Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treating our kids unfairly?

118 replies

L251090 · 02/07/2022 01:20

So I’m 32+4 with our first child. My partner has a 4yo to previous partner. His daughter is very spoiled by all the family which I get, she was the first baby in the family after all. Since we’ve fallen pregnant though something’s been bothering me and I don’t know if it should or not so I’d really like peoples feedback on this …

hes started a savings account for his daughter … his daughter who since we fell pregnant has had an extravagant Xmas, an extravagant Easter and an extravagant birthday, all of which I have spent money on too with regards to trips out, toys and clothes etc. i asked him about this savings account being opened for her (considering we now have a baby on the way) and he agreed to open an account for our baby too. Fine.

So far he’s saved £550 for his daughter and £60 for our baby. Since agreeing to set up an account for our baby he had added £150 to his daughters account and £60 to our babies. He agreed to opening this account 2 weekends ago.

i must also point out that I’ve bought all of the nursery furniture, the travel system and loads of clothes. I’ve arranged the baby shower which is this weekend and he has so far bought 2 baby grows.

is this fair/unfair? Am I being a whinge and expecting too much? I just want to feel like our children are being treated fairly and I really don’t but I’ve mentioned it a couple of times and I feel like if I mention it again it will make me look bitter.

I’d love peoples help on trying to get my head around this.

PS my partner pays full child maintenance for his daughter and has her 2-3 nights per week so I can’t put this down to making up for that.

please help I feel horrible about the way I feel on this matter :-(

thanks xxx

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:26

aSofaNearYou · 02/07/2022 17:14

No I haven’t asked for half. I couldn’t, it’s too much. I just want him to be a bit more proactive on buying things we need as I have spoken to him about it a few time.

If half of the house you both live in is "too much" then how on earth is it appropriate for him to be putting money into savings?

Good point!

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:25

NumberTheory · 02/07/2022 17:16

You are not being unreasonable to think he can clearly afford to pay more towards the set up for your baby and that he ought to.

But I think you are being unreasonable to think this isn't related to bills. Your baby needs bills paying as much as they will need a cot and babygrows. You need a proper sit down conversation about how your finances are going to work. With step children in the picture and you not being married, all money being joint as is often common in family set ups, probably isn't the way to go. But that just means you need to be more explicit about how much you each are going to contribute and how you are going to ensure all the kids are taken care of well and fairly.

You're buying a family house for you all, that's a big commitment that will hopefully be a good investment for you and benefit the family as a whole. Perhaps, instead of savings accounts for his kids, he should be looking at a more general investment that will be good for him and benefit his kids when they're older too.

Yeah I get you.

i need to sit down and work out what’s what.

its all so stressful and there’s a much bigger picture here!

anxiety level 100!!

thank you for the advice x

OP posts:
L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:24

CoffeeBeansGalore · 02/07/2022 17:10

Forgot to say congratulations & good luck!

Just protect yourself @L251090 . I wish you all the best for the future & hope everything works out for you.

Thank you so much x

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 02/07/2022 17:16

You are not being unreasonable to think he can clearly afford to pay more towards the set up for your baby and that he ought to.

But I think you are being unreasonable to think this isn't related to bills. Your baby needs bills paying as much as they will need a cot and babygrows. You need a proper sit down conversation about how your finances are going to work. With step children in the picture and you not being married, all money being joint as is often common in family set ups, probably isn't the way to go. But that just means you need to be more explicit about how much you each are going to contribute and how you are going to ensure all the kids are taken care of well and fairly.

You're buying a family house for you all, that's a big commitment that will hopefully be a good investment for you and benefit the family as a whole. Perhaps, instead of savings accounts for his kids, he should be looking at a more general investment that will be good for him and benefit his kids when they're older too.

aSofaNearYou · 02/07/2022 17:14

No I haven’t asked for half. I couldn’t, it’s too much. I just want him to be a bit more proactive on buying things we need as I have spoken to him about it a few time.

If half of the house you both live in is "too much" then how on earth is it appropriate for him to be putting money into savings?

Stag82 · 02/07/2022 17:14

I would want a more equitable split of finances if I was in your shoes… stay away from the savings as this really the least of the issues.

At the very least make sure your deposit is protected. You can get a legal agreement drawn up - I forget it’s proper name.

Get him to properly contribute to costs For the running the house. My partner has just moved in. We (for now) pay 50% of our the home pay (less child
maintenance for him) into a joint account.

For the babies stuff did you not agree on furniture / travel systems together? What was said when it came to order / pay?

if it were me I would be very direct, clear and open about my expectations.

i wud leave the savings for now as I think you have bigger issues at hand:

mrsbitaly · 02/07/2022 17:11

I get why he hasn't put the same amount in, as your unborn child will end up with more money then his child due to the 4 years he hasn't been putting money in his daughters account. I would also absolutely not expect my partner not to chip or get anything for a baby shower it never crossed my mind when I had mine to be honest. What I don't agree with is you shouldn't be left paying for all the baby products that you need he definitely should be chipping in. Is the new home going to be in your name as you have plowed so much money into it?

L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:10

Hi, yes he pays maintenance, a little over what’s required by law and also has his daughter 2-3 nights per week. We and his mother buy the clothes etc for her, his ex doesn’t seem to spend her money on anything but herself but that’s another story.

i agree on having savings it was me who put it in to his head about setting one up but what’s happened is he’s set her an account, contributed pretty well and yet our baby has had nothing … I’m due in 5 weeks!

just seems unfair and I’m getting anxiety over it as I have soooo much to pay out myself it’s all getting a bit much!

OP posts:
CoffeeBeansGalore · 02/07/2022 17:10

Forgot to say congratulations & good luck!

Just protect yourself @L251090 . I wish you all the best for the future & hope everything works out for you.

L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:08

CoffeeBeansGalore · 02/07/2022 17:04

feel like im preparing for our child alone! I adore his daughter so to call me a stepmother from hell is absolutely awful. I contribute to her with clothes and days out and love and attention and gifts etc etc.

with regards to bills etc this is besides the point he moved in with me and I only take £50 a week towards bills and yes the house is in my name only because his ex screwed him over and he can’t have a mortgage now because of his credit.

Get everything legally set up so that if you split he cannot screw you for half of YOUR house. "Oh he won't do that" shouldn't come into it. Spend a few hundred ££ on legalities to ensure peace of mind. No one knows the future.

Stop spending your money on his daughter. You have your own child to think about as your OH is ignoring that this imminent child needs clothes, equipment etc. Hopefully once here he will step up.

Have you sat down and said outright I have bought xyz which has cost abc so your half is £x. Transfer it to my account?

Once the baby is born I would quietly set up a premium bond account for your child & buy a set amount every month. He is saving an amount for his eldest child and a lesser amount for your joint child. This is you saving for your child & making sure they have independent savings at 18 that your partner does not have access to.

Some good advice thanks so much. Definitely will be opening a savings / bond for sure.

i will discuss legalities with my solicitor I also have a will.

No I haven’t asked for half. I couldn’t, it’s too much. I just want him to be a bit more proactive on buying things we need as I have spoken to him about it a few time.

feel so guilty for feeling this way it’s so frustrating!

OP posts:
Whatever00 · 02/07/2022 17:04

I wonder if he is feeling a bit guilty that this baby will live with both parents. Maybe he is trying to demonstrate that he loves his child. Only he knows. Realistically, the older child should have more savings. He should have started saving for her years ago. However, now he needs to contribute to the new baby. The baby should be treated fairly. He is paying maintenance to the mother and also saving for her (which he should) but ye should also paying for living costs and savings for the baby. If he can't afford it he shouldn't have had another.

L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:04

Cantdoitallperfectly · 02/07/2022 16:59

I completely get it OP, it’s a sense of fairness for both children. Is it possible that because you do have your shit together and are money savvy that the responsibility for your DC together will fall on you? But with his DD he is “going it alone” as in her mother won’t be providing in the same way that you will for your child?
I agree that it’s unfair that you’re being expected to buy all the expensive things a baby needs and he should absolutely be helping out with these. I think it’s become more of an issue because rhe money you expected to help buy things is going to his DDs savings account. FWIW he sounds very generous towards his DD and rightfully so (always a good idea to start a savings account) but you do deserve some of this too given that you’re about to have a baby together!

Definitely keep your home in your name only.

Thank you for your response.

he is such a great dad and partner, honestly. He’s had a lot going on financially and emotionally since he split from his ex so this is partly why I haven’t pushed for more money. I’ve always been able to afford everything on my own.

but now we have a baby things need to be fair. I think im scared that our baby will be ‘second best’ and that petrified me. I do suffer with anxiety though and am a huge overthinker this is why I’ve posted to get other peoples feedback and hopefully support!

thanks again x

OP posts:
CoffeeBeansGalore · 02/07/2022 17:04

feel like im preparing for our child alone! I adore his daughter so to call me a stepmother from hell is absolutely awful. I contribute to her with clothes and days out and love and attention and gifts etc etc.

with regards to bills etc this is besides the point he moved in with me and I only take £50 a week towards bills and yes the house is in my name only because his ex screwed him over and he can’t have a mortgage now because of his credit.

Get everything legally set up so that if you split he cannot screw you for half of YOUR house. "Oh he won't do that" shouldn't come into it. Spend a few hundred ££ on legalities to ensure peace of mind. No one knows the future.

Stop spending your money on his daughter. You have your own child to think about as your OH is ignoring that this imminent child needs clothes, equipment etc. Hopefully once here he will step up.

Have you sat down and said outright I have bought xyz which has cost abc so your half is £x. Transfer it to my account?

Once the baby is born I would quietly set up a premium bond account for your child & buy a set amount every month. He is saving an amount for his eldest child and a lesser amount for your joint child. This is you saving for your child & making sure they have independent savings at 18 that your partner does not have access to.

aSofaNearYou · 02/07/2022 17:04

It does seem really off that he's chosen now to set up this savings account whilst clearly not contributing enough to his life with you.

It's nice to have savings for your kids but it doesn't sound like he can actually afford to do this and he's taking the piss.

L251090 · 02/07/2022 17:01

LosingMyPancakes · 02/07/2022 16:55

I think you're confusing the issue by bringing his daughter into it. It's not relevant.

All you need to say to him is - I've paid X amount for these baby essentials. Can you transfer me half of the money for it now?

Fair play, so perhaps feeling the way I am is a bit unreasonable and I need to focus on the real issue rather than comparing with what he’s doing for his other child.

so hard to separate the two when I’m feeling like this i can’t help but feel like our baby is being treated unfairly. I dunno if it’s normal or not to be feeling this way :(

thanks though I appreciate your thoughts

OP posts:
Cantdoitallperfectly · 02/07/2022 16:59

I completely get it OP, it’s a sense of fairness for both children. Is it possible that because you do have your shit together and are money savvy that the responsibility for your DC together will fall on you? But with his DD he is “going it alone” as in her mother won’t be providing in the same way that you will for your child?
I agree that it’s unfair that you’re being expected to buy all the expensive things a baby needs and he should absolutely be helping out with these. I think it’s become more of an issue because rhe money you expected to help buy things is going to his DDs savings account. FWIW he sounds very generous towards his DD and rightfully so (always a good idea to start a savings account) but you do deserve some of this too given that you’re about to have a baby together!

Definitely keep your home in your name only.

tomatopsste · 02/07/2022 16:58

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:55

The £50 per week is a temporary thing. This is t about our bills. This is about the contribution with the baby.

i know fine well what I’ve got going on, I know his personal circumstances and if I didn’t, I wouldn’t be asking for £50pw … I’m doing that because o don’t want to make things difficult whilst he’s still dealing with an ex who dunces him for whatever she can.

it’s hard! But maybe I’m too independent and being a push over. I’m struggling with the balance and what I should expect from him. I’ve never been in this situation before … not here to be judged on age here for genuine help on how I’m feeling.

So he can't afford to pay more than £50 for his "rent", you don't expect him to be able to afford that?

But he should be able to afford to buy baby stuff?

I am totally confused, he's either got the money or he's not?

GoldenSpiral · 02/07/2022 16:56

I agree with @tomatopsste, what are you doing OP? Come on now, it's time to put your foot down. At the very least your DP should purchase all the remaining baby items. You need to make it clear that it is an expectation, not a wish.

He sounds like he has a very, very good deal.

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:55

The £50 per week is a temporary thing. This is t about our bills. This is about the contribution with the baby.

i know fine well what I’ve got going on, I know his personal circumstances and if I didn’t, I wouldn’t be asking for £50pw … I’m doing that because o don’t want to make things difficult whilst he’s still dealing with an ex who dunces him for whatever she can.

it’s hard! But maybe I’m too independent and being a push over. I’m struggling with the balance and what I should expect from him. I’ve never been in this situation before … not here to be judged on age here for genuine help on how I’m feeling.

OP posts:
Eightiesfan · 02/07/2022 16:55

If you are paying for everything, including the deposit on the house, you must make sure that your name is the only one on the mortgage. You are not married so first and foremost you need to protect your assets.

At the moment your joint financial contributions are very unbalanced, and he is seems happy for you to pay for everything which is allowing him to be overly extravagant with his child.

I’m not saying he shouldn’t treat his child, but this should not be at the expense of your child. You need an open and frank discussion about your joint finances.

LosingMyPancakes · 02/07/2022 16:55

I think you're confusing the issue by bringing his daughter into it. It's not relevant.

All you need to say to him is - I've paid X amount for these baby essentials. Can you transfer me half of the money for it now?

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:52

Coffeenoww · 02/07/2022 03:53

It may be a clumsy attempt to let you enjoy your first baby as he has already done this before. The savings I wouldn't worry about will even out in the end. As a previous poster has said men don't really get "it" until baby arrives, good luck 😊

Thank you. Nice to have a response where I don’t feel attacked.

appreciate your comment x

OP posts:
tomatopsste · 02/07/2022 16:49

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:45

I sound very young? I’m 32. How do you think I view his little girl? I adore her.

my point is the contributions from my OH not his little girl.

Just trying to explain the bigger picture.

I have a good job, I pay all bills/mortgage, I pay for 2 cars, I have sold my apartment and using the equity to buy us a family home in my name because his ex screwed him over and he can’t be joint mortgage owners because of her. I am saving £1000 a month to be able to pay for the fees so we can buy a family house and sell my current home. I treat his little girl with love and respect and spoil her on her birthday/Xmas etc and take her for days out to experience fun family days.

so please, don’t tell me I sound ‘very young’. I’ve very much got my sh**t together so that’s extremely patronising.

I'm sorry OP and this won't be welcome, but you've not got your shit together!

He's contributing £2,600 per year for all that? That's just not acceptable!

It's you financing everything, it's financial abuse.

Think about what he's providing, or ever going to provide?

L251090 · 02/07/2022 16:45

I sound very young? I’m 32. How do you think I view his little girl? I adore her.

my point is the contributions from my OH not his little girl.

Just trying to explain the bigger picture.

I have a good job, I pay all bills/mortgage, I pay for 2 cars, I have sold my apartment and using the equity to buy us a family home in my name because his ex screwed him over and he can’t be joint mortgage owners because of her. I am saving £1000 a month to be able to pay for the fees so we can buy a family house and sell my current home. I treat his little girl with love and respect and spoil her on her birthday/Xmas etc and take her for days out to experience fun family days.

so please, don’t tell me I sound ‘very young’. I’ve very much got my sh**t together so that’s extremely patronising.

OP posts:
Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 02/07/2022 16:42

Savings account and baby shower - YABU

Contribution to baby stuff - YANBU

Did you discuss how things would be paid before buying? Did you ask him for his share? Probably wise to figure out finances before baby gets here as this issue is likely to persist and it's not the fault of a 4 year old but she is likely to be the one who is resented for it (basing this on comments about being spoiled and about having more in a savings acc).

Swipe left for the next trending thread