Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A tax question for pro-life believers

32 replies

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 20:05

If there were a vote to allow/not allow abortion, and in order to vote not allowed, you had to commit to paying an extra 5% tax in order to fund free childcare as well as better maternity pay and an increase/restoration of child nenefit, would you still vote Not to allow ???

Obviously the cost /cost of childcare is only one of many reasons not to want to go ahead with an unplanned pregnancy. I do realise this.

Aibu - i hold pro life views and i would not be prepared to pay any more tax

Not being unreasonable - i am pro life but understand that bringing children in to the world is hugely expensive and women shouldn't be left to bear the cost/lose freedom to earn.

Disclaimer, obviously i am pro choice so to me being pro life is unreasonable but hopefully this question makes sense

OP posts:
DoYouRememberTheInnMiranda · 30/06/2022 20:24

Do you mean everyone would have to pay the extra, or just the pro-lifers?

It feels to me a bit like asking people to vote for whether slavery should be banned or not, but those who vote in favour of banning have to pay 50% more for their goods, to compensate for the extra cost of labour.

Pro lifers aren't wanting to ban it because they want to inconvenience people, but because they believe it is murder. The result of banning abortion may mean society needs to pay extra tax for childcarer, just as how banning slavery meant everyone had to pay more for goods. But that cost should fall on everyone, not just those who can see it's immoral.

Not everyone believed slavery was wrong when it was banned, doesn't mean it should have been left to everyone's conscience whether they have a slave or not.

Namechanger355 · 30/06/2022 20:22

I’m firmly pro choice

but I think a lot of people who are anti-abortion would be willing to pay the additional tax because they firmly believe the foetus’s life is more important than the woman’s and nothing will change that

also I think there would still be many abortions even if there was free childcare

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 20:19

Whatsboutery?
The assumption that women lose their freedom, their earning potential or pay huge unaffordable childcare is not whataboutery.

OP posts:
PurpleDaisies · 30/06/2022 20:15

When will all these whataboutery threads end?

I think you’re misunderstanding the majority of people with anti abortion views (to the point of wanting it banned) if you think a significant number would be bothered about a bit more tax.

I also don’t think many women would be persuaded not to have an abortion of childcare was a bit cheaper.

BiscuitLover3678 · 30/06/2022 20:14

I find this debate generally pretty awful and I don’t think it as black and white as both sides make out.

But the part of me that is pro-life would very much want to play extra tax! One of my biggest issues with pro life is what would happen to all those women and babies 🥲 plus I’m a big believer in tax anyway. I’ve seen a lot of poverty mess through work (I had a nice childhood) and wouldn’t wish it on anyone.

Child abuse and poverty is incredibly upsetting to me so tbh I wish we paid more towards it anyway.

NrlySp · 30/06/2022 20:11

I would vote for the free childcare. In the USA there are already many organizations (mainly Christian) providing nappies, clothing, Amazon Gift lists etc to pregnant women.
I would support that being provided to.
motherhood is undervalued as it is anyway.

FunDragon · 30/06/2022 20:10

I’m not the demographic your AIBU is aimed at because I’m firmly pro-choice, but it’s a fair question. I suspect the answer will be no (because it’s not really about protecting babies but about controlling women).

Without wanting to derail the thread please can we stop using the term ‘pro-life’? It’s manipulative and nasty because it implies that the opposite is ‘pro-death’ or ‘anti-life’. Just use the term ‘anti-abortion’ which is clear and factual.