Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School run help when her husband could've done it

112 replies

mineymimey · 30/06/2022 15:48

I've been stewing on something since Monday, but I'm not sure if I'm being unreasonable!

For context, we live 15 minutes walk away from the primary school my DD6 attends.

The friend / school mum that this relates to lives 15 minutes away, but in a different direction from my house. She has a useless husband when it comes to childcare and help.

Our 2 eldest DDs are in the same class.

On Monday, she told me her youngest DD was poorly but that was she having to take her on school run as her husband was working away for the day. So I offered to pick her eldest up and take her to school.

She lives 10 minutes in a different direction. So off we toddle on Monday, leaving the house 10 minutes early to pick up her DD.

We also pick her up after school and take her home, again 10 minutes in the wrong direction, in the rain. Only for her DD to say on the school walk back that her Dad was home, and was all day.

He was working, but I know his job is flexible and could have easily done school runs, or even have sat with the poorly child whilst mum did school run.

I feel annoyed that she told me her husband was working away. He is useless with childcare and won't step up unless specifically asked. So I have a feeling she just thought I was the easier option.

AIBU to be annoyed at this?

OP posts:
Anothernamechangeplease · 30/06/2022 18:40

mineymimey · 30/06/2022 18:22

Wow a right mixed bag of comments!

In answer to some of the queries:

  1. she definitely said he was away for the day. She specifically mentioned a town a couple of hours drive away. This was said in a text at 1030pm Sunday night

  2. the child said that her dad was home for breakfast, which in her words 'doesn't happen very often'. She also said 'daddy didn't pick me up or take me because you and mummy had already planned it'

  3. both cars were on the drive when we arrived back after school run. They were also both there in the morning when I picked her up. I just didn't twig at the time. The place were the DH went is only accessible by car, and not train

  4. the husband has form for not stepping up. A hobby he is obsessed with and has put before his family many times (think the usual annoying hobby that pops up on Mumsnet frequently!) I know this because the mum has moaned about it many times

I have no problem helping out, I truly don't. But what I really didn't appreciate was the half truth.

But I really appreciate everyone's views. I will take on board a lot of the comments, but just be a bit wary in the future.

Might he have left after breakfast with a colleague?

Maybe she was lying, maybe she wasn't, but I wouldn't rely on a 6yo knowing exactly what her parents were doing on any given day!

WeAllHaveWings · 30/06/2022 18:36

I wouldn't be too bothered about it if you both regularly reciprocate helping each other out. Cultivating a group of mums that can do this for each other can be invaluable when they are in primary.

But if it is always one way I wouldn't be helping out again.

CallOnMe · 30/06/2022 18:30

In this scenario I would t get worked up about it as just because he was WFH doesn’t mean he didn’t have an important zoom meeting or something that meant he couldn’t be flexible.

Id be slightly annoyed she said he was working away but he could have been initially and then last minute they decided to do it over video chat instead.

I wouldn’t make it a regular thing though if he’s got form for not stepping up.

mineymimey · 30/06/2022 18:22

Wow a right mixed bag of comments!

In answer to some of the queries:

  1. she definitely said he was away for the day. She specifically mentioned a town a couple of hours drive away. This was said in a text at 1030pm Sunday night

  2. the child said that her dad was home for breakfast, which in her words 'doesn't happen very often'. She also said 'daddy didn't pick me up or take me because you and mummy had already planned it'

  3. both cars were on the drive when we arrived back after school run. They were also both there in the morning when I picked her up. I just didn't twig at the time. The place were the DH went is only accessible by car, and not train

  4. the husband has form for not stepping up. A hobby he is obsessed with and has put before his family many times (think the usual annoying hobby that pops up on Mumsnet frequently!) I know this because the mum has moaned about it many times

I have no problem helping out, I truly don't. But what I really didn't appreciate was the half truth.

But I really appreciate everyone's views. I will take on board a lot of the comments, but just be a bit wary in the future.

OP posts:
5128gap · 30/06/2022 18:11

KosherDill · 30/06/2022 17:05

Nothing will change until we all refuse to enable this.

People need to live with the consequences of the choices they've made. And maybe others observing them will make better choices.

