Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disparity in cost of gifts between DSC and DC

109 replies

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 16:55

It's DSC's birthday next week and partner has just been sat with him making up his list of birthday present requests. Multiple console games, random things, expensive new trainers (he just bought him new trainers not three months ago)

Meanwhile for our DD's birthday last month he bought her 1 kindi kids doll totalled to less than £20. Obviously she got more than just the one doll, I was buying her bits here and there in the months leading up.

We're not well off, infact we're counting pennies at the end of every month trying to stretch until one of us gets paid. My children do not walk around in expensibe trainers. We have separate finances which is partly due to the fact he is crap with money, when he gets his wages he pisses them up the wall after transferring me his half of the bills. I'm then left to do all of the budgeting and worrying about making X amount stretch the full month.

I don't feel able to say anything about the birthday gifts because it's his son, he wants to treat him but AIBU to be feeling annoyed?

There are a couple of factors at play, how bad he is with money being one of them, but the disparity between birthday gifts has upset me.

He's not over compensating for DSC not getting anything at his mums. He has a huge family on his DMs side and gets dozens of gifts every year. Our children don't though.

OP posts:
WeAreBob · 01/07/2022 00:07

*in their joint account

caringcarer · 01/07/2022 00:04

Just read your update. Why are you putting up with this? If rent is £1000 then he pays £500 towards rent. Work out other cost and bill him half. Stop subsidising him he is not your child. Partners are supposed to be equal.

caringcarer · 30/06/2022 23:59

Can't you just point out gas, electricity and food is all going up and £600 is no longer enough. Tell him he will need to pay £675 from next month. Tell him he might have to go up to £700 in October to cover winter fuel. Tell him you need more help with budgeting and shopping for bits too. Tell him children must have an equal budget for Xmas

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 23:49

scotscorner · 30/06/2022 23:12

Hi OP, can I suggest you do the inverse of current approach:

right now - he gets his pay, gives you some and sees the rest as his

better approach - pay goes in joint account, and he gets an allowance back to spend as he pleases based on what you jointly think you can afford based on your family outgoings each month. Anything spent from the joint is pre agreed with both of you (regular outgoings).

He gets to spend that on whatever he wants, but if your family outgoings go up or are not managed effectively then the allowance is at risk.

my husband and I do this (he is lovely but not very interested in budgeting…) and we’ve fallen out much less since we did.

It does not sound like he can be trusted with access to a joint account.

Once money is in a joint account, including OP's money, then it is legally available to either of the named people.

It really doesn't sound like he can be trusted to see all that money in their and only spend what has been transferred to his sole account. He would take more.

scotscorner · 30/06/2022 23:12

Hi OP, can I suggest you do the inverse of current approach:

right now - he gets his pay, gives you some and sees the rest as his

better approach - pay goes in joint account, and he gets an allowance back to spend as he pleases based on what you jointly think you can afford based on your family outgoings each month. Anything spent from the joint is pre agreed with both of you (regular outgoings).

He gets to spend that on whatever he wants, but if your family outgoings go up or are not managed effectively then the allowance is at risk.

my husband and I do this (he is lovely but not very interested in budgeting…) and we’ve fallen out much less since we did.

madasawethen · 30/06/2022 22:56

How much do you both make each month? It sounds very unfair.

violetbunny · 30/06/2022 22:44

One more thing - I also recommend reading A Couples Guide to Thriving with ADHD.

There is a talk here by the author which is worth watching, the book then goes into a lot more of the practical strategies to address some of the issues.

violetbunny · 30/06/2022 22:41

Op, if your partner has ADHD it may be his symptoms that are the main issue here as they can lead to him behaving impulsively when it comes to finances and prioritising the "now" rather than being able to plan how to spend for the month. There was even an article in The Guardian recently on how people with ADHD can be impacted when it comes to financial management - some people really struggle.

A couple of things you can do:

  • If he is not medicated, then he needs to at least try some medication - it can take a bit of trial and error to find one that works
  • Sit down together and work out your joint budget for the year - not just rent and bills, but incidentals like birthday presents, Xmas, groceries, kids stuff, medical stuff, savings, etc. Then divide by 12. This is the amount you need to put into a joint account every month, so he needs to contribute half that amount. (Personally we have 2 joint accounts - one for the fixed stuff like mortgage, power, insurance etc and one for things like groceries, pet food etc - that way we know the fixed bills are always covered). Anything left over can be divided up and shared as "fun" money.
GoodThinkingMax · 30/06/2022 22:22

The energy drinks - he's basically addicted to them.

They’re just sugar. He’s addicted to the sugar. Nothing else.

What is the point of him in your life?

girlfriend44 · 30/06/2022 22:15

Spoiling his son won't help he will make a rod for his own back. Kid will expect more and more.

Kids want expensive things then wait till they can buy themselves. So many idiotic parents around.

Herejustforthisone · 30/06/2022 21:39

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 18:09

He upped the amount he transfers to me from 500 to 600 pcm as of last month. He sees it as 'half towards everything' when it's not, not really.

For reference our rent is 1000 pcm. So 500 of his 600 is his rent contribution.

I forgot to note that he also puts £40 on the electricity meter (not included in his 600 transferred) and that 40 on the meter only lasts 4.5 days now if we're careful with usage. The other three weeks of the month topping up the metres are down to me.

I pay for our Sky broadband, C.T and all of the food shopping every week. When he's spent what's left of his money I pay for his energy drinks and transport to work (was a driver, not any longer)

If the kids need clothes then the majority of the time its me who buys them. Not always so i wont lie, but definitely most often. I buy all the packed lunch stuff. The

So it all adds up and I'm definitely paying for alot more than he is whilst he has more disposable than me.

Jesus Christ. He’s feckless and stupid. You need to redress the balance here.

iwantmyownicecreamvan · 30/06/2022 21:20

I'm not sure if I'm going to mention the difference in presents yet.

I wouldn't mention it at this point but concentrate on pointing out how he isn't paying anywhere near half and on setting up a separate account for birthday and Christmas presents. The disparity might well come up at the next round of birthdays.

Of course the risk with this idea is there could be problems depending on when the birthdays are - if DSS's birthday is before DD's, then don't let him use all the money in the fund - point out that there are other birthdays. That might be when you point out that maybe there should be a limit, over which he has to pay out of his spending money.

billy1966 · 30/06/2022 21:19

OP,

He is a waster that is stealing from your child.

He isn't paying anywhere near 50%.

He is living off you.

You sound afraid and bullied by him.

Your children deserve better.

So do you.

900vhb557 · 30/06/2022 20:45

I think there are clearly two issues here. On the one hand, presents and honestly I would strongly encourage you to spend as little on the 3 year old as you can. They dont know how much stuff costs and I would always say buy it second hand and save your money because by the time they are 8 you wont be able to do that and it will be expensive. so no need to over compensate there, the three year old is fine. Revisit in a few years when and if the difference because too apparent to the kids. And again just buy second hand, if it makes you feel better put the money you saved on the presents into an account for her.

But the other is joint finances and that you should address. He should pay more and his money shouldn't just be for treats. You really do need to sit down and sort it out

The problem is that if you mix the two - he might just think you sound bitter hen in reality these are two different issues that can be addressed in different ways

HardRockOwl · 30/06/2022 20:45

You've posted about this scenario before haven't you?

PaperTyger · 30/06/2022 20:36

Don't frame it like that.
Don't make him defensive, say you both need to look at what you both can contribute towards the extra pots.

Your setting up pots for clothes/ birthday, /Christmas/ saving/emergency fund.
What's left over is his.same for you but not enough is being set aside at the moment.

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 20:07

aSofaNearYou · 30/06/2022 19:50

You shouldn't feel that you can't talk to him and point out the disparity Op, it's obviously unreasonable. His defensiveness is a big red flag

Indeed. I always feel apprehensive when there is an issue to be raised as I know how defensive he can be when he feels attacked. Attacked to him can be as little as somebody saying "I don't like the way you do X Y or Z"

There's something called rejection sensitive dysphoria which can be a factor in people with ADHD and I think he fits that well.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 30/06/2022 19:50

You shouldn't feel that you can't talk to him and point out the disparity Op, it's obviously unreasonable. His defensiveness is a big red flag

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 19:42

There's alot of sterling advice here, thank you all.

I'm definitely going to sit him down tomorrow with a calculator and and go over everything.

I'm not sure if I'm going to mention the difference in presents yet.

OP posts:
Gentleness · 30/06/2022 19:22

This is a good place to point reluctant budgeters : youtube.com/watch?v=R4VbZCxDDvY

Gentleness · 30/06/2022 19:20

It sounds like he has a poor understanding of how household expenses work. Learning what "true expenses" are is a sobering process, but really he has to. There are some really useful but funny and light videos on YouTube by Hannah from YNAB that might get him started if he is ready to start growing up. If he isn't, you're pretty much stuck with choosing between fair adulting or him.

NoSquirrels · 30/06/2022 19:17

Part of it for me is that I know he has maintenance to pay, so I pick up his slack so DSS doesn't miss out. Not that he would miss out. His mum is OK for money. But CM is non negotiable as it should be.

Basically* *what you’re describing is that he’s got 2 kids, with 2 different mothers, and he thinks bunging about £100 to cover costs for each is fair enough, because the mothers will sort the rest so the kids don’t miss out. He’s still Disney Dadding, you just haven’t realised it. His money is for fun.

WeAreBob · 30/06/2022 19:16

Livelovebehappy · 30/06/2022 19:14

Tbh, you say you both pay 50/50 bills, and I assume what each of you has left is yours to do with as you want? If the bills are accounted for in his contribution, then unless there is something else he needs to pay, then the money is pretty much his to do with as he pleases. If other things such as presents, clothes, holidays, need to be taken into consideration, then you just need to up his contribution. Me and DH have our own accounts, and pay half towards the bills, and then I spend my remaining money on what I want, which he might think is wasted as I spend on clothes, nails and expensive face creams.

This person hasn't bothered to actually read your posts. Ignore this.

Livelovebehappy · 30/06/2022 19:14

Tbh, you say you both pay 50/50 bills, and I assume what each of you has left is yours to do with as you want? If the bills are accounted for in his contribution, then unless there is something else he needs to pay, then the money is pretty much his to do with as he pleases. If other things such as presents, clothes, holidays, need to be taken into consideration, then you just need to up his contribution. Me and DH have our own accounts, and pay half towards the bills, and then I spend my remaining money on what I want, which he might think is wasted as I spend on clothes, nails and expensive face creams.

NoSquirrels · 30/06/2022 19:12

FFS. He sounds useless and selfish.

No one is so ‘bad with money’ that they think £100 a month covers 50% of all the household costs involved in raising a child and running a home. No one.

Don’t just add up the fixed monthly bills. Work out variable things like clothes & shoes for DD over a year, food and energy, presents (birthday AND Christmas), random shit like playgroup or soft play, haircuts, all that stuff. Divide it by 12 and add it to the bills. Then add a bit more for contingency.

Financial inequality with useless arsehole fathers really grinds my gears.