Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ILs won't take no for an answer, but AIBU?

186 replies

PinkCheetah · 30/06/2022 18:13

Hi all. I'm a first time mum and LO is 11 weeks old. We live in a different city to my ILs about a 90 min drive away.

Since she was born, actually since I was pregnant, the ILs have been asking on repeat when they can take the baby away overnight to stay at theirs for a few days at a time. DH and I keep declining for many reasons. For example, she's exclusively breastfed. And mainly I don't like being apart from LO too long. Even when she goes out for a few hours with DH, I feel unsettled. And I don't agree with some of the things they want to do e.g ILs want to cosleep sometimes. I do sometimes cosleep but I only trust myself to do this and no one else. ILs have also been dropping hints that I should do things differently. For example, they keep suggesting I should just formula feed, so they can help with feeds. But I want to keep breastfeeding for the health benefits and she's growing well. I wanted to postpone a dummy until she was established with breastfeeding, but they kept pushing us to use a dummy. So all these little things add up and make me think even if I let LO stay over they wouldn't respect how I'd want her to be looked after once I'm not there.

Anyway they came to visit and again asked the question when we are going to let her stay over a few nights with them. And again we've had to state our position and DH was getting angry with them. It doesn't help that their own daughter's son, who lives around the corner from them, they look after him 4/7 days a week so they think this should be the same as ours. But I said it's different living round the corner as opposed to living in a completely different city.

I'm posting really just to get some perspective. Sometimes I do wonder if I'm the one BU? Are they just trying to help? Should I give in?

OP posts:
LittleOwl153 · 01/07/2022 17:34

Continuing to bring it up when you/DH have said NO so clearly, needs consequences.

If you bring it up again the visit will end.
If you bring it up again it will be 1 week / 1 month before we see you again.
If you bring it up again you will only be allowed to see DD with both of us present.

And stick to them. They have shown they do no respect you or your DH as parents (probably as adults!) It's time they change that - or they loose.

DogsAndGin · 01/07/2022 16:53

YANBU

billy1966 · 01/07/2022 16:50

His being on your side of this is crucial.

Him having a frank word with them is a great idea.

I would give him full credit for this after the call.

This is a great marker for a long term successful relationship.

If they continue to harrass you about this, simply curtailing contact will be best.

Nothing should come between you and your new family enjoying this special time.

It doesn't bode well for the future and it is better to be realistic about these things than fight it.

The very best of luck.

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 01/07/2022 16:41

My kids slept over at their (lovely, kind, normal) grandparents when they were about 5.
But I might worry about letting my 5yo stay over with people who ride roughshod over other peoples opinions, wants and needs in the way that your ILs do. What if they bully and harass your child in the same way that they do you?

rnsaslkih · 01/07/2022 16:29

People who actively make demands to take an 11 week old baby away from his/her mother (who doesn’t want it) for a few nights are unhinged. Stand firm.

hellobeautifulsoul · 01/07/2022 16:24

Your DH sounds supporting and really lovely. I'm so glad you both feel the same. I really hope you can stop worrying about it and they stop asking x

Morred · 01/07/2022 16:24

If they refuse to stop asking, you need a consequence. If you're not willing to cut off contact immediately (and/or feel it's a bit much for a 'first offence' - even though this wouldn't be a first offence), tell them that you and DH think about 4yo before a sleepover, but every time they ask about it, the age goes up by 6 months. Mean it - make a note on your phone when they do it. "Well we did think 4, but you've asked twice since then, so it's 5 now."

it's petty and childish, but they are behaving in a petty and childish way by refusing to listen to you.

hellobeautifulsoul · 01/07/2022 16:13

No no no and no.
She stays over when you and your partner decide. Don't let them bully you into letting them take her, lots of people wait years to let their children stay out! And I'm sure lots let them younger but it's totally personal preference. Especially if you are breastfeeding. I would make it very clear that you will let them know when you are ready and they don't need to keep asking.

To be honest it makes me wonder why they are so persistent to have the baby overnight anyway?
And I get the feeling they wouldn't stick to your rules when they had the baby either, which is my pet hate.

Don't do anything you aren't comfortable with and don't feel guilty about it. Your baby, your rules 🥰

uncomfortablydumb53 · 01/07/2022 16:02

YADNBU
They are overbearing, and their ideas are really quite strange
Seems like to repeat your DH's childhood
It's good you and DH are on the same page. Stick to your boundaries
When your DC asks if she can stay, that's the time to consider it!

Summerwhereareyou · 01/07/2022 15:58

Perhaps he needs to make it clear that you're getting to end of your tether with it and if they want to still come....shut up about and learn some basic manners

Summerwhereareyou · 01/07/2022 15:57

He's admitted he wants the child to stay over? Why?
When you're both ready? Fabulous, but what if the child isn't?

Op this is the last thing you should be worrying about. I can't believe that your having to worry so much about what your mil wants.

It's cruel and selfish beyond belief.
I think you need to be clearer with your dh and make him read some information about baby blues but also fog/ toxic parents.

RedCardigan · 01/07/2022 15:51

Your DH sounds amazing.
fuck no would be my answer.
and if it was yes it would be a few hours to start and then build up bit just handing her off for a couple of nights!

Lola4321 · 01/07/2022 15:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mememene · 01/07/2022 15:44

Good luck and when they bring it up again you can refer back to today's conversation again and refuse to discuss it again.

PinkCheetah · 01/07/2022 15:27

A bit of an update.

First off thank you all so much for your responses and kind words. You've really helped to clarify my thinking. To also clarify also, FIL keeps asking for overnight stays but it's the MIL who wants to cosleep. I don't think FIL has any preference on the matter so I get everyone's concerns but I find it unlikely anything sinister going on.

DH and I have had a long talk about it again this afternoon. I discussed all my concerns mentioned here. I've told him it feels like harassment/bullying. He is equally as frustrated and admits when ILs bring up the subject he just loses it sometimes with them meaning talks are not as productive as they could've been.

He's admitted he would like DD to stay with them for a few days but he was thinking when she was 4 or 5 years old. And when we felt ready. I agreed with him.

He's going to get both of them on the phone this evening and speak to them again. Restate the position and tell them not to bring it up again. I offered to be there with him or wait to do it face to face altogether but he says he just wants to deal with them sooner rather than later. I just don't feel hopeful it's going to change anything because we've been here before and they keep doing it.

OP posts:
QOD · 01/07/2022 12:46

that's crazy! all of mine were a nightmare and I had to force my mum to have dd one afternoon a week (because she would cry at nursery until she threw up as she hated it so) and was DESPERATE for the grandparents to have an interest.

But overnight> no co - sleeping ? GTFOOH
way way way over the top

couple of hours when YOU are ready? to spring clean/get your hair did/sleep/go for lunch - oh god please - but when YOU feel comfortable

MeridianB · 01/07/2022 12:32

RampantIvy · 01/07/2022 12:22

If they're not keen on that idea, then you know this isn't about DD and helping you and DH

They live 90 minutes away. A 3 hour round trip just to push a pram is not my idea of a fun day out TBH.

RTFT! OP has invited them to stay over. They did this once and then have been 'busy' for subsequent invitations.

Rainbowshine · 01/07/2022 12:24

I would be tempted, given that they are going on about cosleeping, and that they are not accepting the “no” from you, to use the “advice from the health visitors” or some other authority as a possible tactic when dealing with them.

overnight - health visitors recommend against this as the parents are bonding with the baby and due to the practicality of breastfeeding.

cosleeping - also not recommended by health visitors, similar reasons to above and also it has led to safeguarding concerns. We wouldn’t want anything like that to happen.

Of course that’s all nonsense but I found that saying that the GP/midwife/health visitors had said something meant interfering people would accept it or at least shut up about it for a while.

And yes, they are the crazy ones, not you!

RampantIvy · 01/07/2022 12:22

If they're not keen on that idea, then you know this isn't about DD and helping you and DH

They live 90 minutes away. A 3 hour round trip just to push a pram is not my idea of a fun day out TBH.

Sapphire387 · 01/07/2022 12:16

If they're that keen to be helpful, perhaps they could come over a couple of times a week and take DD out for a walk in the pram so you can catch up on some sleep. If they're not keen on that idea, then you know this isn't about DD and helping you and DH, but some other weird control issues. Which I suspect it is.

bridgetreilly · 01/07/2022 12:15

And no one except parents ever gets to co-sleep. Ever.

bridgetreilly · 01/07/2022 12:13

Overnight, maybe when she’s 3 or 4. Several days, when she’s 7 or 8. They are being utterly bonkers.

MeridianB · 01/07/2022 12:11

Sorry, @TheVillageElder I disagree.

They sound like they're desperate to be more involved
There are so many ways to express or do this. Why is there a massive focus on taking this tiny baby away from its parents overnight?

If they then ask again after saying this, I'd suggest asking them what date they were thinking of. Then say, OK, that's a date, at your home. You're then being very reasonable and offering them more contact in a manner you find comfortable.
So OP needs to give them a date now one, two or more years away when she will hand her child over, regardless of her feelings or the childs?

What's wrong with just saying no?

OP has just given birth. She doesnt need this harrassment. The ILs and their wants and expectations are not her priority. They have shown they really don't prioritise the baby's needs by asking for BF to stop. And they don't care about OP's needs by asking again and again when they can take her 11 week old baby away to co-sleep with them.

They need to listen when they have been repeatedly asked to stop raising this topic.

TheVillageElder · 01/07/2022 11:51

@PinkCheetah
They sound like they're desperate to be more involved and so this is then coming across to you as being incredibly intense and repetitive.

I do not want it think that you can infer anything sinister due to them having coslept with their own children and other grandchild.

Are your parents @PinkCheetah more local? Do you have more frequent and regular contact? Please bear in your mind that often the father parents do get a rougher "deal" when it comes to grandchildren etc and their dils attitude towards them.

I don't think that you need to lose your shit. I think that you need to just be stating that you have no, intneiton of your child sleeping elsewhere overnight until they're significantly older. If you want say a toddler or something.

If they then ask again after saying this, I'd suggest asking them what date they were thinking of. Then say, OK, that's a date, at your home. You're then being very reasonable and offering them more contact in a manner you find comfortable.

Lola4321 · 01/07/2022 10:17

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread