Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ILs won't take no for an answer, but AIBU?

186 replies

PinkCheetah · 30/06/2022 18:13

Hi all. I'm a first time mum and LO is 11 weeks old. We live in a different city to my ILs about a 90 min drive away.

Since she was born, actually since I was pregnant, the ILs have been asking on repeat when they can take the baby away overnight to stay at theirs for a few days at a time. DH and I keep declining for many reasons. For example, she's exclusively breastfed. And mainly I don't like being apart from LO too long. Even when she goes out for a few hours with DH, I feel unsettled. And I don't agree with some of the things they want to do e.g ILs want to cosleep sometimes. I do sometimes cosleep but I only trust myself to do this and no one else. ILs have also been dropping hints that I should do things differently. For example, they keep suggesting I should just formula feed, so they can help with feeds. But I want to keep breastfeeding for the health benefits and she's growing well. I wanted to postpone a dummy until she was established with breastfeeding, but they kept pushing us to use a dummy. So all these little things add up and make me think even if I let LO stay over they wouldn't respect how I'd want her to be looked after once I'm not there.

Anyway they came to visit and again asked the question when we are going to let her stay over a few nights with them. And again we've had to state our position and DH was getting angry with them. It doesn't help that their own daughter's son, who lives around the corner from them, they look after him 4/7 days a week so they think this should be the same as ours. But I said it's different living round the corner as opposed to living in a completely different city.

I'm posting really just to get some perspective. Sometimes I do wonder if I'm the one BU? Are they just trying to help? Should I give in?

OP posts:
Spacemonkey2016 · 30/06/2022 20:45

Just say no! Don't even entertain any further convesation on the matter. My two were exclusively BF and they would have hated being away from me all night at that age, let alone several night. My rule has always been they can go when they ask me. They're 5 and 2 and haven't asked yet.

Floella22 · 30/06/2022 20:39

OP do not say perhaps when your dc is older because they’ll just push and push.
Tell them straight that you refuse to discuss your baby leaving your care and will not give it any thought at all until you’re ready to do so.
If they bring it up again just close the conversation down every time.
And the answer to what do you think will happen is ‘nothing because my child is staying with me.’

BigCheeseSandwich · 30/06/2022 20:36

Oh and as others have said (but I just have to say again) non parents cosleeping with babies is dangerous. OP they just sound awful!

Rainbowqueeen · 30/06/2022 20:36

If your DH gets angry with them, let him. This is outrageous behaviour by them.

id be deeply suspicious of someone who thinks this is ok. Do one or either of them have mental health issues???

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 30/06/2022 20:34

Don't doubt yourself! Don't let them dent your confidence.

My dch didn't stay with their DGPs until they were 8 or 9 and the ILS let them watch an 18 cert film that frightened the living daylights out of them, so that was the first and only time!

BigCheeseSandwich · 30/06/2022 20:34

Get them a reborn doll.

honestly, encouraging a mother to give up feeding her tiny baby just so they can have the baby overnight is absolutely insane. Who do they think they are, putting their own needs above a newborn’s!

Sannesmom · 30/06/2022 20:31

They asked when your baby was 2-3 weeks old, WTF??? Absurd! I'm amazed they didn't try to take her when she was fresh out of your womb 😟

My daughters started sleepovers with their grandparents at about 3 to 4 years old. Grandparents never asked for this when they were babies.

Lifeismeh · 30/06/2022 20:31

PinkCheetah · 30/06/2022 20:08

My ILs were like this from pre-birth too. Can I ask what your relationship with them is like now? Do you let them look after your DC independently in any other capacity? I'm starting to think the way it's going I'm gonna have to burn bridges with them.

We went no contact for about six months, she realised it was me who facilitated the relationship (mostly due to DHs work comitmenrs)

my DH told her that if her behaviour didn’t change she wouldn’t see them at all because she wasn’t respecting us when we said no. It’s harmonious now.
i still don’t trust her, I still don’t like her, but she’s a fantastic grandmother and I don’t want to get in the way of that.

she sees us once a week, and maybe once or twice a month she’ll have them for a couple of hours. We drop them off at her house (I’m anal about car safety and don’t trust her/anyone) and that’s it so far. I’m not ready to be away from them for the night yet! (1&3)

set your boundries, be firm. It was easier with the second because she’d made a mug of me with the first, basically 😂

PaperTyger · 30/06/2022 20:28

Pink, I can't understand why in law's do this.
I had the same,my mil absolutely ruined the happiest days of my life when dd was born.
She wedged in, critising, telling me I was lucky, because I was walking around, got me working, told me off for eating chocolate breast feeding, shouted at me.

Then as I was distraught the health visitor said DH should take dd there once a week ???

Where mil would wake her up and when dd cried she said "it's because she doesn't know me".

I'll never ever forgive her. .we don't speak now,we have tried but it's her personality and yes these people are like this with the DC!
It's beyond disrespectful to override you and their own son! He said no!!!!

Belephant · 30/06/2022 20:26

Keyboardist · 30/06/2022 18:18

Tell them to piss off. I never understand other people's desperation to take another mother's child away from her when the mother has said no.

It's bloody weird isn't it? I also don't understand why people, especially grandparents, get sooo obsessed with wanting to feed the baby? Especially to the point where they're encouraging a mother to give up breastfeeding!

My mum was gutted when I had to start combi feeding and I still maintained that I wanted to be the only one to feed him (except for DH) 🤣

As for wanting to co sleep with your baby?! Utterly bizarre

smilingthroughgrittedteeth · 30/06/2022 20:25

Why are people so obsessed with having a baby for a sleepover? My mum is amazing and close to all my children, sees them regularly and they adore her and have done since they were tiny but they didnt go for sleepovers until they were older. DS was 4yrs, DD1 was 2yrs (wanted to be like her brother) DD2 was 3yrs. They have a rota system and she has 1 of them every friday night (they are now 7yrs, 5yrs and 4yrs) which they love but no way would i have let them go as babies.

Aquamarine1029 · 30/06/2022 20:22

In life I have been one to avoid conflict and people please. But not with my daughter

I'm very glad you've realised this. You no longer have the luxury of avoiding conflict. You shouldn't give a fuck what these nutters think anyway.

PinkCheetah · 30/06/2022 20:18

Thank you everyone for your responses. I'm actually getting a bit emotional because I started to doubt myself and think maybe I'm the crazy one. But this thread has showed me that I can trust my instincts. In life I have been one to avoid conflict and people please. But not with my daughter. I've so far stuck to my guns on that but just needed a bit of hand holding today.

OP posts:
WishILivedInThrushGreen · 30/06/2022 20:17

Please don't cave.
Your baby, your rules.
Your baby might never need a dummy , your mil is just latching onto this and bottle feeding so that she can have her all to herself.

Honestly, she sounds a bit desperate to relive her own babies all over again.

Keep firm and don't relent until you're comfortable. Tell her that you'll let her know when you're comfortable about leaving her overnight. Keep repeating this in a firm but friendly tone.

Your daughter is your baby, not hers. She's had hers.

Me... I'd love to be a grandmother ( my children are mid/late20s ) but the thought of a needy / feedy baby , overnight, fills me with angst.

PaperTyger · 30/06/2022 20:16

@SeaToSki

What a perfect response!

I wish I had said that !

NoSquirrels · 30/06/2022 20:15

Oh they sound absolutely awful. Stick firmly to your guns on this. Your baby, your boundaries. They don’t sound like they have anyone’s interests at heart but their own.

Ledkr · 30/06/2022 20:14

Omg this makes me angry just reading it.
I'd just laugh and say don't be silly I'm nowhere near ready for that (shake head and carry on chuckling)
It's ludicrous. I have 6 gc and help if I'm asked to but apart from that I see that when it suits the parents.
They are jokers.

PrinnyPree · 30/06/2022 20:10

Oh my god YADNBU! That's insane, my son's 2 and I'd feel uneasy about that situation even now! No way in hell! I could understand them asking you ALL to stay over so they get an extended visit (although I still wouldn't be comfortable with this until 6 months) but why the hell do they want your baby alone. As another poster said I would be VERY uncomfortable with someone who'd try to seperate me from my baby.

Don't feel like you're being rude you tell them you don't want to hear about it again, it's not going to happen until your child is much older (and has the ability to communicate whether they would like to go). But certainly you will never be seperated from your child overnight whilst they are still a baby! I can't believe they are pressuring you to stop BFing to fascilitate this utter selfishness too. Absolutley appalling! Flowers

I wouldn't be letting them take her for hours on end without you either, I wouldn't trust them to not try to introduce formula or wean early with their inability to respect boundaries. X

AmaryIlis · 30/06/2022 20:10

You need to say that it isn't going to happen till your child is at least a year old, and you're not guaranteeing it will happen even then. And say that if they can't stop asking you're going to have to stop letting them see her even in your presence, because they're just causing a nasty atmosphere and unnecessary stress.

PinkCheetah · 30/06/2022 20:08

Lifeismeh · 30/06/2022 19:53

I had this with my in-laws from pre birth. I said no and I got painted to be an absolute heathen and the exact words were ‘you’re ruining my chance to be a grandmother, this was my chance to do it all again’ 😬

in the end it went explosive and I said that there’s no way it would be happening until they were old enough to communicate it’s something that they wanted. It would have been sooner if she wasn’t such a dick 😊

YANBU op.

My ILs were like this from pre-birth too. Can I ask what your relationship with them is like now? Do you let them look after your DC independently in any other capacity? I'm starting to think the way it's going I'm gonna have to burn bridges with them.

OP posts:
SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2022 20:06

Mine is nearly 3 and I am thinking that she might like to have a sleepover with Mil in the next year. Might have done it sooner if the relationship was close but due to overbearing behaviour at the start it isn't. I definitely wouldn't do it before 18.months unless I actually needed a break myself. I don't think it's in the baby's interest and wouldn't do it for grandma's benefit alone. Plus it would cause problems with breastfeeding. If I thought they were going to cosleep against my wishes I would leave it until the child was school age.

I think you just need to be very clear and say she will not be staying at yours overnight for at least a year as it will interfere with breast feeding. They will get the message.

DelosParks · 30/06/2022 20:05

My dd was nine (years) old before she wanted to have a sleepover.

CoffeeLover90 · 30/06/2022 20:02

My DS turned 3 this month. He's never slept out. My mam has let me know the offer is there, when I'm ready/needs must. I know a few people the same, I know some people who let theirs sleep out for a night from a few months old. Never heard of anyone having their 11 w.o stay out for a 'few days'. It's good to hear your DP is standing firmly in your corner. Tell them YOU decide when DC stays out and how long for. You're the parents and only yours and DP opinions matter.

Lifeismeh · 30/06/2022 19:53

I had this with my in-laws from pre birth. I said no and I got painted to be an absolute heathen and the exact words were ‘you’re ruining my chance to be a grandmother, this was my chance to do it all again’ 😬

in the end it went explosive and I said that there’s no way it would be happening until they were old enough to communicate it’s something that they wanted. It would have been sooner if she wasn’t such a dick 😊

YANBU op.

RockinHorseShit · 30/06/2022 19:48

Definitely NBU!!

Your baby is not a toy for their entertainment & they definitely don't have your babies best interests at heart, or are very ignorant. Neither one bodes well I'm afraid, it won't get easier unless you really put your foot down & then there can be falling out which in my experience is no bad thing with family like this

I'd reflect her question back to her... "oh really MIL, did FILs dad take your kids when they were so tiny?" I bet it's a no & even if she says yes, they did, then remind her how awful & taken over she most likely felt about it, & can you imagine if they lived so far away too" I would suggest ending with I hope you now understand why baby will not be staying with you until we are ready, if at all & that you must stop pressurising us as of now, as it puts us off ever letting DC stay with you at all as yiu are not respecting our very clear boundaries... now would you like tea, cake or whatever & refuse to discuss it further

Swipe left for the next trending thread