Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Second hand toys as gifts?

34 replies

NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 22:08

I have 3 children and almost all their toys are second hand, great quality, expensive toys for a fraction of the cost. I love finding a bargain & new toys IMO are almost always over priced.

The problem is, I find it very difficult to then go and buy brand new for friends/families children for birthdays. But up till now I have had to because I feel like I’ll be judged otherwise!

It is genuinely not just a money thing, of course we all know it’s better for the environment to not buy new as well. But also, I feel like I can get the child more/better quality toys if they’re pre-loved.

One of the children in the family is turning 3 soon and they love peppa pig. I could get them 3/4 sets they love second hand or just 1 brand new. Once it’s out the box in 5 seconds flat what’s the difference really?

But AIBU? Will their parents call me a tight arse?!
😂

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cadot · 02/07/2022 12:19

I would never give anything second hand as a gift for a birthday etc.

Passing on things to friends that we're finished with? Yes absolutely. Wrapped up as a present? No no.

Caspianberg · 02/07/2022 08:43

Yes I would prefer

For those peppa pig sets for a 3 year old I would love if someone bought some secondhand, washed, and put in a nice storage basket with lid and gifted.
That way it’s ready to play with, no package and I don’t have to find where it’s going to be kept after.

Aprilx · 02/07/2022 08:40

I would and do buy second hand things for myself, but I would not buy second hand as a gift. I would also be taken aback if somebody got me something second hand as a gift, unless it was a rare book or an antique clock or whatever.

I also don’t think I would appreciate three lots of peppa pig rather than one (whether second hand or not) because of the additional stuff and space required.

NoGoodUsernamee · 02/07/2022 08:33

@InChocolateWeTrust charity shops can be a bit hit and miss but fb marketplace is great for good condition second hand toys. (& other stuff!)

OP posts:
InChocolateWeTrust · 02/07/2022 06:08

I'm always amazed by people who say they've had great condition second hand stuff. I've tried really hard to buy second hand and its always had stuff wrong with it, missing bits, looks really shabby when you actually see it alongside a newer toy, battery powered functions no longer work etc.

Duplo and brio do tend to be in good nick as they last well but theres hardly any ever sold and when it is, its not cheap!

LaTangerina · 02/07/2022 05:32

I have bought both new & second hand for my kids for gifts. I've been gifted second hand by family & been happy with it! Who are you buying for? Good friends, family or both? What sort of things do they buy for their kids? If all new bare in mind some people are bad at looking for & finding bargains.
I'd be surprised if most people weren't happy with whatever you give them.

caringcarer · 02/07/2022 04:59

I gave my son our old lounge furniture and he was really pleased with it. He has gone far away to live and he said it made him feel more at home in his new house. I have bought a Duplo farm and zoo that were second hand and put them through dishwasher and they are perfect. I gave them to my GC. My dd could not believe they were not new. I usually give friends children a voucher so they can get what they want.

LAtalante · 02/07/2022 02:17

I honestly wouldn't care if someone gave one of my DC a secondhand toy for a gift. I'd want it to be clean, that's about it.

I hate the thought of people stressing about spending money on a gift - homemade card and a bag of sweets is fine. I wouldn't get 3/4 sets of anything though - one is fine.

pimlicoanna · 01/07/2022 23:46

It's not something I would do. I give away our used stuff to anyone who wants or needs it but not as their birthday gift.

Lou98 · 01/07/2022 23:29

Will their parents call me a tight arse?!

It depends on the person really, some will, some won't.

My Gran got my Son loads of toys from the local charity shop for Christmas last year, she loves a bargain and is always coming in with something from there! Personally, my Son loved the gifts and it never even occurred to me that it was any less of a gift because it was second hand. We often buy him second hand stuff so I'm happy with other people doing the same.

Equally though, one of DP's friends have just had a 1st birthday party for their Daughter. They're the type of people that if we'd dared to buy them something second hand they'd have been disgusted. They won't buy anything second hand and would make it clear they weren't happy with a second hand gift. She actually told me once that she's donated all her DD's clothes and baby stuff to charity shops to help "poor people" that "can't afford to give their kids stuff". They are TTC again this year and said they want to buy all new stuff for the next baby which is why they've not kept anything of DD's.
To each their own but I wouldn't bother going to the effort of buying them a second hand gift when I knew how it would be received.

I always tend to buy new gifts, I just think it's not worth risking if I don't know how they'll react. The only person's kids I buy second hand for is my Sister's as I know they appreciate it and they also buy second hand for mine

NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 23:03

Does it miss the point a bit though, to give more gifts because they were secondhand and therefore cheaper?

yes I do agree with this, or would ordinarily but these particular sets are minute! Have attached photos. The characters are like duplo person size & then an accessory. So 3 of them doesn’t seem an excessive amount of plastic iyswim?!

Plus people usually sell this sort of stuff in bulk second hand rather than individual pieces.

Second hand toys as gifts?
Second hand toys as gifts?
OP posts:
RavenousBugblatter · 01/07/2022 22:45

Does it miss the point a bit though, to give more gifts because they were secondhand and therefore cheaper? It feels like it just encourages a plastic tat consumption mindset a bit.

I'd give secondhand gifts to people that I know are OK with it, so my child, my partner, and my sibling.

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 01/07/2022 22:44

You would have to be sure the other family feel the same about 2nd hand but i do understand why it would feel odd buying new for others and not your own DC. In this case you could gift clothes or things you wouldn't buy second hand such as stationery, craft items or experiences.

allboysherebutme · 01/07/2022 22:39

I would never buy someone else a second hand gift. X

GiltEdges · 01/07/2022 22:39

It wouldn't even occur to me to give second hand toys as a gift, but I do also refuse to buy plastic/poor quality.

If someone asked if they could gift something second hand for DS it would very much depend what it was. I don't think the extra quantity argument is a great one though, most parents already feel like their children have far more toys than they need.

Anotherdayanotherdisappointment · 01/07/2022 22:38

I'd prefer second hand and I know several friends that do through general chit chat about environmental issues.

DC classmates I don't know and friends that turn their nose up at my eco stuff I would buy new though. Although I do try to sneakily give new but reusable items where possible (not so easy for toys).

billy1966 · 01/07/2022 22:38

I am 100% the same.

Proudly.

I recycle at every opportunity. Alls have.

We look after our belongings and we pass our clothes on.

My children attend private schools and we have accepted, and have past on uniforms.

I abhor waste.

I very happily am a second hand shopper my whole life and will encourage my children likewise.

The boys don't listen to me but my girls are definitely open to it.

The gratification of a great vintage find is pure exquisite joy...not dissimilar to other gratifications!

Today, I just past on a set of old, but still fine, 8 year old teak garden furniture, to a friends son.

Its not perfect by a long shot, but it definitely has another 5+ years in it.

My friends son is just setting up his home and was beyond thrilled, and appreciative, to take my old things.

Just like I was at his age.

I am not a member of the disposal society.
Neither are my children.

We have happily accepted second hand clothing and I have loved passing clothes on.

Oh and without doubt the best gifts mt children EVER received were the well loved toys of dear friends.

We were hugely blessed by these gifts.

CuriousMama · 01/07/2022 22:37

Can you put them in a nice gift box?

Confusedteatowel · 01/07/2022 22:37

I would more than happily receive a second hand gift for me or my child, but I don't give them unless I'm 100% sure that the other person doesn't mind, which basically means mine and DH's immediate family.

ChickinMarango · 01/07/2022 22:36

I always encourage people to buy my DC second hand. Close friends I’d always check and see if it’s something they’d be ok with.

NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 22:35

@Mally100

They might even think you gifted something from your DC pile.

I did think of this too 😂 My own DC do have similar sets. I won’t do it, I don’t have the balls but I do wish I could!!

OP posts:
NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 22:33

I don’t think i could ask. They’d probably just say yes out of politeness then call me a tight cow behind my back 😂 I do have other friends/family that I think might be more susceptible to the idea though.

My mum would be thrilled with a second hand gift providing she liked it! She’d probably be more excited at the saving than the item itself😁

OP posts:
SmileyPiuPiu · 01/07/2022 22:32

I think its fine unless it's soft toys

Mally100 · 01/07/2022 22:32

I wouldn't gift someone else's child second hand items. It may make sense to you as you have 3 and it gets costly but how do you know the next person feels the same? They might even think you gifted something from your DC pile.

NoGoodUsernamee · 01/07/2022 22:28

I think people are becoming less squeamish around second hand stuff but there is definitely still some stigma and especially with gift giving.

  • The distinction I make is that a gift should be something special, or a treat, a one off you’d perhaps have to think about buying for yourself.
I do understand this point though, but in this particular case the gift will be exactly the same. Just potentially more of it if it’s second hand! Usually in almost identical condition to the new stuff too. These are small peppa pig sets, think 1 small plastic character & it’s accessory like a bike/oven/car/hat.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread