Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treating our kids unfairly?

118 replies

L251090 · 02/07/2022 01:20

So I’m 32+4 with our first child. My partner has a 4yo to previous partner. His daughter is very spoiled by all the family which I get, she was the first baby in the family after all. Since we’ve fallen pregnant though something’s been bothering me and I don’t know if it should or not so I’d really like peoples feedback on this …

hes started a savings account for his daughter … his daughter who since we fell pregnant has had an extravagant Xmas, an extravagant Easter and an extravagant birthday, all of which I have spent money on too with regards to trips out, toys and clothes etc. i asked him about this savings account being opened for her (considering we now have a baby on the way) and he agreed to open an account for our baby too. Fine.

So far he’s saved £550 for his daughter and £60 for our baby. Since agreeing to set up an account for our baby he had added £150 to his daughters account and £60 to our babies. He agreed to opening this account 2 weekends ago.

i must also point out that I’ve bought all of the nursery furniture, the travel system and loads of clothes. I’ve arranged the baby shower which is this weekend and he has so far bought 2 baby grows.

is this fair/unfair? Am I being a whinge and expecting too much? I just want to feel like our children are being treated fairly and I really don’t but I’ve mentioned it a couple of times and I feel like if I mention it again it will make me look bitter.

I’d love peoples help on trying to get my head around this.

PS my partner pays full child maintenance for his daughter and has her 2-3 nights per week so I can’t put this down to making up for that.

please help I feel horrible about the way I feel on this matter :-(

thanks xxx

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:39

Lazypuppy · 02/07/2022 16:26

OP when you bought stuff for the baby what did he say when you asked for half the money? I think you're expecting him to be a bit of a mindreader

I’ve had a couple of conversations about it. One of which was just in the car a couple of weekends ago which was when I said I can’t do this on my own and at the moment i feel like I am. I pointed out that he had recently set up the savings account for his other child but hadn’t contributed to ours yet. That’s when he set up the savings account for our baby. But since then he’s put £150 in her savings, £30 in our baby’s savings and still bought nothing.

still need bottles, baby monitor, nursing pillow etc he has access to my wish list that I created to keep tabs on what we need too so I don’t think there’s an excuse.

i dunno, I just can’t do it all.

OP posts:
Bananarama21 · 02/07/2022 16:38

You sound very young and I'd be worried how you view the little girl,2 years in a short time to then be pregnant with a new partner and the fact he doesn't contribute to the household properly or baby things is a massive red flag.

TheGraceFace · 02/07/2022 16:34

Whose idea was it to open up an account for his daughter? I’m thinking it could be the ex to make sure her kid don’t get left out when your baby’s born.

You shouldn’t have to pay for everything just because his ex screwed him over. If you only take £50 from him he probably thinks it’s OK not to contribute to anything else, including the child that you will have together.

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:34

I’m not a fool … I’ve just always lived by myself in my own apartment and up until recently when bills etc increased I asked him to contribute £50pw. I can afford the apartment on my own. He had been dealing with other things with regards to his old house as his ex really screwed him over so I did not want to add to that financial burden. He also buys food, as do I obviously.

anyways the point here is about how I’m feeling just trying to understand if I’m being unreasonable about this as I feel guilty about feeling annoyed.

it’s complicated I guess!

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:30

How am I being mean about his daughter? I’m absolutely not at all. I’m being open and honest about my feelings in a forum of strangers and asking if IBU, I’m being vulnerable in asking for advice. I adore his daughter I’m just trying to explain the bigger picture. Your comments haven’t helped at all you sound like you’re just here to be mean to strangers.

keyboard warrior perhaps. No response required from you on this unless it’s actually to help me understand what I’m feeling.

thank you <3

OP posts:
tomatopsste · 02/07/2022 16:29

*Since I’ve fallen pregnant my OH has purchased 2 baby grows for our baby. I have spent over £2000 on essentials such as full nursery set and travel system, clothes, nappies etc. he has then set up a savings account for his other child and saved £550 for her and £60 for ours. How is that fair? He bought things for his first daughter with his ex when she was pregnant … why is it different for ours?

i feel like im preparing for our child alone! I adore his daughter so to call me a stepmother from hell is absolutely awful. I contribute to her with clothes and days out and love and attention and gifts etc etc.

with regards to bills etc this is besides the point he moved in with me and I only take £50 a week towards bills and yes the house is in my name only because his ex screwed him over and he can’t have a mortgage now because of his credit.*

Well you're a fool! £50 a week and that's all he contributes! He's a "cocklodger" why haven't you asked for more? What did he say when you asked for a contribution towards the baby stuff?

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:27

MassiveSalad22 · 02/07/2022 03:37

Is it weighted like that to make up for not saving for the past 4 years? We did the same with our boys - eg didn’t set up savings accounts for them until the second one came along, so DS1 had more as he’s older. Just as if we had saved for him from the beginning, he would have had more in his account when brother was born. So when they’re 18 they end up with the same amount. Don’t know if I’m explaining myself very well!

Explaining perfectly l thank you. So i totally get you and I agree with you about when to start savings account HOWEVER … I’m not getting any help so far towards any baby stuff … he bought stuff for his first child with his ex partner (presumably) so why is he not doing the same for ours? Do you get what I mean?

if he had set up a savings account for his other child and not for ours but was buying things to help such as pram or high chair or things like that then I’d be completely fine with it. But I’m not getting help yet he’s now decided to save for his other child .

it’s hard to get my head around x

OP posts:
Lazypuppy · 02/07/2022 16:26

OP when you bought stuff for the baby what did he say when you asked for half the money? I think you're expecting him to be a bit of a mindreader

tomatopsste · 02/07/2022 16:25

Ok. Do you not think he should be contributing towards our pregnancy and our baby though? I’m doing it all myself it doesn’t seem right …

Yep, he should! Makes him a selfish arse! But not the 4 year olds fault, either for being the 1st grandchild or for how people treat her.

So stop being unkind about the child and address the issue, which is your DP not paying for his second child.

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:23

ThePumpkinPatch · 02/07/2022 13:15

This. Every time her Dad buys her something the OP is going to come running up and start searching through the bag to see what's been bought 😢

Just remember OP, your baby (for now at least) is going to wake up every morning with both his/her Mummy & Daddy there - that little 4yr old isn't going to ever have that again.

To both comments:

This thread isn’t about spoiling a 4 yo it’s about equal contribution.

Since I’ve fallen pregnant my OH has purchased 2 baby grows for our baby. I have spent over £2000 on essentials such as full nursery set and travel system, clothes, nappies etc. he has then set up a savings account for his other child and saved £550 for her and £60 for ours. How is that fair? He bought things for his first daughter with his ex when she was pregnant … why is it different for ours?

i feel like im preparing for our child alone! I adore his daughter so to call me a stepmother from hell is absolutely awful. I contribute to her with clothes and days out and love and attention and gifts etc etc.

with regards to bills etc this is besides the point he moved in with me and I only take £50 a week towards bills and yes the house is in my name only because his ex screwed him over and he can’t have a mortgage now because of his credit.

im only asking if, the way im feeling is normal or if IBU im not asking to be attacked. Just trying to understand why I might be feeling this way.

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:20

Sprogonthetyne · 02/07/2022 13:16

Could he be trying to make up the 4 years of not saving before baby is born, then plan to add equally to both.

Eg. If he budgeted to pay £20/month into each account, then the baby would have £4320 at 18 but the older child would only have £3360, as he would have only been saving fior them for 14 years. So for them to have even amounts at 18 he would need to give his DD's saving a head start now, before he has the expense of another child.

Might not the case, but if there were a plan like that it would be equal, even though not the same.

Totally get you with this. But it’s the fact he isn’t contributing to the things we need for our baby but has managed to save £550 in a few months for his other child whilst I’ve paid for everything myself for ours. Feels unfair. This is what I’m feeling but also feeling guilty that I’m feeling this way … :(

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:19

tomatopsste · 02/07/2022 13:21

I'm assuming you won't want your DD to be very spoiled, like you describe DSD, so maybe it's a good thing he's not treating them equally?

Ok. Do you not think he should be contributing towards our pregnancy and our baby though? I’m doing it all myself it doesn’t seem right …

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:18

Rainbowqueeen · 02/07/2022 12:56

Put the house in your name only. How old was dsd when he and his ex split?? You’re right you do seem to be doing it on your own. Maybe his ex felt similarly??

Yes the house is going in my name but the house isn’t my issue here just someone asked about contributions in the relationship.

i appreciate your thoughts. She was 2 when they split.

he paid for most things in his last relationship she absolutely rinsed him and left him up sh**s creek without a paddle and we’ve sorted that now . Thankfully!

OP posts:
tomatopsste · 02/07/2022 13:21

I'm assuming you won't want your DD to be very spoiled, like you describe DSD, so maybe it's a good thing he's not treating them equally?

Sprogonthetyne · 02/07/2022 13:16

Could he be trying to make up the 4 years of not saving before baby is born, then plan to add equally to both.

Eg. If he budgeted to pay £20/month into each account, then the baby would have £4320 at 18 but the older child would only have £3360, as he would have only been saving fior them for 14 years. So for them to have even amounts at 18 he would need to give his DD's saving a head start now, before he has the expense of another child.

Might not the case, but if there were a plan like that it would be equal, even though not the same.

ThePumpkinPatch · 02/07/2022 13:15

RaspberryParfait · 02/07/2022 10:39

His poor little 4 year old. Sounds like she’s going to have the ‘stepmother’ from hell when her half sibling is born.

How can he possibly treat a child who hasn’t been born yet, the same as a child he’s been bonded with for 4 years! Nuts.

This. Every time her Dad buys her something the OP is going to come running up and start searching through the bag to see what's been bought 😢

Just remember OP, your baby (for now at least) is going to wake up every morning with both his/her Mummy & Daddy there - that little 4yr old isn't going to ever have that again.

Rainbowqueeen · 02/07/2022 12:56

Put the house in your name only. How old was dsd when he and his ex split?? You’re right you do seem to be doing it on your own. Maybe his ex felt similarly??

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 02/07/2022 11:22

Why is he not automatically buying half of everything for the baby? Like if you say 'we need a pram' do you just leave it at that or say 'its £500, do you want to pay half or do you want to get the travel system?' Have you asked him for his contribution for the baby equipment directly? You need to do this and see how he reacts. If its 'yes of course, sorry I havent transferred anything to you yet' then fine but if there is resistance then I think you might have a bigger issue. How is your maternity leave being funded? I hope you're not putting the house in his name at this stage while you have doubts about how much he will contribute

RaspberryParfait · 02/07/2022 10:39

His poor little 4 year old. Sounds like she’s going to have the ‘stepmother’ from hell when her half sibling is born.

How can he possibly treat a child who hasn’t been born yet, the same as a child he’s been bonded with for 4 years! Nuts.

MissMaple82 · 02/07/2022 10:29

I wouldn't compare as the baby is not even here yet. And men are particularly known for not being connected until after they are here. And it does sound like you are a little jealous, your child will too, one day have "extravagant" birthdays and Easters, as thars what you do as a parent

Cakecakecheese · 02/07/2022 10:26

The savings accounts aren't really the issue here, the main thing is you have a baby arriving and you're feeling like you're preparing for it alone and obviously that's not on at all and you need to speak to him about that.

converseandjeans · 02/07/2022 10:18

But your baby hasn't even been born yet! I don't think he's done anything wrong.

Savings for the future is better than splashing out on a baby shower. I don't get baby showers as they seem like an opportunity to ask people for stuff. All seems a bit grabby.

Momicrone · 02/07/2022 10:17

'His daughter is very spoiled by the rest of the family', as your second sentence is worrying - you have a long road ahead, presumably you knew he was the father of a toddler (then?), when you got together.

blubberyboo · 02/07/2022 10:16

I think you are way overthinking the savings account. His DD only has 14 years left til she is 18 whereas your baby has 18 years worth of savings. If he had started the plan when she was born then that’s likely what he would have saved. Hopefully by the time your baby is 4 he will have saved £500 into their account.

dont fall into the trap of thinking that just because you are pregnant that he will have to treat you or your baby with more importance than her. She was here first and if you don’t like it you shouldn’t have gotten involved with a man with a child. She will need many things throughout her life like trainers , dresses , electronics and he will want to buy things for her at times when he doesn’t buy the exact same thing at the same time for your child. You need to have an acceptance of this and not continually roll out “how come she gets this?”. Keep the jealousy well at bay and be mindful of the things he does buy for your child at other times.

your main issue right now is having a fair way to split household bills and costs

Aprilx · 02/07/2022 10:15

L251090 · 02/07/2022 09:49

So he set the account up for his 4yo recently, as in a few months ago. He only set them an account up and not one for our baby. If he had been contributing in other ways ie buying baby things we need then I would have this ‘issue’ (yes let’s call it that).

sorry forgot to specify when the accounts were set up.

with regards to bay shower what I’m getting at is that friends and family are contributing but I’m still not seeing anything from him.

should I leave it a little longer to see if things change or should I address it again? I do feel guilty about feeling this way but it’s obviously bothering me … :-/

I am also buying a house for us I have sold my apartment and using the equity for deposit and thousands of pounds savings for the fees. So although I earn about 25% more than him per year (before taxes) I’m shelling out so much money and feeling like I’m doing it on my own … x

Your baby isn’t even here yet! Why would he set up an account for a baby that isn’t born yet, I wouldn’t have even thought he could assuming the baby’s name would be mentioned on the account. It took him four years to organise an account for the other child, if he was being “fair” then he would set one up when the new baby is four years old not prior to birth.

As for the rest to be honest, I can’t fathom it as DH and I have always shared money, we actually have separate bank accounts as we never got round to merging but we have equal access to all money and the concept of him buying something or me buying something is meaningless to us.

Maybe DH isn’t interested in the concept of a baby shower, or thinks it is something women do.