Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling very private about my pregnancy with regards to in-laws - AIBU?

91 replies

RougeRosé · 01/07/2022 02:10

Has anyone felt ferociously private about their pregnancy? It's happening to me and I am a little shocked.

I have come to realise that a pregnancy and labour are very intimate things for me and that my body and my new family do not suddenly belong to the public domain just because I'm pregnant. This is something no one ever told me.

I discuss very intimate things like my own insecurities about becoming a mother with people I trust, namely, my DH, my mother and my close friends. I can have more lighthearted conversations with acquaintances (baby names, health issues). But when it comes to my in-laws and strangers, I just shut down. I can't help it.

For context, I will admit that I am no people pleaser. Some things I don't enjoy are:

-Being the centre of attention
-Being touched by people I am not close with
-Cooing over babies
-Having corny (pregnancy) conversations

My MIL makes me the centre of attention in a very anxious way (but it doesn't feel genuine—rather because I'm carrying precious cargo?), rubs my belly even when I cover it with my arms and handbag, wants to exhibit me before her extended family so they can all admire/ touch my bump and say how cute it is (ew), calls me affectionate names since she found out about the pregnancy and absolutely smothers babies with attention—so much that it has made me feel awkward in the past. I just cannot give her the type of bond she craves the same way she cannot give me the adult-to-adult friendship I would like to have with her.

She's a good woman and I feel lucky to have them as PIL, but something doesn't add up/ come across as sincere. I get that they are excited, but why would she/ they become more affectionate with me since we revealed the big news, when we have known each other for a decade? Is it because they have a reason to be extra nice to me now? Unfortunately, that makes me feel like they have ulterior motives.

We have told them about major things like the sex of the baby, the medical evaluation results, the due date and so on. But I can't open up to them about baby names or other things that involve my feelings. I even had covid and we never told them (my DH's call). It comes as a shock for them because the baby is all they ever want to talk about. They will try to talk about other topics but it soon becomes obvious that it's just a warm-up before going back to the main and only topic—the baby. My family is not obsessed like that so it's quite strange.

In fact, it seems like the prospect of having a grandchild has given them a purpose in life, so now they are quite literally just sitting around waiting until they become grandparents. I'm a bit like "hey, I'm just doing my thing, minding my own business—please get a hobby!" I do not want this kind of responsibility/ expectations on me, my family or my unborn child. Do I want them to be loving grandparents? Sure. But I wish they would dial the intensity down, a lot.

DH shares my views mostly.

As a result of all of this, I have been avoiding them since the beginning of the pregnancy. I have visited but not nearly as often as I used to. That way I avoid being ambushed weekly about the nursery and so on. Still they find a way to bring some things up although I clearly don't want to talk about them, so I find myself acting cold and avoidant, which makes the relationship awkward.

Am I being unreasonably for feeling/ acting like this?

OP posts:
MindatWork · 01/07/2022 10:31

I think you’d have received different responses if you’d included the info in your last updates in you op.

My PIL are like this, I love them but they’re so overbearing and overinvested in every practical element of our lives, but offering little emotional support if any kind (while demanding it from DH constantly).

They constantly give opinions on what we should do in a million different situations, from how often to mow the lawn to what cleaning materials to use, what tools to buy etc. MIL in particular is also massively negative and catastrophises all the time (eg we told her we were going to the beach on a day off with DD - her immediate comments were how had the traffic would be and the weather forecast 😒).

We live round the corner but BIL has moved an hour away.

I’d give yourself a few topics that are ‘safe’ to discuss with them and put some clear boundaries in place if they start being overbearing. Good luck!

DaphneeBridgerton · 01/07/2022 10:29

You are not their blood relative, but you are now carrying their blood relative hence why they naturally feel more inclined to be caring, loving and protective towards you.

I have had similar thoughts about my PILs who are MUCH more interested in me now we have DD, but I figure that a child cannot suffer from having too many people who love them in this world, so I suck it up and try to appreciate it.

GodspeedJune · 01/07/2022 10:28

I think it depends what your relationship is like with your in-laws in the first place.

My DP’s parents are separated and I’m a bit wary of one side. They’re asking for my pregnancy appointments and putting the dates and times on their calendar 😳 I don’t like it and feel pressured to update them afterwards. Partly blame DP for giving them that info in the first place.

The other side, his Mum, I genuinely love and have no issues sharing details with her, although she doesn’t ask for the same level of detail in the first place.

Do you feel able to challenge them? It can help to take back control.

SteamingHind · 01/07/2022 10:27

Greenqueen40 · 01/07/2022 03:41

You are grouping your in laws in with strangers, they aren't strangers as they are your unborn child's grandparents
Yab massively u to be like this, they are just as important and linked to this child as your mum and dad are!

As far as discussing personal medical details go, they are strangers. Anyone who thinks OP is unreasonable to not want to discuss her personal issues (sorry, I can't think of a better word) with anyone she is not comfortable discussing them with is beyond contempt. She should be able to discuss these things with who ever she wants to and not with whoever she doesn't want to.

RougeRosé · 01/07/2022 10:24

saraclara · 01/07/2022 09:53

Yes, and this

I think you're reading wayy too much into it that they're being nicer to you because you're carrying precious cargo. I think its more that they're excited and want to be close to you and share in the experience of a new family member. Perhaps your mil sees it as a bonding thing, you'll be a mother too after this.

I think that a lot of MILs see a pregnancy as an opportunity to become closer to their DILs. Finally something that they can bond over. Something they've both experienced - pregnancy and motherhood.

I often see comments on MN where people think that their MILs just see them add a vessel for their GC, but I think that's unlikely in most cases. It's just excitement and something that the MILs feel they can share (in most cases).

I get you on the touching thing though. I didn't want my own mother stroking my bump either. So just say, "Sorry, I really don't like being touched"

Thanks both for sharing your angle. I do take issue with the gene thing, unfortunately, no matter how primordial the feeling. I was expecting them to be excited but I am an individual, not a gene carrier, and my baby will be one as well. The baby will not be someone's purpose in life or someone's toy (you should have seen her interact with a friend's GC—I was shocked).

I KNOW they will shower the baby with love and affection and they will play a big role in their life. I would hate to be the one getting in the way. But I also need to protect my child from being suffocated, and tbh I am wary after seeing how they are with their own children. Anyway, hopefully that won't be the case.

I guess one of the things that I find hard to understand is how this is suddenly an event that is all about them becoming grandparents, while we're trying to figure out logistics and come to terms emotionally with an event that will turn our whole world upside down.

Regarding the bonding—I can see that happening, totally. But once I'm a mother and if my boundaries are respected. I believe these things evolve naturally, you just can't force them.

OP posts:
BeeDavis · 01/07/2022 10:18

Please don’t treat them like this when the baby is born, they are linked to this child just as much as your parents are. I’m surprised your husband isn’t sticking up for them more. I feel bad for them!

CurbsideProphet · 01/07/2022 10:16

I'm pregnant and no one touches my bump apart from me, DH, and my midwife. I would be pretty horrified if either my mum or MIL kept touching me and encouraging other people to touch me 😱

My MIL struggles with how independent I am - meaning I don't need to ask her approval or opinion before we buy furniture or make life decisions. However I would say her relationship with BIL is partly to blame for this, as he and his wife are younger than us and seem happy for her to do things like be involved in what house etc they buy. I will add that I don't ask my own parents for approval on anything, so it's all "fair" in that respect. I don't treat her any differently.

Really your DH needs to put his foot down on anything you feel uncomfortable with, especially the incessant bump touching. He should be saying quite firmly "please stop touching @RougeRosé it's not necessary / polite / makes her uncomfortable".

Gonnagetacatwhenimovein · 01/07/2022 10:16

Sounds like control and power are important to you

RougeRosé · 01/07/2022 10:03

NoSquirrels · 01/07/2022 02:28

I mean, feeling are feelings so you’re never unreasonable to have them - but you sound rather intense in your own way about your privacy and if you’re being cold towards your child’s grandparents then yes, I guess I’d say you acting that way is unreasonable.

Loads of women don’t like having their bodily privacy disrespected (bump touching etc) and it is a bit annoying when all conversational roads lead to pregnancy, birth and baby but nothing you’ve said makes them sound at all unusual or obsessed. I suspect you don’t feel your own family behaves this way just because they’re used to your boundaries and recognise your (possible) anxieties and are used to managing that in a relationship with you, like all parents are with their children. Ironically, if you’d open up a bit more to your in-laws they’d be more likely to back off.

Your pregnancy isn’t the defining thing about you and it’s OK to feel private about intimate things. Loads of people don’t like to discuss baby names - I personally think it should be a rule not to, pre-birth! But decorating a nursery, baby equipment like prams etc - there’s always something you can let them in on that’s not intimate or private. Have a think about what you can include them in, instead of lumping them in with ‘strangers’ in your mind and shutting them out.

Yes, definitely. My family "gets me", and also my mother is quite good at listening and respecting boundaries in general. I'm sure that this also played a role in my personality growing up. I am introverted but friendly most of the time. But I hate feeling managed or finding people inhabiting my life.

You said that all parents manage their kids' anxieties—well, my PILs are not very good at that (see my previous post). They have had big arguments about boundary breaching in the past. They have been incredibly intrusive and pushy with their children about some very personal topics, so much that the children withdraw from them for months. Witnessing that made me see them under a different light entirely.

Thank you. I have been thinking about stuff that's not private that we can share with them so they don't feel too excluded. I will try to visit soon and discuss these things. I am however afraid they will take it as an invitation to move on to more personal topics or give unsolicited advice.

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 01/07/2022 10:03

No one should be touching you without your express permission and if they don’t stop that’s as good a reason as any to keep away from them. They’ll be the same with your baby, they sound the type to pick them up when they’re sleeping or not give them back when they’re crying or need a feed.

It’s good your DH is on the same page. Breastfeed if you want to, buy a sling, prepare to respond with “we’re doing what suits us and the baby”, “that’s interesting but we’re following the current guidance”, “no thank you”, “I don’t want to discuss that again thanks” to their inevitable interference and remember at all times you’re the parents and you get to make all the decisions about their care and upbringing.

I expect you’ve got some bumpy months ahead, keep talking to DH and standing your ground.

saraclara · 01/07/2022 09:53

Tranquilsea · 01/07/2022 02:34

She is excited about being a grandmother, it's natural. I can only comment from my own point of view. It's an almost primordial feeling - my genes are being carried on and it was like a purpose in life and I absolutely adore my grandchildren. Cut her some slack, she can't help it. Congratulations on your pregnancy!

Yes, and this

I think you're reading wayy too much into it that they're being nicer to you because you're carrying precious cargo. I think its more that they're excited and want to be close to you and share in the experience of a new family member. Perhaps your mil sees it as a bonding thing, you'll be a mother too after this.

I think that a lot of MILs see a pregnancy as an opportunity to become closer to their DILs. Finally something that they can bond over. Something they've both experienced - pregnancy and motherhood.

I often see comments on MN where people think that their MILs just see them add a vessel for their GC, but I think that's unlikely in most cases. It's just excitement and something that the MILs feel they can share (in most cases).

I get you on the touching thing though. I didn't want my own mother stroking my bump either. So just say, "Sorry, I really don't like being touched"

Mariposista · 01/07/2022 09:52

Not unreasonable OP. I would absolutely hate this. You sound like a 'let's just get on with it' kind of girl, and not every conversation has to be about the baby. And I would hate getting felt up too.

RougeRosé · 01/07/2022 09:50

Regarding our relationship—I wanted to add that all this asking about how we are managing our lives is layered with a LOT of anxiety (they are both very anxious). It's very hard to have a conversation with someone who is so intensely focused on getting as much information from you as possible while managing everything from the amount of food that you are eating to your relationship with your sister in law sitting next to you while also being perceived as a great PIL, because surely you'll keep visiting often. There's just no chill.

We do end up feeling like our ability to be adults is being scrutinised (and most of the time, we don't pass the test).

I do realise that intentions are what really matters and that this is their love language. I feel grateful to have them as PIL because it could be much much worse. But still I feel the need to establish boundaries.

OP posts:
SemperIdem · 01/07/2022 09:43

I felt like you did when I was pregnant. As a pp suggested about you, I am indeed a bit uptight. That doesn’t make how I felt, or how you feel wrong though.

More introverted personalities are always expected to tolerate the extroverted without much/any consideration given to their feelings.

RougeRosé · 01/07/2022 09:35

mumorworkduties · 01/07/2022 02:16

How was your relationship with them prior to getting pregnant?

Will this be their first grandchild?

Congrats on your pregnancy Smile

Hi mumorworkduties,

Thank you!

Answering this for you and everyone else who inquired abour our relationship.

It was OK but they do have their boundary/ trust issues with their own adult children—which has an indirect impact on our relationship. Generally though it's amicable. Problem is that neither their children nor myself feel really seen by them. They don't understand or care about us as adults. They avoid conversations about interests or hobbies or anything they don't understand. They just focus on everything practical and sometimes that can feel like they want to manage us like kids: constantly encouraging that we eat enough during meals, constantly asking if we did this or that in the new apartment ("Did you buy the windows yet"? "They they put in the doors"? "Were the tiles delivered"?), insisting that we return a car that we bought... They are like this with all their children and it pushes them away. It's not terrible but it's annoying because I have my own parents and our relationship has evolved enough over the years to give me space to be an adult. I mean, if their own kids find it frustrating, what's it like to a DIL/ SIL then?

All in all I can see that they have good intentions at heart. But they are very stubborn in insisting to treat us this way even when we constantly show that the dynamic is not working for us. Their need to baby us is stronger than whatever we might feel or need.

OP posts:
FunDragon · 01/07/2022 05:58

Well your feelings are valid. And you certainly shouldn’t be touched or displayed to other people when you don’t want to be. It’s also frustrating when you’re pregnant and people only want to talk baby, but I think it’s often their way of trying to show interest in you.

I don’t think you would be unreasonable to set boundaries in a firm kind way.

But do bear in mind that if they’re genuinely good people who are interested in being grandparents - which you say they are - then they’re likely to be a huge benefit to you and to the baby when it arrives. I have a toddler and a baby and I can’t tell you what I’d give for invested grandparents (on either side). A child can’t have too many people to love it.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 01/07/2022 04:45

You feel how you feel and I do believe you have a right not to have your belly rubbed etc if it makes you uncomfortable.

but. Treating your in laws like strangers and not even giving them the same level of information as your work colleagues is a bit harsh. They’re excited about their grandchild and that’s understandable. I wonder what you’ll be like with them once the babies born? Hopefully once it’s outside of your body you’ll feel a bit happier for them to be involved.

remember they will love this baby in the same way your parents will. Try not to cut the off if they’re genuinely good people.

LetitiaLeghorn · 01/07/2022 04:35

she’s just the meat sack bringing the baby into the world.

Golly. Really? That's an excessive remark.
Her in laws are excited. They talk to her about the baby not like she doesn't exist Maybe it's difficult to understand my reaction to lumping people you like in with strangers if you don't like your in laws?
Anyway neither of us are going to change our thoughts on this so no point discussing it further.

yzed · 01/07/2022 04:31

I don't understand why people seem to think your rights have disappeared. Several posters seem to be demonstrating exactly what you're struggling with. You said many times in your post that for ten years you've got on well with your PILs. But now they're smothering you. Perhaps that's what you should say to them, that you're feeling smothered, but try to be a bit general about who (ie don't say it's them, but do say what.) You could say you don't like how people stroke your belly, and ask over-personal questions. She's likely to understand your dilemma, and start asking if certain things are okay with you. Be sure to speak up and don't pretend it's okay. And if you're lucky, when she backs off a bit you may begin to feel more relaxed about some things.

Congratulations on your pregnancy, and I wish you joy.
Flowers

ReeseWitherfork · 01/07/2022 04:27

She feels comfortable chatting with acquaintances about baby names but not her mil. The op says she's fiercely private about her pregnancy and hates baby discussions but is doing that with acquaintances so can't hate it that much.

I’m the same with my in laws. In my comment I wrote:

I can handle it a lot easier when they’re being intrusive about which new towel set I buy or what I have for dinner. It’s not that they think they have a right to an input on those things, it’s like they forget they won’t be using the towels or eating the dinner, and that I don’t really need to factor their opinions and preferences into the decisions.

The comparison here is that my MIL would think she had equal input on the name of the baby. She’ll be tenacious and relentless about her suggestions. It becomes uncomfortable and tedious, and unfortunately makes me want to shut down completely.

This isn’t the OP just deciding to be an asshole for no reason. This is the OP saying that they’re crossing boundaries into an uncomfortable place for her and it’s making her clam up.

stuntbubbles · 01/07/2022 04:23

And? She can like them and feel lucky to have them and also not want them to parade her around, commenting on her bump, rubbing her, and speaking exclusively about the baby as though OP herself no longer exists, she’s just the meat sack bringing the baby into the world.

Perhaps she’s more comfortable discussing the pregnancy with acquaintances because they don’t do all those things, and thus has listed her in-laws in the same category as strangers in the Venn diagram of “people I don’t want to discuss my pregnancy with”. She’s still not categorising them AS strangers. Just as people she wants to back off and have some boundaries with. You can like people AND set boundaries with them.

LetitiaLeghorn · 01/07/2022 04:17

They’re a “free gift with purchase” that I got with DP that I didn’t want and couldn’t decline.

But that's not the case here. The op says she's lucky to have her in laws.

LetitiaLeghorn · 01/07/2022 04:16

Well, because you don't opt to have inlaws in your life the same way you do other friends and acquaintes.

But she says "She's a good woman and I feel lucky to have them as PIL" so she does get on with them. She feels comfortable chatting with acquaintances about baby names but not her mil. I do think that's harsh on the grandparents. The op says she's fiercely private about her pregnancy and hates baby discussions but is doing that with acquaintances so can't hate it that much. Even if I didn't like my in laws, which is not the case here, I still wouldn't treat them like I would strangers.

ReeseWitherfork · 01/07/2022 04:13

Could have written your post myself. I love my in laws but my goodness they’re intrusive. About everything!!! But there was something about pregnancy that made me shut down even more. It’s just so personal. In my last pregnancy, MIL was telling half the town that she was anxious about my induction and that I should be having a CS. I was fuming!

I can’t really give advice on how I dealt with it (and continue to deal with it). Every big thing to happen in my life (house purchases, wedding, even holidays) has been the same and it makes me want to push them away completely, but they pick up on the energy, and then they sulk. Not in an obvious way, in a very sly emotionally manipulative way.

I can handle it a lot easier when they’re being intrusive about which new towel set I buy or what I have for dinner. It’s not that they think they have a right to an input on those things, it’s like they forget they won’t be using the towels or eating the dinner, and that I don’t really need to factor their opinions and preferences into the decisions.

You said they’re cold and avoidant. I’m the same. The only way I’ve found to combat this is to be particularly enthusiastic about something when we’re first together. Initiate conversation about something neutral, and be chatty and pleasant. And as soon as the conversation turns to your pregnancy: put up whatever boundary you’re comfortable with even if it makes you cold. If you come across as an asshole then so what. You could always then revert the conversation to something pregnancy related that’s more lighthearted. “I’ve finally washed all the new babygrows, such a cute load of laundry.”

Also… I hate the comments on this thread like “you’re uptight” and “I loved the attention (so you’re a weirdo!)”. Extroverts never get this kind of thing. For introverts, this sort of attention is hell on earth. And that doesn’t make us weird or uptight!!!

stuntbubbles · 01/07/2022 04:12

LetitiaLeghorn · 01/07/2022 04:01

She doesn’t say her in-laws are strangers, she says “in-laws and strangers”

Treating your in laws the same as you would strangers is pretty harsh, though. If your in laws treated your children the same as strangers would you think that was ok?

My in-laws are related to my children; they’re not related to me. They’re a “free gift with purchase” that I got with DP that I didn’t want and couldn’t decline.

Swipe left for the next trending thread