Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bursary to attend Independent schools - insights sought

61 replies

User404 · 01/07/2022 15:10

I'd be very grateful for any insight current or former bursars could offer, or from anyone who typically sits on the decision making panels/boards for your independent school. Panels which decide whether to offer a bursary or not, and if an offer is made, how much should be offered.

A neighbour of mine has a 10 year old daughter who was advised by her under performing state primary that her daughter was gifted and that she should consider sitting her daughter for grammar school 11+ exams. Unfortunately we don't live anywhere near any grammar schools.

My neighbour investigated other options and decided to try her for a bursary place at local independent schools. The family are local authority council tenants, former refugees. One parent is able to work full time and works a minimum wage job. The other parent works for minimum wage, part-time, their hours are fitted around their children's school/ nursery hours.

The daughter sat 3 exams and was offered a place at 2x schools (Channing and Francis Holland (I'm unsure which site). However neither school offered her a bursary, as such this extremly bright little girl is now on her way to the local underperforming comprehensive school in September, 2022.

I understand that bursary pots are finite, and there will always be many deserving applicants each year.

I'm particularly interested however in understanding which types of applicants are offered bursaries. I was surprised by my neighbour's experience and I guess I'm trying to rationalise it. If this little girl was not found worthy, can someone venture ideas on which types of applicant are.

Many thanks for reading.

OP posts:
Meadowbreeze · 02/07/2022 00:29

There's just too many of these kids, this will sound
heartless but plenty will have even worse stories. It's not really about the situation they're in but the suitability of the candidate. I personally wouldn't want a child in that situation at either of those schools. It's very difficult to be surrounded by so much wealth.
It's a bit mean of you to emphasise that this super bright child will sadly have to got to a crap school. That's sad for any child, not just the clever ones. Also, I highly doubt she will go to a crap school, Hackney has brilliant schools. Any application now will be a late one, so where they live doesn't matter.

User404 · 02/07/2022 00:18

Hi @debbiewest0 , Thank you for sharing this info.

Hi @nomoneytreehere , this is interesting, so the order is possibly:

a. Do you qualify for a bursary, yes/no.
b. How high did you score in entrance exams, interviews, tests etc.
c. Any other quality that marks the child out for special treatment.

Hi @coffeecupsandfairylights , those stats are dizzying, and go someway to explaining how much of a lottery the process is. Thank you for sharing your perspective.

OP posts:
BonjourCrisette · 01/07/2022 23:46

There is absolutely no point in looking at Camden School for Girls, Marylebone or Fortismere at this point unless the parents plan to move house which seems unlikely from the details shared so far. Moving house tends to be expensive even for people who are renting.

Marylebone has, I think, its own admission process for out of borough children which will have been done and dusted some time ago (and is probably too far away). Camden very popular and too far away. Ditto Fortismere. All three schools will have a waiting list and places will go to children who are nearest. This will absolutely not include children who live in Hackney and who have not yet applied or gone through any of the admissions processes for these schools.

There's no point in telling the parents about these schools because you will only raise their hopes for something that is unachievable, though they might well be a possibility for sixth form when distance is not so important.

runningpram · 01/07/2022 23:42

Mossbourne School is in Hackney and gets good results -it operates a lottery system for places as far as I know

cestlavielife · 01/07/2022 23:29

I dont know anything about hackney schools but they can look at nearby boroughs. Kids commute for secondary . If she bright she will do ok.

User404 · 01/07/2022 23:06

Hi @cestlavielife ,

Thank you for these suggestions, I will double check with the parents. My understanding is that the location of the family home falls out with the catchment/last distance offered for these schools. However, there's no harm in them exploring again, September is still a couple of months away...

OP posts:
BonjourCrisette · 01/07/2022 22:25

I'd imagine it would be quite difficult on the child to attend the school even with a full bursary. Uniforms for independent schools are extremely expensive, school trips etc will be expensive too and these won't be covered by the bursary

I don't know about other schools, but my daughter's school gives grants for all of these things for those who are receiving financial assistance and covers even very expensive trips for bursary children where there is educational benefit to the child, such as foreign language exchanges, trips for geography or biology fieldwork, history visits to important sites in other countries. I would be surprised if other schools were substantially different. Plus there is a thriving trade in secondhand uniform - the uniform is donated and sold at a much reduced price and the profits go to the bursary fund.

BonjourCrisette · 01/07/2022 22:20

There is no point in looking at Fortismere if they live in Hackney! FWIW my friend's very bright child lives in Hackney and has done very well at Clapton Girls, but it depends where in Hackney they are. It honestly sounds like a really nice school from what my friend's daughter has told me. For state schools, you have to live within a reasonable distance. As your friend's child is not massively upset, it would be far better to make the most of the school she has and perhaps go on waiting lists for anywhere they prefer that is within striking distance (most councils have maps of allocations on their websites and there tends to be movement on the lists over the summer).

If she decides to try again for A Levels, your friends should be aware that they are likely to have a better chance of a bursary at a bigger name school which is likely to have better funding and a larger amount of funds to disburse. I know for a fact that at DD's school there are many children on 100% bursaries and around 1 in ten children there are receiving financial assistance. There are other schools with similar numbers though I don't know about North London.

However, the fact is that bursaries are awarded not to those in most financial need (though they do have to meet the requirements which are simply that they should not be able to afford to pay the fees, which can perfectly well apply to someone on £50,000 salary given that the schools might cost as much as £25,000 a year and people do need money to pay the rent and buy food) but to those who have done the best in the exams and interviews out of the people who qualify for financial assistance. It may be that eg your friend's daughter is a lot better at Maths than arts subjects or vice versa and she would have a better chance at A Level when she will be applying to study the things she is best at.

As others have said, she sounds clever, hard-working and well-supported and she will probably do really well wherever she goes to school. It sounds like you are taking it harder than the family, OP!

User404 · 01/07/2022 22:17

LIZS · 01/07/2022 18:59

One of our local independents has bursary funding specifically for local housing association tenants.

That's intriguing @LIZS , thank you for sharing this insight.

I'll pass on this info on, along with the information offered from a previous poster above re specific, grants, charities and organisations which are founded to support specific groups of people.

OP posts:
User404 · 01/07/2022 22:13

Hi @FourOclock

Yes, you might be onto something, perhaps there were many applicants to these schools who only required partial support, in these circumstances the schools are able to assist multiple families per year, which is great for the children and I'm sure benefits the schools records when it comes to evidencing their ability to fulfill any widening participation obligations they may have from the Charity Commission.

OP posts:
User404 · 01/07/2022 22:08

vanillasunshine · 01/07/2022 18:53

Both my kids are on 50% bursaries plus scholarships of 10% - SE but not london. Definitely worth applying for other independent school to see what is on offer. However, times may well be tighter for independent school now so they might not be offering so many bursaries.

Hi @vanillasunshine , I suspect you're right, it's possibly just an incredibly difficult time for bursary applicants, I'll pass on your advice to perhaps investigate possible other options. Thank you for sharing your experiences.

OP posts:
User404 · 01/07/2022 22:05

Hi @acornpattern , many congratulations to your nephew, I hope he is enjoying his time at school, it sounds like his parents were very considered in the choice they made for him. Wishing them all the best of luck.

OP posts:
User404 · 01/07/2022 20:27

Hi @IdiotCreatures

Yes, the school you've mentioned is completely right. The family live in Hackney, I think they looked at these grammars and understood them to ineligible due to distance/post code catchments.

They were however eligible for Dame Alice Owen due to the location of their daughters primary school, however, they were nervous about the distance of the commute.

I will tell them Fortismere, I don't really know anything anything about that school myself.

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 01/07/2022 20:21

this extremly bright little girl is now on her way to the local underperforming comprehensive school

I get that you're coming from a good place and that you're understandably frustrated on behalf of this family. The child has obviously overcome a lot of adversity to do so well, and seems like a great candidate for a bursary.

However, I struggle with the implicit suggestion in your post that it's somehow worse for this child to go to the local underperforming comprehensive school because she is extremely bright, as if the underperforming school would somehow be OK for a less academic child. I really can't agree with that. If anything, the bright child at least has brightness and supportive parents on her side, and she will very likely be successful at the comprehensive school. It's the children who are not quite so bright, and who don't have interested and supportive parents, who might really benefit from what a private school would be able to offer. But nobody ever considers that those children are deserving of a bursary.

I'm not having a go at all. I get where you're coming from, and it's lovely that you obviously care about this family and want their dc to have the best possible opportunities. However, if she's as bright as you say she is, and if her parents are as supportive as they sound, then I'm sure she'll do well regardless. Others, sadly, may not.

User404 · 01/07/2022 20:17

InChocolateWeTrust · 01/07/2022 18:28

User404 christs hospital used to have a rep for offering a lot bursary wise.

There are some schools linked to livery companies etc that particular prioritise kids with parents working in certain trades. Could be worth a look.

Thank you @InChocolateWeTrust , you're completely right, I guess it's never possible to truly understand the rationale behind the final decision. I'm unaware of whether my neighbour's child has any marketable qualities, over and above impeccable academics and the ability to triumph over and persevere through adversity.

I know of a family which has a family income of £180k that was offered a 50% bursary for their child to attend a popular North London mixed independent secondary...

I will forward on details of Christs Hospital, thank you for this recommendation.

OP posts:
User404 · 01/07/2022 20:06

Thank you for sharing these @Maytodecember , it is very kind of you. I will show these links to my neighbour, thank you 😊

OP posts:
User404 · 01/07/2022 19:18

Thank you @00100001

I believe the means testing process was very thorough, lots of evidence was required in addition to parental bursary interviews. The family do not earn much, they do not own many possessions and do not go on vacation.

They worked hard to ensure their daughter was prepared and they're delighted that she was deemed both bright enough, and a good fit to be offered a place. They can all be very proud of themselves.

OP posts:
HighRopes · 01/07/2022 19:18

Uniform etc doesn’t need to be an issue. I know a DC who (this year) was offered a 110% scholarship at one school (so uniform, trips, laptop all covered), and a 100% at another. His parents preferred the second school, but explained the financial issue, and they matched it. He’s bright and sporty but not a genius by any means.

coffeecupsandfairylights · 01/07/2022 19:10

My neighbour's circumstances would appear on paper to be quite compelling, refugees, living in social housing, earning minimum wage, with a child bright enough to be offered a place, but evidently not compelling enough for that place to be funded by the school.

It's not about it not being compelling enough.

I went to private school - there were approximately 60 students per year group, and only one of those would be on a bursary. Think of how many people apply for private schools each year - only a tiny number are eligible for bursaries and an even tinier number will be accepted.

There are probably 10-20 children who applied who are in the same situation - if the school only offers one or two bursaries per year group, that leaves 18-19 children without a bursary offer.

It's obviously disappointing that this girl didn't get a place, but it's not because the situation wasn't compelling enough - it's because loads of families are in similar positions and only one child can be lucky enough to get the bursary.

nomoneytreehere · 01/07/2022 19:07

Bursary's are oversubscribed. The brightest children that meet the financial criteria are awarded them not the poorest.

debbiewest0 · 01/07/2022 19:04

FourOclock · 01/07/2022 18:55

In my limited experience, 100% bursaries are a lot rarer than partial bursaries. The school we are considering for secondary say they only give 100% bursaries in very exceptional circumstances. I have also known bursaries to go towards children already at the school first, who's financial situation may have changed, to provide them with consistency.

I would say though that in that family's situation, I'd imagine it would be quite difficult on the child to attend the school even with a full bursary. Uniforms for independent schools are extremely expensive, school trips etc will be expensive too and these won't be covered by the bursary. They may also be the only pupil there in council housing for example and feel quite excluded/different to their peers.

Though our local independent school states that when you get a bursary, you also get a uniform allowance, trips discount etc so it is all covered to avoid this being the reason bright children don’t apply for the school.

cestlavielife · 01/07/2022 19:04

If she close to those
Surely she can get into a camden comp
Which do fine
And send kids to oxbridge med school etc
Or camden school.for girls
Or marylebone etc
Which school.is she offered ?

User404 · 01/07/2022 19:01

Hi @essex42

Thank you for your insight, it is appreciated.

The family seem disappointed however they don't appear to be devastated, they seem very pragmatic people. I'm not aware of all the timetables however I understand they received their school and bursary results a while ago. So I guess by now they've processed their experience and have moved on.

Yes, you're right, hopefully their daughter will keep her head down and will fingers crossed be in a strong position to try again in a few years time at 6th form.

My neighbour's circumstances would appear on paper to be quite compelling, refugees, living in social housing, earning minimum wage, with a child bright enough to be offered a place, but evidently not compelling enough for that place to be funded by the school... I wonder, are the successful applicants those who have both passed the entrance exams and have the very lowest income? Could the fact that my neighbour's have minimum wage jobs actually have counted against them?

I wonder if their income had been 100% funded by state benefits, would this have put them in a stronger position for a bursary?

It's difficult to fathom really...

OP posts:
LIZS · 01/07/2022 18:59

One of our local independents has bursary funding specifically for local housing association tenants.

FourOclock · 01/07/2022 18:55

In my limited experience, 100% bursaries are a lot rarer than partial bursaries. The school we are considering for secondary say they only give 100% bursaries in very exceptional circumstances. I have also known bursaries to go towards children already at the school first, who's financial situation may have changed, to provide them with consistency.

I would say though that in that family's situation, I'd imagine it would be quite difficult on the child to attend the school even with a full bursary. Uniforms for independent schools are extremely expensive, school trips etc will be expensive too and these won't be covered by the bursary. They may also be the only pupil there in council housing for example and feel quite excluded/different to their peers.