Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A tax question for pro-life believers

32 replies

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 20:05

If there were a vote to allow/not allow abortion, and in order to vote not allowed, you had to commit to paying an extra 5% tax in order to fund free childcare as well as better maternity pay and an increase/restoration of child nenefit, would you still vote Not to allow ???

Obviously the cost /cost of childcare is only one of many reasons not to want to go ahead with an unplanned pregnancy. I do realise this.

Aibu - i hold pro life views and i would not be prepared to pay any more tax

Not being unreasonable - i am pro life but understand that bringing children in to the world is hugely expensive and women shouldn't be left to bear the cost/lose freedom to earn.

Disclaimer, obviously i am pro choice so to me being pro life is unreasonable but hopefully this question makes sense

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
tirednessbecomesme · 01/07/2022 19:04

I think there should be reform to childcare provision- eg why in Europe is it so much cheaper? Presumably the government heavily subsidises nurseries? And also child benefit - it's ridiculous a household of 2 jointly bringing in £100k can claim but a single household bringing in £60k cannot. But it shouldn't have anything to do with abortion. I don't really see how the 2 are linked TBH. The cost of raising children doesn't begin and end with nursery fees and a paltry £22 per week CB doesn't make a dent in the cost of raising a child.

OMG12 · 01/07/2022 19:01

I think a more realistic question would be, if you voted against abortion would you still vote that way if you had to adopt a child or completely sponsor a child to live with its birth mother when otherwise there would have been an abortion, would you also be willing to pay for treatment for any physical and/or psychological issues arising from forcing a woman to have a baby. Would you also be willing to pay additional taxes to cover all the additional services, health, education etc for the rest of that child’s life? Would you be willing to cut your carbon foot print, eg not flying, getting rid of your car to try and slightly compensate for that extra person. And would you be happy for a house to be built in your garden to help house the additional people. You must also cut down on food, clothing etc.

UnimpeachableBravery · 01/07/2022 18:41

How would this even work when voting is anonymous?

Valeriekat · 01/07/2022 18:28

Contraception is free in the UK (unlike in America). Grown ups should use adequate contraception most of the time. Abortion I would hope would be a last resort because contraception failed, circumstances changed or rape/coercion.
As we used to say...every child a wanted child.

Famalamabunfight · 30/06/2022 21:36

Over 210,000 abortions happened in the UK last year, though of course that’s a small percentage of the 40 million that happen each year. Seems a little excessive to me and I would pay more tax to get that down

Dinoteeth · 30/06/2022 21:33

DaisyDozyDee · 30/06/2022 20:38

I’m pro-choice and think it should actually be a choice. No one should have to have a child they don’t want, but equally no one should have to abort a wanted child for financial reasons.

Well said!

Nobody should be forced into abortion for financial reasons but at the same time I do agree with the limit on the number of children the state are prepared to support.
So many families who are scraping by but not entitled to benefits end up doing their family planning around finances. It seems unfair that families on benefits can just expect more cash for more children.

MrsRinaDecker · 30/06/2022 21:27

I think it’s a reasonable question, especially given the huge spike in terminations since the two child limit was introduced for most benefits.
FWIW I don’t really identify as pro life or pro choice, but I am..


  • pro education

  • pro contraception

  • pro consent

  • pro healthcare

  • pro welfare

  • pro programs that support victims of domestic abuse, trafficking, prostitution, and drug addiction

  • pro improved maternity (and paternity) leave

  • pro a fully funded and functional social work department, including overhauling adoption policy, so that it’s a genuine option, but not a baby mill for rich white women

I do believe in policies (as above) that cut abortions, by preventing unwanted pregnancy, but I also believe it should still be available - a necessary evil if you like - as banning it doesn’t stop abortion happening, it merely blocks access to safe, legal abortion.

PurpleDaisies · 30/06/2022 21:15

What are you hoping to get out of this thread? I’m genuinely asking.

Do you expect many of the anti abortioners to say they don’t want their taxes put up to this reason? What then?

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 21:12

daretodenim · 30/06/2022 20:56

So this is a tax to remove women's right to bodily autonomy? Oh I'm sure there are many out there who would find a 5% tax increase cheap for that.

I know that's not your point, but that's exactly what the reality would be I'm afraid.

No, it's not handing over autonomy in exchange for chilcare, i was clearly and only asking if pro lifers would "put their money where there mouth was", in a vote. Ie, pay more tax to acknowle the costs of what they consider ideal..
There was a vote in ireland in 2018. So it's not a ridiculous concept.

OP posts:
x2boys · 30/06/2022 20:56

PurpleDaisies · 30/06/2022 20:26

Sorry I don’t think I articulated well what I meant.

There seems to be hypothetical scenario after hypothetical scenario posts aimed at getting a “gotcha” on people with religious anti abortion views.

It seems like a massive distraction from the actual issue at hand. Whether someone who is anti abortion is happy to pay for a women forced to give birth’s childcare is irrelevant because that women should NEVER be forced to give birth. (Most) women don’t seem to be choosing abortions because of childcare costs.

I have to agree with you ,women choose to terminate pregnancies for many different reasons it's not always financial
I watched a really interesting documentary on sky last weeks about s group of women in the 60,s and 70,s who helped other women access safe illegal abortions ,they called themselves the "Janes" although they did a remarkable thing ,it's so sad that society in America is going backwards, and whilst their practices were safe many were not

daretodenim · 30/06/2022 20:56

So this is a tax to remove women's right to bodily autonomy? Oh I'm sure there are many out there who would find a 5% tax increase cheap for that.

I know that's not your point, but that's exactly what the reality would be I'm afraid.

BigFatLiar · 30/06/2022 20:45

restedbutexhausted · 30/06/2022 20:38

Why would you stop those things? That's not going to stop women getting pregnant. As someone who needs both of those things I find that comment extremely heartless. Haven't you noticed what's going on around you?

OP was asking if we'd raise the taxes to fund these, simply pointing out you could simply do away with them if the tax cost was too high.

gnilliwdog · 30/06/2022 20:44

I thought I was pro choice, as I think we should have abortion available as we do in the UK. Then I came across pro choice people who seem to believe the mother's of unwanted children and the world itself, would be better off if those children had been terminated in the womb. They do not believe the foetus is a life. So, maybe I am a bit pro life too. I don't want to ban abortion, but I would like all those benefits for mothers you mention, and would happily pay more tax.

Pumperthepumper · 30/06/2022 20:44

PurpleDaisies · 30/06/2022 20:26

Sorry I don’t think I articulated well what I meant.

There seems to be hypothetical scenario after hypothetical scenario posts aimed at getting a “gotcha” on people with religious anti abortion views.

It seems like a massive distraction from the actual issue at hand. Whether someone who is anti abortion is happy to pay for a women forced to give birth’s childcare is irrelevant because that women should NEVER be forced to give birth. (Most) women don’t seem to be choosing abortions because of childcare costs.

I totally agree. The main argument should be ‘women should be allowed to choose what happens to their body’, not a series of ‘how hypocritical are anti-abortionists’.

restedbutexhausted · 30/06/2022 20:38

BigFatLiar · 30/06/2022 20:30

Absolutely nothing to do with abortion.

Why not just stop free childcare and child benefit?

Why would you stop those things? That's not going to stop women getting pregnant. As someone who needs both of those things I find that comment extremely heartless. Haven't you noticed what's going on around you?

DaisyDozyDee · 30/06/2022 20:38

I’m pro-choice and think it should actually be a choice. No one should have to have a child they don’t want, but equally no one should have to abort a wanted child for financial reasons.

Dancingwithhyenas · 30/06/2022 20:34

At the moment I’m not sure women always have a truly free choice because the economic penalty is so very high. So I’m pro choice (within the limits we have in the UK) but also pro life.

Dancingwithhyenas · 30/06/2022 20:32

I’m pro life in that I see it as sad but I wouldn’t want to ban abortion. I’d want to improve access to contraception, increase every kind of family support from paid leave to housing to childcare to disability support so that the number of women who choose abortion is less and less without controlling anyone. Just though improved support.

…and I vote Labour (who will tax me more) because I want the party that most likely will do more of the above.

PurpleDaisies · 30/06/2022 20:32

To have the absolutely crucial question 'who pays' (,The woman, one way or another) dismissed as whataboutery makes me see im pushing water uphill

This is where I think you’re wrong. Who pays is not the crucial question. It’s who decides. Women should be able to decide to end a pregnancy and whether someone else is prepared to pay for a baby they don’t want to carry is irrelevant at best and at worst, accepting that it’s a legitimate source of debate.

What happens if all the anti abortion posters say they’re happy to pay more tax to save babies (which they probably will)? Does that mean that we can go ahead and ban abortion because childcare costs are sorted? This is why I think this sort of thread does no favours to the pro choice argument.

BigFatLiar · 30/06/2022 20:30

Absolutely nothing to do with abortion.

Why not just stop free childcare and child benefit?

lljkk · 30/06/2022 20:28

American women are quipping when can they start claiming their embryos as dependents (additional tax exempt allowance) on their tax returns. Could they use estimated date of conception in lieu of birthdate, and when can the register the embryo for a social security number.

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 20:28

FunDragon · 30/06/2022 20:10

I’m not the demographic your AIBU is aimed at because I’m firmly pro-choice, but it’s a fair question. I suspect the answer will be no (because it’s not really about protecting babies but about controlling women).

Without wanting to derail the thread please can we stop using the term ‘pro-life’? It’s manipulative and nasty because it implies that the opposite is ‘pro-death’ or ‘anti-life’. Just use the term ‘anti-abortion’ which is clear and factual.

I agreevwith you. I was trying to be respectful to a group that doesn't respect women.

I will give up now. To have the absolutely crucial question 'who pays' (,The woman, one way or another) dismissed as whataboutery makes me see im pushing water uphill.

OP posts:
SlagathaChristie · 30/06/2022 20:27

And yes, I'd pay extra tax (although I'd like to see less of my current tax pissed up the wall first....looking at that subsidised Westminster bar and all those lucrative Stonewall contracts...)

PurpleDaisies · 30/06/2022 20:26

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 20:19

Whatsboutery?
The assumption that women lose their freedom, their earning potential or pay huge unaffordable childcare is not whataboutery.

Sorry I don’t think I articulated well what I meant.

There seems to be hypothetical scenario after hypothetical scenario posts aimed at getting a “gotcha” on people with religious anti abortion views.

It seems like a massive distraction from the actual issue at hand. Whether someone who is anti abortion is happy to pay for a women forced to give birth’s childcare is irrelevant because that women should NEVER be forced to give birth. (Most) women don’t seem to be choosing abortions because of childcare costs.

SlagathaChristie · 30/06/2022 20:26

JustW0nderingWh0Pays · 30/06/2022 20:19

Whatsboutery?
The assumption that women lose their freedom, their earning potential or pay huge unaffordable childcare is not whataboutery.

Yes, having a child is difficult and expensive. I still don't like the idea of killing them in the womb (or outside of it), even if they do reduce a woman's capitalist earning potential...