Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second hand toys as gifts?

34 replies

NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 22:08

I have 3 children and almost all their toys are second hand, great quality, expensive toys for a fraction of the cost. I love finding a bargain & new toys IMO are almost always over priced.

The problem is, I find it very difficult to then go and buy brand new for friends/families children for birthdays. But up till now I have had to because I feel like I’ll be judged otherwise!

It is genuinely not just a money thing, of course we all know it’s better for the environment to not buy new as well. But also, I feel like I can get the child more/better quality toys if they’re pre-loved.

One of the children in the family is turning 3 soon and they love peppa pig. I could get them 3/4 sets they love second hand or just 1 brand new. Once it’s out the box in 5 seconds flat what’s the difference really?

But AIBU? Will their parents call me a tight arse?!
😂

OP posts:
DelurkingAJ · 01/07/2022 22:25

I happily give other people second hand things but not as a birthday or other celebration gift. So, DS1’s best mate is really in the Romans. I spotted a second hand Roman Army fact book and picked it up for him. Delightful all round. For his birthday I’ll buy something new (they are 9, so would notice, which also affects this!).

romdowa · 01/07/2022 22:23

I don't mind second hand but it has to be very good quality. A friend of mine gifted my son some second hand toys and they were very well used , half broken and some of them were quite dirty. I put them in the bin. Friend meant well but I dread when I see her coming with a bag , it usually means more rubbish for my bin.

Kite22 · 01/07/2022 22:22

Like you, I love a bargain, and buy most things 2nd hand (or possibly 3rd or 4th).

But also, like you, it feels wrong to do so for other people's dc, or indeed friends.

I buy most things in charity shops now, or even from free giving sites, and my adult dc have all inherited my love for a mooch in a charity shop / on-line market place / boot sale / etc and they have all introduced University friends to the concepts of Freecycling and charity shopping.

......yet, I still buy new for other people Blush

fighoney · 01/07/2022 22:22

I think it depends. For close family with young children I have asked if there was anything they particularly wanted and how they feel about second hand toys. I'm not sure I would want my child to receive 3/4 sets of something though on a purely selfish storage level! I would rather you just spent less. For children of friends I tend to go new; especially books, sweets or craft materials, which I feel a bit less guilty about buying new!

ThePug · 01/07/2022 22:20

I could've written this exact post! My two best friends haven't bought a single second hand item ever for their children whereas I very very very rarely buy anything new. I've also never dared by them second hand gifts, but I know the children wouldn't notice and would just be pleased with the "better" present. Interested to see others' comments on this. Luckily my sister thinks I'm amazing at finding bargains and so I have managed to send various second hand things for my niece and most recently, a bundle of second hand Sock Ons for new nephew which is what she'd asked for - they cost £1 for 5 pairs rather than £8 for two brand new.

Fabulousfanny69 · 01/07/2022 22:19

NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 22:08

I have 3 children and almost all their toys are second hand, great quality, expensive toys for a fraction of the cost. I love finding a bargain & new toys IMO are almost always over priced.

The problem is, I find it very difficult to then go and buy brand new for friends/families children for birthdays. But up till now I have had to because I feel like I’ll be judged otherwise!

It is genuinely not just a money thing, of course we all know it’s better for the environment to not buy new as well. But also, I feel like I can get the child more/better quality toys if they’re pre-loved.

One of the children in the family is turning 3 soon and they love peppa pig. I could get them 3/4 sets they love second hand or just 1 brand new. Once it’s out the box in 5 seconds flat what’s the difference really?

But AIBU? Will their parents call me a tight arse?!
😂

I got my nieces tons of secondhand Sylvanian toys for Christmas one year. Was NOT appreciated- my Sil thought I'd hit them out my loft from when my dd was little!! So now I buy less but for new
It's inverse snobbery

ShirleyPhallus · 01/07/2022 22:18

I’d much prefer people to buy / regift my children 2nd hand things rather than buy new stuff. It’s such a waste of money and terrible for the environment.

maybe you could subtly put the feelers out on their thoughts on it?

alrhough fwiw, I would not want 3-4 peppa pig toys from one person! Just one would be fine!

ComtesseDeSpair · 01/07/2022 22:16

The distinction I make is that a gift should be something special, or a treat, a one off you’d perhaps have to think about buying for yourself. It’s celebratory in nature. Second hand is fine for a gift if it was something rare, or a situation where you saw it and knew it was the absolute most perfect thing for the recipient; but second hand toys because they’re practical and cheaper just seems a bit functional and every day and practical.

The child might not care, because children rarely do (although I actually remember very keenly the excitement of a brand new toy when I was a child, and the ritual of unpeeling the sticky tape on the lip of the box and undoing all the ties inside the packaging) but I think many parents would feel slighted.

TeddyTonks · 01/07/2022 22:16

We buy second hand for our DC and always encourage others to do the same. We wouldn't want any 'more' tbh but frankly it's better for the environment and why spend ££££ when you can get for £?

Sadly no one has taken us up on this advice and insist in buying excessive amounts of new plastic shite 🤦🏼‍♀️ Which I do realise makes me sound v ungrateful 🤣 But honestly they have too much and I'd rather people save their money and the world!