Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bullshitters- who do you think you're kidding?

114 replies

TooManyAnimals94 · 01/07/2022 20:47

Genuinely confused by this phenomenon. You know the people I'm talking about. They make stuff up that is obviously completely untrue and just expect you to nod along. If you point out their bullshit they backtrack at a billion miles an hour and make up a new story?!
Thread prompted by someone I have to work with sometimes and I left work today with full on bite marks in my tongue so I didn't tell her what I think of her and cause a whole scene.
As an example. I brought in scones for us at tea break. She tells this hugely dramatic story about how she's allergic to cream and she nearly died from having a hot chocolate with cream on 🙄
So, even though I found this story highly unlikely, I made sure we had separate knives for jam and cream. Me being messy, I managed to get cream on the jam knife so I was like wait! Don't use that, I'll get a fresh one. So she says 'Oh, just a bit on the knife is fine, don't worry'.

WHAT? YOU LITERALLY JUST SAID THE TINY AMOUNT OF CREAM ON A HOT CHOCOLATE NEARLY KILLED YOU??

Now I've read that back it seems like I'm being dramatic but it's just constant from the minute she gets there till she leaves, just constant full on lying and elaborate fantasies.

So if you know one (or you are one) why do they do it?

OP posts:
EmmaH2022 · 02/07/2022 10:33

IsAnybodyListening sorry that happened to you. I blame the bullshitters.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 02/07/2022 10:26

My friends and I are constantly having a laugh at someone right now actually because they lie constantly, say they've bought very expensive things, it's on back order, getting designed etc. They are a cleaner, and that is their only income, nothing else. Nothing ever turns up, and if you ask them where it is, it's always 'oh it wasn't right so I'm selling it'. The next time this happens I'm going to ask to buy it, see them struggle for the new lie.😂They are so funny and completely bonkers. I don't even get why they do it, it's not like the rest of us talk about buying expensive shit all the time, and we don't anyway, so it's not keeping up with the Joneses mentality. It's trying to pretend they are better than us.

IsAnybodyListening · 02/07/2022 10:21

Cringing whilst reading these!

10 or so years ago i was friendly with another mum on the school run. We would occasionally have coffee, meet up in the evening with partners. Anyway, she dropped me like a hot stone. Completely started blanking me, would turn her back if she saw me at the school gates. It was actually very upsetting at the time.

Turned out after a few weeks of this and me asking her directly what i had done wrong, she told me she couldn't trust me as I was a bullshitter!!! I had told her a couple of stories about my life that are 100% true, however in her head she chose to think i was lying. Why i would lie about such things?

For me at the time it felt like such a betrayal of trust, to tell someone you thought you trusted something very personal-for them to then think you are a liar! Still galls me to this day.

Georgieporgie29 · 02/07/2022 10:17

Neverendingdust · 02/07/2022 00:56

I have a very very close relative who does this. Whatever, wherever, whoever it is I’m talking about she’s done the same only better. It’s embarrassing for me because DP picks up on it instantly, you can guarantee it will happen whenever we see each other.

I think it’s an insecurity thing for some people, they mask their own issues with such fantastical stories they get lost between fantasy and reality.

@Neverendingdust we have a saying for that, it’s an elevenerifer. If you’ve been to Tenerife, they’ve been to elevenerife

Whengoodtimesatthefairgobad · 02/07/2022 10:07

ticketyboom · 01/07/2022 23:48

No it isn't. Have you ever seen a screening assessment for ADHD? Compulsive lying isn't anywhere in it. At all. How strange of you to pin this on ND people.

It’s not directly on the assessment but it’s to do with crap impulse control and definitely a known part of ADHD for some people.

I used to do it and only stopped in my late teens. It was that tiny rush of saying something that would recieve praise/admiration/shock. I used to hate it about myself and I would know people knew I was lying as I was doing it.

I just really had to practice breathing/counting before talking. Or asking people questions about themselves instead of saying something mad. I used to rabbit on about myself constantly too.

I’m a good person and I’d never lie about something serious/to cover up a fuck up. I consider myself very honest but it was just like verbal diarrhoea that was tied up into my daydreams.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 02/07/2022 09:47

StaunchMomma · 01/07/2022 22:55

I used to work in a company (luckily not the same building very often) as a woman in the 90's who swore she was David Ginola's girlfriend at the height of his fame.

She was in her late 40's, not awfully attractive, constantly working overtime shifts but somehow 'David' was flying in and whisking her off to fabulous places and parties all the time. Honestly, she could have been him Mum. It was so embarrassing but she went on and on and was adamant it was true.

I had to do a shift with her one day and another colleague had left a magazine out on purpose that had him and his real girlfriend or wife on the cover. We spotted it at the same time and she caught me smirking, which isn't awfully kind but in my defence we were caught unawares so I wasn't prepared to hide my amusement.

The next afternoon my boss called and told me I had to meet with the big bosses and that I was suspended from duties until after the meeting. The psycho had reported me for something utterly ridiculous & not in any way an issue but twisted it massively.

Luckily my boss was aware of her batshittery and knew me well enough to know that I would never do what I was accused of.

I never worked with her again BUT I did learn to be wary of bullshitting nutters!! The MOFOs are dangerous!!

Weirdly, I knew a man years ago who used to claim he was secretly dating an England footballer, but that it had to be very hush-hush as ‘the press would bury him if he came out’.

I could have almost believed him, had he not been nearly 50 with over-bleached hair and a Ronseal level fake tan. No multi-millionaire footballer was risking it all for him (which is why his much-vaunted move to London to be near him never actually happened).

As an aside, when I told him I was moving to London and he asked whereabouts, his response to my reply was an airy ‘Not bad’. I longed to say ‘Well at least it’s a real place!’ I wouldn’t think twice about it now.

RitaFires · 02/07/2022 09:22

Reading this thread reminded me of when I was a teenager and one of my friends said the dance teacher was her cousin and that they spent loads of time together at family parties, she talked about it for about 2 years. Later on it became extremely clear that this was not the case but I was just embarrassed for her and didn't say anything about it.

I also had a friend who would embellish everything that happened to her. Once she got locked out and told people she'd slept on the street, when actually she'd called me and slept in my boyfriend's house. When we were in primary school she apparently told the teachers that she had cancer and the truth only came out when they asked her parents how they could support her, I say apparently because she told me this as adults so I don't know if it was a genuine admission or not.

I also knew someone who would claim you were lying about literally anything and say it never happened and then if you wouldn't let it drop would suddenly remember things in a way that was immensely flattering to them. She seemed to rewrite history all the time to make herself feel better, I'm not sure if even she believed it.

user3199 · 02/07/2022 09:12

My partner's mother is a bit like this. Among her classics was when she claimed her cleaner had tried to kill her. We called her bluff - picked up the phone, told her this was very serious and we'd have to report this to the police etc. she then said to leave it as she'd report it herself later. When we asked her a few days later about it she completely backtracked. Just one of many examples! I think she likes the drama/attention.

TimBoothseyes · 02/07/2022 08:52

I just feel sad for them. I think they are either very insecure or lonely and they see the "real" them as boring and/or worthless. I tend not to get worked up by them.

Tilda77 · 02/07/2022 08:40

I worked with a woman for 15 years who was a compulsive liar and she was a talker. What she hadn't done, seen, had! She could relate to everyone through her lies!We had a conversation with another colleague and a few weeks later in a conversation with a different colleague she tried to pass it off as her own experience! She practically recited what he'd said word for word!
We were the longest serving workers and new staff that joined didn't know what I knew ...which was that most things were lies!
She had several days off work when her ex husband passed away. She wanted to be a support to her adult children which was understandable. No one else knew that 5 years previous she'd had a week off work for exactly the same reason!
Quite often I'd say To be a good liar you have to have a good memory!

DanteThunderstone · 02/07/2022 08:26

I knew someone who lied compulsively. Unfortunately in her case it included telling outrageous and very damaging lies about other people. But even restricting it 'just' to the lies she told to boost her image, they were massively implausible. She claimed she'd done so many degrees with the Open University that they were going to name a building after her! What a dingbat.

LegInLegOut · 02/07/2022 08:26

I used to work with a compulsive liar, she drove us all mad with it.
You would be sat having a chat with a colleague while having a break and she would come in and take over the conversation. You could be talking about having a headache, oh when I had a brain tumour, she would say. Then go on about this fictional brain tumour.
According to her, she was actually our supervisor, but rather than be paid as a supervisor in her payslip, the company paid her the difference in cash separately. We didn't even have supervisor's!
Her ( deceased ) father was extremely wealthy and used to build houses for homeless people to live in....free of charge. Then the next day, tell someone else that her father was so poor that he used to go poaching to feed the kids.
In the end we all used to scatter if we saw her coming. It was painful.

Penguinevere · 02/07/2022 07:57

I’ve got a relative who bullshits. My take on it is that
-he chooses stories that are unlikely to be proven untrue
-he likes to sound more interesting than he already is
-he gets a little kick out of fooling people

I once fell out with him because of one of his lies. He told me he ran a local hobby club, and I was proud of this because I completely believed it. Years later I was out of town, and I ran into someone who expressed an interest in this hobby. I said proudly that my relative ran the club in my home town. …. Yes, the man I was speaking to was the one who really did run that club. I looked like the lying twat. It was embarrassing.

Notmybloodymonkeys · 02/07/2022 07:38

knackeredagain · 01/07/2022 23:24

I have an acquaintance who takes other people’s stories and pass them off as her own. Trouble is, she loses track of who’s who. Many times she has told me something hilarious/dramatic that’s happened to her and I’m thinking (or saying if I’ve had a few) “No shit? That exact same thing happened to me six months ago! Remember when I told you?’

I worked with a woman like this. Me and another colleague would just roll our eyes and mouth ‘that was me’ across the desks. I’m sure people knew she was full of shit but let her get away with it.

TooManyAnimals94 · 02/07/2022 07:17

MolkosTeenageAngst · 02/07/2022 00:48

This is really interesting, I wouldn’t call myself a bullshitter but there are time I have spontaneously told a complete lie in social situations and then afterwards thought, why the fuck did I lie about that? Often relatively mundane but believable things, so for example if talking about a band I like I might suddenly say I’ve seen them live when really I haven’t or I might say I’ve been somewhere on holiday somewhere three times when I’ve only been once. Often the lies are based on some kind of truth, so for example I nearly bought tickets to see the band or nearly went back there on holiday etc but didn’t get round to it, maybe they’re things I would have liked to happen but that didn’t. I wouldn’t say I lie very often at all and it’s never planned but sometimes these things just come out and I always regret saying it afterwards but it’s hard to take these things back once you’ve spontaneously said them! I have suspected I have ADHD for a while now and so it’s interesting that this could be a part of that.

That's not what you woukd call yourself but you totally are!
Do people believe you when you tell these stories? How do you respond to further questions about the concert you never went to?

OP posts:
Neverendingdust · 02/07/2022 00:56

I have a very very close relative who does this. Whatever, wherever, whoever it is I’m talking about she’s done the same only better. It’s embarrassing for me because DP picks up on it instantly, you can guarantee it will happen whenever we see each other.

I think it’s an insecurity thing for some people, they mask their own issues with such fantastical stories they get lost between fantasy and reality.

apparentl · 02/07/2022 00:49

Someone who was obsessed with the police. First pretending they were a criminal psychologist, and told everyone, not very discreet about her 'cases'. They'd never been to university and couldn't string a sentence together.
Twice told us she joined the police at entry level, (forgot she told us once already the year before), and probably a lower pay grade than the previous psychologist job.

Pretended to be related to famous people and had attended boarding school in different countries. In reality background was impoverished with single mother and UK state schools. Boasted about money but was a single parent in minimum wage jobs.

A few of us have had a good laugh about it as a coping mechanism, though we feel sorry for her. Nobody believes a word she says obviously.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 02/07/2022 00:48

Eeksteek · 01/07/2022 21:32

It’s very common for people with ADHD to lie in this manner. It’s a sort of not being able to suppress the ‘wouldn’t it be fabulous if it HAD happened like that ‘ impulse we all have and learn to keep a lid on, and not knowing what’s NT and trying to emulate it poorly to mask ADHD.

it’s still annoying. You are understandably irked, but what can you do?

This is really interesting, I wouldn’t call myself a bullshitter but there are time I have spontaneously told a complete lie in social situations and then afterwards thought, why the fuck did I lie about that? Often relatively mundane but believable things, so for example if talking about a band I like I might suddenly say I’ve seen them live when really I haven’t or I might say I’ve been somewhere on holiday somewhere three times when I’ve only been once. Often the lies are based on some kind of truth, so for example I nearly bought tickets to see the band or nearly went back there on holiday etc but didn’t get round to it, maybe they’re things I would have liked to happen but that didn’t. I wouldn’t say I lie very often at all and it’s never planned but sometimes these things just come out and I always regret saying it afterwards but it’s hard to take these things back once you’ve spontaneously said them! I have suspected I have ADHD for a while now and so it’s interesting that this could be a part of that.

Oceanus · 02/07/2022 00:45

@Furrbabymama1987 Lying about having a serious illness is bloody unforgivable, specially they're getting advantages out of it. I would got nuts if I knew sb like that and I'd tell this world and the next about that lie. There are lies and there are lies. Most I just ignore, I ask myself why but I don't dwell on it, unless it personally becomes a problem but lying about having cancer is a one way ticket to hell. 😡

leafyone · 02/07/2022 00:38

Most of all I hate the bloody insult to your intelligence that they think you believe them.

I'm just about to read the thread but I bet that can be applied to most examples here.

Bestshapeever · 02/07/2022 00:36

HollowTalk

Lequeen? Yes utterly baffling but sort of less so on an anonymous forum although I believe she was outed. Pictures of her wedding and kitchen on here! Mind you there were probably only about 26 posters on here back then, must have been 15/16 years ago? Cannot imagine how anyone could do it in RL and expect to get away with it

leafyone · 02/07/2022 00:36

Fake not take serious illness.

leafyone · 02/07/2022 00:36

Furrbabymama1987 · 01/07/2022 20:54

I have a friend who for the past 2 years has told me she's being investigated for cancer. Nothing she says adds up. I know people who have cancer and they tell me she's lying. Apparently she found a breast lump 2 years ago and has had scans and a biopsy, she keeps going for appointments but they don't know if its cancer or not. Then she had skin cancer that was treated with an operation, I said I'm so glad you're doing well and she said well actually I've probably got breast cancer. I hate to doubt people but she's lied about other things in the past and when I ask questions she changes the subject.

It's disgusting people take serious illness. I know of someone who did this but with a brain tumour. Why do they do it! Something very wrong there.

Fucking bullshit, but not challenged by people in case they were wrong. And I played along with it too. This person must have researched the symptoms and mimicked them, but the symptoms never appeared unless they were drunk.

TooManyAnimals94 · 02/07/2022 00:31

So the cream lie is looking really tame now compared to some of these!
She also apparently had to be airlifted off a mountain during her gold DofE and somehow the SAS were involved?
I feel a bit sad for these people but overall more annoyed than sad.

OP posts:
TooManyAnimals94 · 02/07/2022 00:26

Vikinga · 01/07/2022 23:49

So then speak to the person who hires her. Is your job that important and does she not do her job properly? I still fail to see what the big problem is...other than someone being gossipy and wanting to seem better

It just makes the day so much more stressful than it needs to be.
And we work with children and animals so yes, important that you can trust her not to do or say stupid things.

OP posts: