Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disparity in cost of gifts between DSC and DC

109 replies

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 16:55

It's DSC's birthday next week and partner has just been sat with him making up his list of birthday present requests. Multiple console games, random things, expensive new trainers (he just bought him new trainers not three months ago)

Meanwhile for our DD's birthday last month he bought her 1 kindi kids doll totalled to less than £20. Obviously she got more than just the one doll, I was buying her bits here and there in the months leading up.

We're not well off, infact we're counting pennies at the end of every month trying to stretch until one of us gets paid. My children do not walk around in expensibe trainers. We have separate finances which is partly due to the fact he is crap with money, when he gets his wages he pisses them up the wall after transferring me his half of the bills. I'm then left to do all of the budgeting and worrying about making X amount stretch the full month.

I don't feel able to say anything about the birthday gifts because it's his son, he wants to treat him but AIBU to be feeling annoyed?

There are a couple of factors at play, how bad he is with money being one of them, but the disparity between birthday gifts has upset me.

He's not over compensating for DSC not getting anything at his mums. He has a huge family on his DMs side and gets dozens of gifts every year. Our children don't though.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 30/06/2022 18:08

I'd ditch him, I'm afraid. In addition to how he treats your DD, being with someone who is financially irresponsible is incredibly stressful and he doesn't seem to have any good qualities to compensate.

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 30/06/2022 18:02

Has he upped his contribution to groceries/fuel bills in light of current inflation and increases? If not he needs to.

Also a good idea for a budget for birthday and Christmas presents - for the children at least, but a good idea generally. Would he feel resentful if you suggested this (after DSS's birthday)?

cottagegardenflower · 30/06/2022 17:58

It's guilt. Make him see it's not acceptable and one decent present is enough

Thinkingblonde · 30/06/2022 17:58

You need to sit down with him, with an account of all incomes and out goings. Note everything down, every coffee, everything.. Yes, he’s paying half of the bills as do you which seems fair..but then you are also paying 100% of everything else on top of your share of the bills: food, clothes, treats for DD. And this is not fair.
.He should increase the amount he pays into the bills account. Make it clear to him this is not you money grabbing, he’s been the one doing the money grabbing by underpaying into the household expenses. Leaving you struggling every month for essentials while he fritters money on takeaway coffee. Suggest you both agree an amount to be spent on each child. And stick to it.
What he does with what he has left after paying more is up to him but birthday treats for one costing ££££ while the other gets £ is unfair.

GrumpyPanda · 30/06/2022 17:46

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:31

I need to don't I? I just feel so uncomfortable because I know he'll go on the defensive.

He'll spin it as me begrudging DSS birthday presents when actually it's the bigger picture. He won't see it that way though he'll just chalk it up to me wanting to deprive his son of nice things.

You'll need to reassess anyway with all kinds of costs going up. So maybe that gives you a way into the conversation. When you say "half the bills" are you including food and household expenses in general?

Idontgiveagriffindamn · 30/06/2022 17:46

Reading your messages I’m not sure it’s totally about the disparity.
If your ‘Penny pinching’ at the end of the month has the food shopping and other essentials been factored into the £600 he transfers you or is this just bills? If it’s the latter you need to do the former. Then you’ll be fine at the end of the month. I’d also make sure that days out and family presents were accounted for in the joint
money as well.
Im quite passive aggressive that I’d buy presents for your joint child and then bill him for half!

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/06/2022 17:46

Even in a nuclear family, it's normal to spend much less on presents for a toddler than for an older child who is fashion conscious/wants expensive tech.

Agreed. But the DSS is currently 7…

Dontknownow86 · 30/06/2022 17:45

You need to tell him that what he is transferring you no longer covers family expenses and he needs to transfer you x amount instead. Why on earth are you alone expected to be covering the shopping? I bet you are paying to feed his son too aren't you?

Hellodarknessmyoldpal · 30/06/2022 17:45

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:31

I need to don't I? I just feel so uncomfortable because I know he'll go on the defensive.

He'll spin it as me begrudging DSS birthday presents when actually it's the bigger picture. He won't see it that way though he'll just chalk it up to me wanting to deprive his son of nice things.

Maybe don't frame it as an issue about dsd birthday. Maybe suggest that he needs to now transfer an extra (insert amount) per month as DD is getting bigger and needs more than she did as a baby. You can then have a joint DD fund. This fund can also be used to purchase her birthday and Christmas presnts. Also perhaps a rise in his overall contribution to keep up with the rise in the cost of living.

Side note: i do think spending money on lelli kellis for a 3yo especially if money is tight would be a bit daft. Their feet grow unpredictably at that age and you've plenty of time for her to be asking for expensive shoes. (Just my opinion for what it's worth). But i do understand why the difference in his spending on his DCs makes you a bit sad.

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 17:40

You said you're the one budgeting for groceries and bill increases.

So he doesn't pay half the grocery/household stuff costs and he hasn't increased the money he gives for bills to cover the recent hikes??

How have you got into this situation?

He needs increase what he pays to bills to cover to increases.
You need to agree the monthly grocery/household needs budget and he needs to pay half to you along with the bill money.
He also needs to contribute to general "stuff" that your joint kid needs like clothes and shoes.

You've picked the wrong man here. This sounds like a man you sleep with for a few months and then move on but you had a kid with him. He was the wrong man. Now you need to try and fix it by enforcing an even split or walking out.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:37

It's definitely a DP issue, not a DSS issue.

Hell when I was 8 if a parent asked me what I wanted I would probably list off loads of expensive things too. 8 year old have little to no concept of money really.

Him adding a set amount each month to put away for birthdays is a good idea. I have a savings account we could use for that.

I make alot of excuses for DP on account of the ADHD but that's doing a disservice to the millions of other adults with ADHD who don't act like that...

OP posts:
GrazingSheep · 30/06/2022 17:34

His lack of care and fiscal irresponsibility would drive me insane .

GrazingSheep · 30/06/2022 17:33

The issue is not your step son.
The issue is your partner
How bad will it have to get before you think of splitting?

IncompleteSenten · 30/06/2022 17:32

What about him adding a set amount each month which you save up and use for birthdays etc?

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:31

Chasingsquirrels · 30/06/2022 17:29

Talk to him!

I need to don't I? I just feel so uncomfortable because I know he'll go on the defensive.

He'll spin it as me begrudging DSS birthday presents when actually it's the bigger picture. He won't see it that way though he'll just chalk it up to me wanting to deprive his son of nice things.

OP posts:
NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:29

DomPerignon12 · 30/06/2022 17:25

Your ‘D’P is a POS. It never ceases to amaze me how men like this still manage to land partner after partner.

ALL your combined wages should be in a family account, with play money only after everything paid. How can he throw money away while you struggle to budget. What use is he again?

I wouldn't want him having access to all of the joint money if I'm completely honest. He wastes enough of his own without having free reign of it all.

OP posts:
Chasingsquirrels · 30/06/2022 17:29

Talk to him!

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:27

Thank you for seeing my POV and not automatically disagreeing with me on account of me being a SM.

I agree the way our finances are handled isn't working. Years ago when we first moved in together we wouldn't merge money at all, it would be "you pay that and I'll pay this" but it quickly became apparent how bad he was with money and he would plough through a whole months wages within a week leaving us in shits creek getting by on my (low I might add) wage alone.

I had to insist he transfers me his portion of the bills when he gets paid which he now does and has been doing for a year or so, but he's still careless with what's left so I don't feel as though the initial solution changed much.

OP posts:
SmileyPiuPiu · 30/06/2022 17:26

You need to get a shared account.

DomPerignon12 · 30/06/2022 17:25

Your ‘D’P is a POS. It never ceases to amaze me how men like this still manage to land partner after partner.

ALL your combined wages should be in a family account, with play money only after everything paid. How can he throw money away while you struggle to budget. What use is he again?

funinthesun19 · 30/06/2022 17:24

He will obviously feel some guilt towards his older child that he doesn’t get to live with both his parents and is trying to compensate for that, which is understandable.

Do you think mums who don’t see their older children everyday behave like this? Or do they just act like a parent of 2? Why do men get the same lame excuses made for them all the time? If he couldn’t deal with the guilt without taking it out on his younger child then he should have thought about that before having more children.

luxxlisbon · 30/06/2022 17:24

Some of the things you are taking issue with is muddying the situation.
Its normal to just buy things for one child at a time, buying DSS new shoes didn’t mean all kids need new shoes. DD is getting new shoes now and DSS isn’t.
Also presents for a older child will be more expensive usually, their needs are different rather than it being unfair. DDs wants will also get more expensive as she gets older.
£60 on energy drinks is a lot but everyone should have a discretionary amount they can spend on whatever they want. That might be energy drinks, coffee, nails etc.

Clearly you need to readdress how much your bills and expenses are and both increase the joint money accordingly. Things the children need as they grow or gifts etc should be from this joint pot.

Luidaeg · 30/06/2022 17:18

If I say anything I'm just seen as being money grabbing.

And there you are - he wont get any better, you need to do better for your DD - she is not second class

mrsm43s · 30/06/2022 17:17

Even in a nuclear family, it's normal to spend much less on presents for a toddler than for an older child who is fashion conscious/wants expensive tech. And also normal not to buy one child a pair of shoes, just because you've bought the other child a pair of shoes. He's buying your toddler new shoes now her old ones have worn out. Nothing wrong with that, he didn't have to buy her some just because her step brother needed new trainers!

It seems as though the way you split your finances isn't correct, and he's not contributing to some family costs. You really need to go through all your expenses and work out what a fair monthly contribution is from him to cover all joint expenses, which would cover food/clothes and shoes for your shared DC/activities for your shared DC/presents and parties for your shared DC etc in addition to just his half of the household bills. Ideally you'd run a family account which you both pay in to to cover those things. Review this account regularly and you both up your contribution when costs go up etc.

Greensleeves · 30/06/2022 17:17

It sounds like the whole set-up is unreasonable. He seems to have settled into a mindset of "DSS is mine, DD is yours", which is completely unhealthy, divisive and will do neither child any good. It's especially unfair given that you have less money, so your DD gets fewer and less showy presents, but it's the deeper divide within the family that would really concern me. I also find it troubling that you can't have a frank conversation with him about this.

He needs to understand that if he wants to be a family, he needs to treat the children equally and not elevate one over the other, or take responsibility for one and not the other. Poor little DD. Sad