. I have younger relatives who are loaded up though, having done nothing wrong, saved, bought finally last year and given people have described how theyd kill themselves on threads such as these if they lost their homes i think youre a piece of shit looking to hear them squeal.

The only people under 50 who’ll be getting one of my properties are the ones i gave birth to ☺️

And I think you're a piece of shit too, for not giving a fan about future generations.

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 21:01

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 18:55

No, I'm pretty young. Just sensible with money and earn a decent wedge.

But it sounds like you're loaded with debt, and panicking. I'd happily see people like you squeal yes, if under 50s who decided they wouldn't participate in the credit orgy get one of your repossessed buy to let's.

Lol
im far from panicking im very old, but still under 50, shed loads of equity. I have younger relatives who are loaded up though, having done nothing wrong, saved, bought finally last year and given people have described how theyd kill themselves on threads such as these if they lost their homes i think youre a piece of shit looking to hear them squeal.

The only people under 50 who’ll be getting one of my properties are the ones i gave birth to ☺️

SwanBuster · 03/07/2022 18:55

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 14:49

Well luckily for the generation of 35 to 50-year-olds that you would be happily throwing under a bus none of the parties seem to be able to think further than one election ahead and so the pyramid scheme will continue. With peaks and troughs of course but the reality of it is you can whinge about the debt as much as you like, it’s what makes the world go round.

If you’re “fine” I would suggest youre probably of an age where none of this is going to affect you and you won’t be around much longer to see it.

No, I'm pretty young. Just sensible with money and earn a decent wedge.

But it sounds like you're loaded with debt, and panicking. I'd happily see people like you squeal yes, if under 50s who decided they wouldn't participate in the credit orgy get one of your repossessed buy to let's.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/07/2022 17:31

@badgermushrooms I totally agree- having just moved back from Copenhagen one of the things in Denmark is that once Danes get to 25 I believe, they are allocated a flat. (They pay rent) a lot are new builds and nice too . That flat remains theirs, at social housing levels of rent. they can sub let it if they move in with someone etc. so when marriages go wrong etc there is usually a flat that can be moved back to - many use a spell of saving up to buy whilst in their subsidised flat.

Lineala · 03/07/2022 16:56

beastlyslumber · 02/07/2022 15:10

OP, the problem is that if you accept this rent increase, you have both broken your contract. There's nothing to stop him increasing the rent again in October, and again when your contract ends. I wouldn't want to take this risk. Your LL is showing that he's not trustworthy.

I understand why people are saying to absorb the increase for the sake of an easy life. But I think it's too much of a risk to take. I think it's better to politely decline.

Why don't you save the £40 each month and then when your contract is up in February, you'll have a little bit of a buffer for the rent increase that will come then - or to put towards a deposit if you decide to move out.

This is untrue. It is entirely possible, and is a frequent occurence that contracts can be varied by consent. In that sense tenancy agreements are no different to any other contract. So if you both consent, the new term takes effect as agreed, from the agreed date.

If Op does not agree to vary the contract the landlord cannot raise the rent and expect the tenant to make the increased payments because he cannot unilaterally change the terms of the contract and cannot force a change because it is within the fixed term. He can try, but it will not be upheld by a court, therefore he cannot enforce any attempt at unilaterally changing the contract.

If Op agrees this new term, then she is not agreeing to change it at a later date nor is she consenting to anything other than the new rent, so suggesting the landlord will increase the rent further during the fixed term is a moot point because of the points made above.

Generally speaking after a fixed term has expired the rent can be increased unilaterally using a s13, providing it has been properly notified with the correct notice period. I say generally because if the tenancy agreement rolls over after the end of the fixed term to a contractual periodic tenancy then the landlord is still bound by the terms in the contract and must follow the rent increase procedure in that contract, unless the tenant agrees to vary it. If it is a statutory periodic tenancy then the s13 procedure is used if the landlord and tenant cannot agree a variation of the rent and so it can be unilateral.

I hope that clears things up as to the legal position.

badgermushrooms · 03/07/2022 16:14

@Crikeyalmighty Yes absolutely we need to build, on a massive scale. Otherwise everything else - getting rid of section 21 evictions, these ridiculous 50 year multigenerational mortgages - is just tinkering around the edges. The most depressing thing about this thread is that the OP's landlord is entirely in the wrong both legally and morally and yet she's probably going to have to let him get away with it as her other options are so lacking.

Those of us who have managed to buy are just going to have to accept an end to property values automatically going up with time. If we want a bigger place we'll have to get a better job, rather than sitting on our backsides waiting for the next poor sucker to come in at the bottom of the pyramid scheme. We need to build so quickly that house prices don't move an inch for the next decade at least, otherwise we are going to be seeing more and more kids raised in damp B&Bs and more and more talented young professionals giving up on this country entirely.

Crikeyalmighty · 03/07/2022 15:11

@badgermushrooms that's exactly the point you have nailed- people who are doing ok like to talk about market value - so when it comes to buying/selling/renting property, commercial property too they say well the market value is xxx . Very few of them like it if they can't sell or rent out and not keen to accept the market value is way way less than what they think- in fact the market value is whatever someone else is prepared to pay , not some random figure . I think there will be some market value 'corrections' particularly in areas of low and sluggish demand in the next few years. Sadly I think rental values will stay quite high unless there is a radical rethink on housing- simply due to a shortage of properties and a lack of social housing, as a great many people just cannot fulfill deposit/ mortgage criteria , especially in high value areas.

Nothappyatwork · 03/07/2022 14:49

Well luckily for the generation of 35 to 50-year-olds that you would be happily throwing under a bus none of the parties seem to be able to think further than one election ahead and so the pyramid scheme will continue. With peaks and troughs of course but the reality of it is you can whinge about the debt as much as you like, it’s what makes the world go round.

If you’re “fine” I would suggest youre probably of an age where none of this is going to affect you and you won’t be around much longer to see it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread