Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bursary to attend Independent schools - insights sought

61 replies

User404 · 01/07/2022 15:10

I'd be very grateful for any insight current or former bursars could offer, or from anyone who typically sits on the decision making panels/boards for your independent school. Panels which decide whether to offer a bursary or not, and if an offer is made, how much should be offered.

A neighbour of mine has a 10 year old daughter who was advised by her under performing state primary that her daughter was gifted and that she should consider sitting her daughter for grammar school 11+ exams. Unfortunately we don't live anywhere near any grammar schools.

My neighbour investigated other options and decided to try her for a bursary place at local independent schools. The family are local authority council tenants, former refugees. One parent is able to work full time and works a minimum wage job. The other parent works for minimum wage, part-time, their hours are fitted around their children's school/ nursery hours.

The daughter sat 3 exams and was offered a place at 2x schools (Channing and Francis Holland (I'm unsure which site). However neither school offered her a bursary, as such this extremly bright little girl is now on her way to the local underperforming comprehensive school in September, 2022.

I understand that bursary pots are finite, and there will always be many deserving applicants each year.

I'm particularly interested however in understanding which types of applicants are offered bursaries. I was surprised by my neighbour's experience and I guess I'm trying to rationalise it. If this little girl was not found worthy, can someone venture ideas on which types of applicant are.

Many thanks for reading.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clarinet1 · 23/05/2023 09:42

I think the message of this thread is that individual schools have different policies and different resources to fund bursaries.

BonjourCrisette · 23/05/2023 09:13

nicedaydoreen · 23/05/2023 07:27

How much can you earn and get a bursery?
We have a good income but could never afford private school fees. Mortgage, bills etc make it impossible.
But I hear all the time on Mumsnet about them. Are the state comps full of all the squeezed middle class families now with super rich and poor in private?

Obviously comprehensive schools are not full of all the squeezed middle with all the rich and poor in private schools. For a start, you have to pass the entrance exam for most private schools and some of them are extremely selective. I would guess that any that are not academically selective will not have the money to spend on bursaries in the same way.

The amount you can earn depends very much on the school and on location. For instance, at my daughter's school in London a family can be bringing in up to £110K before becoming ineligible. I guess a family on £110K would be unlikely to get a full bursary though. The only way to say for certain if you would be eligible is to contact the schools and ask. They will be happy to discuss the criteria with you if you tell them about your finances. They are obviously aware that families need somewhere to live and that rent/mortgage payments and living expenses can be pretty high in some areas of the country.

BonjourCrisette · 23/05/2023 09:05

Damnspot · 23/05/2023 08:38

Yes both parents have to work plus they expect you to have approached grandparents etc

This isn't true for all schools. Certainly grandparents' finances play no part in a bursary award at my daughter's school. And although they do expect people to work where possible, they also recognise that specific family circumstances may make this difficult or even impossible in some cases.

Damnspot · 23/05/2023 08:38

GreenwichOrTwicks · 23/05/2023 06:22

At my son's school a bursary requirement is that both parents work full time to avoid people gaming it by artificially reducing their income.

Yes both parents have to work plus they expect you to have approached grandparents etc

Meadowbreeze · 23/05/2023 08:33

Iwanderedlonelyasagoat · 23/05/2023 06:29

Both the schools you mentioned are also not that wealthy in the grand scheme of independent schools and won't have that many students on full bursaries (I don't know this for sure, but I would guess). Girls independent schools tend to have less cash in endowments than the big boys ones, so all their income comes from fee income and they have to raise bursary funds themselves. Lots choose these days to give full not partial bursaries as it attracts the genuinely deserving, which means she might have only been competing for 2 or 3 bursary places in a year group. Someone else might know more about exactly how many bursary students they have in each year group at Channing and Francis Holland. Did they apply to mixed schools? Because e.g. Highgate would have more kids on bursaries. And South Hampstead now has a big fundraising drive for more places, so it's 10% of the cohort as goal for full bursaries moving forward.

Highgate doesn't have that many actually. There's a huge drive to increase numbers but they spend most of that money on outreach with schools like London academy of excellence Tottenham etc

nicedaydoreen · 23/05/2023 07:27

How much can you earn and get a bursery?
We have a good income but could never afford private school fees. Mortgage, bills etc make it impossible.
But I hear all the time on Mumsnet about them. Are the state comps full of all the squeezed middle class families now with super rich and poor in private?

Any1Else · 23/05/2023 06:52

Certainly no local independent day school can compete with the traditional boys’ full boarding schools in terms of financial heft. Had the OP’s neighbour been born a boy she would have stood a good chance of a 100% bursary to the place over the bridge from Windsor. Lots (or at least a sizeable number) of children have those …

Iwanderedlonelyasagoat · 23/05/2023 06:29

Both the schools you mentioned are also not that wealthy in the grand scheme of independent schools and won't have that many students on full bursaries (I don't know this for sure, but I would guess). Girls independent schools tend to have less cash in endowments than the big boys ones, so all their income comes from fee income and they have to raise bursary funds themselves. Lots choose these days to give full not partial bursaries as it attracts the genuinely deserving, which means she might have only been competing for 2 or 3 bursary places in a year group. Someone else might know more about exactly how many bursary students they have in each year group at Channing and Francis Holland. Did they apply to mixed schools? Because e.g. Highgate would have more kids on bursaries. And South Hampstead now has a big fundraising drive for more places, so it's 10% of the cohort as goal for full bursaries moving forward.

GreenwichOrTwicks · 23/05/2023 06:22

At my son's school a bursary requirement is that both parents work full time to avoid people gaming it by artificially reducing their income.

Any1Else · 23/05/2023 06:13

Full and clear answer from @BonjourCrisette. I’m wondering, @Habsmummy, whether you are the holidaying family, or whether you’re looking to ‘dob someone in’ because you don’t think they deserve the financial awards?

As pointed out above, family holidays are an experience that one would want every child to have - and an independent school would not want any pupil’s life to be so far removed from that of their schoolmates that they can find no cultural meeting point. As far as I recall, the bursary application guidance I’ve seen mentions ‘frequent costly / extravagant holidays’ as being inimical to the awarding of a bursary. That doesn’t mean children are expected to spend every two month long summer vacation sitting in a hole in the ground eating worms …

BonjourCrisette · 21/05/2023 23:06

Well, there are holidays abroad and holidays abroad. Are you talking three weeks in the Maldives or a week's package holiday in a cheap hotel in Spain or bargain flights to a property owned by a friend or family and costing very little or maybe just a holiday to visit family abroad? No, it would not necessarily break the terms and conditions. Schools don't necessarily think that a bursary family should not occasionally go on holiday. Do you even know that the family paid for the holiday themselves?

The bursary is to fund education and to ensure that the provision of that education doesn't mean that the family has to go without things that a normal family might be expected to enjoy once in a while. A bursary family would be able to enjoy a yearly holiday that doesn't cost a ridiculous amount without forfeiting the bursary.

If one parent is not working at all I'm guessing there's a reason for this, as most schools would expect anyone capable of work to work. The bursary process is detailed and intrusive and absolutely capable of picking up someone who is gaming the system.

Habsmummy · 21/05/2023 22:15

Bursary question - if a family are offered a free place (half bursary and half scholarship) due to a very low family income (one parent not working at all) but they take holidays abroad, is this allowed? Or does it break the terms and conditions? Very curious. Any bursary families who can answer this?

Hocuspocus77 · 21/07/2022 22:05

Hi I think these bursary’s are very weird in how they work / offer . We were offered 25% off the fees . That’s if they had spaces in September next year and subject to if my child did well and pass the tests .
would they get offered more bursary if did well in the tests ? How comes they like to take peoples money registration forms if not needing a bursary or needing a bursary and knowing they may not have a space anyhow in that intake so weird ?
Also we worked it out today lol 😂 that we got about 80-100 roughly a week to spend after bills but the school obviously think we have 300 and something nearly 400 a week to pay the rest of the school fees a year weird . What we don’t like is why on the form for our particular school they ask about cars houses second houses tax income etc but nothing about bills !
obviously if we had that left over £400 a weekly roughly after the normal things food etc bills etc we would take the offer but why would they think we got that much left over after bills we never put bills down as they wasn’t asked for and no space / columns to write it in . Was we suppose to I don’t know . My husband thinks we should write to the school or email to ask and to see if we can get more fees off !
its so hard knowing what to do .

OP I haven’t got no advice unfortunately. I don’t even understand this all myself etc :(

User404 · 02/07/2022 13:33

starpatch · 02/07/2022 09:54

Bit confused as there are actually a lot of comprehensives in hackney which have good results and outstanding ofsted ratings, probably better to make sure she is on waiting list for one of these if not already.

Hi @starpatch ,

Yes, hopefully they are wait listed for their preferred schools. I'm unsure as to the secondary transfer system, I recall that at primary, children were automatically popped onto the wait list for those schools they had listed and were higher placed in their list of preferences, it's very possible the same happens with secondary.

And yes, they should definitely consider looking at wait lists for all of the schools that they're interested in, whether they featured on the original forms or not.

OP posts:
User404 · 02/07/2022 13:29

LIZS · 02/07/2022 09:14

Presumable she was not wait listed for a bursary, in case someone turned their place with one down.

Oh, I'm unsure, that could be possible, I really don't know

OP posts:
starpatch · 02/07/2022 09:54

Bit confused as there are actually a lot of comprehensives in hackney which have good results and outstanding ofsted ratings, probably better to make sure she is on waiting list for one of these if not already.

LIZS · 02/07/2022 09:14

Presumable she was not wait listed for a bursary, in case someone turned their place with one down.

User404 · 02/07/2022 09:11

Hi @SherbertLemonDrop , thank you for this anecdote, its very heartwarming.

Hi @Hoolihan , I'll be sure to forward on this recommendation, it seems to be very popular on this thread.

Hi @PeanutButterOnToad , I think you're right, current pupils will will take priority over a new cohort. I imagine that school coffers are regularly being tested in recent months and years.

OP posts:
PeanutButterOnToad · 02/07/2022 06:31

In recent years I think that the priority for financial aid from schools has been more focused on making sure existing pupils don't have to leave because of families struggling rather than supporting new pupils like they would have previously. That is certainly the case at DD's school.

Hoolihan · 02/07/2022 01:04

They should absolutely look at Christ's Hospital, it's outstanding and a very high proportion of students are on significant bursaries so there are not the social/cultural issues that you might find at other fee paying schools. It's boarding only though.

SherbertLemonDrop · 02/07/2022 00:59

A lady I knows son attended a posh private school funded for by a couple of local education charities. She wrote to them saying he was gifted and they paid for his schooling. She was/is on benefits and her son did get a small bursary.

User404 · 02/07/2022 00:52

Hi @Meadowbreeze ,

I accept your take on my post, it was written very clumsily. Similar to my reply to @Anothernamechangeplease ; I wish and regularly campaign for the right of all children to attend great local schools, I don't believe my neighbour's daughter is more deserving of a positive educational experience than any other child.

All children should have access to great teachers, a safe environment, in a local state school.

OP posts:
User404 · 02/07/2022 00:44

runningpram · 01/07/2022 23:42

Mossbourne School is in Hackney and gets good results -it operates a lottery system for places as far as I know

Thanks @runningpram , I'm not sure whether Mossborne was on their radar, I know it is very popular.

OP posts:
User404 · 02/07/2022 00:41

Hi @BonjourCrisette , thank you, yes, A'level or IB in a few years may offer an opportunity to really shine as she can hone in on her strengths.

OP posts:
User404 · 02/07/2022 00:36

Hi @Anothernamechangeplease ,

Thank you for contributing to this thread, it's tough trying to communicate on difficult topics like this without jarring someone/people.

I would wish that no child be in a position that they must attend an underperforming school. Every child deserves the opportunity to be exposed to the delights that a well considered and well rounded education can offer them.

My neighbour's daughter is no more deserving of a positive school experience than another child.

I think you're right, my neighbour's are intelligent and thoughtful people who have got themselves and their children this far, their daughter is destined for great things. Their journey into exploring the varying education systems in England was sparked by one teacher, who took an interest, hopefully this child will encounter more adults like that as she progresses through her education. Teachers who care can be found across both state and independent sectors. As long as she is safe at school and her brain and her horizons are expanded, she'll do fine, I'm sure.

OP posts: