Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 21:55

@beautyisthefaceisee It is certainly not my intention to misrepresent you, but, no, I still think what you've said is quite different to what you think you've said.

Anyway, moving on...I was concerned upthread when you said being asked to add pronouns to email signatures was not about anyone other than the trans community.
This was following your comment to another poster...
'Why on earth would you be "furious"? NO thanks will do. It's not about you.'

When I suggested it was indeed relevant to women I was asked why it was only my feelings that mattered? (For the record I do not think only my feelings matter.)

So if you do want to try again, please go ahead.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 21:36

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 21:28

A reasonable middle will only be found when both ways give compromise.
For as long as feminists continue to chum each other along with their bile, and TRA's do their bit, compromise won't be reached.
All of this "we say no" bit is all well and good but all it's actually doing is handing ammo to the other side.
All trans people get is dismissal insults and threats too if these threads are anything to go by.

I know that's what you think - and to be clear, I do not accept your wholesale mischaracterisation of the people who point out flaws in the basis on which trans identities are currently being used to appropriate female voices, history and provisions as "bile", in fact I reject it vehemently (which no doubt will trigger another round of "how come it's ok when someone on FWR calls a trans woman a man even though that is known to upset trans people, but not ok when I call feminists' voices bile?" - which I've seen played out enough in this thread so I'm not playing) - but that was not what I asked.

My question is Who? Who is going to make these provisions that you think so reasonable actually happen? Where is the political voice that will bring them into being?

You reject it coming from anyone who won't call a trans woman a woman or use cross-sex pronouns despite them explaining many times respectfully why these are not just trivial courtesies but deep wounds in the right of female people to self definition, political power and the right to exist as separate to male, and despite them being very happy to support trans people's right to safety, security, acceptance and happiness in everything except the appropriation of the reality of the opposite sex into an identity indistinguishable from their own.

TRAs will never support it.

Who then in your view is pure enough to be heard who can do this?

Someone who has respect for both.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 21:34

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 21:09

Of course it would happen amongst feminists! Daily I see mocking of trans - just because you're not threatening death or rape doesn't make you "better" (now what a low bar to set".

While I totally condemn people who mock trans people, and the men in dresses comments etc, I cannot agree that it’s as bad as rape and death threats. Do you really think that? Mocking someone is equivalent to threatening to kill them?

No, I don't think that, and that's what I said.

No, you just said the exact opposite. You said not threatening death or rape ' doesn't make you better'...which surely implies it makes you just as bad?

It's impossible to argue with you @beautyisthefaceisee, because you're not effectively addressing a lot of the criticisms people are making. I said upthread that a point you made wasn't true and you responded by saying I was being mean to trans people and asking why my feelings mattered more. You never actually addressed the concerns I had.

The conversation I've quoted above is another case in point. Here, you're denying you said something that you actually said only minutes earlier. How can someone make an effective argument against that?

No.

Please actually read what I said.

I said that it's not equal - but that doesnt mean its as bad!

You might not be doing rape and death threats, and what you're doing isn't as bad as that, but it doesn't make what you're doing BETTER. It's quite simle to understand (unless you're deliberately misrepresenting me).

What concerns did I not address? Please ask me again.

It's easy to dismiss me when you're miserepresenting what I'm saying!

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 21:28

A reasonable middle will only be found when both ways give compromise.
For as long as feminists continue to chum each other along with their bile, and TRA's do their bit, compromise won't be reached.
All of this "we say no" bit is all well and good but all it's actually doing is handing ammo to the other side.
All trans people get is dismissal insults and threats too if these threads are anything to go by.

I know that's what you think - and to be clear, I do not accept your wholesale mischaracterisation of the people who point out flaws in the basis on which trans identities are currently being used to appropriate female voices, history and provisions as "bile", in fact I reject it vehemently (which no doubt will trigger another round of "how come it's ok when someone on FWR calls a trans woman a man even though that is known to upset trans people, but not ok when I call feminists' voices bile?" - which I've seen played out enough in this thread so I'm not playing) - but that was not what I asked.

My question is Who? Who is going to make these provisions that you think so reasonable actually happen? Where is the political voice that will bring them into being?

You reject it coming from anyone who won't call a trans woman a woman or use cross-sex pronouns despite them explaining many times respectfully why these are not just trivial courtesies but deep wounds in the right of female people to self definition, political power and the right to exist as separate to male, and despite them being very happy to support trans people's right to safety, security, acceptance and happiness in everything except the appropriation of the reality of the opposite sex into an identity indistinguishable from their own.

TRAs will never support it.

Who then in your view is pure enough to be heard who can do this?

onlywhenidream · 05/07/2022 21:22

Trans people in real
Life may not be like the activists - 2 out of the 3 I know I would say are mild mannered rather than activist

But still doesn't mean I think TWAW for single sex purposes

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 21:09

Of course it would happen amongst feminists! Daily I see mocking of trans - just because you're not threatening death or rape doesn't make you "better" (now what a low bar to set".

While I totally condemn people who mock trans people, and the men in dresses comments etc, I cannot agree that it’s as bad as rape and death threats. Do you really think that? Mocking someone is equivalent to threatening to kill them?

No, I don't think that, and that's what I said.

No, you just said the exact opposite. You said not threatening death or rape ' doesn't make you better'...which surely implies it makes you just as bad?

It's impossible to argue with you @beautyisthefaceisee, because you're not effectively addressing a lot of the criticisms people are making. I said upthread that a point you made wasn't true and you responded by saying I was being mean to trans people and asking why my feelings mattered more. You never actually addressed the concerns I had.

The conversation I've quoted above is another case in point. Here, you're denying you said something that you actually said only minutes earlier. How can someone make an effective argument against that?

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 21:08

Cantanka · 05/07/2022 20:47

I would agree that the trans people I know in real life are not anything like the online activists. They’re actually being let down by them, because while some feminists will never accept trans women in any female spaces in any circumstances, my perception is there are a lot of women who are more flexible that that, however are being really alienated and getting pissed off by some of the more ridiculous things coming out of the activists’ mouths (or keyboards)!

All I can say though is I spend a lot of time on Twitter (night feeds and such!) and online, where someone makes a reasonable point which suggests compromise, such as let’s have a sensible conversation about how society should treat sex and gender, it’s the TRAs who take issue with it and pile on. I’ve seen than hundreds of times (not an exaggeration) over the last 5 years and I honestly don’t think I’ve once seen the reverse.

I agree.

i've bene absolutely pounded on the feminist boards in the past - both in trans and male issues, so I can't agree.

But again, as with Rhinos, I think you and I could have a reasonable respectful debate and would probably agree IRL.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 21:07

SmashingEgg · 05/07/2022 20:55

@beautyisthefaceisee Because I see it as an insult and another attack on us natural born females.
I refuse to take part in this woke nonsense and each time I'm presented with it by a company who I have dealings with they will be told in no uncertain terms where to shove that shit.
You might love the idea of being reduced to a pronoun, I don't.

I don't "love" it, but I'm not egotistical enough to be "furious".

The fact you see it as an attack and they can "shove their shit" is exactly what I'm talking about when PP question how there can't be a compromise. Because of people like you.

SmashingEgg · 05/07/2022 20:55

@beautyisthefaceisee Because I see it as an insult and another attack on us natural born females.
I refuse to take part in this woke nonsense and each time I'm presented with it by a company who I have dealings with they will be told in no uncertain terms where to shove that shit.
You might love the idea of being reduced to a pronoun, I don't.

Cantanka · 05/07/2022 20:47

I would agree that the trans people I know in real life are not anything like the online activists. They’re actually being let down by them, because while some feminists will never accept trans women in any female spaces in any circumstances, my perception is there are a lot of women who are more flexible that that, however are being really alienated and getting pissed off by some of the more ridiculous things coming out of the activists’ mouths (or keyboards)!

All I can say though is I spend a lot of time on Twitter (night feeds and such!) and online, where someone makes a reasonable point which suggests compromise, such as let’s have a sensible conversation about how society should treat sex and gender, it’s the TRAs who take issue with it and pile on. I’ve seen than hundreds of times (not an exaggeration) over the last 5 years and I honestly don’t think I’ve once seen the reverse.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:39

Cantanka · 05/07/2022 20:35

Where have I dismissed anyone as anything? I’ve barely posted on this thread since the start when the discussion was about pronouns still.

While I totally condemn people who mock trans people, and the men in dresses comments etc, I cannot agree that it’s as bad as rape and death threats. Do you really think that? Mocking someone is equivalent to threatening to kill them?

and the thing I said wouldn’t happen is that feminists - even the batshit ones - have never, to my knowledge, piled on someone for simply saying that someone shouldn’t be abused for their opinions even if they’re wrong. If that has happened I would be interested to know when, because I have genuinely never seen it.

Not you, personally!

No, I don't think that, and that's what I said.

But what a low bar to set! Oh, we never made death or rape threats and we didnt ile on for saying someone shouldnt be abused therefore we're much better.

No, no you're not.

My trans friend didn't do either of those things either, but he's still being mocked on the internet.

Cantanka · 05/07/2022 20:35

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:30

I agree with Eddie fwiw, I don't agree with a word she says, or the hurt she's caused but she doesn't deserve threats.

Of course it would happen amongst feminists! Daily I see mocking of trans - just because you're not threatening death or rape doesn't make you "better" (now what a low bar to set".

I actually think genuine trans people and reasonable feminists are most reasonable of the four camps - yes four - TRAs, batshit feminists, reasonable feminists and genuine trans. So why can't they work together?

Clue - you dismiss their identity as an "ideology" and then expect them to be on board.

Where have I dismissed anyone as anything? I’ve barely posted on this thread since the start when the discussion was about pronouns still.

While I totally condemn people who mock trans people, and the men in dresses comments etc, I cannot agree that it’s as bad as rape and death threats. Do you really think that? Mocking someone is equivalent to threatening to kill them?

and the thing I said wouldn’t happen is that feminists - even the batshit ones - have never, to my knowledge, piled on someone for simply saying that someone shouldn’t be abused for their opinions even if they’re wrong. If that has happened I would be interested to know when, because I have genuinely never seen it.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:30

Cantanka · 05/07/2022 20:15

I think what’s very telling is that people who want to find a middle ground are dismissed as transphobic - see people like Hadley freeman, Helen Lewis. Look at Eddie Redmayne who said only that while he disagreed with JK Rowling, she shouldn’t be threatened or abused, and he got absolutely piled on. Nothing short of total capitulation is acceptable. That sort of thing simply wouldn’t happen among feminists. One side is just inherently more reasonable than the other, and I hate this “both sides” thing.

I agree with Eddie fwiw, I don't agree with a word she says, or the hurt she's caused but she doesn't deserve threats.

Of course it would happen amongst feminists! Daily I see mocking of trans - just because you're not threatening death or rape doesn't make you "better" (now what a low bar to set".

I actually think genuine trans people and reasonable feminists are most reasonable of the four camps - yes four - TRAs, batshit feminists, reasonable feminists and genuine trans. So why can't they work together?

Clue - you dismiss their identity as an "ideology" and then expect them to be on board.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:28

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 20:25

Compromise with people who, when you say the word 'women', issue rape and death threats.

Sure that will work.

But they're not doing that. The TRAs are (although you did call me a TRA and a MRA yesterday).

I don't condone that.

But nor do I condone women online calling trans an "ideology" and being frankly offensive.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:27

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 19:49

@beautyisthefaceisee
My feelings and whether they're the only thing that matter or not (🙄) have absolutely nothing to do with the fact that what you posted just isn't true...the 'it's not about you' comment.

I'm guessing you're a fan of the old 'attack is the best form of defence' style of argument.

Nice try, but I'm not attacking anyone.

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 20:25

Compromise with people who, when you say the word 'women', issue rape and death threats.

Sure that will work.

Cantanka · 05/07/2022 20:15

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:01

A reasonable middle will only be found when both ways give compromise.

For as long as feminists continue to chum each other along with their bile, and TRA's do their bit, compromise won't be reached.

All of this "we say no" bit is all well and good but all it's actually doing is handing ammo to the other side.

All trans people get is dismissal insults and threats too if these threads are anything to go by.

I think what’s very telling is that people who want to find a middle ground are dismissed as transphobic - see people like Hadley freeman, Helen Lewis. Look at Eddie Redmayne who said only that while he disagreed with JK Rowling, she shouldn’t be threatened or abused, and he got absolutely piled on. Nothing short of total capitulation is acceptable. That sort of thing simply wouldn’t happen among feminists. One side is just inherently more reasonable than the other, and I hate this “both sides” thing.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 20:01

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 19:50

@beautyisthefaceisee

I was thinking about your support for single sex spaces and provisions in some cases and there's a question I should have asked.

Who do you think is going to make sure that happens? Because I honestly don't see where that brake on the process that is removing the acceptability of single sex provisions or the female political voice is going to come from.

Women have been saying no, that's a step too far to be justifiable as just trans inclusion and offering compromises and suggestions for years now and all we get are dismissal, insults and threats. Politicians and institutions are following the hard lines required by Stonewall. You assume a reasonable middle will be found but how if no one is prepared, or allowed, to champion it?

A reasonable middle will only be found when both ways give compromise.

For as long as feminists continue to chum each other along with their bile, and TRA's do their bit, compromise won't be reached.

All of this "we say no" bit is all well and good but all it's actually doing is handing ammo to the other side.

All trans people get is dismissal insults and threats too if these threads are anything to go by.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 19:50

@beautyisthefaceisee

I was thinking about your support for single sex spaces and provisions in some cases and there's a question I should have asked.

Who do you think is going to make sure that happens? Because I honestly don't see where that brake on the process that is removing the acceptability of single sex provisions or the female political voice is going to come from.

Women have been saying no, that's a step too far to be justifiable as just trans inclusion and offering compromises and suggestions for years now and all we get are dismissal, insults and threats. Politicians and institutions are following the hard lines required by Stonewall. You assume a reasonable middle will be found but how if no one is prepared, or allowed, to champion it?

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 19:49

@beautyisthefaceisee
My feelings and whether they're the only thing that matter or not (🙄) have absolutely nothing to do with the fact that what you posted just isn't true...the 'it's not about you' comment.

I'm guessing you're a fan of the old 'attack is the best form of defence' style of argument.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 19:38

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 19:26

But it is about us, of course it is!

Women are being affected by the adoption of this ideology, even if some haven't realised it yet.

And trans people are being affected by your behaviour about their "ideology".

Is it only your feelings that matter?

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 19:26

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 18:31

Why on earth would you be "furious"? NO thanks will do. It's not about you.

But it is about us, of course it is!

Women are being affected by the adoption of this ideology, even if some haven't realised it yet.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 19:16

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 18:53

Yesterday, Bette Midler tweeted about the word woman and a prominent transactivist likened her actions to Goebbels et al in a rant about 'fascist demigoggery'. Honestly the handwringing isn't from women.

Katie Hopkins tweets absolute gobshite all day every day.

Sorry, I thought we were talking about irrelevant people just because of their sex or beliefs.

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 18:53

Yesterday, Bette Midler tweeted about the word woman and a prominent transactivist likened her actions to Goebbels et al in a rant about 'fascist demigoggery'. Honestly the handwringing isn't from women.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 18:39

Helleofabore · 05/07/2022 18:36

Good to see that we have the usual ‘you are mean’ and ‘you are rude’ on this thread. Nothing new.

Great contribution, thanks.