What an illogical comment. Given she can't force her husband to step up, the only way the woman could 'sort out her marital and domestic affairs' is to leave. She will then be a single parent. In what way would that resolve the problem of her taking a sick child on the school run without help? Or perhaps you think she should have done that anyway, so any unattached women who saw would know if they didn't want their future sick children to struggle they should marry a man they could predict would never let them down? In your efforts to make other women look bad, you make yourself ridiculous.

Simplelobsterhat · 30/06/2022 18:09

Its annoying if the dad really could have done it, but I don't see how you can know that for sure. His DD might have misunderstood what he was doing, not realise he was heading off on a work trip that morning etc.

Also wfh doesn't necessarily mean being flexible all the time. Even if you somehow know he is sometimes, I don't see how you could be sure he didn't have an important call or meeting scheduled for drop off time or need to be 'on duty' if calls came in. Admittedly with my kids I'd still be happy to have one in the house while dh did drop off in that situation, but it would depend on age and behaviour of kid!

However, given what you've said about him I can understand you being suspicious!

RadFad · 30/06/2022 18:06

Our DD goes to school with neighbours DDs and if one of them is ill the mum will regularly ask if we can take the other to school even though her DH can work from home and be flexible.
He has a very traditional idea of male/female roles and is quite rigid.
It doesn't bother me as we are going the same way and she will return favour if needed.

TheMushroom · 30/06/2022 18:01

Blowthemandown · 30/06/2022 16:49

Yes. I'd have to say 'Child said Dad was WFH; I thought you said he's away?' If she then said 'yes he is wfh' I'd have to say 'I don't mind helping out when you are really stuck, but in this case I'd have expected him to do it one or both ways. It's not as if you're on my route to/from school' and see what she said.

How is it any of your business how the dad chooses to organise his working day from home though?

I haven't seen any other evidence in the OP that the dad is consistently shit or useless. Like I already said, when my DH works from home, there's no way he can just pop out for the half hour it takes to walk to school and back.

Probably loads of parents at school are judging him for being a shit dad but the fact is his phone never stops ringing and he barely moves from his laptop from 8-6.

Ohthatsexciting · 30/06/2022 17:59

And the idea that op has been stewing on the basis of a 6 year olds comment on the walk home from school is both a bit sad and baffling!!

Ohthatsexciting · 30/06/2022 17:58

GoldenSongbird · 30/06/2022 17:56

I'm laughing at the posters saying the 6-yr-old could be wrong - that's so true. If anyone had asked my teen DS where his DF was this morning, he'd have said DH was working in his room. Actually, DH had been away since the early hours of this morning. DS didn't realise till after lunchtime. DCs often don't pay attention to their parents' whereabouts until they need something from them Grin

Children this age generally can’t see beyond the end of their own now and have no real concept of time and certainly not of the work routine of their father!

GoldenSongbird · 30/06/2022 17:56

I'm laughing at the posters saying the 6-yr-old could be wrong - that's so true. If anyone had asked my teen DS where his DF was this morning, he'd have said DH was working in his room. Actually, DH had been away since the early hours of this morning. DS didn't realise till after lunchtime. DCs often don't pay attention to their parents' whereabouts until they need something from them Grin

YouSoundLovely · 30/06/2022 17:54

Blowthemandown · 30/06/2022 16:49

Yes. I'd have to say 'Child said Dad was WFH; I thought you said he's away?' If she then said 'yes he is wfh' I'd have to say 'I don't mind helping out when you are really stuck, but in this case I'd have expected him to do it one or both ways. It's not as if you're on my route to/from school' and see what she said.

This is exactly what I'd say.

I'd be very annoyed at having been lied to (if that is indeed what happened), and very annoyed that she'd expected me and my child to trail around in the rain so she could avoid facing up to his her husband's behaviour. I understand why some posters are saying they'd be supportive, but that kind of support is enabling/perpetuating this woman's situation in particular and entrenched sexism in general.

dottymac · 30/06/2022 17:51

This resonates because that's happened to me a few times but with people's kids! E.g "Can you look after little Bobby until 5 then their dad will pick them up" cue the dad turning up an hour (or more !!) Late because he decided to work on a bit extra or have a leisurely amble home while I looked after their kid! Without so much as even a text to inform, much less ask if that was ok - because what's another hour and another kid to look after 🤷 pisses me off - my time is not less important than yours ya bunch of using fandans 😡

TheMushroom · 30/06/2022 17:51

This could easily have been me (it wasn't me!).

DH works from home often but I can't rely on him for anything like school runs or additional childcare duties. His boss is a loon and I swear he must have a tracker on DH's phone because he always seems to call DH every time he steps out of the house for anything other than work reasons. Since he was 'caught' and bollocked for giving our eldest a lift to school, he just doesn't do any of that any more to be on the safe side.

Also, he often has a long, boring status call with his team right over the time for school pick up.

I can easily imagine a scenario where, rather than explain all of the above to a school mum friend I don't know very well, I would just say he's away with work.

It was only ten minutes out of the way. Either do the favour or don't. But I would struggle to get really worked up about it.

Penguinevere · 30/06/2022 17:41

YANBU op I wouldn’t mind doing it if she was honest. He’s kind of making a fool of both of you this way.

goldengirlsoncraic · 30/06/2022 17:38

Anothernamechangeplease · 30/06/2022 17:26

The child may well have been mistaken. Perhaps she thought her dad had been at home all day and he wasn't?

Kids also have the uncanny knack of telling the truth and exposing the lies.

Id say more than like the dm was lying rather than the child.

But i wouldnt help again,shes shown herself to be a liar. And possible cf.

Johnnypiratesfriend · 30/06/2022 17:33

To be honest I think you need to see it as help.
You don't know what's going on she maybe planning to leave him and wondering how she would manage. Your support would show her she can manage without him!

onmywayamarillo · 30/06/2022 17:31

Single mum here, you'd be shocked at the women who ask me to pick and drop their kids with perfectly functional husbands/ partners who do absolutely 0 parenting.

My reply: what's wrong with your husband?

They don't ask again

MyAnacondaMight · 30/06/2022 17:30

I get it - it’s annoying. I’ve felt similar helping out a friend with a new baby - I knew she was struggling so took time out to spend an afternoon with her here and there. Ended up doing her husbands gym kit laundry - which is what she wanted help with, but I was cross that she was exhausted yet her husband had time to go to the gym every day.

In those scenarios I feel like I’m acting as unpaid help to the lazy husband - which is what is irritating.

Ohthatsexciting · 30/06/2022 17:28

Can you imagine having a mum like @KosherDill

Shit, I feel sad and depressed just thinking about it!

Viviennemary · 30/06/2022 17:28

It's a cheek. I 'd be annoyed too.

Anothernamechangeplease · 30/06/2022 17:26

The child may well have been mistaken. Perhaps she thought her dad had been at home all day and he wasn't?

Goldbar · 30/06/2022 17:25

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 30/06/2022 16:56

Kids don't always get things right either. My kids get the wrong end of the stick quite often!

This. I wouldn't necessarily go by what the 6yo said. My DC often runs upstairs to show their daddy something because they think he's home when he's actually at work or says he's 'at work' when he's actually having a lie-in or wfh at the weekend. Kids get confused.

starfishmummy · 30/06/2022 17:24

I'd be concerned that she felt she had to lie!! My DH is wfh and isn't always available to pop out as he often has to be in teams meetings, but he would be able to stay in woth a sock child if I had to go out. But maybe this sick child only wanted Mum to look after them - that's not unusual.

BattenburgDonkey · 30/06/2022 17:24

Thinkingblonde · 30/06/2022 17:16

Aside from the lying isn’t it 40 minutes ? 20 mins in the morning and 20 mins at home time. 10 mins to collect the child, then 10 mins to school and the same in reverse at home time.

I can’t see why it matters. But she said the other mum lives a 15 min walk to school like she does, just from a different direction. So they left 10 mins earlier to get friend, then normal 15 min walk to school from there. Then after school normal 15 min walk just to friends house, then the extra 10 mins home. So no it’s 20 mins.

Swipe left for the next trending thread