Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disparity in cost of gifts between DSC and DC

109 replies

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 16:55

It's DSC's birthday next week and partner has just been sat with him making up his list of birthday present requests. Multiple console games, random things, expensive new trainers (he just bought him new trainers not three months ago)

Meanwhile for our DD's birthday last month he bought her 1 kindi kids doll totalled to less than £20. Obviously she got more than just the one doll, I was buying her bits here and there in the months leading up.

We're not well off, infact we're counting pennies at the end of every month trying to stretch until one of us gets paid. My children do not walk around in expensibe trainers. We have separate finances which is partly due to the fact he is crap with money, when he gets his wages he pisses them up the wall after transferring me his half of the bills. I'm then left to do all of the budgeting and worrying about making X amount stretch the full month.

I don't feel able to say anything about the birthday gifts because it's his son, he wants to treat him but AIBU to be feeling annoyed?

There are a couple of factors at play, how bad he is with money being one of them, but the disparity between birthday gifts has upset me.

He's not over compensating for DSC not getting anything at his mums. He has a huge family on his DMs side and gets dozens of gifts every year. Our children don't though.

OP posts:
itsgettingweird · 30/06/2022 19:08

Thing that leaps out here is you're struggling to budget due to increasing cost of living whilst he has spends that uses for what he likes.

Maybe time to look at how much he's transferring you each month towards bills as it won't be nearly enough if it hasn't increased in the last month or so.

LorW · 30/06/2022 19:08

Please get rid of him OP, honestly put him in the bin, claim maintenance. Really what is he bringing to the table, he isn’t even paying half the bills fgs! You and the kids deserve better and I tell you now they will notice the disparity eventually.

PaperTyger · 30/06/2022 19:04

Hi op it sound like you both need to straighten out money.

He has a child with you and yet he's acting like a child himself.

Sit down with him, try and make it nice, maybe get a babysitter and go out.
Pen and paper.
Say you need to sort money out and work out anyway to do it.
He pays his "bills" but actually he isn't.

Bills include children's food/toys/clothes etc.

So ask him and work how much you both need to start giving each month for this.
Here we do £50 each a month but it used to be £20 each.

Every month both put this into a special bank account or within a joint account.
Next, what can you both afford to put towards birthday?
Again we did £10 a month, now Dh does 20 and I do 10.

Bynthe time bday comes around it's glorious to have some ££ to pull on.

Same with Xmas. We save a lot more to Xmas. It used to be a lot less.

Again ear mark somewhere separate for this money to go.
Then you need an emergency fund. Obviously this should have the most money going in but, also hopefully you won't need it for a while so this will accumulate nicely.

These separate savings should cover you.and mean you have ££ for what you need when you need it..

Once he has paid towards this...then what's left over is truly his.

As an aside we go further...we have a car fund, a savings fund.
Every penny is assigned.
If I get 20 for myself it's a miracle.
But so is having a few hundred saved up for Xmas.
We also have a holiday fund.

Without a structure, you won't get anywhere.

He's assigning money to himself that's essentially not his to spend because he has other commitments.

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 19:04

His CM has to come out of his leftover money.

If he could he trusted to have "family money" with everything in one pot and all expenses paid out from that then he could get your help when needed. But he cant be trusted and has resisted being fair to you and has actually called YOU a money grabber.

He is going to have to cough up half the household expenses and pay his maintenance. And just have less leftover.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:59

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 18:56

I understand separate finances, and him just giving you his half up front.

But he isnt paying half. Not at all.

That's what we cant understand.

I'm a mug really aren't I.

Part of it for me is that I know he has maintenance to pay, so I pick up his slack so DSS doesn't miss out. Not that he would miss out. His mum is OK for money. But CM is non negotiable as it should be.

OP posts:
sweetlebeetle1 · 30/06/2022 18:59

I think you are very patient with him. That would drive me nuts . He needs to wise up and support you more.

womaninatightspot · 30/06/2022 18:58

I think you need to relook at his half of bills as prices have increased. If he won’t then I’d consider separating.

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 18:56

I understand separate finances, and him just giving you his half up front.

But he isnt paying half. Not at all.

That's what we cant understand.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:56

The energy drinks - he's basically addicted to them. He does shift work and started buying them to keep up his energy levels but he drinks them like juice now and says he needs to in order to be vaguely productive on his days/nights off.

I've expressed concern about how bad they are for his health and he just gets defensive. He isn't going to stop drinking them, but I should stop funding it.

OP posts:
WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 18:54

What do you really think a conversation will achieve?

He knows how much the rent it. He was very happy paying half of that and nothing else.

He is an adult and, I assume, not a complete dimeit. He knew you were paying all the other bills. He knew you were all eating food that you were the only one buying. He knew his daughter was growing into new clothes and you were buying them all.

He was fine with all that. He thought that was fair.

Talk to him but have a back up plan. Whatever you do, do not give in. Do not accept any less than half ALL costs. Dont back down and let him bully you or accuse you of any money grabbing.

He is the money grabber. He is using you.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:54

We don't tend to label our DC presents at all. It's only us who buys for our DC so there's no need. The assumption is that it's from 'mum and dad' regardless of which one of us has bought it.

He bought her a dolls house with his own money for Christmas but it was 'from mum and dad' iykwim.

It's only me who is aware of the disparity spent between DD and DSC, she doesn't have a clue, so it's all projection on my part but it does bother me that I spent about £70 in total over a few months buying bit by bit and his contribution was an £18 doll at the last minute as he doesn't plan in advance meanwhile he's going to drop atleast £200 that we can't afford on DSS upcoming birthday which means more scrimping for me later in the month when he runs out of money even quicker.

I understand why people find it strange that we have separate finances, it's just necessary when you have one party who is so bad with money it would be a hindrance to combine everything and give him access to it.

OP posts:
canteatlovefood · 30/06/2022 18:46

I don't think the amount spent is the issue here. My stepson took great umbrage with the fact that DD got a very expensive trampoline for her birthday and worked out that his presents were a quarter the amount of the trampoline. Until DH pointed out to him that he got a PS5 for Xmas and DD got much less spent on her for Xmas.

Different ages have different needs. We have a toddler who costs very little for Xmas and birthdays because he just wants cheap dinosaurs etc.

Your issue here is he is not paying his fair share and you have been letting him get away with it for so long.

Why would you pay for his energy drinks when he's squandered all his money before he gets paid. I wouldn't do that for my child let alone an adult who frittered away their wages.

It's also very strange that you would buy your children presents separately. Do you label them one from you and one from him?

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:45

I'm going to have him sit down with me tomorrow and go through all of the bills and other outgoings. Thank you for opening my eyes to the more significant issue of him being a CF all round and not just when it comes to presents.

If any of you were me would you draw reference to the presents or not?

OP posts:
GoodThinkingMax · 30/06/2022 18:41

I pay for our Sky broadband, C.T and all of the food shopping every week. When he's spent what's left of his money I pay for his energy drinks and transport to work (was a driver, not any longer)

You really need a proper budget which includes rent, full monthly electricity costs, Sky, telephones, lunches, DCs’ presents, and so on. Every bit of family spending.

Then contributions in proportion to your wages.

So if he earns 20% more than you, he pays 20% more of the bills. So he would pay £600 of the rent and you would pay £400. Get out your calculator!

GoodThinkingMax · 30/06/2022 18:30

as the budget (what I have to allocate on everything) would never stretch to it. His 'money left after bills' would though.

It sounds as though your joint budget - bills etc - isn’t enough. If you’re spending “your” money on essentials for your family, that suggests he needs to contribute more to his family’s needs. For example, why are YOU paying for your DCs’ lunches, rather than that cost coming out of your joint budget?

Could you include a small amount per month for presents in your family budget, so that that is included in his contribution to bills? Then you can have a conversation about proportionate gifts.

There IS a difference between gifts for a 2 yo and an 8 yo, but not to the level you describe.

Greensleeves · 30/06/2022 18:24

I wonder whether there is a whiff of sexism about his attitude as well. He clearly doesn't regard you as an equal partner and is happy to dump all the emotional labour on you, so perhaps he thinks Lelli Kelly shoes are a waste of money because they're for girls, while his son's taste in lad fashion feels more valid to him?

