Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disparity in cost of gifts between DSC and DC

109 replies

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 16:55

It's DSC's birthday next week and partner has just been sat with him making up his list of birthday present requests. Multiple console games, random things, expensive new trainers (he just bought him new trainers not three months ago)

Meanwhile for our DD's birthday last month he bought her 1 kindi kids doll totalled to less than £20. Obviously she got more than just the one doll, I was buying her bits here and there in the months leading up.

We're not well off, infact we're counting pennies at the end of every month trying to stretch until one of us gets paid. My children do not walk around in expensibe trainers. We have separate finances which is partly due to the fact he is crap with money, when he gets his wages he pisses them up the wall after transferring me his half of the bills. I'm then left to do all of the budgeting and worrying about making X amount stretch the full month.

I don't feel able to say anything about the birthday gifts because it's his son, he wants to treat him but AIBU to be feeling annoyed?

There are a couple of factors at play, how bad he is with money being one of them, but the disparity between birthday gifts has upset me.

He's not over compensating for DSC not getting anything at his mums. He has a huge family on his DMs side and gets dozens of gifts every year. Our children don't though.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bollindger · 01/07/2022 19:02

Don't mention the gift to his son it is a Red Herring, if he actually pay half of all bills, you will have money to spend on your child, and build in a spend for her as well.

Summerwhereareyou · 01/07/2022 17:25

Nano you need to stop mentioning the step sons shoes
The real issue is that you don't have a separate place for money for this sort of thing. If you had a children's clothes kitty then it would be very clear, there is 100 in it, he wants to spend 60 on trainers when 40 isn't enough for everything else they need.

We are now quite trained when it comes to putting money aside for lots of different things but we recently went on holiday and over spent because we weren't able to do what we normally do. Which is take out each day's budget in cash.
So we were blind, sounds silly but without a guide it's almost impossible not to spend.
I would perhaps say you want to take them to somewhat like Disney and you both need to save to do that which means sorting out money..maybe say someone at work managed to go by saving like this?

BritWifeInUSA · 01/07/2022 13:20

Why on earth do you call him your “partner” if you don’t even buy your child a birthday present together? His money, my money, etc. where’s the partnership in that?

I voted YABU. For tolerating this nonsense from him. Stand up for yourself and your child.

Carlycat · 01/07/2022 12:55

Classic Cocklodger. Get rid 👍

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/07/2022 12:52

Sorry just to say again - 8 is not an “older child” ffs

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/07/2022 12:50

He’s 8, just 8! I was assuming he was a teenager from your OP, not a little kid at primary school! 8 yos (I have one) do not need multiple pairs of trainers and multiple consoles. 8 and 3 are both in the “young kid” bracket for present buying really.

I don’t spend vast amounts like that on my 13 yo either unless she needs something particular, like a new musical instrument, which is her thing.

I think a big conversation needs to be had about fair finances. Sounds like he’s contributing a tiny amount and leaving you with all of the burdens, which just isn’t fair.

ToughLoveLDN · 01/07/2022 12:43

You need to write down all of the expenses in a list with the amount next to it. You present that to him. And you say this is how much your half will be.

Also how the actual F do you spend £40 in less than a week on the electric?Correct me if I read that wrong. But I work from home and `£60 will last the whole month

Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 01/07/2022 12:11

These men are such a type, honestly they all behave identically. Be prepared for next level tantrums once you point out his cock lodging. No doubt he will acuse you of being what he is a 'gold digger'. But seriously what adult with 2 children thinks £600 is reasonable amount to pay in costs. I woudn't go into the conversation without it all written down, exactly what everything costs (although bet he'll refuse to look at it). His child support is not your bill btw, especially as he earns more than you. But tbh unless you want to fund the sponge forever, you and your daughter will be much better off financially getting rid of him and claiming CMS and UC.

GlitteryGreen · 01/07/2022 11:58

To everyone defending him because older children want more expensive gifts - the £20 doll that he bought was not the only thing DD wanted. OP spent £70 on gifts for her which her dad didn't contribute to at all, that's the issue.

OP isn't expecting that the two children get exactly the same, but just that their father contributes to both of their birthdays. It's hardly fair to spend £200 on one child and then only £20 on the other, leaving their other parent to cover the rest of it.

