Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Should a male teacher have done this?

873 replies

mycatisannoying · 01/07/2022 23:48

During a residential school trip, enter a girls' shared dorm to wake them up?
To my mind it's a safeguarding issue, and there was also a female teacher on the trip who could have done it.
I wanted to seek others' opinions before raising it.
Thanks.

OP posts:
Runnerbeansflower · 02/07/2022 22:39

I don't assume the male teacher is blame free.

I don't assume that his actions are a safeguarding risk.

I haven't been given enough information about the way in which he woke the girls up to comment either way.

A PP has said that surely we have learned by now to believe children when they make accusations. Actually, what we have learned is to listen and take it seriously, and not to assume that 'lovely Mr X couldn't possibly have done XYZ'. NOT to automatically accept whatever is alleged, and NOT to automatically dismiss it. But to listen to both sides, and any witnesses, and consider any available evidence.

As shown by the Carl Beech case.

milkyaqua · 02/07/2022 22:37

God help all your daughters.

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 22:32

@LAtalante - bollocks. I haven't at any point said the male teacher is blame free. I have said he is to blame if everything is exactly as the OP describes. But if you really believe without question that a teacher behaved exactly as described re the mobile phone incident, without any justification whatsoever, then you seem intent on blaming a teacher just because he is male.

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 22:28

@SirChenjins - it is unclear what you are disagreeing with?

LAtalante · 02/07/2022 22:28

if this thread is anything to go by there are plenty of parents who would bend over backwards to dismiss or ignore any complaint made against a male teacher

Yes, quite.

If he does behave like this for no good reason, he must have a string of accusations as long as your arm already, as no child in the group would accept that was normal behaviour on the teacher’s part

It doesn't sound at all normal, which is possibly why the OP posted for advice. The DD told her parent, the OP posted here, you don't believe their account.

If he did behave like this, why would it have to be one in a long string of accusations? Why could it not be the first? Or the first that he might get called out on?

Your reasons for not believing the OP appears to be an entire construct of if...if...if... designed to ensure the male teacher remains blame-free.

HRTQueen · 02/07/2022 22:23

I knock on my sons door before I go in he is a teenager now and wants and should have privacy

I thought that was normal

I am especially careful when he has friends round again I thought this was normal

SirChenjins · 02/07/2022 22:14

Murdoch1949 · 02/07/2022 22:08

If he knocked, opened the door, wakened them, then it’s fine. He wasn’t alone with one girl, which obviously would have been a problem.

It’s fine to walk into a dorm where girls might be getting dressed?

Oceanus · 02/07/2022 22:13

@username00 If he went to wake them up, chances are the girls were asleep. They didn't have a mobile and I doubt they took an alarm clock. What are the chances they were already awake and heard him knock?
My money's on him walking in unannounced to try and catch the "mobile" he was looking for earlier with the codeword. He sounds determined.

SirChenjins · 02/07/2022 22:11

I disagree @Walkaround - if this thread is anything to go by there are plenty of parents who would bend over backwards to dismiss or ignore any complaint made against a male teacher.

Murdoch1949 · 02/07/2022 22:08

If he knocked, opened the door, wakened them, then it’s fine. He wasn’t alone with one girl, which obviously would have been a problem.

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 22:07

@LAtalante - what did the OP say that made me doubt it?! It’s very hard to believe a teacher would set up codewords for children to report on another child who had given zero reason for anyone to suspect her of inappropriate behaviour. If he does behave like this for no good reason, he must have a string of accusations as long as your arm already, as no child in the group would accept that was normal behaviour on the teacher’s part, and it’s amazing a teacher with this sort of reputation was allowed on a trip in the first place. It’s just such a partial version of events, I simply can’t take it at face value.

Lou898 · 02/07/2022 21:53

I have done residential trips for several years and we usually keep the female staff supervising the girls in the dorms and the make teachers the boys. On the odd occasion I had to attend to the boys ( eg diabetic child having a hypo) , I always knocked and asked if they were all decent before entering a dorm.
whilst I don’t think was a wise decision, I’m assuming he would also have knocked prior to entering or similar to protect himself against any allegations.

LAtalante · 02/07/2022 21:49

raising the mobile phone incident made me doubt the OP, so I disagree there is no reason to doubt them

Why? What did the OP say that caused you to doubt their truthfulness?

This isn't the first thread lately that has gone the way of supporting the man at all costs, to the extent that the OP has to be branded a liar in order to make it fit.

And here we are again.

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 21:42

SirChenjins · 02/07/2022 21:17

Inappropriate and presents a safeguarding issue.

Yes, sorry @SirChenjins , I didn’t notice you’d asked about inappropriateness and safeguarding.

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 21:29

@LAtalante - raising the mobile phone incident made me doubt the OP, so I disagree there is no reason to doubt them.

LAtalante · 02/07/2022 21:25

It sounds inappropriate if exactly as described

Yep. And the OP has given no reason to be doubted.

The OP's account and treatment here is entirely separate from the necessity for the school to investigate. Of course they should find out exactly what occurred, and why. That's probably a given.

Mariposista · 02/07/2022 21:22

SnackSizeRaisin · 02/07/2022 20:16

A male teacher should not be going into girls sleeping area unless a life and death emergency. Can't believe so many think this is ok. I would report him if this really happened.

Agree with this. Unless a child is unwell and they need urgent immediate adult attention, no male adult (or child tbh) should be entering a girl’s dorm. A female member of staff should have done the wake up. I doubt very much there is anything to worry about but it is careless on the teachers part and he should know better. Teachers have so much safeguarding training nowadays, you shouldn’t put yourself on such a risky situation where a kid could make up a story about you.

SirChenjins · 02/07/2022 21:17

Inappropriate and presents a safeguarding issue.

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 21:15

SirChenjins · 02/07/2022 21:03

Would you agree that if it’s confirmed that he did enter the dorm and did set up a code word then it’s beyond inappropriate behaviour and the former presents a safeguarding issue @Walkaround ?

@SirChenjins - It sounds inappropriate if exactly as described, especially if no good reason for any of it to have happened.

SkeletonFight · 02/07/2022 21:11

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 20:20

It's just a word, to be used however words are used.

I've seen it used on here and I've challenged it in the wrong context.

but I do think some of the PPs are hysterical.

Hysterical is a word based in misogyny. It comes from "hystera" the uterus and a new word shellshocked had to be constructed for soldiers at the start of the 20th century as it was deemed unseemly to use for a man. It's a horrible word.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 02/07/2022 21:09

Oops

should Probably have refreshed before posting

HRTQueen · 02/07/2022 21:04

Well I doubt the teacher is going to be on this thread but stranger things have happened on MN

you don’t have to believe it’s true. But the question of should a male teacher walk into a girls bedroom to wake them up and the answer is absolutely no

there is no argument around that

SirChenjins · 02/07/2022 21:03

Would you agree that if it’s confirmed that he did enter the dorm and did set up a code word then it’s beyond inappropriate behaviour and the former presents a safeguarding issue @Walkaround ?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 02/07/2022 21:03

It was aimed at the OP and PPs who are hysterical at a man setting foot into a room with teenage girls

no one is hysterical

people are talking about basic safeguarding, if what the teacher has done hasnt breached the school’s safeguarding policy then thats that

the OP is perfectly entitled to ask if it has breached that policy

the school usually has rules in place, if that teacher has broken those rules then he needs to be told…if only for his own protection

Walkaround · 02/07/2022 21:00

LAtalante · 02/07/2022 19:48

Walkaround I was going to quote bits of your post, but my comments really all came to the same point: you don't believe the OP/the OP's daughter/both.

Were the other teachers unaware, or did he not actually walk into the room all on his own while the girls were asleep?

This assumes that the OP/her DD has lied. Why?

You can automatically assume this is due to an insane, power-tripping, misogynistic, inappropriately behaved teacher

And now a lot of hyperbole pointing in the same direction of travel.

When you strip away all of that, this is about a very simple incident: a male teacher walked into a girls dorm room to wake them.

This is against all the safeguarding I'm familiar with.

Why is this so hard to believe? There is a knot of posters that either refuse to accept that this simple incident happened at all, or that if it did, what's the fuss about?

There's a bit of Men Can Do No Wrong around lately, I agree with a pp.

@LAtalante - I have said it would be right for the OP to report her concerns to the school and to ask for clarification, but I’ve seen enough internet posts from parents who make incidents sound very simplistic and black and white, but for it to turn out that the reality was nothing like it (or even exactly what their child told them - parents often fill in the blanks with their own assumptions). I no longer therefore “believe” anything until I have heard both sides. It’s not as if it would be remotely difficult to verify if the teacher really had strolled into a room of sleeping girls to wake them up, as there are multiple witnesses to check with. Until fair checks have been made, I don’t believe anything other than that this accusation is worth investigating, for everyone’s sake. Why do you find that so difficult to accept? As for the phone incident, that sounds bizarre and genuinely hard to believe it was exactly as described and stripped away has sweet fa to do with the bedroom incident, but it was the OP who connected the two, not me.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread