Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 11:47

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 11:36

The activists, they are not outliers. They don't sit quietly on the internet, they are quite blatant about getting people kicked out of their jobs, screaming in people's faces if they dare to turn up to women's events. They are real and they are very, very scarey. They are often lauded for being 'feminsts' - one example just last week, the guy tweeting JKR's address along with instructions for making a pipe bomb is a 'feminist' apparently'. Just because someone says something does not make it true.

It is all completely out of hand. Why would we entertain for a single minute this mystical 'middle ground'? There is no middle ground.

Pronouns, just the tip of the iceberg.

This.

Not to mention the fact that half the Labour front bench have adopted positions @beautyisthefaceiseewould no doubt claim were extreme TRA, as do Stonewall who are responsible for providing training to both children and adults and doling out sought after diversity points to businesses.

GerryAtrick · 06/07/2022 11:38

SmashingEgg · 06/07/2022 09:15

@beautyisthefaceisee Yes furious and I'll continue to be furious.
Sick to death of men who think they're women, whether they've still got their balls attached or not, impinging on natural born females and demanding everything be their way.
You might bang your drum for them, but I won't.
You can sit bashing your keyboard all you like, but it won't change the fact that because of them, women are slowly but surely being eroded.
Chest feeders, womb carriers, people who menstruate? Pronouns to state my sex?
As I said, they can shove that shit up their arses!

@SmashingEgg

I'll second that until the end of time.

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 11:36

The activists, they are not outliers. They don't sit quietly on the internet, they are quite blatant about getting people kicked out of their jobs, screaming in people's faces if they dare to turn up to women's events. They are real and they are very, very scarey. They are often lauded for being 'feminsts' - one example just last week, the guy tweeting JKR's address along with instructions for making a pipe bomb is a 'feminist' apparently'. Just because someone says something does not make it true.

It is all completely out of hand. Why would we entertain for a single minute this mystical 'middle ground'? There is no middle ground.

Pronouns, just the tip of the iceberg.

Marynotsocontrary · 06/07/2022 10:15

@beautyisthefaceisee
Thank you for your explanation posted earlier.

I think we agree on a lot of things as it happens.
Sometimes I've been confused by a lack of precision in your language.
Saying "x is no better than y", or "x is not any better than y" (as you did), will always imply "x is just as bad as y" to me. Lots of explanation and sidetracking later and I do understand that is not really what you meant.

Similarly, if you had said to the pp who was upset "it's not only about you" or "it's not just about you" instead of the exclusionary "it's not about you" I would have had no argument with that. Again, the problem was with language. What you said implied something different to what you actually meant, I think.

The fact we seem to think that anything under rape and death threats is Ok is chilling. It really is.
Just because I"m questioning what you're saying doesn't mean that I, for one, think anything of the sort. You keep making sweeping generalisations like this with no evidence of their truth.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 06/07/2022 10:06

Males not makes 😒

honestly…

SmashingEgg · 06/07/2022 09:15

@beautyisthefaceisee Yes furious and I'll continue to be furious.
Sick to death of men who think they're women, whether they've still got their balls attached or not, impinging on natural born females and demanding everything be their way.
You might bang your drum for them, but I won't.
You can sit bashing your keyboard all you like, but it won't change the fact that because of them, women are slowly but surely being eroded.
Chest feeders, womb carriers, people who menstruate? Pronouns to state my sex?
As I said, they can shove that shit up their arses!

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 06/07/2022 09:10

i kinda thought we had halfway a few years ago before all this kicked off

obviously we had the same human rights whether that was upheld or not

transwomen used female toilets and changing rooms, joined womens clubs on occasion

then self id was mooted, some people realised that it would let in piss taking makes and then it all went tits up

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 08:43

What does meeting trans people half way look like, @beautyisthefaceisee?

I don't think anyone minded pronouns a few years ago, but now pronouns are being used as evidence that we all agree that trans women are women and belong in women only spaces.

I can't respect a male person's identity as a woman because I do not believe a male person is a woman. And to agree that they can be one, just to be nice, would mean prioritising their belief that woman is an identity over my own belief that woman means female person, and my right not to share any kind of identity with them.

I'm not sure how we can meet people halfway when you either believe that trans women are women or you don't.

And before you mention trans men again, well no, I don't believe trans men are men either. The reason they don't feature so much in this debate is because they aren't taking sporting opportunities from male athletes or making men feel unsafe in their rape therapy groups. But you can't logically accept that trans men are men and not accept that trans women are women. The same logic has to apply to both.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 06/07/2022 08:43

It doesn’t matter if i want to meet transwomen halfway…I don’t even know what halfway means in that instance

TRAs will still get in the way…they are the loud ones telling people where they think half way is

Howcoldloveis · 06/07/2022 08:36

Happy for trans people to do their thing, as long as it doesn't infringe on me - not happy to be lied to when I ask for a female health care professional and I get a transwoman. Not happy for transwomen to have access to female only spaces, not happy for transwomen to compete in women's sport. The pronouns thing is bullshit - no sane person believes transwomen are women. They may not feel like men - but they are not women - maybe like in sport they need a new category. I suspect I am therefore a trans bigot and weirdly I am ok with that.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 06/07/2022 08:36

And luckily for me i never said you did…

Both transwomen and women are collateral damage in this situation

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 08:29

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 06/07/2022 08:20

TRAs: be kind or we will kill, rape, threaten, assault you, we will bomb you, we will track you down, we will take your jobs, your income, your businesses, your funding, your same sex spaces, your support groups, your networks, your gigs, your art, everything you stand for and the very words you use to describe yourselves oh and your kids

and then once this has taken place you need to compromise, you need to meet us halfway

and most of this stuff like the NHS removing ‘women’ from their literature (not men) leaves ‘genuine’ transpeople going …well I didn’t ask for this

I didnt ask you to meet TRAs halfway. I asked you to meet trans people halfway.

Yes, they didnt ask for it. So why are they collateral?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 08:29

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 07:48

Both sides are 'wrong'.

TRAs: be kind or we will kill, rape, threaten, assault you, we will bomb you, we will track you down, we will take your jobs, your income, your businesses, your funding, your same sex spaces, your support groups, your networks, your gigs, your art, everything you stand for and the very words you use to describe yourselves oh and your kids.

Women who know sex is real: Male violence is the problem. See Exhibit A ^

So your trans person down the street is saying those things, are they?

Do I hold all feminists accountable for Bashir feminists?

No.

Yet for trans people, you deny their identity, mock them, call them an ideology, and then when you're bored of that you link them to nutters on Twitter.

The irony is you are part of the problem and it will go on and on.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 06/07/2022 08:20

TRAs: be kind or we will kill, rape, threaten, assault you, we will bomb you, we will track you down, we will take your jobs, your income, your businesses, your funding, your same sex spaces, your support groups, your networks, your gigs, your art, everything you stand for and the very words you use to describe yourselves oh and your kids

and then once this has taken place you need to compromise, you need to meet us halfway

and most of this stuff like the NHS removing ‘women’ from their literature (not men) leaves ‘genuine’ transpeople going …well I didn’t ask for this

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 07:48

Both sides are 'wrong'.

TRAs: be kind or we will kill, rape, threaten, assault you, we will bomb you, we will track you down, we will take your jobs, your income, your businesses, your funding, your same sex spaces, your support groups, your networks, your gigs, your art, everything you stand for and the very words you use to describe yourselves oh and your kids.

Women who know sex is real: Male violence is the problem. See Exhibit A ^

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 07:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

And you're talking nonsense.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 07:38

KnittingWords · 06/07/2022 00:45

No men, NO MEN, in women's spaces, girls' spaces. NO MEN. That should be clear enough.
NO MEN.
NO MEN.

It is usually helpful if you read the thread before getting your caps lock on.

Nobody, me included, is saying otherwise.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 07:37

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 21:55

@beautyisthefaceisee It is certainly not my intention to misrepresent you, but, no, I still think what you've said is quite different to what you think you've said.

Anyway, moving on...I was concerned upthread when you said being asked to add pronouns to email signatures was not about anyone other than the trans community.
This was following your comment to another poster...
'Why on earth would you be "furious"? NO thanks will do. It's not about you.'

When I suggested it was indeed relevant to women I was asked why it was only my feelings that mattered? (For the record I do not think only my feelings matter.)

So if you do want to try again, please go ahead.

Il make it clear then.

Do I think mocking people online is as bad as rape and death threats? No.
Do I think feminists have an equal part to play in the problem as the idiots on twitter? Yes.

Nust because they're not threatening to rape and murder anyone doesnt make their choices any better. It's a low bar to set.

In layman's terms - I work with children (donut will be back fuming about that again). The other day, one drew on someones stuff, he called her a fat cow and she hit him. In legal terms, the strike was worse. In morale terms, his caused more hurt. However, I didn't say, well he called you a fat cow and therefore you werent as bad. Because they played an EQUAL part in the incident. Ultimately it doesnt matter who was worse, both played a part. Life doesn't work on who was worse. If I batter the shit out of someone, a judge wont say oh well. You didnt kill them so it's okay.

The fact we seem to think that anything under rape and death threats is Ok is chilling. It really is. That aside, my trans friends didnt make thoss threats. Tra's did. A feminist was rude to me the other day, does that make you accountable? No.

I stand by my question.

Telling them you are furious and to shove their shit implies that only YOUR (not you, you see)feelings matter. cause the trans person who values pronouns isnr get a look in here.

Fwiw, I do see how it affects women.

But let's say there was a petition for safe spaces, and my trans friend didnt agree (he does, but imagine he didnt) and he was furious and said shove that shit. I would be telling him that womens' rights matter too and not just his.

I am completely, and squarely in the middle, (although when it comes to rape services and prisons and spaces etc I'm with you). But I am in the middle in terms of the morality side of things. Both 'sides' are wrong, and it will go on and on and on.

KnittingWords · 06/07/2022 00:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

KnittingWords · 06/07/2022 00:45

No men, NO MEN, in women's spaces, girls' spaces. NO MEN. That should be clear enough.
NO MEN.
NO MEN.

Marynotsocontrary · 06/07/2022 00:17

"But that was a general question

If you are 'furious' that one would use pronouns, you are disregarding the feeling of trans people, no? "

What was a general question?

And I never said anything at all about being 'furious', that was a pp.

I simply asked why you thought the introduction of pronouns to everyone's email signature was a subject only of relevance to the trans community?
I wondered why you thought it was not 'about' the rest of us and not relevant to our lives?

(And, to be clear, I asked this because you said "It's not about you" to another poster when she was upset about being asked for her pronouns.)

You still haven't answered by the way...

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/07/2022 00:03

No not reasonable to me
I don't thnk tw are "valid women"
nor do i agree with TM instantly being cast aside!

Ah, ok. That is a shame, it was an 100% genuine attempt.

To be clear, TM weren't cast aside. I've gone into my thinking around TM with you in some detail but for this post, in the interests of brevity I gave a partial example just around TW since that is the area where most differences seem to arise.

And I used "valid women" specifically because that is a phrase I see often used in statements from trans allies. I'm actually surprised you weren't ok with it.

BUT - it's just an example to get the conversation started. I was trying to work out what this Someone who has respect for both would say.

And ok, clearly I got it wrong but I'm sure you can do better.

What would you say?

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 23:45

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 22:12

Someone who has respect for both.

What will that person or group say that you would consider respectful to both? (Using TW here because the TM concerns are different)

Here's my guess at the sort of thing you mean:

"Trans women are valid women and have earned their pronouns. Nevertheless, they will be excluded from [list here, for me it would be women's sports, feminist political groups, political roles reserved for women, women's cultural prizes, intimate personal and medical care, areas where women may be undressed, women-only support groups, all women shortlists, recruitment drives aimed at increasing women applicants] because these are needed to support female people of any gender in a sexist culture."

I mean, that looks reasonable to me, but it unavoidably puts a limit on the degree to which trans women are women and for that reason I don't think it would ever be accepted by trans advocates.

Can you do better?

No not reasonable to me

I don't thnk tw are "valid women"
nor do i agree with TM instantly being cast aside!

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 23:44

Marynotsocontrary · 05/07/2022 21:55

@beautyisthefaceisee It is certainly not my intention to misrepresent you, but, no, I still think what you've said is quite different to what you think you've said.

Anyway, moving on...I was concerned upthread when you said being asked to add pronouns to email signatures was not about anyone other than the trans community.
This was following your comment to another poster...
'Why on earth would you be "furious"? NO thanks will do. It's not about you.'

When I suggested it was indeed relevant to women I was asked why it was only my feelings that mattered? (For the record I do not think only my feelings matter.)

So if you do want to try again, please go ahead.

But that was a general question

If you are 'furious' that one would use pronouns, you are disregarding the feeling of trans people, no?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 22:12

Someone who has respect for both.

What will that person or group say that you would consider respectful to both? (Using TW here because the TM concerns are different)

Here's my guess at the sort of thing you mean:

"Trans women are valid women and have earned their pronouns. Nevertheless, they will be excluded from [list here, for me it would be women's sports, feminist political groups, political roles reserved for women, women's cultural prizes, intimate personal and medical care, areas where women may be undressed, women-only support groups, all women shortlists, recruitment drives aimed at increasing women applicants] because these are needed to support female people of any gender in a sexist culture."

I mean, that looks reasonable to me, but it unavoidably puts a limit on the degree to which trans women are women and for that reason I don't think it would ever be accepted by trans advocates.

Can you do better?

Swipe left for the next trending thread