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:23

Bollindger · 30/06/2022 18:22

Write out a NEW budget.
List all the bills, tell him shopping and things have gone up.
Tell him that your going to cut sky and other things as YOU can't afford it on the £600 he gives you.
List things your DD needs and tell him you need £20 a month to put away for Birthday and Xmas for your DD.
Tell him that he need to see costs have gone up so much, and pay up.

This sounds like a plan

OP posts:
Bollindger · 30/06/2022 18:22

Write out a NEW budget.
List all the bills, tell him shopping and things have gone up.
Tell him that your going to cut sky and other things as YOU can't afford it on the £600 he gives you.
List things your DD needs and tell him you need £20 a month to put away for Birthday and Xmas for your DD.
Tell him that he need to see costs have gone up so much, and pay up.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:22

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 18:13

So what are you going to do about it?

Going to warn you here; he isnt going to change. As soon as he has to actually be a grown up and fully pay half the household expenses, he is going to be shouting at you, calling you money grabbing, being a petulant child about not having "his" money anymore.

All he has paid for is half your rent. That's it. You've paid for everything for your child, all the household bills, all the food. Everything.

How can anyone let this happen?

Do you have somewhere you can go? Because t

I don't know, it makes for sobering reading when I read it all back to myself. I've been a mug.

I think he sees it as fine because he buys the 'fun' stuff such as a pizza hut or Indian once a month which can come to aron 30-40 quid, takeaway coffees and snacks if we're out somewhere. He buys things for the house that we don't need. Random shit.

None of that pays the bills though or DD's birthday presents

I couldn't afford to get him anything apart from a card on father's day so I said as much and said if he wanted something in particular let me know and I'll buy it belated when I get paid. What does he want? A bloody wireless xbox controller. I was thinking along the lines of £10-20..

I'm not going to be buying it.

OP posts:
Idontgiveagriffindamn · 30/06/2022 18:18

You need to write down all household expenses and then all joint kids expenses and as long as there isn’t a massive disparity in wages he needs to pay half of these.
But if he doesn’t change you’ve either got to suck it up (and the resentment) or leave.

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 30/06/2022 18:16

I think you need to write a list or spreadsheet of all the regular monthly costs and show him how far his contribution goes. Also show him how much you have left to spend after topping up his share (which I presume is nothing).

Also I wouldn't be buying those energy drinks - "Sorry DP but I haven't enough money, I've had to top up the meter and if I get these there won't be enough for groceries and DD needs shoes (or whatever she needs)." He doesn't need energy drinks - they're bad for him anyway, and if he insists he needs them he has to fund them out of his left over spending money - which is a much larger amount than you have.

Don't forget to indicate somewhere on your list items which aren't monthly but are regular - presents, clothes, haircuts - whatever.

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 18:14

*because you need to just leave. Your life is going to he a constant struggle with this man.

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 18:13

So what are you going to do about it?

Going to warn you here; he isnt going to change. As soon as he has to actually be a grown up and fully pay half the household expenses, he is going to be shouting at you, calling you money grabbing, being a petulant child about not having "his" money anymore.

All he has paid for is half your rent. That's it. You've paid for everything for your child, all the household bills, all the food. Everything.

How can anyone let this happen?

Do you have somewhere you can go? Because t

Georgyporky · 30/06/2022 18:13

He can't be paying his fair share.
Write it all down & tell him what he really needs to pay.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:09

He upped the amount he transfers to me from 500 to 600 pcm as of last month. He sees it as 'half towards everything' when it's not, not really.

For reference our rent is 1000 pcm. So 500 of his 600 is his rent contribution.

I forgot to note that he also puts £40 on the electricity meter (not included in his 600 transferred) and that 40 on the meter only lasts 4.5 days now if we're careful with usage. The other three weeks of the month topping up the metres are down to me.

I pay for our Sky broadband, C.T and all of the food shopping every week. When he's spent what's left of his money I pay for his energy drinks and transport to work (was a driver, not any longer)

If the kids need clothes then the majority of the time its me who buys them. Not always so i wont lie, but definitely most often. I buy all the packed lunch stuff. The

So it all adds up and I'm definitely paying for alot more than he is whilst he has more disposable than me.

OP posts: