Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lowering Cms

32 replies

MuddlingThroughLifeLittleByLittle · 01/07/2022 20:13

Dh has a dc age 10. Always paid cms above the stated figure. Lost his well paid job as the company went bust and around here jobs are fee and far between.
So hes taken a job that unfortunately is minimum pay of 18k but has potential to progress in around a year.
However the only way to survive, and to be able to travel to collect dsc 1.45hr round trip, provide when here etc is to lower cms.
Now this is the absolute last resort. We've already cancelled the likes of netflix etc. Sold 1 of our cars. We physically cannot cut back further within our home. He's re done a cms online calculation and with new wage (he's got to tell them anyway as its more than 25% lower) its significantly drops his payments.

This is obviously the last resort.

Other option was to be on a benefit meaning he only would pay £7 pw.

I get that his ex will take a drop in finances but he can't give what he hasnt got. Yet he feels awful. He thought his job was for life so to speak.
He provides everything for dsc when here which goes without saying. Dsc here 3 nights a week
He cant approach his ex about it as shes not allowed contact with us, unless to do with dsc health due to previous issues with how shes treated dh. But that's another story.

Hes on the fence as to whether to change it, but if he doesn't we'd be racking up debts to survive.
We're both working and other dcs at home. Ive juggled my hours to cut 80% of childcare costs for our youngest

I know we're prob BU to lower it but we have no choice.

Ive been the receiving end of similar and i know hard it is but we have to keep a roof over our head and all the dcs

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DottyLittleRainbow · 01/07/2022 22:17

Just pay the required amount based on CMS for his new salary. There is no need for him to soften the blow by overpaying when he simply can’t afford it, the child is with him 6/14 nights and he is paying for a school uniforms and clubs as well. If he has lost his job and had to take a lower paid one it’s unfortunate but you can’t leave your household unable to meet basic expenses. Nothing to feel guilty about, as he has been massively overpaying for years he clearly wants the best for his child - but right now that will be contributing CM within his means. You’re already upping your hours and making cuts but that can’t be used to continue to overpay CM if you’re struggling - it’s based on the fathers income not the household income.

Another solution is up one night every 14 days so it’s 50/50 and then no maintenance required, if that would be doable for your household and agreeable with his ex.

Youseethethingis1 · 01/07/2022 21:36

£350 pm is alot of money considering he has the child 3/7. It's very obvious that this is either the result of a massive voluntary overpayment, showing that he is not routinely mean with money for his child, or the result of a huge wage, meaning the drop to less than £18k is going to be far more painful for the child in OPs household than it will be in their mothers.
There's not a thing to think about. The maintenance will have to drop to a manageable level as the child must be provided for in both homes, not just one.

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 01/07/2022 21:32

Does the CMS have a mediation mechanism by which he could communicate the changes? Or did I see there was some online service for sorting out non-CMS CM without direct contact?

HinchcliffeandMurgatroyd · 01/07/2022 21:30

I would soften it by splitting the difference and paying £225 pcm for a year, to give her time to adjust, if that’s possible. Which is at least saner than his idea of just continuing as he is, and is as reasonable as anyone could expect in the circumstances.

MuddlingThroughLifeLittleByLittle · 01/07/2022 21:11

He was on 42k (but always paid over cms figure) now 18k
Its bloody hard. I've changed my hours, but often means im working online at home till midnight as we stopped childcare as that was huge.
Sold 1 car.
Cut Netflix and Disney

As said this hopefully is temporary. And he still looks elsewhere. But 18k is better than no job. If he gets overtime he'll send extra money.

OP posts:
MuddlingThroughLifeLittleByLittle · 01/07/2022 21:08

It states No contact other than health /illness.
No there's not a reduction for my dc. As we didnt feel that was right going back when he moved in. However cms did say they knew there was my dc living here and calculated it BUT he paid more than they said because we didn't feel it was appropriate.

Hes been looking at doing take away delivery driving on top of his job but means when dsc is here he wont be 2 out of 3 of those nights . I dont mind and nor does dsc so may be idea for a temp gap.

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 01/07/2022 21:02

Just looking at your figures... if I've worked this out correctly your DH has gone from a sizeable £50-60k income down to around £17500?

In which case like it or not your household simply cannot sustain significant CMS overpayment. It kust be an absolute nightmare to work with that reduction in income - both as a working budget and mentally for your husband!

LittleOwl153 · 01/07/2022 20:49

He cannot inform her she is not allowed contact with us.

What does that order actually state? Is it no contact either way, no sharing of addresses? Could he write her a letter explaining the (facts only) situation? If that is not allowed then there is nothing he can do if he not allowed to contact her he will need to leave it to the CMS.

The reduction is what it is. If it is a case of jobs change and it wasn't his choice then that's that!

Wallywobbles · 01/07/2022 20:49

If you have DSC 6 out of 14 nights could you up it by one and stop the payments?

BalloonsAndWhistles · 01/07/2022 20:46

If they were still together then she’d have to put up with less money in this situation. As long as it goes back up ASAP when he gets a pay increase then it’s going to have to do for now. Let the CMS break the news.

rainbowunicorn · 01/07/2022 20:44

LilyMarshall · 01/07/2022 20:22

theres a lot of irrelevant information in the op. But if you cannot afford it, you cannot afford it.

not sure what the question is. Obviously the child cannot rely on the father financially.

going from a well paying job to minimum wage for a year is a poor choice.

how many dc are there?

Can you not read? The man lost his job due to the company going bust. He had to take a job paying minimum wage as that was all he could get. There is not always a choice. It is not a case of the child not veing able to rely on the father. OP states that they have the chidl 3 nights a week anyway.
Your post is horrible and judgemental.

Sidehustlehoping · 01/07/2022 20:42

I’m assuming you have your own dc’s who don’t belong to your dh?
If so, and he’s included your dc’s into the cms calculation, then I think that’s unfair.

SmileyPiuPiu · 01/07/2022 20:39

plasidr · 01/07/2022 20:37

If so. Ask the court to inform her. Totally unreasonable for her to have no warning given the magnitude of the drop.

Sounds like it's her fault she's not allowed contact, she should have thought through the consequences of her actions.

user2345266 · 01/07/2022 20:38

It isn't his fault and I really wouldn't worry about it.

As soon as he is back on his feet, he can increase the payments. He needs to make sure all his bills etc are covered first.

She would benefit if he had a pay increase so unfortunately she also has to deal with pay reductions. If they were still together she would have to be dealing with it too.

SmileyPiuPiu · 01/07/2022 20:38

It's fine. It's something she has to accept as a result of their separation.

plasidr · 01/07/2022 20:37

If so. Ask the court to inform her. Totally unreasonable for her to have no warning given the magnitude of the drop.

girlmom21 · 01/07/2022 20:37

There's nothing you can do - it'll need to be reduced for you all to survive.

Badgerstmary · 01/07/2022 20:36

As you have him 3 nights a week & the mum has him 4 then surely your husband wont need to pay much anyway as you have him nearly 1/2 the time. If dss was with his mum most of the week it would be different but presumably you share costs anyway.

plasidr · 01/07/2022 20:36

Just checking when you say isn't allowed contact with you. Does that preclude him contacting her?

MuddlingThroughLifeLittleByLittle · 01/07/2022 20:33

It wasn't a choice

Sorry yes he pays for ALL uniform and the only club dsc does. And this will continue as budgeted that in
And obviously school meals on his days etc. He provides all clothes and everything needed here which is 3 days a week.
And yes of course all kids have taken a cut in our home. Including my dc.
But hopefully it is temporary.

He cannot inform her she is not allowed contact with us. Ordered by court due to her previous behaviours towards dh.
Only way she will find out is cms contacting her.

OP posts:
SmileyPiuPiu · 01/07/2022 20:29

Same as if he was too ill to work or died or something. The children's lifestyle will have to adjust accordingly.

SmileyPiuPiu · 01/07/2022 20:28

MuddlingThroughLifeLittleByLittle · 01/07/2022 20:22

He tried and is still looking in case something better comes up. But it was the case of take this or no job at all.

He can't afford the current rate of CMS then he has to lower it. Simple. Same as when families who have parents that are together have to make cuts due to redundancy. The only difference here is there's no communication between the parents.

washingwakeup · 01/07/2022 20:28

LilyMarshall · 01/07/2022 20:22

theres a lot of irrelevant information in the op. But if you cannot afford it, you cannot afford it.

not sure what the question is. Obviously the child cannot rely on the father financially.

going from a well paying job to minimum wage for a year is a poor choice.

how many dc are there?

Where was the choice? He lost his job as the company went bust.

His child can rely on him as much as any child can rely on their parent not to be let go through no fault of their own.

Pigsears · 01/07/2022 20:26

£250 per month drop is huge for DSC. There would be some households that could absorb this- but few without impacting quite significantly.

Your household must be reeling too.

InChocolateWeTrust · 01/07/2022 20:24

As long as he's applying cuts evenly across his kids it's not unreasonable. You've mentioned you've already made a lot of cuts at home. Life happens, if he was still with her he wouldnt be able to provide income he doesnt have.

What does it mean for them? Is their mum going to be able to keep them fed & housed without it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread