Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For agreeing to a dog I do not want!

167 replies

Hotair1234 · 30/06/2022 18:59

Just that really. Grew up with big dogs and they just give me the ick, the smell, the poop, the drool, everything.

I know that’s already made me a horrible person but I dont dislike dogs per se, just don’t ever want to live with one. Have cats.

Dd(15) has been desperate for a dog for years. I’ve always been very firm against but recently come up again as her mental health has taken an absolute dive the last few years. Have spent year going on and on about the responsibility/commitment, she’s still keen.

As a reward for sh*y hospital visit I agreed to go to a rescue centre (secretly hoping smell and staff going on about responsibility would be off putting) but I was also aware we might end up with a little dog - like Maltese or chihuahua or something, but she fell in love with a huge bloody collie!!!! 🥺🥺🥺Wouldn’t be swayed by anything cute.

Booked in to go and collect him next week and am completely dreading it. I know it’s everything she needs and couldn’t be more sure about the commitment but I hate the idea now, will hate the idea more next week.

Aibu to still live with a dog I don’t want?? Has anyone else been here but ended up liking? Help 😭😭😭

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WallaceinAnderland · 17/11/2022 01:24

THIS THREAD IS FOUR MONTHS OLD

WHAT IS WITH ALL THE ZOMBIE THREADS

nudnikit · 17/11/2022 01:16

www.oldies.org.uk/fostering-dogs

nudnikit · 17/11/2022 01:14

Have you thought of dog fostering? There are many dogs who just don't do well in shelters and are placed in family homes until they can find their forever family.

We're fostering an abandoned old dog at the moment. He's really lovely and only wants a bit of loving plus his energy needs are much lower than with a younger dog.

And we're doing it without the long-term commitment that comes with adopting a dog which might be more appropriate for your situation given your daughter's age and your feelings about keeping a dog.

Maybethistime123 · 16/11/2022 12:29

Don’t do it! If you hate the idea now you’ll hate the idea even more in a year or two. If you can cope with a small dog I would say you can handle that only. It will only end in heartache otherwise. Good luck.

vix3rd · 16/11/2022 11:44

Does she realise how much energy & exercise a Collie requires so it's not destructive ? - Not to mention the shedding & dirt when it runs off into the mud.

I would be saying hard no.

InBlue · 16/11/2022 10:11

As PP said, an older retired greyhound is a better idea. They sleep 18 hours a day and only need one short walk.

Definitely don’t get a collie.

MrsSkylerWhite · 16/11/2022 10:06

Disaster waiting to happen. Your daughter will probably lose interest or become too busy with exams etc to care for the dog.
you’ll be stuck with a dog you don’t want, will resent it and because collies are very bright, it will know.
Pull out now and give the dog a better chance of a home where it’s wanted by everyone.
Sorry but feeling as you did it was unfair to your daughter to go to the shelter. Expect her to be angry with you.

Jaybird43 · 16/11/2022 10:03

@Hotair1234 I know this thread is a few months old, but did you ever get the dog?

Frazzled2207 · 01/07/2022 10:40

OP are you saying that your post was meant to convey that you just needed reassurance that it would be ok? You won't get that here.

Honestly CANCEL THE DOG. I'm not sure what you were thinking given that your dd could leave home in 3 years.

A cat or certain small breeds of dog might be more realistic.

ListerLess · 01/07/2022 09:53

Back out now OP, we got a young rescue when our perfect old boy passed away. 6 months later it is literally the worst mistake of my life, however we've now committed to him so feel we have to carry on.

LobeliaBaggins · 01/07/2022 09:45

XelaM · 01/07/2022 08:42

Going against the grain here... my daughter is the one who begged me for a dog for years and ai have always been extremely sceptical (having grown up with a dog myself) but I finally gave in and au absolutely adore him! 🥰 He's currently on my lap eating a massive disgusting stinky chew, but he's my little boy and I love him SO MUCH.

Stop. You will make me want to get a dog and I just cannot. All that unconditional love....sigh...

jeaux90 · 01/07/2022 08:59

Op I get it.

My DD13 has ASD and ADHD and her consultant says this to me, a dog would benefit her hugely.

I'm going to go with it but a small one. For her. (I love dogs but I have a very busy life)

You've committed so the best thing now is rules. Rules around the dog that your DD needs to comply with.

Some kids really benefit from a dog, caring about something more than their own needs is very therapeutic but it's also a massive headache for you.

Good luck!

sacklunch · 01/07/2022 08:52

I would not have a dog in my house, ever. I have just got this place under control cleaning-wise. We have two cats and I work from home. A dog would mess everything up. I've told my partner, who wants one, that if he brought a dog home I would be leaving the same day.

Wistfultimes · 01/07/2022 08:50

I LOVE dogs - but having lived with my mum’s two latest, I will never have another dog in my house again.
The mess, the noise, the destruction and the tie - it’s all really stressful.
DCs loved the idea of having them and were infatuated / entertained by them as puppies but not so interested now - won’t consistently help with walls / bath/ feeding as homework, etc gets in the way.
You either have to commit to looking after the dog yourself, or back out - because it WILL fall on your shoulders and you will feel resentful of you’re not besotted.

XelaM · 01/07/2022 08:42

I*

XelaM · 01/07/2022 08:42

Going against the grain here... my daughter is the one who begged me for a dog for years and ai have always been extremely sceptical (having grown up with a dog myself) but I finally gave in and au absolutely adore him! 🥰 He's currently on my lap eating a massive disgusting stinky chew, but he's my little boy and I love him SO MUCH.

saraclara · 01/07/2022 08:40

Hotair1234 · 30/06/2022 21:27

Thankyou. You clearly misread my post but I appreciate you feeling strongly enough to advise.

What was there to misread? Your post was really clear. You don't want a dog yet you're getting a really difficult breed of dog because you think it will help the mental health of a 15 year old.

What is there to misunderstand?

HannahDefoesTrenchcoat · 01/07/2022 08:36

I was in a similar situation 8 years ago although DD was younger. We got a pair of 5 year old dogs.
I love them to bits. At first I was really worried and couldn’t sleep for a couple of nights. I guess lots of people get puppy regret. After a while one was ill and vet feared it was pancreatic cancer (it wasn’t fortunately). I was surprised to be a tearful, distressed owner like on every vet programme.
I took them on accepting they’d be my responsibility. DD has taught them some tricks, really loves them but is going to university this year.
they are whippets though so famously easy to live with (not for cats and we don’t have one).
Good luck. I do hope it works out well for the dog and for you both.

erinaceus · 01/07/2022 08:31

@Hotair1234 You wrote "I know it’s everything she needs and couldn’t be more sure about the commitment but I hate the idea now, will hate the idea more next week." It just doesn't seem reasonable that you feel obliged to do this.

Even if the dog was everything that she needs, which I suspect is not the case, you are not obliged to have something you hate the idea of in your home. In not that many years, your DD will be an independent adult and able to get a dog of her own.

Until then, can she form a closer relationship with a neighbour or friend's dog, volunteer at a shelter, get a job at a kennels, or work on borrow my doggie?

ILProbs · 01/07/2022 08:19

If you're trying to 'bribe' your dd with the dog, I can tell you from experience that it won't work. My dd is under camhs, and I have tried all sorts of bribery over the last few years. Each becoming more and more out of proportion to the task - at one point I was offering roughly £1000 worth of gadgetry and games if she would go to school for a day. Desperation makes you try anything!

We have two new animals for the same reason.

Having said that, a pet that gives her unconditional love without pressure or judgement, and I know that my dd finds some comfort in that. But a collie is a high energy dog, and unless she is going to be capable of looking after its high energy needs, it may be better to steer her towards more of a couch potato. My dd couldn't cope with a high energy breed, because walking it might mean she'd have to talk to other dog walkers and she would panic. She couldn't volunteer in a rescue centre for the same reason.

Not all families suit every breed of dog, and that's OK. If you think you both won't cope, would she be open to revisiting and perhaps asking which dog has been there longest, which had the most extensive vet treatment, or the oldest? I ask because I know my dd would get a sense of accomplishment from taking on the animal with the least chance of adoption, and with mental health its all about baby steps to build them up.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 01/07/2022 08:17

Oh gosh OP, you have to pull out! Collies are extremely active and need a lot of mental stimulation it’ll be so hard!

I got a dobie with lots of research etc and at points I was crying - lovely dog now and wouldn’t change her for the world but it’s really hard!

Uyhko · 01/07/2022 08:11

Op. If you are going to rescue the dog this morning asks them two questions. Is the dog good with other dogs. And how is the dog around traffic. A lot of collies are either frightened or try to herd traffic and it makes it difficult to walk them on a pavement. These are two things that you need to know before you take on the dog. As they are two things that could make it difficult for a first time owner. It may be an amazing dog who bonds with your daughter and they do tricks and agility together. I hope so anyway

oceanskye · 01/07/2022 08:01

Speaking from experience, I wouldn't get it. As in, I let myself be talked into a dog by my husband and kids, and pretty much from day 1 all training, walking, poo picking up, vet taking, feeding, blah tedious blah, was on me. They are a huge chore and mental burden (unless you just really love doing stuff with dogs I guess). That dog died young due to health issues and I will never, under any circumstances, get another one!

rookiemere · 01/07/2022 07:48

Have you sat down with DD and worked out who is doing what?

The dog will need at least a 20 minute walk every single morning and another one in the afternoon ( this is absolute bare minimum our dog needs 2 hrs a day or he gets a bit antsy).

I know it's a rubbish situation and I know that you just wanted to make your DD happy, but this is not the way to go.

If you get this dog it will be back at the rescue within 6 months, do you want that on your conscience?

And no - to answer your original question- we got a dog, I didn't want a dog, love the dog but I wish we hadn't. Costs a bloody fortune with food, dog walking vets, holiday care and means when DH goes away I can't meet friends for long and my day is taken up with dog walking. At least when he is here he's the primary owner, I could not cope with the responsibility and time by myself.

risefromyourgrave · 01/07/2022 07:40

YABU to imply that collies are not cute! They are the most adorable dogs, so beautiful. BUT - they are a lot of hard work, they are incredibly intelligent and need a lot of stimulation. I grew up with a collie and he was an amazing dog, such a character. He couldn’t really be left alone though, he would get destructive and would howl.

I now have a chihuahua cross and she’s the best dog I’ve ever known. She has about a 40 minute walk in the morning and then a short 15 minute walk in the evening and the rest of the time she just chills with me, she’s my little shadow and I adore her!