GlitteryGreen · 01/07/2022 11:55

I'd go down the route of increased cost of living and literally write down every single bill - including non-fixed like food, things for your DD (including enough for you to put a bit aside for her birthday) - and go through that in your conversation.

I completely understand the separate finances and I am the same. My DP is not as bad as yours but he is used to flying by the seat of his pants when it comes to money whereas I'm not like that. He also overspends on SCs for birthdays and fails to prepare so he can spread the cost, and I don't want to have a joint fund that just ends up getting rinsed for treats for SCs.

I would definitely try to increase what your DP is handing over to you each month so you can cover more costs, and tbh for your DD's birthday and Christmas, I'd ask him what he prefers - would he like to agree all the gifts with you and then pay half, or for you to choose what she's getting and allocate him a few bits to get? Either way he needs to contribute.

easyday · 01/07/2022 10:58

My son's list was always way higher in terms of money value - ps4 games, earphones, clothes with the right label... my daughter was happy with Tesco clothes and a book and a few other crafty bits. When young it seems more the same quantity than value mattered to them. Now my son still gets more spent in his birthday (turning 19 and he wants Beats earphones, nice watch and gold earring). All my daughter could come up with was a few special art pens (of course I got her more things). To be honest I'm happy one is not as spendthrift as the other!
If it's family money he's spending I would hope you discussed it. I imagine part of it is guilt.

FayeGovan · 01/07/2022 10:40

The 3 yr old wont stay 3, she'll start noticing soon.

poetryandwine · 01/07/2022 09:24

Hi, OP - I think the difference in the presents was the thing that got you thinking, thank goodness. But it is relatively minor within the overall scheme of things, so I would not mention it at the moment.

As PPs have said, your H is not paying anything like half your joint expenses. He is paying half the rent plus a tiny bit. Grossly unfair.

I suggest that all joint expenses for your entire family including all DC and all DSC be listed and shared out equally, but I know some prefer to allocate big expenses for DSC to their own parent. (That doesn’t feel like a family to me. But whatever works for you.). As PP have said this includes all those things for your DD that it is clear you have been paying for unthinkingly. This will include quite a lot you haven’t listed. Your H can have his treats with anything that is left.

If you want to be generous - and you will still come out well ahead, I think - you could add the CM your H pays into the pot of common expenses to be shared. But that is a philosophical question each woman needs to answer for herself. (If your money was pooled you would essentially be doing this, but you have a rare situation where pooling your money seems a bad idea.)

I am not worried that your DD has missed out yet, because 3 year olds don’t notice. But how many treats have you had? I think you deserve something to help recover from this situation and put the new arrangement on a sound footing.

user1471538283 · 01/07/2022 09:07

I think he knows exactly what he is doing. No adult thinks that £100 a month covers groceries and utility bills.

You keep saying he pays half but he doesnt. You are paying to have a boyfriend in your life. His priority is the flash presents and dinners out. So others think he is successful.

He either truly pays half of everything from now on or he goes. I would want some of the money I'd been subsiding him as well.

Spanglemum · 01/07/2022 08:52

I have family members with ADHD and the lack of ability to plan, the pulse buying and the energy drinks are all very familiar. You don't need to buy them for him though.

What struck is that it won't be that long before your child realises their siblings gets a lot more 'stuff' and money spent on them.
I hope you can put some plans into place.
Good luck OP.

FayeGovan · 01/07/2022 08:49

The bottom line is, its up to you if you want to put up with an arsehole and keep making excuses for him and treating him like a baby who cant help it. Its your choice.

Newmumatlast · 01/07/2022 08:39

NanoNano156 · 30/06/2022 17:09

We have separate bank accounts, my wages go into mine and his go into his. He transfers me £600 when he gets paid which is his half of the bills and what he's left with in his account gets splashed on whatever he wants to buy. He doesn't do any of the budgeting. He sees what's left in his bank as money to play with and spends it as he sees fit.

Meanwhile I have to budget for everything, the shopping, the increase in energy bills, everything the kids need throughout the month like pack ups etc.

The last week of every month we're always scraping by which wouldn't be the case if he took more care with his money. He spends about 60-70 per month on energy drinks for one thing..

If I say anything I'm just seen as being money grabbing.

If you mean by you having to budget for everything that you're budgeting out of the bills money you both contribute towards then to be fair you are only the one budgeting rather than him because you chose to take on the task due to him being bad with money. I do this too. However if you mean you're budgeting for additional things for the family out of your own money then you both arent paying enough into the joint account for bills. You shouldn't only pay in sums to cover actual paper/electronic bills but also a sum which will cover less fixed bills like food costs, things like clothes for the kids and days out etc.

Trisolaris · 01/07/2022 07:57

Hi OP,

can I suggest that before you sit down and Leo the budget you give him some warning first? I know that the people I know with ADHD would feel ambushed if they were just sat down with a spreadsheet and calculator without having had a chance to prepare for the conversation.

Its just a case of saying that bills have gone up and you are finding it hard to manage so you think it would be helpful for the two of you to sit down at a later point and work out bills together.

MrJollyLivesNextDoor · 01/07/2022 07:42

Good luck OP

Methinks you will need it.

How you haven't got the ick with him I'll never know!

Friendship101 · 01/07/2022 07:20

Record everything you spend in a month on family things so rents, bills, food etc. Then ask him for half.
Or do it another way and make sure you both have the same percentage of your wage left over after bills as spending money.
Do you have other children other than your shared 3 year old? This could change how much he should be contributing

StoppinBy · 01/07/2022 07:15

I wouldn't bring the presents in to your discussion as it's money in general that's the issue and if you can get through to him then everything like the presents will sort itself out hopefully.

Realistically, he is paying for half the rent and then 25 per month towards all the other bills (not taking in to account the $45 on the meter). This is not ok at all.

How he can be ok with having all that spare money while you scrape by is beyond me.

My DD is diagnosed as having ADHD ..... it took me a long time to accept that as she is a 'mini me' so I strongly suspect I also have ADHD, it's not an excuse for him to be like this and I suspect that he is taking advantage of the fact that you let his ADHD be an excuse. Stop doing that.

Maybe bring it up, have it all written down and tell him you'd like him to take a look at it so you can have a talk about it later on. This will give him time to process it without getting defensive and with any luck you will be able to have a reasonable conversation with him.

Weenurse · 01/07/2022 07:15

Lots of good advice.
look at the bill for the last 12 months.
Look at income.
Remove his CM from his income, what is he left with?
split bills 50:50.
Discuss what he thinks is reasonable to put aside each month for DC birthday and Christmas. “If we put aside $10 each month for each DC that leaves $60 for birthday and $60 for Christmas, do you think this is enough or should we put aside more?”
What does he think is a reasonable amount for a holiday?. Look at the holidays you want, cost them out and then put aside each month.
good luck 💐

Shoxfordian · 01/07/2022 07:08

He isn’t really contributing half; you need to note down all the bills and work out what half of the month is then that’s what he should send you

Why did you trust someone to be the father of your child if he can’t be trusted to have a joint account?

Whatafustercluck · 01/07/2022 06:55

A few things here op.

He gives you half for bills etc. Do you both earn the same? If not, and if you have separate finances, he should be giving you a proportionate split. E.g. if he earns 50% more, he contributes 50% more to the bills meaning you have a little more 'free' cash too, to splash on what you want.

He 'pisses his half up the wall' doesn't sound like the makings of a harmonious relationship. Does he get to go out and enjoy himself, buy whatever he likes etc, while you struggle and are left caring for your dd?

I have a dsd and dh and I have two younger dc together. We give them all exactly the same amount for Christmas and birthdays and always have. Dsd is now an adult, and we've helped her out with bigger items for her home, education or whatever but always in the knowdge we'll do the same for our dc (plus we spend more on them on a day to day basis). Your partner is a Disney dad. It's no way to continue.

HairyScaryMonster · 01/07/2022 02:55

I think whatever he spends on DSC you should be making a point to note and saying he owes you half for DD for next birthday, and ask for extra on paydays leading up to it.

It would be different if they were each your own children, and you split all other joint costs evenly (or equably)