Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For agreeing to a dog I do not want!

167 replies

Hotair1234 · 30/06/2022 18:59

Just that really. Grew up with big dogs and they just give me the ick, the smell, the poop, the drool, everything.

I know that’s already made me a horrible person but I dont dislike dogs per se, just don’t ever want to live with one. Have cats.

Dd(15) has been desperate for a dog for years. I’ve always been very firm against but recently come up again as her mental health has taken an absolute dive the last few years. Have spent year going on and on about the responsibility/commitment, she’s still keen.

As a reward for sh*y hospital visit I agreed to go to a rescue centre (secretly hoping smell and staff going on about responsibility would be off putting) but I was also aware we might end up with a little dog - like Maltese or chihuahua or something, but she fell in love with a huge bloody collie!!!! 🥺🥺🥺Wouldn’t be swayed by anything cute.

Booked in to go and collect him next week and am completely dreading it. I know it’s everything she needs and couldn’t be more sure about the commitment but I hate the idea now, will hate the idea more next week.

Aibu to still live with a dog I don’t want?? Has anyone else been here but ended up liking? Help 😭😭😭

OP posts:
SurferRona · 30/06/2022 21:54

Foster. You can help the dogs, and their families, who need it. Your daughter gets the support but the dogs go home to their family after a while. Up to you if you continue, you can take a break etc. Can stop when daughter leaves.

oakleaffy · 30/06/2022 21:52

collieresponder88 · 30/06/2022 21:43

Collies are lovely highly intelligent dogs but they need an awful lot of attention and exercise! I think a greyhound would be a better fit They sleep most of the day away and are more than happy with a Trot round the block. They don't drool either.

I agree.. A small greyhound is a far more suitable choice. Greys are calm and cat like. Sleep a lot, don't need much exercise.

Pallisers · 30/06/2022 21:52

Seriously don't do it. We got a dog after much pressure from dd. But she was 8 and I was prepared to have a dog. I chose the breed - small. I took the hit of organising dog care, working from home, having the dog follow me around all the time, being responsible for his walks etc., organising holidays around him, paying for someone to mind him when we are away. My dd, aged 8 wasn't capable of doing any of this and neither is your dd aged 15.

At 15 that same dd had a lot of MH issues - quite serious ones. The dog was not a help. She had nothing left over to mind the dog or pay attention to him other than an odd tickle. the other kids who didn't have issues were way more capable.

This is a bad idea for everyone, including the dog.

ToastedCrumpetwithCheese · 30/06/2022 21:51

I would cancel on the collie, but maybe not on a dog quite yet. I would get your daughter to start doing a load of breed research; which dog breeds suit your family's lifestyle and I would look at fostering, rescue centre dog walking (if you can take your daughter) and/or Borrow My Doggy. It would give your daughter a taster without the full-time committment.

galaxyqueen · 30/06/2022 21:50

PoseyFlump · 30/06/2022 21:31

@galaxyqueen 😂 oh alright then! But you know the best person for prime minister is someone who doesn't want the job..... that's not going to persuade you is it?!

Ha! But I guess it's so easy to judge. I probably would be shouting a dog who was weeping and pooing in the house.

oakleaffy · 30/06/2022 21:50

Muminabun · 30/06/2022 21:07

I have dogs and I know they can be a pain in the arse but collies are different. They are so clever and in tune. I am inclined to think that this could work out.it could really be the therapy dog you are looking for and collies in my view are a higher level dog that can provide exceptional company.

Collies re absolutely the WORST type of dog for this situation.
They need so much work, dedication and stimulation if they aren't to become a problem.
This one has already had one home, and been given up on.
OP doesn't want a dog.
a PP have said, a collie is the worst sort to get.

Successful collie owners are absolutely dedicated to training and working their dog.

Adventurine · 30/06/2022 21:46

Don't do it. I have a big Alsatian I didn't want, I absolutely hate the dribbling, farting, stinking, hairy, muddy mess of it all. Mine is 4 and I'm never ever ever living with a dog again after this one is no longer with us. Husband and kids adore the dog they feed and take out and pick up shut after once in a blue moon. I, the cat lover who has somehow been handed 90% of the dog care, do most definitely not.

collieresponder88 · 30/06/2022 21:43

Collies are lovely highly intelligent dogs but they need an awful lot of attention and exercise! I think a greyhound would be a better fit They sleep most of the day away and are more than happy with a Trot round the block. They don't drool either.

bishbashboshhhhh · 30/06/2022 21:43

I wouldn’t adopt from a rescue that thinks novice owners would work well with a collie tbh

oakleaffy · 30/06/2022 21:40

It sounds a pretty crap ''Rescue'' if it's letting you choose.

Decent rescues ''Marry up'' a suitable dog with the potential people who want one's lifestyles.

Aquamarine1029 · 30/06/2022 21:40

Your post was very clear. Can't imagine what you think any of us misread.

Highfivemum · 30/06/2022 21:39

Wot a tricky situation. If you pull out your DD will be devastated and even though as some will say that’s not the point the fact is you have said she has suffered a lot over the years and this will not help.
To be honest you agreed to look at rescue. You were not forced and you didn’t have to agree to a large dog that could have been the compromise. I think it would be cruel to back out now. You have had dogs and if your daughter does the keg work it will do her good. My DH was not to keen on getting a dog and yet now our Dog is his shadow and he adores her.

bellac11 · 30/06/2022 21:33

Hotair1234 · 30/06/2022 21:27

Thankyou. You clearly misread my post but I appreciate you feeling strongly enough to advise.

Beg pardon?

oakleaffy · 30/06/2022 21:32

@Hotair1234
PLEASE DO NOT GET A COLLIE.
Someone I know got one, pestered by her kids, she gave in, got the Collie, and it has been a disaster for the poor dog.

Kids lost interest fast.
A Collie needs masses of stimulation, both mental and physical to keep it sane.
Their once smart house looks a shadow of it's former self. The dog is bored and neurotic.
She barks. A lot. They have fitted an anti bark collar to her. Not fair.

Chewed doors, trashed garden, where the dog just paces a circle around it.{stereotypies} constantly & manically.

Don't, if you love dogs, get a collie.

They are for absolutely dedicated, committed owners who do sports like flyball or agility and who Devote hours a day to their dog, OR the owners work sheep or cattle.
I'm shocked the rescue centre is even countenancing a collie.

shockthemonkey · 30/06/2022 21:32

Dogs are not good mental-health props for young teenagers.

You're sentencing yourself to 14 years, let's be realistic, of looking after a dog you don't want.

I am sorry but there is no way this would work.

Etinoxaurus · 30/06/2022 21:31

A dog is a fantastic idea. Just not this one - unless possibly it’s an older bearded collie.
Phone the rescue and tell them dad has fallen in love with the dog but you can’t regime it due to size and temperament. They’re naughty to let you pick- Battersea offers particular dogs. Ask the rescue to suggest a different one, perhaps visiting without her and tell her the Rescue want to place her with a family better suited not care for her.
I’d recommend a smaller maybe older dog. Flowers

PoseyFlump · 30/06/2022 21:31

@Amipreg1 I don't think the OP said she couldn't show the dog love?

PoseyFlump · 30/06/2022 21:31

@galaxyqueen 😂 oh alright then! But you know the best person for prime minister is someone who doesn't want the job..... that's not going to persuade you is it?!

Hotair1234 · 30/06/2022 21:27

Thankyou. You clearly misread my post but I appreciate you feeling strongly enough to advise.

OP posts:
Amipreg1 · 30/06/2022 21:26

I adore dogs and can't imagine my life without but please don't agree to getting one if you aren't going to be able to show it love and give it affection/ attention. It's not fair on the dog.

You should have never given your daughter hope if you knew it wouldn't work for you

rookiemere · 30/06/2022 21:24

I'm amazed you were accepted by the rescue centre tbh.
What age is the dog - apologies if you have said ?

I think a lie about the rescue centre having rehomed elsewhere, or you failing the home check is the way to go.

Maybe an elderly greyhound? My friend has one and says it needs one walk a day and just snuggles the rest of the time.

galaxyqueen · 30/06/2022 21:23

PoseyFlump · 30/06/2022 21:20

@galaxyqueen I would argue that as you've instantly recognised your neighbour's shortcomings you're more than likely to make an excellent dog owner Smile

Ohno!! 😂 I want to enjoy my life. I love being spontaneous, sleeping, going on holidays and saving money! I cannot in no way shape or form afford to have a dog.

Myotherusernamesafunnyone · 30/06/2022 21:22

This is a really big mistake. Please don't do it. It's not fair on anyone involved.

ZooKeeper19 · 30/06/2022 21:22

@Hotair1234 OP could you talk to your DD and say she can try and foster some doggies first? See if she can shoulder the responsibility, wake-ups, poo cleaning, dog walking, training etc.

I love dogs and I got a dog at 15 that my mum also was not thrilled about but I spent 16 years begging (yes I swear I started before I was born) and she caved. I took excellent care of that dog every bloody day. So your DD may surprise you.

But if you are in doubt, try the foster route first Good luck!

Happenchance · 30/06/2022 21:22

OP, your daughter is probably too young to volunteer in a dog rescue but you could volunteer for the Cinnamon Trust and take your daughter with you when you walk the dog(s). Alternatively, the Cinnamon Trust and the Dogs Trust Freedom Project are always looking for short term fosterers, which could help both you and your daughter decide if a dog is for you.