Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bullshitters- who do you think you're kidding?

114 replies

TooManyAnimals94 · 01/07/2022 20:47

Genuinely confused by this phenomenon. You know the people I'm talking about. They make stuff up that is obviously completely untrue and just expect you to nod along. If you point out their bullshit they backtrack at a billion miles an hour and make up a new story?!
Thread prompted by someone I have to work with sometimes and I left work today with full on bite marks in my tongue so I didn't tell her what I think of her and cause a whole scene.
As an example. I brought in scones for us at tea break. She tells this hugely dramatic story about how she's allergic to cream and she nearly died from having a hot chocolate with cream on 🙄
So, even though I found this story highly unlikely, I made sure we had separate knives for jam and cream. Me being messy, I managed to get cream on the jam knife so I was like wait! Don't use that, I'll get a fresh one. So she says 'Oh, just a bit on the knife is fine, don't worry'.

WHAT? YOU LITERALLY JUST SAID THE TINY AMOUNT OF CREAM ON A HOT CHOCOLATE NEARLY KILLED YOU??

Now I've read that back it seems like I'm being dramatic but it's just constant from the minute she gets there till she leaves, just constant full on lying and elaborate fantasies.

So if you know one (or you are one) why do they do it?

OP posts:
SirenSays · 02/07/2022 00:24

My SIL does this all the time about the most random things. I've caught her out numerous times and accidentally outed her when she's lied to other people.

ashitghost · 02/07/2022 00:21

Yeah we had one like this where I work:

he was late in because his house had been bombed by the IRA. The next day he received a letter of apology from them

his younger child had managed to get on his laptop and order every item of Lego that AMAZON had in stock and a huge lorry turned up to his house and dumped tonnes of Lego on his drive

same child was so impressive in his school nativity that he was scouted by some kind of agent and he was then doing this one child nativity show in the west end

other child had written to the Cats Protection so movingly about wanting a cat that they said she was the first person to ever be given a cat without a home visit and one just arrived

he’d been involved in a bidding war with Tesco for some kind of invention and he’d won

QuandaleDingle · 02/07/2022 00:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

IDreamOfTheMoors · 02/07/2022 00:17

I know someone who for years said, “yeah, I knew a bunch of guys who died in Vietnam.”
COMPLETE BULLSHIT.

I listened to this lie over & over for literal years until finally I blurted out, ”name ONE.” We knew all the same people.

They sputtered around, and ended up saying they were all from university, where I didn’t know their friends.

My comeback: “You were at university for less than a year.”
I don’t think they ever gave up on that one.

The OTHER BULLSHIT I hate is people who re-write history to make themselves out to either be the victim or the perfect person.

SillySausage25 · 02/07/2022 00:15

I get ya OP. I also cannot stand a Billy Bullshitter. I also work with one day in and day out and it ends up driving you insane. Bullshitters are particularly nasty creatures in an office environment and wreak havoc in a well functioning team. They can't be trusted, need copious amounts of attention and sulk like babies when caught out.

Actupfishy · 02/07/2022 00:05

I had a very strange friend once that tried to convince us that her true job was running multiple brothels, even though I had met her on several conferences she had been on for her very run of the mill job.

I think she read too many Martina Cole books

QuandaleDingle · 02/07/2022 00:01

Ha ha I used to know someone who swore blind she was allergic to pepper, it was such bollocks as she regularly ate things that clearly had pepper in like pizzas etc. And so bizarre that she'd lie about it, just pure attention seeking

Foreverfrustrated · 01/07/2022 23:56

@TooManyAnimals94 don't suppose this person's initials are FT are they?
If they are believe NOTHING!!

FriedTomatoe · 01/07/2022 23:51

It's a bit of a mental health issue really isn't it?

I've known people who have claimed multiple allergies - what they actually have is an eating disorder. People who are always saying how accomplished they are, are usually trying to hide something about themselves. If they were to be confronted with the truth of themselves they would probably break down.

JubileeTrifle · 01/07/2022 23:51

DD has a friend who constantly lies about everything. Her mum just brushed it away when she does it in front of her.
Its always silly things that DD doesn’t really pick up on. Last week she was saying she needed have blood tests so they took the blood from each of her legs, arms and both hands. Then she told me she had babysit a 3 day old baby overnight. Total rubbish, was hoping by the age of 13 she would have outgrown it.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/07/2022 23:49

These people are brilliant though! When they aren't obviously talking about dead people and cancer...

The shit they come out with is so funny. It's hard not to laugh when they talk at all, as you just know not one word is the truth. But they are funny, it's a shame they don't realise they are being laughed at, too stupid I guess.

Vikinga · 01/07/2022 23:49

TooManyAnimals94 · 01/07/2022 21:18

I genuinely find it hard to do my job when she constantly talks at me about things that aren't true. Luckily she's a freelancer who mainly covers illness and holiday so I don't see her often but I've done today and I know she's in tomorrow and I'm just dreading it.
It also makes her untrustworthy. I don't like leaving her to do things alone because if something went wrong she would probably lie and cover it up.

So then speak to the person who hires her. Is your job that important and does she not do her job properly? I still fail to see what the big problem is...other than someone being gossipy and wanting to seem better

ticketyboom · 01/07/2022 23:48

Eeksteek · 01/07/2022 21:32

It’s very common for people with ADHD to lie in this manner. It’s a sort of not being able to suppress the ‘wouldn’t it be fabulous if it HAD happened like that ‘ impulse we all have and learn to keep a lid on, and not knowing what’s NT and trying to emulate it poorly to mask ADHD.

it’s still annoying. You are understandably irked, but what can you do?

No it isn't. Have you ever seen a screening assessment for ADHD? Compulsive lying isn't anywhere in it. At all. How strange of you to pin this on ND people.

Hied · 01/07/2022 23:46

If I lived my life again, I think I'd like to do psychology just to study these people.

I really really can't understand them. I can't understand their motivation.

I mean I can understand someone lying about being in a better job or having more money etc because of self-esteem problems.

But the downright Pathological Liars, absolutely fascinate me!

I have a family member like this, and every time she opens her mouth it's a just a stream of lies. It's such a shame as she's a really lovely person, or could be if she didn't talk such shit.

I also worked with a person who'd lived with all these famous people, MPs, actors you name it, she'd lived with them. It took us a few months to realise we'd all been thinking the same thing, that she was lying through her teeth.

She even went on holiday to an unusual location, say Tibet. She brought the travel money in to show us. We all believed her and thought she was very brave going by herself.

She posted loads of pics on Insta (none with her in) which I reversed imaged .... of course they weren't her pictures.

The weirdest thing ever. She lived near where we worked too, she must have hidden in her flat the whole 10 days.

She also had a dying mum, dying dog ... you name it, it was dying.

MangyInseam · 01/07/2022 23:45

Apparently a lot of people like this start during childhood, and it can reflect being in an environment where they had to lie a lot.

I guess maybe they never develop the same filter that makes them feel they have to tell the truth?

I also think it has to do with an inability to form authentic relationships, instead they try and make connections through telling these stories.

TitsInAbsentia · 01/07/2022 23:43

I had a random cause to look up a former friend on linkedin the other day...her profile was reassuringly bullshit...listing universities she's attended for pretty much an open week and nothing more. You didn't get a degree from there love just from buying coffees. Librarian? Yeah I could put that too since I did a few days at my local library getting my girl guide badge. Just take a deep breath and be real and unapologetic for who you are instead of spinning a yarn.

I do find it hard not to just full on guffaw in the face of people who are so blatantly bullcrapping.

HollowTalk · 01/07/2022 23:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

HollowTalk · 01/07/2022 23:40

@knackeredagain Oh but Nessa was telling the truth! Don't you remember her wedding when John Prescott walked in?

Notgoodatchoosingnames · 01/07/2022 23:32

I had an ex like this. He had been in the SAS (he was in the army for basic training in his late teens and was no good!), He'd bought me a car then i dumped him (he bought the car for himself and i had my own!), last time i saw him He'd been invited to the bar (when I'd known 6 months earlier he was working in collections, and it turns out he was working in a collection legal dept).
There were other lies which i am sure i believed when we first got together. He just couldn't help himself. It's when i heard some about myself i got cross!

EmmaH2022 · 01/07/2022 23:27

I hate these people as OP
They cause a huge amount of serious trouble at work!

I've also been with one in a friendship and it's awful to realise you trusted someone who made up a load of crap. I feel as if there is more of this around than there used to be? I wonder if it's because society is more accepting of it and usually finds a label for it to remove the personal responsibility.

knackeredagain · 01/07/2022 23:25

CthulhuInDisguise · 01/07/2022 23:06

I work with a woman who claims to be related to several former Cabinet Ministers, half of Scotland and Ireland, and several celebrities. She also claims to have babysat Prince William when he was small (at a friend's house), to have advised a former PM about social policy, and accompanied a Hollywood actor fish the red carpet at Cannes.

The reality is a middle aged, junior grade civil servant who is very lonely and has multiple disabilities. She is a lovely kind lady and good at her job, she has ASD and is a vocal activist for equality. She's awesome. But she is also a fantasist, and it can be difficult talking to her when you know she is fabricating everything.

Do you work with Nessa, from Gavin and Stacey?

knackeredagain · 01/07/2022 23:24

I have an acquaintance who takes other people’s stories and pass them off as her own. Trouble is, she loses track of who’s who. Many times she has told me something hilarious/dramatic that’s happened to her and I’m thinking (or saying if I’ve had a few) “No shit? That exact same thing happened to me six months ago! Remember when I told you?’

Overtired201984 · 01/07/2022 23:23

Im with you here , I also work with one , allllll day every day bull shit , by the end of the day I’m shattered from listening to it .

got home today fell asleep for 3 hours and she just shattered me out with her all day dribble !

JubileeTrifle · 01/07/2022 23:19

Everything that comes out of BIL/SILS mouth is bullshit. They tell stories back to us, about us, that bear no relation to what happened (they always come out very well).

I follow a semi famous woman on Twitter and not one thing that she says is true. It’s a personality disorder.

NewBlueGoo · 01/07/2022 23:14

People who do this don’t really get that they are not telling the truth. There’s not a hard boundary between their daydreams and their experiences / memories.

My dad is like this - he genuinely seems to believe he was in a famous band in the 60s and that he taught Charles Manson on a prison outreach creative writing scheme. He also told his colleagues for years that his wife was dead (she wasn’t!) and that he had no children. But this didn’t stop him inviting them round for dinner parties at our house, with seemingly no cognitive dissonance whatsoever. It was my mother and I who had to field the questions about whether I was a stepchild / how had my mother died, etc. when we confronted him about it he denied it.

He’s had quite an impressive career - having a very loose grip on reality is no impediment to success.

I think Boris Johnson is like this, too.